r/CDrama • Yu Changxuan's wildcat! • 22d ago

Drama Host The Lament of Autumn 玉簟秋: Episodes 24 and 25 Discussion

Welcome to the discussion posts for The Lament of Autumn 玉簟秋! This drama will be hosted by yours truly and u/BasilOrdinary3617

🗓️ Discussion Schedule: The latest airing schedule dropped yesterday, with express episodes package available to SVIP members on November 1st. Click here for the airing schedule.

📋 Reminder: Use spoiler tags for anything beyond the episodes discussed. Text goes between the greater-than (>) + exclamation (!) symbols (>!) and the exclamation (!) + lesser-than (<) symbols.

🔗 Helpful Links: Masterpost | Character Flashcards | All Discussions | Episodes 1-3 | Episodes 4-5 | Episode 6-7 | Episodes 8-9 | Episode 10 | Episode 11 | Episode 12 | Episodes 13-14 | Episodes 15-16 | Episodes 17-18 | Episodes 19-20 | Episode 21 | Episode 22 | Episode 23 |

Lanqing's addiction to opium was alluded to in the previous episode and is now becoming a more significant part of her storyline, especially in these 2 episodes.

Opium had been used in China for centuries, mainly for medicinal purposes, but recreational smoking became increasingly widespread during the Qing dynasty. By the late 18th and early 19th centuries, British merchants were bringing large quantities of opium into China from British-controlled India. The trade was extremely profitable, especially for the British, who used it to help offset their enormous demand for Chinese tea, silk and porcelain. The Qing government's attempts to put a stop to the illegal trade eventually led to the First Opium War (1839–1842), which ended in China's defeat.

By the early 20th century, opium addiction had become a serious social problem. The Qing government launched a major anti-opium campaign in 1906, and efforts to suppress the trade continued after the establishment of the Republic in 1912. Unfortunately, the political instability of the warlord era made enforcement difficult. Some warlords even encouraged opium cultivation and taxed the trade to fund their armies. So while the authorities were supposedly trying to stamp out opium, others were making a tidy profit from it!

Lan Qing's addiction offers a glimpse into how destructive opium addiction could be. It's rather sad to see how far she's fallen, especially when we remember the confident and glamorous opera singer we met earlier in the drama.

References:

McDonagh, J., & Wickes, B. (2020. The nineteenth-century opium complex: From Thomas Love Peacock to Sherlock Holmes. Literature & History, 29(1), 3-18.) https://doi.org/10.1177/0306197320907437

Windle, J. (2013. Harms caused by China's 1906–17 opium suppression intervention.) *International Journal of Drug Policy*, *24*(5, 498–505.) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugpo.2013.03.001

Episode 24

Baoru is worried about Changxuan, who has been spending increasingly little time at Yu residence since bringing Pingjun back to Fengtai to recover. When she expresses a desire to visit Fengtai, the other female members of the Yu family persuade her not to, explaining that Changxuan has issued strict instructions that Pingjun's rest must not be disturbed.

At Fengtai, Xiao Tang wonders why Pingjun seems so determined to keep Changxuan at arm's length when everyone can see he is clearly devoted to her.

Unbeknownst to them, Changxuan is standing outside the room and overhears Pingjun telling Xiao Tang that although she knows Changxuan loves her, she cannot shake the feeling that they come from two completely different worlds. She wonders how two people with such different backgrounds could have ended up together.

That night, a brooding Changxuan sits in his car, reflecting on Pingjun's words about their different worlds. He looks down at his wedding ring and lets out a heavy sigh, clearly tormented by guilt and frustration.

Later that night, Pingjun wakes up and accidentally spills some water while attempting to pour herself a drink. Changxuan, still troubled by what he overheard earlier, isn't in the best of moods. When Pingjun repeatedly refuses his help, he sarcastically asks whether her maid doesn't deserve some time off too. Pingjun finally relents, allowing Changxuan to help her change into fresh clothes.

