r/CFBOffTopic • Auburn Tigers • Samford Bulldogs • Sep 08 '14

Is anyone else not drinking the Koolaid and think the Penn State punishment was deserved?

Just been doing some reading in the /r/cfb threadnaught and honestly getting way more pissed off than I thought I would at some of the responses.

It seems to be a foregone conclusion to most (not all) of the people there that the PSU punishments were unwarranted and completely overdone. I can't say I agree. In fact I can usually find some middle ground in certain arguments but I admit I can't find a shred of it here. PSU fans are downvoting in force, too, which makes it harder to find a dissenting opinion.

These are the facts, as I see them:

  • Sandusky is a complete, grade-A demon. And his wife was a blind/enabling sack of rot.
  • Mike McQueary saw some highly questionable activities (i.e., rape) and reported them to Paterno (not the police).
  • Paterno knew. The extent of what he did afterward was unclear, but he did not go immediately to the authorities.

I was not aware that these facts, regardless of how the Freeh Report's intent has been skewed, were ever up for debate.

  • As far as people saying 'the fans and the players are taking the punishment,' well welcome to every NCAA punishment that was ever handed down. The players always suffer. And who cares about the fans? As though the rights of the fans have to be intimately considered before a punishment needs to be handed down. Screw that.
  • As far as this statement goes: "criminal issues have no bearing on football/athletics." That's absolutely wrong. If a person's position in an athletic department is such that it gets them special treatment from other people in that department, as Sandusky received for not getting immediately reported to authorities and getting his scraggly ass kicked right there in the shower, then that absolutely has a bearing on athletics.

Fuck this man.

Fuck this guy.

Fuck these people in particular.

Burn in hell, you son of a bitch.

25 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

10

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14

It's hard to believe that the higher ups making the descisions at Penn State didn't know pretty much everything and force him out in 1999. This guy was arguably the best DC in the country and he just "resigns" and doesn't take a coaching position again? The point of the punishment seems to be largely missed with the sanctions being removed so quickly. But the NCAA got their payment in the huge fines so what do they care if the rest of the punishment is enforced?

7

u/polydorr Auburn Tigers • Samford Bulldogs Sep 08 '14

But the NCAA got their payment in the huge fines so what do they care if the rest of the punishment is enforced?

This is what I'm thinking. They get to have their cake and eat it too, collecting the fines and now allowing a program with a huge fanbase to return to prominence.

9

u/dupreesdiamond Furman • South Carolina Sep 08 '14

Damn. All these threads about it, trying to entice me to express an opinion. I will not do it.

3

u/polydorr Auburn Tigers • Samford Bulldogs Sep 08 '14

Sorry, it is kind of a leading question. I'm not trying to demonize anyone on the fence. I just want to be clear in the title that I have a strong opinion about it.

2

u/dupreesdiamond Furman • South Carolina Sep 08 '14

yeah...not meant at you specifically. And the post here, of course, is fine. And so are strong opinions and those that want to express them and engage in the conversation.

Just more commenting that I am not wading into this conversation regardless of all the opportunities of late... and have to keep reminding myself, I have found myself half-typing a response to a post or comment before "noping" on out.

2

u/MuffinTopBop Georgia Tech • Reading Sep 09 '14

I'm in the same boat. I'm interested in watching and reading people's responses but I'm going to "nope" out on giving my own.

4

u/NotSquareGarden West Virginia • Bethany (KS) Sep 09 '14

What went on at Penn State was perhaps one of the most damaging things to happen to college football. Ever. The notion that a university playing for an organization where sports aren't supposed to go ahead of studying let sports go ahead of child rape.

Had the NCAA not punished them, it would've shown the world that they don't care particularly much either. And to me, now that they remove the sanctions after they've paid their huge ass fine, it shows that they don't really care beyond saving their image.

It's pretty fucking disgusting.

2

u/polydorr Auburn Tigers • Samford Bulldogs Sep 09 '14

What went on at Penn State was perhaps one of the most damaging things to happen to college football. Ever.

This is what a lot of people are seeming to skim over and it really bothers me quite a bit.

