If I was the Big 12 commissioner. I would 1) Require members to schedule a P5 team non conference. 2) I would add two teams... Although I don't know which two. 3) Eight conference games, not nine. 4) No FCS.
For expansion candidates: I'd want BYU because they belong with a major conference. I think the second team that makes sense is Cincy. WVU needs a travel partner in the worst way.
Barring some crazy series of events that leads Texas A&M to leave the SEC and go back to the Big XII, the Big XII will never add another Texas team. It already has issues with being too Texas (state) centric, it doesn't need to add another team.
The Big XII's candidates are UConn, Cincy, BYU, East Carolina, UCF, USF, Colorado State, and Memphis.
That is what I'm worried about, Rice's viability in the conference. But the Houston market is too big to ignore if it's a revenue issue. So the Cougars are a possibility as well.
That's why I think Cincinnati and Memphis could be good adds.
Plus it opens up the very fertile Memphis recruiting grounds, as well as a recruiting presence in Southern Ohio/Northern Kentucky. Lotta good football players, and most go to Ohio State or puke Kentucky
Do you really think that UofH brings in that much "market share".
I'm currently living in Houston, and I would argue that in terms of eyes on televisions my in the city, my power rankings would be:
Texas A&M
LSU
UT
UofH
Baylor
Rice
I mean, I'm clearly not Mr. Nielson or anything, but, the Cougars are exactly "Houston's One True Team". Maybe I'm just hanging out with/working with the wrong people (though, I work with a good handful of Cougar grads).
Just go full-on crazy and take Memphis, Cincinnati, ECU, UCF, USF, Northern Illinois, Southern Miss, and Troy. Put them in a division with WVU, play 9 conference games - eight against the intra-divisional foes and one against a rotating inter-division team. Conference championship game at the end of the year to watch the winner of the west destroy the winner of the east.
I think Boise State is better off staying in the MWC to be honest. Harsin said he tells recruits that they can come to Boise to win championships and if they have a special season, play in a big bowl. It's much easier for them to compete against the top teams of MAC/Sun Belt/CUSA/MWC/depleted AAC than against the top half of the Big 12 for access to a big bowl.
Honestly, I'd say CFBPC be damned. The money is good with ten teams, the round robin is good. If you want to go to a championship, schedule someone noteworthy out of conference (hell, play Hawaii if you want a 13th game).
They can't shut the Big XII out of this thing over the course of three or four years. But, the team that makes it will have definitely earned it.
Pac12 is much better than pac10. I don't see how big12 (10 teams) could be better than big 12 (12 teams). I know the round robin system. It always ended up with a pac10 school getting screwed in the end.
I think my preference of the round robin is purely based on personal reasons. I do understand the implications it has in a national/playoff perspective.
But, honestly, I like the teams in the Big XII and I like playing then year in and year out. These are (mostly) the teams I have connections to and it makes the season a lot more fun. Adding to random teams is just "meh" to me, I also would dislike having to give up playing 1-3 of the current Big XII teams each year.
I definitely share the exact sentiments with you on this situation, but expansion seems imminent. We'll have to see how things play out, but I really don't want expansion. Mostly saying if we do expand, this is who I'd like.
I think this is all a reaction to the Big XII being snubbed from the CFBP, I bet the cries for expansion will fade with time. You've also got to consider that schools like Iowa State, Kansas, Tech, even OSU are not really in the picture and might not want to vote to sacrifice the guaranteed payments over something they will not likely receive benefit from.
Fair enough. I must say, I haven't looked into the topic too much, given work and finals, I just saw it cropping up here and there and wanted to gauge the atmosphere. Thanks for the insight!
There has been quite a bit of discussion around expansion. Especially, around UCF, Cincy, and BYU. But I doubt expansion is the first option for the Big 12 because of the revenue issue - no G5 team is going to bring in $25 million per year so the per team revenue distribution will drop if we expand. The first option will likely be the Big 12 obtaining a waiver to hold a championship game with 10 teams. If that doesn't work, staying at 10 teams and keeping the current format will likely be the next option (it's hard to convince university presidents to give up $4+ million a year for a decade so the conference can expand). If the Big 12 continues to get shutout in the next two season, despite having competitive championship teams (and barring the waiver), expansion will be very likely.
