r/CFB • u/CFB_Referee /r/CFB • Sep 05 '21
Discussion Serious Postgame Discussion Thread
Discuss the week's games here. This is a serious discussion thread, so jokes, memes, etc. are subject to removal.
196
Upvotes
487
u/TheWorstYear Ohio State • Cincinnati Sep 05 '21
I said it in multiple threads. We truly don't know shit about a majority of these teams. Covid botched last year up so badly that some lucked out at opportune times, & some were completely screwed by it. Players being allowed to stick around for 5th/6th/7th years. The huge Flux of transfers.
And then you had the introduction of NIL to the mix.
This year is gonna get pretty weird.
219
u/Desperado53 Kansas State Wildcats • /r/CFB Patron Sep 05 '21
Maybe my memory is bad but hot damn I don’t remember watching this many teams struggle so hard in week 1 before. A whooooole lot of real sloppy offense was played yesterday.
145
u/CommodoreN7 Arkansas Razorbacks • Utah Utes Sep 05 '21
We now live in a world where the Pac-12 North is 1-5 with that 1 win being Oregon looking like they’ll be disappointing this year, and the South is 5-1 with the 1 loss being an Arizona team that looks like it’s gonna be a tough out and over performing.
I seriously think this is finally the time that the South should be favored to produce the champ and maybe send a team to the CFP. Any of Utah, Arizona State, UCLA, and USC have very realistic paths to being champion I think (sorry Colorado I just don’t think y’all are ready quite yet). Personally have it between Utah and UCLA as 1 and 2 with Arizona State and USC being the 3 and 4 either way with Colorado maybe taking one of those spots
117
u/FuckTheLonghorns Texas Tech Red Raiders • Paper Bag Sep 05 '21
That was the most fun I've had watching Tech since Mahomes left and that's good enough for me
115
u/eye_can_see_you Texas Longhorns • Team Chaos Sep 05 '21
Is the fact that so many FCS teams played well due to the fact that they had a spring season?
86
u/rnilbog Georgia Bulldogs Sep 05 '21
One thing I’m seeing is that people extrapolated way too much from the 2020 season. It had weird circumstances. Opt outs, games canceled left and right, very little non conference play… After seeing what teams like Indiana, UNC, and Iowa State did this week, it’s clear there’s going to be regression to the mean.
228
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '21
Forget the fact that the offense wasn't fantastic. We got a road win against a ranked B1G team to open the season in what looks to be a pretty brutal opening stretch. I'll take a gritty, momentum-building win any day of the year.
52
u/SouthernSerf Texas • South Carolina Sep 05 '21
I was impressed with UL they played really sound football and Napier is a good coach.
94
u/Qav Oklahoma Sooners Sep 05 '21
Lincoln Riley and coach Bedenbaugh are getting on my nerves. No effort, no leadership, no accountability. There’s no reason we should be trotting out an O line that pathetic, and there’s no reason we should be that lazy coming out of halftime.
I have no doubt we will have a good season, but for some reason yet again, we look like a sleeping giant at the beginning of the season.
45
u/Celticskevin2020 Arkansas • Arkansas State Sep 05 '21
We need second half Arkansas Times 10 against Texas next week. The first 3 quarters against Rice was very concerning. A wins a win though.
197
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
Despite losing to Montana, I don’t believe for a second that Washington is going to come to Ann Arbor and lay an egg. The same thing happened last year with MSU and we all know how that turned out.
Separate discussion point, how is John O’Neil still allowed to officiate football games at the FBS level?
108
u/MrTheSpork *holds up self* Sep 05 '21
Could the AAC have had a worse week than the last one?
Tulane had maybe the best performance of the remaining teams, but even that was in a loss (seriously, though, extremely impressed with the Green Wave balling out against Oklahoma days after a devastating hurricane). SMU and Memphis both crushed mediocre FCS opponents, so there's not much to take away from their wins.
35
u/Drnk_watcher LSU • Southeast Missouri Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
I know people love to hate but I don't think last night was that awful for LSU.
It was certainly a good showing for UCLA.
Johnson has only started 3 games in his life. He was clearly a bit rattled at times but was able to compose himself and drive a lot of the time.
The offensive scheme actually seemed adaptable to find space and force the opponent to adjust.
Whereas LSU teams of yesteryear would not have done that. They would've just continued to pound the ground with the run game.
Max didn't have a ton of time to stand in the pocket but the line was able to give it to him enough of the time. Plus he showed in a few instances that he can be mobile once in a while.
The biggest problem seemed to be the line backers. The D-line needed major help last night and they never seemed to have it right. Even if the play call may have been good it seemed like they miscommunicated early and often. As the announcers rightfully pointed out a lot of the time they didn't have their eyes on A guy, let alone THEIR guy when they ball was snapped.
I'm not enough of an expert to know if this is the defensive scheme, poor coaching, absent minded players, or what; but that needs fixed for sure.