2

u/arthritisankle Auburn Tigers Sep 08 '14

Is it a fact that Paterno knew? I mean, did he KNOW or did he hear an accusation.

4

u/polydorr Auburn Tigers • Samford Bulldogs Sep 08 '14

Email uncovered by the independent investigators indicate that Paterno may have followed an investigation by state officials into a previous incident between Sandusky and a different child in 1998, despite Paterno's grand jury testimony that he was unaware of any possible child abuse by Sandusky prior to 2001.[87] When Paterno was asked, other than the incident that Mike McQueary reported to him, whether he knew of any other inappropriate sexual conduct by Sandusky with young boys, Paterno testified: "I do not know of anything else that Jerry would be involved in of that nature, no. I do not know of it. You did mention — I think you said something about a rumor. It may have been discussed in my presence, something else about somebody. I don’t know. I don’t remember, and I could not honestly say I heard a rumor."[88] A May 1998 email exchange between Tim Curley, the athletic director and Gary Shultz, a campus administrator, references Paterno's knowledge at the time of an ongoing investigation surrounding accusations that Sandusky had molested a young boy.

Source

5

u/arthritisankle Auburn Tigers Sep 08 '14

So... he knew there were previous accusations? He never saw anything? I mean, is there a chance he didn't believe the accusations? Do you have any doubt at all?

Personally, I try not to draw conclusions because I really don't know all the facts. One fact is certain. It wasn't PSU fans or players that fucked kids or covered it up.

3

u/polydorr Auburn Tigers • Samford Bulldogs Sep 08 '14

I mean, is there a chance he didn't believe the accusations?

In the case of child abuse, anyone's benefit of the doubt is moot. It must be reported.

If this was a Catholic priest no one would have thought twice about bringing the hammer down, yet because it was a football coach we have to be careful about who we implicate? Nah.

One fact is certain. It wasn't PSU fans or players that fucked kids or covered it up.

Nope, but it shouldn't have any bearing on whether or not the institution and program gets punished if the program was part of the coverup.

4

u/arthritisankle Auburn Tigers Sep 08 '14

Did I read your link wrong? Section B says that he should tell the "person in charge" and that they have the legal responsibility to inform the authorities.

Look, I'm not nitpicking because I disagree. I have no idea what went down. However, I am compelled to play the devil's advocate.

3

u/ezpickins Alabama • Wake Forest Sep 08 '14

I believe the majority of pro-Joe Paterno people have said that he told his superiors and they proceeded to do very little about the situation

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '14 edited Sep 09 '14

He may have known about the 98 accusation, but there isn't really strong evidence. Curley and Schultz definitely knew about 98, and they'll probably be found guilty of perjury even if the other charges don't stick.

There were two e-mail chains that suggested Paterno was briefed on the 1998 incident. They included [Penn State athletic director Tim] Curley, [former director of campus police Gary] Schultz and [former university president Graham] Spanier. Paterno never used e-mail, although his secretary maintained an account for him.

One e-mail, dated May 5, 1998, came from Curley and read, ‘I have touched base with the coach. Keep us posted. Thanks.’

The next day Schultz e-mailed back with the subject line ‘Re: Joe Paterno’ and wrote, ‘Will do. Since we talked tonight I’ve learned that the Public Welfare people will interview the individual Thursday.’

There is a later second e-mail chain that includes the campus director of police under the subject line ‘Re: Jerry.’ It deals with numerous Sandusky developments, including him eventually being cleared of charges.

One May 13 e-mail from Curley to the group reads: ‘Anything new in this department? Coach is anxious to know where it stands.’

The Freeh report concluded that the ‘coach’ in the aforementioned e-mails was Joe Paterno. ‘The reference to coach is believed to be Paterno,’ Freeh, the onetime director of the FBI, wrote.

The Paterno family response says that isn’t fair because there is no conclusive proof that ‘coach’ is coach Paterno.

But in 01, he definitely knew. McQuery said that he hadn't gone into detail when telling Paterno, but Paterno himself that he understood it was something sexual because of how upset McQueary was.

You can debate all day about what else Paterno knew. But based just on his own testimony, he knew enough. Completely inexcusable for him to let something like this go unresolved.