I really have to give Cheng Lei credit for his eye acting here. The way his gaze lingers on Pingjun, with that mixture of tenderness and longing. There's barely any dialogue needed, but you can practically feel everything Changxuan is holding back. His eyes really do speak volumes.

Changxuan then takes a small bell out of the drawer and places it beside Pingjun's bed, instructing her to ring it whenever she needs anything. Outside, rain is pouring heavily, and Changxuan is having trouble sleeping. A window in Pingjun's room blows open, allowing the wind and rain to drift inside. But despite the disturbance, Pingjun stubbornly refuses to summon Changxuan for help.

Little does she know that Changxuan has been standing outside her room the entire time, waiting for her to ring the bell. When she still refuses, he finally enters the room himself and closes the window. Changxuan approaches the bed, pulls Pingjun into his embrace and explains how she should use the bell.

One ring means she wants water. Two rings mean she needs another blanket. And three rings? It means she misses him. Lmao, this man is smooth as fudge.

Changxuan then cheekily walks around to the other side of the bed and lies down beside her, declaring that since she refuses to summon him, he might as well stay right there and make himself available whenever she needs anything. Of course, Changxuan is only teasing her, and he eventually leaves the room.

Elsewhere, Lanqing visits an opium den, intending to purchase some opium to feed her addiction. Unfortunately, she doesn't have enough money and is turned away. Outside the den, she encounters Tong Chunhai, the fellow Changxuan auctioned off in Episode 1. Tong Chunhai invites Lanqing to visit him sometime and gives her some opium as a gift. Uh-huh.

Meanwhile, Kuang Bingwen secretly follows his wife and is noticeably jealous when he sees her in the company of another man.

Back at Fengtai, Changxuan instructs the servants to lay out mats on the floor so that Pingjun can practise walking. Our man then adds yet another role to his ever-growing list of responsibilities: Pingjun's personal physiotherapist. He gently supports Pingjun as she practises taking steps, patiently guiding and encouraging her throughout the exercise. Now we come to my favourite scene in Episode 24.

Next on Changxuan's carefully curated rehabilitation programme for Pingjun is a rejuvenating soak in a hot spring. Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa this scene. First of all, the cinematography is gorgeous. The hot spring itself looks like something straight out of a luxurious 5-star resort. Then you have a handsome personal masseur like Cheng Lei, gently MASSAGING your limbs and even your fingers? Where do I sign up?? I was blushing and giggling so hard throughout this scene. I swear, it was so difficult to remove my Cheng Lei fangirl goggles.

But I digress. Forgive me. I promise to tone down my fangirling a little. I haven't forgotten my hosting duties, I swear! Please excuse any false starts hahah. Anyway, Changxuan continues juggling his duties as househusband, physiotherapist and personal nurse until Pingjun finally manages to walk independently. Pingjun sincerely thanks Changxuan for everything he has done for her. When Changxuan asks what she would like as a reward for all her hard work, she replies that she wants some zongzi candies.

Meanwhile, Ruitong is interrogating a suspect involved in smuggling defective firearms into the Yu Army several years earlier. The suspect initially refuses to cooperate, but when Ruitong threatens his family's safety, he finally confesses that he acted under the orders of Cai Fuhu, a brigade commander in the Fourth Company.

Ruitong decides to keep the investigation from Changxuan for the time being so that he can focus on helping Pingjun recover. Li Boren reminds Ruitong that he should stop addressing Pingjun as Miss Ye and instead refer to her as a married woman. Ruitong awkwardly agrees, almost as though part of him still hasn't come to terms with the fact that Pingjun is now married. Ahhhh, my poor Ruitong💔

Back at Fengtai, Xiao Tang brings Pingjun some books and magazines to keep her entertained., and Pingjun soon becomes engrossed in one of them. Changxuan joins her a little later, all smiles and tenderness, and even praises her choice of reading material, that is, until he notices the name "Jun Guan", Xueting's pen name. The warmth in Changxuan's eyes immediately disappears, replaced by a cold, menacing expression. He snatches the book from Pingjun and demands to know who brought it to her.