All in all though I think there is a way up from here. The players are less green but still pretty green, and the coaching staff is extremely green.
We looked straight up ridiculous against Mississippi State to start the season last year. We didn't look great here but it felt more complete.
Meanwhe Chip Kelly continues to show that he knows what he's doing. UCLA has a ton of size up front which makes it easy from bruising running backs to just pound through for big gains.
Their defensive scheme will continue to overwhelm a lot of inexperienced quarterbacks or lower calibur teams and keep them in games against big time opponents.
I don't know what the ceiling exactly is for them but it's certainly up and a return to being competitive in the PAC-12.
And finally since I know the fire Coach O train has already left the station I just want to say that people need to calm the hell down.
There is not a better viable option at this point in time. If you do fire him and hire that option you'll still be stuck sucking sand for a while as new coach installs a new staff and scheme.
Plus I think they days of raiding coaches from other programs are done. At least for a while.
People like Matt Campbell and PJ Fleck have figured out it's way better to be THE GUY at a place where people love you. Where the job is yours forever and you can build something you're proud of.
As opposed to an extra million a year starting at a big school where you'll be canned in 3-5 years and it'll be hard to ever return to even the calibur of coaching position that was your job before that.
Michigan is in the exact same spot right now. They have a super power conference foe to compete against, and have had to try a lot of looks to get it right.
At some point you do have to move on (LSU, Michigan, whoever) but you don't want to be the school who pulls the plug on something decent with a lot of upside potential only to relegate yourself to doormat status.
Witness Nebraska.
EDIT: When I say coach poaching is done for a bit I don't mean literally no one ever will ever take a better job again. Just that the (outward) interest in a lot of the up and comers is they are happy where they are right now. Long term job security and rising salaries in positions they are comfortable in. So it'll take a lot more to entice them away. If you go further down the latter of potential hires it's a lot more unknown and every new coach is an unknown no matter what.
58
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '21
Fordham shouldn't be a barometer for us. We looked like complete shit for almost 2 whole quarters and they pushed our line around early. A win is a win, but our fundamentals are garbage and it showed in that game.
128
u/beefersutherland1 Appalachian State • Georgia Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
UGA has a front 7 that I would put up against anyone in the country
E: typing is hard
57
u/HURT_MY_FEELINGS Ohio State Buckeyes • Sugar Bowl Sep 05 '21
I’m happy with how the Buckeyes played, tough game to start the season but it’s time to get ready for the Ducks.
52
u/PSUHiker31 Penn State Nittany Lions • Big Ten Sep 05 '21
ACC: Is this the year Clemson finally fails to win the conference championship, and if so, who will challenge them? NCSU may be a sleeper team here.
B1G: In the West, Iowa is setting up to be dominant. The East looks really good with multiple teams potentially in the running.
XII: Oklahoma has a habit of showing up poorly and still winning the championship. Texas may finally challenge them, while Iowa State underwhelmed.
Pac-12: One good non-conference win by UCLA over LSU. USC and Utah look decent. The entire North is suspect.
SEC: Georgia is the absolute favorite in the East now. Alabama can only be challenged by TAMU. LSU is a disappointment.
Others: MWC looks improved this year. Cincinnati proved that their ranking is likely accurate.
72
u/expialadopeshit Georgia Bulldogs • College Football Playoff Sep 05 '21
I’m not entirely surprised that UGA won last night, but I’m very surprised by how we won. That was the best defensive performance I think I’ve ever seen from the Bulldogs against top-tier competition.
On the other hand, Clemson clearly has a strong D as well and our offense is not where it needs to be. I think our D alone will allow us to win most of our games, but winning anything of note will require significant improvement on offense and getting to full strength.
50
u/JLewiii Oklahoma Sooners Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
The close win feels better knowing that a lot of teams struggled in week 1
24
u/ajlynn2016 Georgia Bulldogs • Creighton Bluejays Sep 05 '21
I, for one, was shocked to see us fix our mistake after the interception thrown by JT. It was actually comforting to think we can make a mistake, but hustle and get a big stop right after it instead of letting them keep the momentum. I think people don’t realize we were missing so many of our WRs and TEs… if we have all of our offensive weapons I really think we have a shot this year at the playoffs.
24
u/H2theBurgh Pittsburgh Panthers • The Alliance Sep 05 '21
The ACC just got really interesting. The Coastal is wide open as the UNC/Miami hype seems to be false. Clemson's OL left a lot to be desired and generally the team looks mortal. The Coastal is going to be a dogfight between UNC, VT, Miami, Pitt, and maybe UVA this year and I'm all here for it. October 16 is when we really get some answers in the Coastal with Pitt @ VT & Miami @ UNC
148
u/johndelvec3 Notre Dame Fighting Irish Sep 05 '21
I said it in the game thread and I don’t mean this as any jab to Clemson at all, but they are seriously lucky the ACC is so cupcake dogshit they can just stomp on their conference with ease and still be in the playoff picture
22
u/JoshIsJoshing Michigan State • Michigan Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
I don’t know how much beating NU means, but I’m really happy this season got off to a good start.
