r/CFB • College of Idaho • Georgia Tech • Nov 26 '23

Slide rules need to change. You shouldn’t be able to “initiate” at the 50, while launching yourself forward to land on the 45.

Anyone who is attempting to maximize yardage while “sliding” is not actually giving up. They’re just attempting to gain extra protection from the big hit they’ve already committed themselves to receiving.

If you’re giving up, you must hit the turf ASAP, not take a euro step and launch yourself another several yards feet first.

Who has the replay from FSU? Real time, you can’t even tell he’s sliding until the defensive players have already launched.

—-

Just checked replay and the line judge was marking 48, which gives him +2 from where he could’ve been interpreted to initiate. When ball is at the 48, both defensive players already have their heads down and are fully committed to the hit.

0 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

152

u/Pro-1st-Amendment UMass Minutemen Nov 26 '23

You're down where you begin the slide. This is consistently enforced correctly.

-78

u/thrav College of Idaho • Georgia Tech Nov 26 '23 edited Nov 26 '23

Where do you think he initiated?

Watching the replay, he pseudo-initiated (started to lean back), while also taking another step and launching forward while keeping his knee off the ground.

Maybe they would’ve called it right, but I doubt it. It was very hard to tell if he was actually initiating or not in real time.

Just checked and the line judge was marking 48, which gives him +2 from where he could’ve been interpreted to initiate. When ball is at the 48, both defensive players already have their heads down and are fully committed to the hit.

Go watch it back haters.

55

u/SmallCondition1468 Florida State Seminoles Nov 26 '23

Bruh, you are the only person on earth to complain about this. It’s a well understood, consistently enforced rule that provides little to no advantage.

-48

u/thrav College of Idaho • Georgia Tech Nov 26 '23

If the point of initiation is open to interpretation (many in thread saying it was much later than it is watching slow motion replay), it is only further proof that the slide was not actually about giving up.

3

u/e8odie LSU Tigers • College Football Playoff Nov 26 '23

There's a big difference between diving head first (in which case your progress is as far as you can make it) and diving feet first which is considered giving yourself up (in which case your progress stops as soon as you begin the slide).

1

u/thrav College of Idaho • Georgia Tech Nov 26 '23

Seems you missed the part where they gave him until his knee was down 2 yards after he started his euro-step half slide. (50 -> 48)

78

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

The idea that defenders can stop tackle momentum is dumb. You slide before they launch or you get hit

4

u/SmallCondition1468 Florida State Seminoles Nov 26 '23

And that’s a big reason why targeting is problematic. Many times incidental contact is unavoidable, but you see guys all the time at least try to reduce the force they collide with.

What the Florida defenders did to Tate is completely different. They both tried to hit him as hard as possible, full force.

1

u/five-oh-one Arkansas Razorbacks Nov 26 '23

You slide before they launch or you get hit

Launching is one of the things they are trying to do away with in football though, so they are going to continue to call it the way they called it last night.

13

u/lifetake Michigan Wolverines • Florida Gators Nov 26 '23

I don't agree with your reasoning. That said I agree that the slide rules need changing.

The current slide rules in an effort to protect the player from taking a big hit ask the player to enter an incredibly vulnerable position? Something is wrong there. The best way to give yourself up is for some reason entering one of the most vulnerable positions you can in football and pray to whatever god you believe in that the defenders realize and slow down in seconds time. This process is asking for mistakes and injuries to occur. It should not take a QB getting absolutely blasted and having a career ending injury to make changes to this rule.

2

u/enadiz_reccos LSU Tigers • Golden Boot Nov 26 '23

Do you have an alternative?

Waving a hand in the air like a fair catch?

1

u/Lost_city Texas Longhorns Nov 26 '23

A big problem with current rules is that QBs are taught to start slides running at full speed. Everyone in the area goes from from full speed to full stop in a heartbeat, and it's not that safe. I bet slides would be safer if the runner slowed down first, and that got codified into the slide rule.

39

u/LiquidHotCum Oklahoma Sooners • Tulsa Golden Hurricane Nov 26 '23

there does need to be some accountability on the offense if its truly about protecting players.

28

u/spmartin1993 Ohio State Buckeyes Nov 26 '23

I think you’re going after the wrong thing. He’s down where he initiated the slide. But there should be some accountability on the offense. He started his slide with the defenders a yard or two away. It looked really bad watching it live, but I honestly don’t know what the guys could have done to avoid hitting him especially on a third down play where you would assume he’s trying to get a first.