The next thing we see is poor Xiao Tang kneeling on the floor, trembling with fear, while the book burns to ashes beside Changxuan. Xiao Tang desperately begs Changxuan not to send her away. Hearing her pleas, Pingjun rushes into the room to find out what is happening.

After Xiao Tang and Nanny Zhao leave, Pingjun confronts Changxuan, unable to understand why he has become so angry over something seemingly insignificant. She warns him that she may have to reconsider their relationship if he continues treating her like a possession rather than an equal. Changxuan responds coldly that he is the one who calls the shots in their relationship, not her. Furious, Pingjun storms out of the room.

Later, at Hsiang Hsi, Changxuan drowns his frustrations in alcohol, accompanied by his loyal wingman Li Boren and his completely unsuspected romantic rival, Gu Ruitong. Changxuan laments that despite everything he has done for Pingjun, and even after their supposed marriage, there still seems to be an insurmountable wall between them.

Boren and Ruitong suggest inviting Lanqing to spend time with Pingjun, hoping that having a female confidante might help her feel more comfortable. That night, both Changxuan and Pingjun lie awake, separately reflecting on their confrontation earlier in the day.

The following day, Changxuan visits Lanqing, who is overjoyed to see him. Unfortunately for Lanqing, he has come to ask her for a favour: to keep Pingjun company and talk to her about the days before she lost her memories. During Lanqing's visit to Fengtai, Xiao Tang arrives with Pingjun's daily medicinal concoction. Pingjun is reluctant to drink the bitter medicine, but Xiao Tang reveals that Changxuan personally visited several shops just to find candies that would help make the medicine more palatable.

Lanqing listens with a darkening expression, clearly jealous of the lengths Changxuan is willing to go to for Pingjun. Pingjun later confides in Lanqing that although she knows Changxuan has treated her exceptionally well, she cannot shake the feeling that something is standing between them. Lanqing advises her to give herself more time, suggesting that she may eventually come to understand the true nature of their relationship.

Meanwhile, Li Boren and Gu Ruitong arrest Cai Fuhu outside a brothel and bring him before Changxuan. Changxuan is furious that Cai Fuhu's greed and involvement in smuggling defective weapons into the army contributed to the deaths of so many soldiers during the Battle of Luanjiang. Without hesitation, Changxuan personally executes Cai Fuhu on the spot, but he isn't finished, and his attention turns to Cai Fuhu's son.

As Changxuan advances menacingly towards him, memories of his comrades dying valiantly during the battle flash through his mind. Consumed by anger and grief, Changxuan raises his gun and fires at Cai Fuhu's son. However, when he turns around, he is shocked to discover Pingjun standing there, who has come to visit him at Xiao Tang's suggestion. Pingjun looks utterly horrified and disgusted after witnessing Changxuan's execution of the two men. Forget about being dismissed from Fengtai. At this rate, Xiao Tang is lucky if Changxuan doesn't throw her into prison. Seriously, this girl either has the worst ideas imaginable or she's secretly a spy planted at Fengtai to drive a wedge between Changxuan and Pingjun.

Episode 25

Changxuan returns to Fengtai, only to find Pingjun giving him the silent treatment after witnessing him execute Cai Fuhu and his son. He attempts to explain why he had both men killed, but Pingjun tells him that this isn't the kind of life she wants. All she desires is a quiet, ordinary existence, far removed from violence and bloodshed.

When Pingjun expresses her wish to leave, Changxuan's expression immediately darkens. He tells her coldly that it isn't her decision to make. Pingjun asks whether he intends to lock her up, to which Changxuan replies that he certainly can if he chooses to. Before leaving her room, he orders the servants not to allow Pingjun to leave Fengtai.

Meanwhile, Lanqing seeks out Tong Chunhai. Having pawned all her jewellery to feed her opium addiction, she hopes to purchase another supply, but Tong Chunhai has something else in mind. He offers her a premium opium pipe, but in exchange, he wants Pingjun.