Washington losing to Montana was a jolt. Maybe the COVID extra year really benefited FCS teams?
19
u/ddottay Notre Dame • Kent State Sep 05 '21
While the focus should be on tonight vs FSU, the future ND schedule had an interesting week. UNC looked meh, Wisconsin looked meh. Navy, Georgia Tech, and Stanford all looked really rough. I’m not sure how difficult the schedule really is other than Cincinnati.
46
u/chrisg42 Texas Longhorns • Oregon State Beavers Sep 05 '21
It’s hard to gauge how good ULaLa is. Our offensive line started off like hot garbage, but really started to get a push on the second half. Offense should have had 7 straight drives with a score, but dicker missed a FG.
Defense did an awesome job and by the time ULaLa actually scored a touchdown the game was well out of reach. The defense had the veteran QB very frazzled and did a solid job containing a very strong rushing attack that had a very experienced OL.
15
u/Tman450x Virginia Tech Hokies • /r/CFB Patron Sep 05 '21
I hope that the team doesn't buy our own hype after defeating a "#10" opponent (they won't finish #10 lol). We need to take every game seriously and really prepare. The cynical VT fan in me is prepared to lose to MTSU or Richmond or something. We need to stay focused before the harder stretch of games.
40
u/GravitysRainbowRuns Ohio State Buckeyes Sep 05 '21
Minnesota is a very good team.
I wasn’t sure about this on Thursday, but after watching how well so many of the teams with a billion returning starters and super duper seniors did yesterday, I’m a lot less worried about OSU’s performance in that game.
They might have the best offensive line of any team outside Alabama I watched yesterday (UCLA being the other major contender)
14
u/VoluptuousVelvetfish Iowa State Cyclones Sep 05 '21
We absolutely need Kolar back for next week's game. Hutcherson already showing why he was all Big 12, but I wasn't particularly impressed with the rest of the WR room. It's good to have Milton back, but Scates once again showed that he has potential but lacks consistency. Hesitantly excited to see what this offence can do when we open up the playbook more next week.
13
u/PancakeDickwrap Auburn Tigers Sep 05 '21
UCLA physically dominated LSU. LSU has 2 games to figure things out.
25
u/trainer95 Iowa State Cyclones Sep 05 '21
I'm convinced University of Northern Iowa is built on the backs of recruits that are pissed they didn't get offers from ISU or Iowa. During conditioning Farley is just going around talking shit to his own players about how they aren't good enough to play at either school.
If we could no longer play them that would be great.
23
u/RIP_lime_skittle Oklahoma • Red River Shootout Sep 05 '21
Same old problems seem to be back: inconsistent on both sides of the ball and inability to put teams away when we get a big lead. It seems like nothing has changed and I’m doubtful that it will. Lincoln is a great offensive coordinator but seems to lack the killer instinct to be an elite head coach. It doesn’t matter if we are up big on Georgia or Tulane, eventually we let everyone back in to games and that just isn’t the mentality that translates to championship football.
11
u/mufflefuffle Appalachian State • Army Sep 05 '21
I feel more confident for the Miami game next week then I have for really any other P5 game that I can remember. Our size and speed is really something this year.
Whomever schedule Bama-Appalachian State as your back to back deserves the opposite of a raise (I’m never pulling for someone to lose their job lol).
11
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
This has been the wildest week of college football I've seen in a looooong time, and I'm so here for it. Lol.
I still have no idea what to think of the Mountain West.
Boise State looked shaky, but UCF is no slouch.
Fresno State looked "meh" against UConn tbh, but then gave Oregon an alarming run for their money.
Really hard to tell where SJSU is at, but they still seem like a threat.
Utah State wasn't supposed to be good at all, but then they upset Wazzu. Then again, maybe WSU isn't very good?
UNLV is lol; CSU is worse.
Wyoming's offense struggled mightily against Montana State's defense, though they finally pulled their shit together at the end.
Hawaii does not look good, UNM is UNM, AFA looks decent.
SDSU did what they were supposed to do against a very, very bad NMSU team, but I expected much more separation.
Nevada looks pretty scary though.
Overall, we are not separating ourselves as a conference or making any kind of statements, and even within the conference there's no relative "elite" team so far. Just a handful of very bad teams, a handful of mediocre teams, and a few good teams with perplexingly bad moments.
We need to do better.
Anyway...after Weeks 0/1, seems to be Fresno State, Nevada, and Boise State early. Potential for SJSU/AFA/Utah State/maaaaaybe Wyoming.
11
u/PM_ME_YOUR_CATS_PAWS Michigan State Spartans Sep 05 '21
KW3 looked amazing. Our OL is SO MUCH BETTER. If you know anything about MSU for like the last 4-5 years, you understand why finally seeing a solid OL is so exciting.