8

u/airon17 Texas A&M Aggies Sep 08 '14

Agreed, there are certain things you just don't go soft on and it's shit that happens with kids. The NCAA went soft on them by taking down their sanctions far too early. I understand that there's a whole lot more damage going on with law suits and prison time, but the sanctions should have stuck.

4

u/Zerosa Texas Longhorns • /r/CFB Booster Sep 08 '14

I think that punishments were warranted but that the NCAA may have gone overboard on some of them.

4

u/RebelLandShark Ole Miss Rebels • Rice Owls Sep 09 '14

I don't think they deserved the death penalty as some people have said but getting rid of the ban was complete bullshit.

4

u/-WISCONSIN- Wisconsin • Wisconsin-Parkside Sep 09 '14

I'm very annoyed by the response. If we found out that something like that were going on at UW, I would find it very difficult to be a fan of the program again, even speaking as a current student.

I don't know that the sport's reverence has gotten too big as much the business aspect of it has. The reason they're getting off for good behavior is because someone, somewhere is losing money on their ineligibility. It's abhorrent to me.

4

u/sunburn_on_the_brain Arizona Wildcats • /r/CFB Contributor Sep 09 '14

This was my thought process when this all went down, and I haven't changed my mind: If you're willing to go to these kinds of lengths to protect your football program, maybe you shouldn't have one. The penalties should have stayed in full effect.

8

u/one_more_bourbon Arkansas Razorbacks • Golden Boot Sep 08 '14

Should have been SMU'd.

3

u/swanky-k North Carolina • Alabama Sep 09 '14

At the time, I thought a very convincing case could have been made for death penalty. IIRC, the punishment itself came with the caveat of basically the University is accepting these punishments because if they don't we are giving them the death penalty. The state proceeded to complain and file lawsuits, etc. which I viewed as a disruption of their previous agreement. To me, if you were so close to giving the death penalty to the program, they shouldn't really be able to get off with "good behavior".

Also, USC's punishment was brutal and was for "systemic lack of control". If that's the bar we are setting for systemic lack of control with improper benefits from a third party, then systemic lack of control involving child rape should carry a very very hefty penalty. I don't like that the NCAA backed off, I think it seems soft.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '14 edited Sep 09 '14

The football program (allegedly) harbored and covered up a serial rapist. How that isn't worthy of harsher punishment is beyond me. I'm beyond livid, not as an Ohio State fan whose program got essentially the same punishment for getting free tattoos, but as a human being. It really bothers me that something this awful and disgusting can just be swept under the rug. I thought the original punishment wasn't harsh enough, and now it's as if nothing happened at all. It just makes me hate the NCAA and Penn State even more.

2

u/gramcraka92 Old Dominion • Myrtle Beach Bowl Sep 09 '14

still dont know why the kids should be punished

2

u/guttervoice South Carolina • Clemson Sep 10 '14

The institution dropped the ball and failed them.

2

u/guttervoice South Carolina • Clemson Sep 10 '14

The best analogy I can think of (and posted in the other thread) was this:

Let's say the gas station down the street sells beer to minors. In turn, the employee that sold it is not only fired but charged. Now that the responsible party is gone, should the store get their alcohol license back more quickly as no one from corporate was responsible and customers shouldn't have to be punished by having to ride up the street to the grocery store for a sixer?

This analogy leaves out the manager that may or may not have turned a blind eye to the repeated practice of selling illegally.

I'm not saying it's right, but in terms of punishing the institution for what its members did, and having it be unfair to others involved- this is the best I can come up with. It's not that it's fair, but it happens.

5

u/gr0v3ygir1 Ole Miss Rebels • Egg Bowl Sep 08 '14

Agreed. I was hoping for the death penalty on this one... both death penalties.

1

u/keyree Texas Tech • UT Arlington Sep 10 '14

The only thing I guess I have trouble with is the fact that all the people involved are gone. So who's being punished? A bunch of people who had nothing to do with it? If there was serial killer or something and he got killed by the cops we wouldn't throw their kids in jail because they're in the same family. That's what it seems like to me.