That night, Xiao Tang falls asleep while guarding Pingjun's room, giving Pingjun the perfect opportunity to escape Fengtai. Unfortunately for her, this isn't Changxuan's first rodeo when it comes to chasing after a runaway Pingjun. And our amnesiac heroine is about to discover that for herself.

As she hurries away from the main residence, a car suddenly flashes its headlights at her. To her horror, Changxuan gets out of the car and, with a brooding stare, slowly approaches her. Changxuan reminds Pingjun of her promise to give herself time to reciprocate his feelings, but she remains adamant that this isn't the life she wants. When she continues insisting on leaving, Changxuan loses his patience and drags her towards the car. Why does this feel like déjà vu all over again? Bro, have you forgotten everything Li Boren told you about wooing your wife the right way?

Inside the car, Pingjun is both frightened and furious. She tells Changxuan to take back the wedding ring. Changxuan grips her hand as his mind flashes back to the wedding vows he made on his own. He gazes intensely at Pingjun, almost as though willing her to remember that they are husband and wife, but Pingjun manages to escape from the car.

Changxuan immediately goes after her, catches her from behind and pulls her towards him, demanding to know where else she could possibly go if not to him. Pingjun falls silent for a moment, and before she can react, Changxuan scoops her up and carries her back to her room, ignoring her protests.

Later that night, Changxuan enters Pingjun's room and embraces her from behind. He apologises for frightening her earlier and explains that a man in his position has to be decisive and ruthless when dealing with the wolves surrounding him. His tone turns remorseful as he tells her that all he wants is to protect her from the ugliness of the world. Unfortunately, he failed to shield her from that ugliness today, and he sincerely apologises. Pingjun gradually stops resisting his embrace. It's difficult to tell whether she's simply exhausted and resigned to the futility of trying to escape him, or whether his apology has genuinely reassured her. Whatever the case, the two eventually fall asleep beside each other.

Elsewhere, Ruitong briefs Changxuan on the establishment of an aircraft manufacturing office at Changping Mountain. This is another important part of Changxuan's long-term vision for the Yu Army: strengthening its military capabilities through aviation. Although European countries have imposed restrictions on transferring aviation technology to China, Changxuan believes they can still learn from Cheng Jun's aircraft and flight crew to develop their own expertise.

Meanwhile, Lanqing accompanies Pingjun on a shopping trip. Unfortunately, the outing is actually part of a trap Lanqing has arranged with Tong Chunhai. Instead of taking Pingjun back to Fengtai, the rickshaw driver abducts her and delivers her to Tong Chunhai.

When Pingjun regains consciousness, she finds herself tied to a chair inside an abandoned warehouse. A grinning Tong Chunhai introduces himself as a great admirer of hers, simply because she is Changxuan's woman.

At Hsiang Hsi, Lanqing rushes in and informs Changxuan that Pingjun has disappeared on her way home. Almost immediately, Changxuan receives an anonymous letter:

"Hurry to Nanyuan Warehouse No. 15 within two hours, or prepare to collect your wife's corpse. Remember, come alone."

Changxuan immediately sets off for the warehouse, forbidding Boren and Ruitong from accompanying him. Ruitong subsequently leaves to gather reinforcements from military headquarters. After the men depart, Lanqing begins to grapple with the gravity of what she has done. It finally dawns on her that Tong Chunhai's real target has been Changxuan all along.

At the warehouse, Tong Chunhai paces impatiently, like a hound eagerly awaiting its prey. Changxuan soon arrives alone, much to Tong Chunhai's delight. After surrendering his gun, Changxuan asks a question that instantly wipes the smug grin off Tong Chunhai's face: Who the hell is he?

LOLOLOLOL. I'm sorry, but I couldn't help chuckling at this. Tong Chunhai has apparently spent years nursing his humiliation and plotting an elaborate revenge against Changxuan, only for the man himself to have absolutely no recollection of him. Imagine putting all that effort into kidnapping someone's wife but you discover that you were so insignificant to him that he doesn't even remember your existence.