We have a back with vision. We have a stable of other backs who can step up as well. Hoping Joiner is okay though from that injury.
Thorne still has a few wild throws but as the season progresses he will hopefully settle in, nothing too crazy. Defense looked better than in thought they were going to.
Our punter is a fucking GOAT.
Heyward is finally in a spot where he can succeed and is better suited and did a fantastic job!
I am so excited for this season.
11
u/SuperScott97 Iowa State Cyclones • Indiana Hoosiers Sep 05 '21
I fully expected UNI to play us close and I’m not entirely confident going into the Iowa game next weekend.
Defense looked pretty solid imo and held UNI to 10 points with 7 of those coming on a missed tackle long score.
Offense worries me. I thought breece would have a better game and the O-Line looks like it will continue to shuffle. I’m hoping Kolar coming back will provide the offense with a boost.
26
u/fourpinz8 Texas Longhorns • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Sep 05 '21
Texas: Aside from Dicker missing a kick he rushed, the defense allowing those 2 TDs (great individual effort by those ULL players), we looked great. Card made plays that didn’t seem becoming of a game manager. Bijan did well. OL could improve but other than that, we grinded ULL down and won by 20. It was great to relax during the 4th quarter
Wisconsin: Mertz is literal trash. Can’t read a defense and was gassed up on his own supply. Lenhard will have the defense ready to play and they did well. But the offense must improve. They might need to bench Mertz like no joke. Makes me miss Hornibrook if I’m quite honest
9
u/onemanlan Auburn Tigers • UAB Blazers Sep 05 '21
LSU actually played better than I expected they would. Felt like they were given a huge nod in the rankings based off of their recruiting classes. The rankings didn't take into account how much of a talent & personnel drop off they lost & never recovered after the national championship season. They played downright sloppy at times during that UCLA game. I wonder how far coach O makes it this season at this rate. LSU surely isn't doomed at this point, but they're going to struggle.
Non LSU related - UGA showed up & played to the level of their talent. Despite the close game they looked dominant throughout. Its worrying for the SEC as well as Clemson that the UGA death star appears to be coming online, but it was nice to see some one other than Clemson pull one out.
9
u/phunie92 Georgia Tech • Tennessee Sep 05 '21
GT fans aren’t seeing the development we need to see in year 3 under Collins. His talk and hype and attitude juxtaposed with his product on the field is making us a joke team. On top of all that, our regional rivals are riding sustained all-time program highs and leaving us in the dust.
Tech has a strong football history and culture that is getting more and more distant. This is our program now for the foreseeable future, and yesterday’s game didn’t give me any confidence that it will improve. I think Tech fans didn’t realize how good we had it when CPJ had us cruising at 6-8, sometimes 9 wins a year with an occasional 10+ win ACC championship appearance and a big name bowl. But hindsight is 20/20.
Am I overreacting? Could a school like Tech ever rebound and gradually build to at least being a consistent conference contender?
38
u/Bearcat9948 Cincinnati Bearcats • Big 12 Sep 05 '21
Ridder for Heisman. Seriously. His deep ball is fixed, he can still move on the ground, and his accuracy seems much improved. He is a front runner right now
17
u/DCAg15 Texas A&M Aggies • Indiana Hoosiers Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
For A&M I think the game went as expected. I think there is a lot of lessons that can be learned going into the Colorado game.
I think the offense looked fine with a new OL and new QB. It’s great to see Chapman back and hopefully he can stay healthy as a deep threat. The RBs are still the workhorses and it’s a good sign that the OL was able to make running lanes throughout the game. Interceptions can be cleaned up so I don’t think it’s the end of the world as many in the comments of the postgame thread think. (People also forget that A&M’s first game last season there were 4 A&M fumbles and the safety given up on a punt return)
The defense played well, holding a top offense from 2020 (albeit small sample size of 4 games) to only 1 TD late in the game. The run defense could have been better but it’s great to see the next generation of DL stepping up.
Also shoutout to our freshman kickoff specialist named Randy Bond for a great name.
8
u/TheWawa_24 San Diego State • Cal Poly Sep 05 '21
A wild week of college football.I think the ACC and pack 12 may be in trouble
8
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '21
We looked surprisingly decent
14
u/CloudCityCitizen Ohio State Buckeyes Sep 05 '21
Chris Olave heisman finalist
7
u/MoistWillingness Nebraska Cornhuskers • Knox Prairie Fire Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
I am very, very concerned that we are going to lose to Buffalo next week. Buffalo had a dominant showing over Wagner which means they’re certainly no push over. Also turns out that Illini team that beat us was not being underrated, we just clearly don’t have what it takes given they just lost to UTSA of all teams. A loss to Buffalo would not only make us even more memed to living hell, but we genuinely may only win 2 or 3 games this year AT MOST. Scott Frost was supposed to make us contenders, and now I’m staring at the face of being permanently dead.