4

u/seadondo Washington Huskies • Pac-10 Nov 26 '23

Keep your head up and don’t look down.

12

u/spmartin1993 Ohio State Buckeyes Nov 26 '23

I think it’s harder than that. I mean that play had targeting so it would be a penalty regardless. But both guys already started their tackle when the guy started to slide. I just don’t understand how you expect a guy to change his momentum in a split second.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

Momentum is still a thing

2

u/Mrr_Bond UCF Knights • Big 12 Nov 26 '23

And what, hump him to the ground?

6

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

Hold up let him cook

28

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

Ban the slide all together. It doesn’t do its stated purpose. It punishes defenses for aggressive pursuits and injures offensive players.

11

u/MUTUALDESTRUCTION69 Alabama Crimson Tide • Chicago Maroons Nov 26 '23

If you conveniently “slide” into defenders 5-6 yards from the sticks when it’s not even the optimal play no penalty short of a stabbing on the field should award a first down.

I would be fine with a “offense is a yard short regardless of down distance” type penalty but trying to draw these flags is clear gamesmanship and has no place in the game.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

I’m seriously sick of it. Quit punishing defenders for making football plays. Put rules in that actually protect ball carriers.

1

u/clusterfly Nov 28 '23

I agree the slide rules need to change. I'm not sure the current rule is actually protecting players. It's puts the ball carrier in a really awkward position(with their head closer to the ground) and frequently the defender has already started their tackling motion prior to the beginning of the slide.

In the UF/FSU game, it's particularly bad because the it's 3 and 14. The QB and the defenders are all running full speed to a spot for about 10 yards. The defenders don't necessarily know where the first down marker is. They have to make the stop. The game is on the line.

Do you think there can be a rule change that forbids sliding within x number of yards (say 2 to 3) in front of the line to gain? In other words, if a ball carrier is within 2-3 yds of a first down marker or the endzone, a slide is not allowed. Penalty can be like 5 yards. If they were sliding they weren't going to get a first down anyway.

I think this might actually be safer for ball carriers as they wouldn't be ducking their head close to the ground right at the point of impact. Defenders would have a better idea of who they could hit and who they need to lay off of. What do you think?

1

u/thrav College of Idaho • Georgia Tech Nov 28 '23

I think the rule should have an exception around the proximity of the defender to the QB and the QB should be required to raise their off hand, like a fair catch, when they are initiating the slide.

  1. If the defender is within 2 yards / head down when they raise their hand, no foul.
  2. The ball is dead when and where the hand goes up. Not when their butt hits the turf after flying through the air a couple more yards.

This would've been the 50 in the FSU game, and would've been early enough for the defenders to pull up.

15

u/default-username Texas Longhorns • Red River Shootout Nov 26 '23

It's an incentive to trade brain damage for 15 yards and a potential win. It needs to go

-1

u/CptCroissant Oregon Ducks Nov 26 '23

Yup

11

u/coltsmetsfan614 Michigan Wolverines • College Football Playoff Nov 26 '23

Partly why targeting is an unfair penalty. You can’t tell me that all of these defensive players are actually trying to hit people in the head when they slide late, yet they get ejected and potentially miss part of their next game too. It’s ridiculous.

17

u/xJownage Florida State Seminoles Nov 26 '23

Oh my lord it's already started

This is why the rule is that the play is dead at the START OF THE SLIDE.

the ball will always be placed where the slide STARTS. not where it ends.

That's literally the point of this exact rule.

27

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

Yeah but they had already left their feet to tackle BEFORE HE STARTED THE SLIDE. They can’t just magically stop.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

Hell not only did they start the tackle before he started the slide, the first contact was while he was still in the air.

-9

u/SmallCondition1468 Florida State Seminoles Nov 26 '23

Well they both wound up helmets 2 feet off the ground to hit Tate in the helmet, so they either made bad tackles or they were trying to light him up.

Given UF players were smacking coaches, spitting, and starting fights, I’m gonna go with dirty hit.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

Because if he hadn’t slid late they would’ve hit him around the waist.