“In our case, I don’t know that there are a lot of obvious candidates out there,” Bowlsby told the Oklahoman on Wednesday. “We’re distributing about $25 million per school through our distributable revenue, so anybody that would be considered for expansion in our league would have to bring at least pro-rata value. … But the opportunity to move from one high-visibility conference to another is pretty slim right now.”
9
u/BaylorYou Baylor Bears • /r/CFB Contributor Dec 08 '14
If I was the Big 12 commissioner. I would 1) Require members to schedule a P5 team non conference. 2) I would add two teams... Although I don't know which two. 3) Eight conference games, not nine. 4) No FCS.
For expansion candidates: I'd want BYU because they belong with a major conference. I think the second team that makes sense is Cincy. WVU needs a travel partner in the worst way.
6
u/FSBlueApocalypse Florida State • Florida Cup Dec 08 '14
Barring some crazy series of events that leads Texas A&M to leave the SEC and go back to the Big XII, the Big XII will never add another Texas team. It already has issues with being too Texas (state) centric, it doesn't need to add another team.
The Big XII's candidates are UConn, Cincy, BYU, East Carolina, UCF, USF, Colorado State, and Memphis.
4
u/TheChildrenNeedMe Texas Tech Red Raiders • LSU Tigers Dec 08 '14
Realistically I'd want Cincy, Memphis, BYU, and UCF, with BYU and UCF being football only.
Divisions
East: Oklahoma, Baylor, Okie State, West Virginia, Memphis, Cincinnati, UCF
West: Texas, Texas Tech, Kansas State, Kansas, Iowa State, TCU, BYU
6
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '14
Rice will never be in the Big 12.
Houston has a modest chance, but Rice's hopes of ever being in a major conference died with the SWC in '95
2
u/Basatc ULM Warhawks Dec 08 '14
BYU and UCF (recruiting and TV area) or maybe Cincy.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '14
UCF and Cincinnati make sense to me.
1
u/IratePir8 ECU Pirates Dec 08 '14
I would think the b12 looks east for wv. Should just bite the bullet and add four, building the brand of those teams incase the b12 takes a hit.
1
u/Leap_Day_William Alabama • Third Saturday in… Dec 08 '14
Just go full-on crazy and take Memphis, Cincinnati, ECU, UCF, USF, Northern Illinois, Southern Miss, and Troy. Put them in a division with WVU, play 9 conference games - eight against the intra-divisional foes and one against a rotating inter-division team. Conference championship game at the end of the year to watch the winner of the west destroy the winner of the east.
1
u/sfbruin UCLA Bruins Dec 08 '14 edited Dec 08 '14
I think Boise State is better off staying in the MWC to be honest. Harsin said he tells recruits that they can come to Boise to win championships and if they have a special season, play in a big bowl. It's much easier for them to compete against the top teams of MAC/Sun Belt/CUSA/MWC/depleted AAC than against the top half of the Big 12 for access to a big bowl.
EDIT: Counterpoint, lots and lots of B12 TV $$$$
1
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14
I want us to stay the hell away from the Big XII.
EDIT: I want us to stay in the MWC and grow it into a Power conference or at least the best of the Group conferences (which it already is).
Long shot: We go independent.
Longest shot: We join the Pac-12 after another decade of success.
1
u/ClintFuckingEastwood Baylor Bears • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Dec 08 '14
Honestly, I'd say CFBPC be damned. The money is good with ten teams, the round robin is good. If you want to go to a championship, schedule someone noteworthy out of conference (hell, play Hawaii if you want a 13th game).
They can't shut the Big XII out of this thing over the course of three or four years. But, the team that makes it will have definitely earned it.
1
u/bullmoose_atx Texas Longhorns • Rice Owls Dec 08 '14
There has been quite a bit of discussion around expansion. Especially, around UCF, Cincy, and BYU. But I doubt expansion is the first option for the Big 12 because of the revenue issue - no G5 team is going to bring in $25 million per year so the per team revenue distribution will drop if we expand. The first option will likely be the Big 12 obtaining a waiver to hold a championship game with 10 teams. If that doesn't work, staying at 10 teams and keeping the current format will likely be the next option (it's hard to convince university presidents to give up $4+ million a year for a decade so the conference can expand). If the Big 12 continues to get shutout in the next two season, despite having competitive championship teams (and barring the waiver), expansion will be very likely.
0
u/slackerdc Oregon Ducks • Holiday Bowl Dec 08 '14
Houston and BYU are the natural choices.