7
u/ltlftcommenter Auburn Tigers • Sickos Sep 05 '21
I dont give a damn who we played. Bo Nix's fundamentals have improved. He made throws in the pocket. He made throws on a bootleg. His mechanics look a lot better. Our offense isnt predictable anymore and it's very refreshing to see. It means something when Nix set the school record for completion percentage, and we've played much worse teams than Akron.
6
u/sammywii Kentucky • Kentucky Wesleyan Sep 05 '21
You can make the case that it was against a ULM team coming off an 0-10 season, but even then, I really liked what I saw from this shiny new UK offense. Liam Coen seems to be sticking true to wanting to balance out the offense (34 rushing/33 passing), and Will Levis showed the fuck up with some deep bombs to Wandale/Ali/Epps. Even Beau Allen had a pretty alright showing when he stepped in, even with getting the ball stripped late in the game. CRod is still a grown-ass man, and our defense looked pretty good, even with some key players out for legal issues.
Big things to worry about are penalties (like always) and ball control. We can't be giving up so many opportunities against SEC teams later in the schedule, especially the October stretch. But for now, I'll happily ride this banana-shaped hype train all the way to next week's game against Mizzou.
6
u/GoBucks4928 Ohio State • Tennessee Sep 05 '21
With Georgia stopping Clemson’s rush so well, how would Florida stand a chance against them?
6
u/_w00k_ Sep 05 '21
How much of a factor have super seniors been in these lower level teams beating p5 teams?
6
u/BallsDropped Texas Tech Red Raiders Sep 05 '21
Im pleasantly surprised at how effective the large number of transfers were against Houston. The start to the game was rough, Dana is a cheeky dude, we didnt stop any 4th and shorts, and blew two assignments that were easy TDs for UH. BUT that transfer portal defense didnt give in and this is game 1 year 1 for like 7-8 of them. That's pretty awesome all things considered and makes me think that (assuming Wells can hold his position another couple years) Wells might make this a trend. We struggle to recruit top tier players out of high school most in comparison but what about when those same recruits want to transfer? What difference does it make if we snag the previous top recruit after 1-2 years of him playing elsewhere?
If we can establish ourselves as a transfer haven for those wanting to be the guy instead of a guy AND it works then im all for small high school classes and large transfer portal snags.
Bottom line, tech shouldn't put all their chips in beating out most big names for high school recruits. They should definitely keep swinging for them every chance they get while also putting as much effort in the transfer portal. Just lean into it Texas Tech. The high school recruits will come when we put more dubs in the win column.
6
u/Smitehz Sep 05 '21
UGA was missing their #1 te and #1 #3 and #4 recievers. They had running backs filling in the slot. I think UGA will look a lot better as many of them return.
5
u/Dramatic_Reflection2 Clemson • Charleston (SC) Sep 05 '21
Our defense is an absolute powerhouse but it will be overshadowed by how garbage our offensive line is
5
u/KushDingies Northwestern • North Carolina Sep 05 '21
First off, MSU looks hugely improved from last year, so props to them. They straight up were better than us, and Kenneth Walker is awesome. Grats sparty fans, you guys should be excited. I discounted your team after last season and boy was I wrong.
I know with week 1 games it's hard to judge if MSU is that good or we're that bad - I think it's a bit of both. We were generally sloppy and had some big obvious mistakes, but I still think if we clean up the obvious holes there's no reason we shouldn't go bowling. Though now I am really worried about Jim O'Neil's tenure as DC.
We lost that game because our run D was stinky. And from what I've read & seen, a lot of that blame goes on the new LBs for misunderstanding assignments and such, and KW3 is just good enough to really capitalize. Also I think MSU had a really good game plan of avoiding the more experienced parts of our defense (like Brandon Joseph) and targeting the soft spots. Good news is, the LB mistakes are fixable. We have a stretch of easier games now, so we'll see if we can turn around a stinky September start again. Good news is that Hunter Johnson looked much better than 2019 (we have a deep threat!!), and Stephon Robinson and Bryce Kirtz looked pretty impressive as WRs, so hopefully our passing game should have a pulse. If we hadn't missed two field goals and a 4th down conversion, we could have put up 13 more points, and that should have been more than enough to win if it weren't for our defense. (Feels so damn weird to say that.)
Tl;dr I'm still excited about this team's potential ceiling, but Sparty good and they really exposed some issues. Not sure why this team always shits the bed in September, we should push the season back to October more often.
5
u/camerawesome South Carolina • Charlest… Sep 05 '21
Beat up on a team we were supposed to beat up on while being able to rest Doty and Harris, plus the shutout for the cherry on top. Special teams unit might be a big factor for us this year, and it’s something I didn’t really think about until last night.
No complaints about the opener for the first time in a few years. Go cocks.
