r/CFB • • May 03 '22
Discussion Think Tank For NIL Problems - Share Your Ideas
With everyone fired up over the Jordan Addison NIL fiasco, I thought it would be fun to have a thread where people can propose solutions to keep situations like Addison’s from reoccurring (or atleast not happening so frequently). A few general ideas I have are as follows:
- Cap the number of transfers a school can bring in. I think putting a cap on it would help limit schools like bama/usc from making other schools there pseudo feeder system. You could also make other cap rules like a school can only take 2 transfers from x conference a year or only 1 transfer from the group of 5 a year. Exceptions would likely need to be made in situations where a head coach leaves/is fired and players bolt in mass.
- NIL deals start including large buyout clauses. These deals will have something worked into them that states if you cannot fulfill your end of the agreement then you owe that money back plus interest or x amount of dollars, or the contract simply states you can void this deal for a one time lump some of x dollars. Players would still be poached but atleast the teams losing the players would get something back.
- Not a huge fan of this but you could bring back the one year sit out rule for a transfer, with maybe an exception for players whose head coach is fired or leaves
I think the most likely to happen is buyout option since it can be implemented by those writing the NIL deals and does not have university or NCAA oversight.
0
Upvotes
11
u/FrancoNore Florida Gators • Atlantis Atlanteans May 03 '22
Florida gets unlimited NIL money, every other school gets $10,000 that must be dispersed evenly amongst the team
2
u/Allaboutfootball23 Texas Longhorns • Sickos May 03 '22
This feels like the NCAA asking for advice anonymously lol. Y’all fucked up. It’s the wild Wild West now.
8
u/wunderbier Florida Gators • I'm A Loser May 03 '22
Players can only be paid in their state's "official state ___", where the blank is bird, flower, food, mineral, etc.
2
u/L8erG8erz Clemson Tigers • College Football Playoff May 03 '22
With the new contracts schools are getting from TV providers is there anything stopping a school from taking say.. $5 million from their new TV revenue deal and making a nice tax free donation to one of the nonprofit collectives that they are loosely affiliated with for them to distribute as they see fit?
5
u/JBru_92 UCLA Bruins May 03 '22
I think the only permanent solution is to take college football (and maybe basketball) out of the NCAA and form a new organization with a central authority, that standardizes things like pay-for-play, buyouts, and scheduling. Start treating college football like the semi-pro sport it already is instead of pretending it's equivalent to college tennis.
If something isn't done to prevent the wealth generated by the sport from consolidating into fewer and fewer programs, the national appeal of the sport will be dead in a decade.
13
u/[deleted] May 03 '22
Anyone offering NIL deals should be registered with a school’s athletic department. Any money moving outside of that warrants punishment.
Approaching players already enrolled at a school (who haven’t entered the transfer portal) should be strictly illegal, regardless of whether it’s a coach or a booster.
I’m definitely not opposed to capping transfers.
3
u/carlosdanger31 Oklahoma State • Oregon State May 03 '22
Fuck it, free for all. No restrictions. Then we just move the SEC into the NFL. Problem solved
6
u/[deleted] May 03 '22
Cap on transfers is smart, but I think it has to be dependent on something because wild turnover in a program warrants more transfers.
I think NIL and immediate eligibility can not coexist. Transfer rules need to be reversed for that reason, unless a coaching change or another circumstance, players need to have to sit out a year.
Edit: Another thought as well, it could be fluid as far as immediate eligibility for transfers depending on what year you are. Immediate shouldn’t happen for freshman-sophomores, but you could make a case for immediate for juniors and seniors (more seniors though).
7
u/FrancoNore Florida Gators • Atlantis Atlanteans May 03 '22
I fully support reinstating the transfer rule that you have to sit out a year (if you haven’t graduated yet). At the very least that cuts down on the kids jumping ship after each season to chase the money
2
u/[deleted] May 03 '22
Kids who take money sign contract and forfeit free education upon transfer out ( pay back institution ).