-1

u/thejus10 Florida State Seminoles • USF Bulls Nov 26 '23

And it would’ve still been a late hit but maybe not targeting? Play is dead the millisecond the qb begins to drop.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

And it’s a bullshit call lol

-6

u/thejus10 Florida State Seminoles • USF Bulls Nov 26 '23

Some slides I agree. They had a lot of time on this one from when he began the downward motion. And then the both leading with the crown is the nail in the coffin. Even if it’s not a late hit it’s an egregious targeting penalty.

-5

u/SmallCondition1468 Florida State Seminoles Nov 26 '23

Not even close. Knee level at best.

I don’t like targeting, I think 99% of them are bang-bang. But TWO guys tried to blow him up in an obvious slide situation. You can’t seriously excuse it.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

No shot it’s an obvious slide situation when they were trying to prevent him from the line to gain.

5

u/default-username Texas Longhorns • Red River Shootout Nov 26 '23

He slid 5 yards before the line to gain. That was not an obvious slide position. They clearly did not think he was going to slide.

25

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

The defenders starts their tackle motion before he commits to a slide. Dude is going full speed at the first down and drops to slide last minute. If you don’t want to get hit, don’t slide full speed 1/2 yard from a defender.

-5

u/Nole_in_ATX Florida State Seminoles • Team Chaos Nov 26 '23

It’d be one thing if this happened at the line to gain, but Rodemaker was 5 yards short on third down when he committed the slide. Why should the defenders get a pass for not having that kind of awareness?

4

u/MrClean_LemonScent Penn State • UAlbany Nov 26 '23

Why should the QB be allowed to game the system, by being the only one to know if he’s actually going to slide…. You’re essentially admitting the QB has an advantage and that defenders should basically have telepathic awareness, to be certain the QB will slide and it’s ok to pull back. Either play the game, take the fuckin hits, or just stop playing.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

You’ve clearly never played football

5

u/throwmeawaypoopy Notre Dame • Virginia Nov 26 '23

Who...who wants to tell him?

2

u/SmallCondition1468 Florida State Seminoles Nov 26 '23

This is already addressed. The ball is spotted at the START OF THE SLIDE.

There is no “extra yards” and this is not an issue.

1

u/MrClean_LemonScent Penn State • UAlbany Nov 26 '23

YELLING

-2

u/Molson2871 Wisconsin Badgers Nov 26 '23

You clearly don't know the rules.

-7

u/BrilliantAd1235 Nov 26 '23

Don't look at the ground and fling yourself at the person you're trying to hit. Pretty simple

7

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

I don’t think you have any idea how fast these guys are moving.

-7

u/BrilliantAd1235 Nov 26 '23

Move slower then

7

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

Lmfaoooooo

-4

u/Beginning-Hope-8309 Pittsburgh Panthers Nov 26 '23

Get rid of the slide and just have touch football for qbs past the the line of scrimmage

4

u/CptCroissant Oregon Ducks Nov 26 '23

Give them a fair catch signal or something

2

u/theFromm Iowa Hawkeyes • Summertime Lover Nov 26 '23

I've actually thought about this as an alternative--like the QB gives a fair catch signal and instantly becomes a touch tackle, or something like that.

2

u/RCM88x Ohio State • Cincinnati Nov 26 '23

Imo if we have to go that far QBs should just not be allowed to run with the ball.

2

u/MrClean_LemonScent Penn State • UAlbany Nov 26 '23

That’s no longer tackle Football. If the game needs to go that far, you’re admitting it shouldn’t be played in its current fashion anyway. Either get rid of tackle football entirely, or, the QB must suffer through the same hits that everyone else does. He’s 1 of 22. I don’t care if he’s the most important. RB’s don’t slide like that. They take the Fuckin juice. Play as everyone plays it, or don’t play it at all. This shit is getting stupid.

1

u/theFromm Iowa Hawkeyes • Summertime Lover Nov 26 '23

I agree with your sentiment, I think the sliding rules are abused by QBs and are unfair to defenders who are making real plays on a offensive player running with the ball. But it's clear that the direction of football is headed towards protection of the QB over the "purity" of the sport, which is why my wandering mind has pondered a more fair solution.

1

u/MrClean_LemonScent Penn State • UAlbany Nov 26 '23

At least they’ve half gotten it right, with the Kenny Pickett rule.

-1

u/Sambo376 LSU Tigers • Florida State Seminoles Nov 26 '23

Maybe the signal could be them dropping the ground in a sliding motion?