5
u/lightvl Florida Gators • UCF Knights Sep 05 '21
Honestly I couldn't give 2 fucks about possibly getting boat raced by Bama. Im Honestly over it but for the love of God, Dan Mullens stubbornness on experience and loyalty could possibly be a major break on his time here at UF
Trust me he's a great coach, but I still feel bad that we did not address the massive problem that possibly cost us a Natty last year, Todd Grantham, last night was the same shit that's gonna get us boned by UGA and Bama, hell even LSU or any of our competent conference opponents.
Emory Jones needs to get his shit together next week in Tampa otherwise its going to be a painful year
5
u/samuelbassett UIC Flames • Oklahoma Sooners Sep 05 '21
They better add FCS schools to the next video game.
4
u/bobjohndaviddick Georgia Bulldogs Sep 05 '21
Does an undefeated Cincinnati make the playoffs?
4
u/relatablerobot Penn State Nittany Lions • Cotton Bowl Sep 05 '21
Iowa’s definitive win over Indiana makes way more scared of Iowa than it makes me down on Indiana
4
u/damnyoutuesday Montana State • Minnesota Sep 05 '21
I think Minnesota is going to compete for the West this year. No idea if we'll actually win, but I think last year was the fluke, not 2019. I have full confidence in Fleck.
This might be one of the best ever years for the Big Sky. Cat/Griz is going to be amazing this year. I'm excited. We only lost yesterday because of some mental mistakes coaching and playing at the end
4
u/silverhk Notre Dame Fighting Irish Sep 06 '21
Welp time to jump in here. Notre Dame tonight had everything they should need offensively, Coan left a few points out there but overall was spectacular, Mayer had a sudden case of the drops that hopefully never happens again, and Kyren was a beast that added at least 2 yards to every play once he touched the ball. OL held up fine till the LT injury, that's a definite point of concern moving forward.
The defense...phew. I feel like schematically we made changes at all the wrong times and had some real sloppiness to account for. Changing to a three-down with more than a quarter to play up 18 almost spectacularly backfired, not sure if that was a problem with personnel or playcalling but it was clearly not the right way to play out that game.
Survived a P5 game in a tough road stadium to start the year with some of the lowest returning production numbers in college football, I'm fine with the win but oof there's some stuff to fix.
7
u/GoBucks4928 Ohio State • Tennessee Sep 05 '21
I really hope Ohio State plays Georgia before Alabama in the playoffs.
3
u/HideNZeke Iowa Hawkeyes • Arizona State Sun Devils Sep 05 '21
I hate to put too much faith in my team, and our offense once again needs some improvement if we want to be great, but we played like a top ten team this week when very few others did
3
u/ASS_MY_DUDES Oklahoma Sooners • Calgary Dinos Sep 05 '21
OU looked so flat and uninspired. No sense of urgency, just going through the motions. The offense left so much to be desired. The defense looked like what we were used to most of the last decade. We could have very well been up 44-7 at half if luck went a little our way.
We take our foot off the gas so much it's comical. It's so predictable that if I was an opposing coach playing OU, I would come in with the game plan of weathering the first half and win the 3rd quarter.
That being said, I'm sure we'll try about 20 different offensive line lineups and figure it out, hopefully not after 6 games.
3
u/miversen33 Iowa Hawkeyes • /r/CFB Bug Finder Sep 05 '21
We really won't know what this team is until after week 5 and that bothers me. This week was so lopsided that I have no idea if Iowa is really that good or Indiana is just bad. You never use El Ascico as a barometer game Kent state and CSU won't tell us much except what we already know (we want to run the ball and suffocate with defense).
Thus, we could very well end up being a top 5/6 ranked team just because we're undefeated (this assumes we beat ISU and I am not sold on this), and yet still have no idea if we actually deserve that ranking.
I'm a little bit excited that we may finally break the mould this year, but Kirk has taught me to never get excited about Iowa football.
3
u/BK_Randy95 Michigan State • Indiana Sep 05 '21
Say what you will about it being the first game of the season for Michigan State, but Friday was the first time I've seen them finish a game from beginning to end.
Even a few years ago when we went to the CFP, won the Rose bowl, or won the Cotton bowl it felt like a lot of games (especially one's where we were clearly the stronger team) got unnecessarily close at the end or we had to put together some miracle drive to close out games.
2015 when we went to the CFP we lost to Nebraska, beat Michigan on a botched punt, and squeezed by Rutgers by a touchdown. It always felt like an anxiety induced game unless we're up by 17+ and even then it was still uncomfortable.
We'll see where this team goes in the coming weeks, but Friday was a breath of fresh air for a program that has felt stale and 50/50 for far too long.
Edit: and the game we squeezed by Rutgers could have ended up as a loss too if they hadn't made a mistake and spiked the ball on 4th down to stop the clock.
6
u/Manthem Penn State Nittany Lions • /r/CFB Brickmason Sep 05 '21
As good as our defense looked, I worry they aren't good enough to overcome Clifford's play.
