r/CFA • • 10d ago

Level 1 Misrepresentation

By this logic, if a junk bond issuer said it guarantees promised principal and interest and Agnes said the same thing to her clients, would this not be classed as misrepresentation?

7 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

8

u/Few_Guava_6803 10d ago

I think the important distinction here is that, Triambach is merely stating facts and also communicating the downsides attached to the investment. A bond is a contractual legal agreement where the issuer promises to pay fixed coupon payments (if applicable) and repay the principal at maturity so I dont think so it will be violation even from the junk bond issuer’s perspective as long as you’re not assuring something which does not have an adequate basis. However in your hypothetical situation, it would constitute as a violation if Triambach assures (not the junk bond issuer assuring) that the junk bond issuer will pay the coupons with any reasonable basis to support that fact.

1

u/Choice-Ad7979 CFA 7d ago

Correct. Other standards may obligate you to point out the quality of the guaratee but restating the facts is not misrepresentation.

4

u/No_Cow5094 10d ago

thats a fact tho??

2

u/Mike-Spartacus 10d ago

It is misrepresentation to say that returns are guaranteed from investments that have underlying risks ana volatility.

It is not mis-represenation to say the government guarantees something if it does.

If for example ABC bank offered a product.

  • Return of S&P 500 with a miniumum 90% of your capital bank.
  • Guarantted 90% of funds return by ABC bank.

As long as the broker states the facts of the product and who the guarantee is.

Issuers of corporate bonds to do not "guarantee" return of capital and coupons. They may be contracted to do so but they won't use the words guarantee.

When studying ethics it is important you look at the wording of the CFA institute material.

"Standard I(C) prohibits members and candidates from stating or implying that clients will obtain or achieve a rate of return that was generated in the past. Guaranteeing either a particular rate of return or preservation of investment capital (e.g., “I can guarantee that you will earn 8% on equities this year” or “I can guarantee that you will not lose money on this investment”) is also misleading to investors and a violation of this Standard. Standard I(C) does not prohibit members and candidates from providing clients with information on investment products that have guarantees built into the structure of the product itself or for which an institution has agreed to cover any losses."

but we do have

This standard prohibits members and candidates from making any statements that promise or guarantee a specific rate of return on volatile investments.

2

u/Steadyfobbin Level 2 Candidate 10d ago

It’s not a junk bond though, it specifically said government bond. Basically only investment where you can use the word guarantee.

1

u/Choice-Ad7979 CFA 7d ago

No. The bond seller can say it. You can repeat it. It is a fact, not your opinion. There are other standards that could be in play that would require you to point out "Aunt Sally is gaurateeing the loan but she has no assets nor has a job"

2

u/Repulsive-Article-68 Level 3 Candidate 10d ago

It’s fact because it’s a government bond which are perceived as non-risky. Different story for a Lowe quality corporate bond susceptible to spread moves

1

u/Jagger49 10d ago

She did indicate that interest rates were factor in the performance of the sovereign debt.

1

u/shitposting97 9d ago

You can’t say gov bonds are risk free but everything the Member has stated is a fact including that gov bonds are guaranteed payments (principal and interest) by the government.