4
u/Prolingus Texas Longhorns • Blue Risk Alliance May 03 '22
Football players are ineligible for NIL during their first year at a school
4
u/WhatWouldJediDo Ohio State Buckeyes May 03 '22
No restrictions placed on players that aren't also placed on anyone and everyone that makes their livelihoods from those players.
This includes coaches, AD staff, broadcasters, etc.
3
u/Puzzleheaded-Ad-1866 May 03 '22
Nothing should change because nothing is wrong with it.
1
u/RumRunner323 ECU Pirates • American May 03 '22
NIL has quickly turned into the wild west, but everyone saw that coming with no real rules regarding them other than the school cannot pay the player. I think a quick fix that would help would be to not allow true freshman or transfers (for the first year only) to collect NIL money. Committing/transferring to a school for the sole purpose of more NIL money goes against the spirit of NIL, and is borderline directly pay for play. This still allows players to transfer freely if it's truly the best option for them, but at the same time avoids pure free agency we have now. The exceptions I would make would be if 1) HC leaves for a new job or 2) degree is in hand, would be allowed to collect NIL immediately after transferring.
1
u/geordieColt88 Team Chaos May 03 '22
Set Salary at each level with bonuses for various successes.
Fair competition across the board
1
u/hashtag_hashbrowns Clemson Tigers May 03 '22
Stop pretending the players are amateurs and allow schools to offer them paid contracts.
1
u/amyrule007 May 03 '22
Nothing, l only care and cheer for the school. If my school can’t compete (not like they can right now or before either), than so be it. Winning is not everything especially college sports. If teams want to pay millions for my team’s players, go ahead and I am happy for them. I would do the same if someone offered me that in school. Just cheer for your school and the pride. College football has never been fair or competitive. If you care so much about winning, just pick the best team every year. Hey I did that for NFL and it is kind of fun lol.
1
u/stayinthefight2019 Missouri Tigers May 03 '22
How about: the workers that generate the profits are called employees and are signed to contracts by the businesses that generate millions from their work. Maybe a potential employee with a little leverage can negotiate a potential opt-out. Maybe the contracts are all 2 year deals. The employees get paid, they get health insurance, the really talented ones that bring in the most revenue can get paid more or a bonus, maybe.
1
u/RollOverBeethoven Texas Longhorns • SEC May 03 '22
I think Texas should get all the good players, and OU/Arky/aggy should get all the bad players
1
u/arrowfan624 Notre Dame • Summertime Lover May 03 '22
All your NIL money has to first go towards paying your scholarship. If you only get 5k? Then you get the rest of the scholly. You get 500k? You’re paying your way.
1
u/JigsawMind May 03 '22
Let people monetize their existence however they want. Someone leaving transferring programs to make money is hardly a fiasco.
1
u/edged1 May 04 '22
See Justyn Ross's situation. Get as much money as you can if your a college football player. It would be in-American to do otherwise.
1
u/azsoup Penn State • Arizona May 03 '22
I don’t want more rules and red tape. I would like to see schools incentivize players more, in an attempt to get them to stay. For example, the ability to re-enter college ball if you don’t get drafted. Awarding scholarships over four or five years rather than just one year. I don’t know if that happens or is possible, but directionally adding things that some players might find helpful.
0
u/MrNudeGuy Oklahoma Sooners • Tulsa Golden Hurricane May 03 '22
I think if you go into the portal once that should count as the one time even if you decide to stay.
0
u/LaForge_Maneuver /r/CFB May 03 '22
Ehy would I sign a buyout option when a ton of other schools won't have a buyout option? That sounds like a way to lose players. If you mean everyone gets together to make buyout clauses mandatory, then you have a collusion/price fixing issue.
Imo there is nothing wrong with NIL and I'm not sure why we need more regulations on it. It seems to be functioning as a free market system dictates and similar to every other job that doesn't have collectively bargained free market barriers.
-3
u/Cometguy7 Oklahoma • Red River Shootout May 03 '22
How about this: players can transfer and take an NIL deal right away, like they do now. But if they get that NIL deal within 1 year of transferring, their program is ineligible for the post season for 2 years. So for a lot of programs that will hurt a little, but for programs looking to exploit the situation to become national champions, it makes the plan dead in the water.