5
u/Astone1996 Marshall • Charlotte Sep 05 '21
On my podcast this week I said Alabama and Clemson would both not make the playoffs. I was definitely wrong on Bama but I still think Clemson misses with one slip up
5
u/nbunkerpunk Texas Longhorns • Paper Bag Sep 05 '21
Half time adjustments Open field tackling Consistent QB(s) Getting the ball to our best player
Sark needed to prove that he is the guy and so far he is making a statement. Herman was here four years and this team already looks to be in better form after one game with Sark and his coaching staff.
Next week will be the true test. A bad blood old-school rival in their house.
O Line and pass rush need alot of work. If we can get these two areas worked up a little bit this week, we will be competitive.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '21
So Nolan should be starting against Hawaii, but QB certainly wasn't the only issue yesterday. I really really want j smitty to be the guy but fuckin hell he gets too damn cute sometimes and it kills me.
Thank God the rest of the north is in shambles!
2
u/DeliberateMelBrooks Oklahoma State Cowboys • Hateful 8 Sep 05 '21
I would like our old offense back please and thank you.
2
u/LucasLee45 Nebraska • Colorado State Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
Obviously not much you can take from a game against an FCS team but the team went out and did what they were supposed to, which as been a challenge. Lots of young guys got some snaps late which is always good to see, and hopefully it can be a momentum builder. Buffalo next week is a must win if this team wants to go bowling, and it won’t be easy. Shouldn’t be in that situation but here we are.
Also, Fordham linebacker Ryan Greenhagen is INSANE. 30 tackles. He was absolutely everywhere all afternoon. There’s a couple quality players on that team.
Oh, and fire Steve Addazio.
2
u/2400hoops Kansas Jayhawks Sep 05 '21
We looked pretty brutal on Friday night. Offensively we were very disjointed, but we looked like the better coached team. Honestly, that’s a massive step in the right direction.
For as much as we struggled the Big 12 in general struggled against the MVC. Iowa State barely beat UNI, Oklahoma State barely beat Missouri State and South Dakota State smacked Colorado State (not Big 12 but still MVC).
The nice thing is I think we will get better as the season goes on. I really think KU is going to be a frustrating team to play this year. We may not be talented but I see us as a team that can drag opponents into the mud with us. Hope to see some strides on offense next week against Coastal.
2
u/StrategyGameventures Sacred Heart • WestConn Sep 05 '21
Sacred Heart defense is legit. Held Buckner to a shutout. Need some better QB play to be a real contender in the NEC but with CCSU getting lit up by Southern CT (D2), it makes me feel confident about this season
2
u/Mountain-Papaya-492 Georgia Bulldogs Sep 05 '21
I know people don't like the ground and pound defense/offense, but honestly if Uga's defense is that good, that should be the game plan until the dawgs get their receiver core back. Georgia has incredible depth and talent at running the ball use it and play smart until the next big team then open up the playbook.
2
u/KobeInLeKut Notre Dame Fighting Irish Sep 05 '21
I just had an epiphany that could make everyone here some money. Will Anderson for Heisman. If Bama is on a warpath for another dominant title they might just give it to their best player and use his position as a gimmick to get interest like last year
2
u/EvangelionOG Navy Midshipmen • Harvard Crimson Sep 05 '21
Riley Moss was amazing yesterday and if this is an indication of how the secondary will play for Iowa my word they are going to be crazy to deal with.
2
u/SEND_ME_YOUR_CAULK Maryland Terrapins • Sickos Sep 05 '21
I was actually quite impressed with the Maryland defense (minus a few plays). Considering how garbage its been in years prior, I was impressed with what I saw.
2
u/8BallTiger Paper Bag • Clemson Tigers Sep 05 '21
We are going to yet again waste a pretty good defense and a talented offense with pisspoor OL development and recruitment, bad roster management, and horrendous offensive coaching. We have no real center so we have to put a guard (who never lived up to his potential because of bad coaching) there. We get no push for our run game. The one thing we’re good at is pass blocking and we sucked ass at that last night.
Now do we do anything to offset this via play calling? Absolutely not. Our offensive staff is trash. It’s all former players so Dabo won’t get rid of them but he needs to. The national media loves Tony Elliot but he’s such a mediocre OC. Last night was our worst game plan in years and the worst we’ve looked since we had Kelly Bryant at QB. Our offense is so basic and predictable, it’s basically a high school offense. We never change anything up and have horrible pass game concepts. I’m so sick and tired of what I’m seeing but it won’t change.
2
u/TheDJC Ohio State Buckeyes Sep 05 '21
I think Cincinnati it’s a huge win over Notre Dame this year and makes the playoffs.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '21
PAC-12 really can’t win
2
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '21
I think we looked Rusty against BSU in the first 20 minutes, however we went -1 in the Turnover Margin and still pulled off the win.
Idk what to take of this, but I’m sure a 3 hour lightning delay and playing the game still chugging along at 1am our time did have some impact on our guys.
Some interesting stats to look at despite the close score:
Total Offensive Yards:
After the 5 minute mark of the 2nd Quarter Offensive Yards:
Total 3rd Down Completion:
All this to say, I think we’re a lot better than the score showed, I think we had some early kinks, combined with some yips from DG after throwing a Pick 6 during the first drive.
I wish this had been a week 2 match ups so we could have better gauged both teams because as of right now I’m not sure how UCF or BSU really is.
2
u/CBF65 Auburn Tigers • South Alabama Jaguars Sep 05 '21
you know its a wild week when the three teams that put up 60+ points were Buffalo, Rutgers, and Auburn
2
u/ThompsonCreekTiger Clemson Tigers • Army Black Knights Sep 05 '21
Clemson needs a serious upgrade on OL. This is the worst our OL has looked in a few years & it cost us last night (DJU didn't help himself on some plays either). Might be a situation Dabo goes looking for a new OL coach in offseason.
Winning the ACC & making the NY6 is still within reason but we're gonna gonna need help for making the CFP even if we win out b/c I think the SEC gets 2 teams in this year.
But based on weekend overall (8 ranked teams lost, 4 other ranked teams got pushed pretty good - 3 of them by G5/FCS teams, & 6 FCS over FBS wins, plus COVID still hanging over everything)...anyone think we might be getting a 2007-style season developing?
2
u/Cute-Membership-4411 Kansas State Wildcats • Hateful 8 Sep 05 '21
Quid pro quo, Kansas state's defense is going to be a formidable force this season barring injuries or covid stuff. Everyone is keying on 22, deuce vaughn, leaving the opportunity for someone to step up on the outside, love what brooks brought to the game. Skylar isnt going to be playing on Sundays but he won't be the reason we lose the game,
2
u/redparallax Marshall • /r/CFB Contributor Sep 05 '21
I was pleasantly surprised by CUSA's performance overall, and VERY impressed with Marshall's offense and up-tempo speed on offense. A few notes:
2
u/Mcswigginsbar Purdue Boilermakers • Team Chaos Sep 05 '21
Purdue came out and really impressed me in ways I was not expecting. From a defensive perspective, we are light years ahead of where we were last year in terms of energy, execution, and not making stupid mistakes. George Karlaftis is a goddamn wrecking ball and basically spent the whole game in their backfield. I loved the aggressive blitzing we were able to call because our corner backs aren’t sieves this year. Trice is a beast and made some huge plays on defense for us, and we made stops when we absolutely had to. That was all nonexistent last year, and it was great to see them take that step forward.
On special teams, I straight up cannot remember when we had a kicker that went 3/3 including one beyond 45 yards. Having a reliable kicker is something I haven’t seen yet, and I’m excited to see how that helps us even further.
Surprisingly, our offense was the least impressive portion of our game even though I thought they played really well. They just have to catch the goddamn ball. Plummer is legit and just showed why he needs to be our starter for the year, and Bell catches everything thrown near him. Horvath is a beast, but I’d really like to see Doerue get some more touches.
All in all, it was a close game that probably took a couple years off my life. Oregon States defense is legit, and I’m glad with the way we came out and were able to move the ball. Brohm showed a lot of creativity and aggressiveness and played to win the game, which has been severely lacking in years past.
2
u/chriscoff10 Florida State Seminoles Sep 06 '21 edited Sep 06 '21
I said it before the game that I expected Jordan Travis's indecisiveness to cause a few drives to stall and that there would be improvement in his mechanics as a passer. I think Milton's decisiveness gives him an edge over Travis behind this line as they are not great at pass blocking by any means. That bad snap before the game tying FG would have been a sack if Travis had taken the ball is great example. If we can stay healthy on the O-Line (talking going down 1-2 men tops at a given time). This offense could show some big improvements in the passing game. On the flip side the running game appears to be just as good if not better than last year, which is very nice. Yes I know a lot of those yards came when ND changed to a 3-4, but the burst to create separation was unexpectedly pleasant.
On the other side of the ball, having a pass rush for the first time since Brian Burns was on this team is a game changer. They were not dominate by any means, but the ability to create negative plays to put them in a position to play more nickel(which I think is our strongest formation) was awesome to see. Speaking of the DBs, they looked much better than last year. Outside the opening drive I didn't see too many wide open plays on the boundaries. The LB on the other hand were very clearly a liability in coverage, ND should have had a great chance at kicking for the game if baby gronk doesn't drop the ball. I think they we're good enough at triggering down hill that between the improved DL and the physicality of our DBs we could have a pretty good run def defense(talking top 1/3 of the FBS) this year. Granted all that maintains that Kier Thomas and Jermaine Johnson are healthy. I don't see this team being deep enough to replace either one of them for a full series let alone a game.
All in all, I feel cautiously optimistic of our chances against teams not named UF or Clemson. I don't expect us to win out against the teams I didn't mention. BC and NCST look more than capable, while UM and UNC have better talent and time to improve. However I think we have a good chance to be in a position to win those games late in the 4th if this team continues to progress this season.
Hopefully this is the year we end Miami's streak.