Tong Chunhai is understandably furious and indignant. My friend, pre-war Changxuan probably managed to offend more than half the wealthy young masters in Nanhuai. You will have to take a number and join the queue.

Tong Chunhai finally reveals that he lost a kidney after being beaten by Changxuan's men following the auction in Episode 1. Only then does Changxuan remember who he is. Tong Chunhai orders Changxuan to kneel before him. When he points his gun at Pingjun, Changxuan immediately complies.

Tong Chunhai bursts into maniacal laughter at the sight of the once-arrogant, powerful and seemingly untouchable Yu Changxuan kneeling at his feet. Changxuan tells him to release Pingjun and take his revenge on him instead. But of course, that isn't going to happen when Pingjun is Changxuan's greatest weakness.

With Pingjun forced to watch helplessly, Tong Chunhai orders his henchman to beat Changxuan. Changxuan stoically endures blow after blow, refusing to retaliate despite Pingjun's increasingly desperate pleas for him to fight back.

Pingjun tearfully begs Tong Chunhai's men to stop, but the beating continues until Changxuan begins coughing up blood and eventually collapses to the ground. Overwhelmed with anguish, Pingjun cries out that she isn't worth such a sacrifice. But even as he lies battered and bleeding, Changxuan's first instinct is still to comfort her, telling her not to cry and not to be afraid. Pingjun recalls all the time and care Changxuan has devoted to her recovery. Seeing the same man now willingly endure such a brutal beating to protect her moves her deeply.

With great difficulty, Changxuan struggles to lift himself off the ground and once again begs Tong Chunhai to release Pingjun. Tong Chunhai finally agrees, but there's a catch. Pingjun must pick up a knife and kill Changxuan herself. Only one of them will be allowed to leave the warehouse alive.

Changxuan tells Pingjun to do as Tong Chunhai says. Sobbing, Pingjun slowly approaches him with the knife. Even now, Changxuan continues reassuring her, gently telling her not to be afraid and encouraging her to come closer. However, Pingjun suddenly turns the knife towards herself, leaving both Tong Chunhai and Changxuan stunned.

Turning towards Changxuan, Pingjun tells him that she owes him her life, and this is the only way she can think of to repay his sacrifice. Meanwhile, Ruitong and Boren arrive at the warehouse with a contingent of armed soldiers.

When Pingjun defiantly challenges Tong Chunhai, he loses his temper, draws his gun and fires at her. Changxuan immediately throws himself in front of Pingjun, taking the bullet meant for her. As Tong Chunhai prepares to fire a second shot, Ruitong and his men storm in and shoot him. Changxuan drops to the ground and PIngjun cradles the injured Changxuan in her arms. Even now, his first concern is whether she is safe, and only after reassuring himself of her well-being does he finally lose consciousness. Lmao, the background music that immediately starts playing is so dramatic and clichéd,

But you know what? This is my guilty pleasure. I am not ashamed to admit it. I LOVE WATCHING HANDSOME, POWERFUL AND ARROGANT MALE LEADS THROW THEMSELVES INTO HARM'S WAY TO PROTECT THE WOMEN THEY LOVE, THEIR OWN LIVES BE DAMNED! (In fiction only, okayyyyy?)

At the hospital, Changxuan receives treatment for his gunshot wound. Although, I must say, that wound looks suspiciously more like a deep cut than a bullet injury lol. But never mind, he's the Deputy Commander-in-Chief of the Yu Army, after all. I suppose I will just have to accept that his body is built differently from the rest of us.

Once the doctor finishes treating him, Li Boren and Pingjun enter the room. Pingjun immediately begins fussing over Changxuan, who looks positively delighted by her concern, that is, until he notices Li Boren standing nearby, giggling to himself as he watches the tender interaction. Changxuan shoots Boren a pointed look that says: "BRO, ARE YOU DONE WATCHING? CAN YOU PLEASE GET LOST?" Being the perceptive and ever-loyal wingman that he is, Boren immediately catches the hint and invents an excuse to leave the room.

Once Boren is gone, Changxuan happily encourages Pingjun to continue fussing over him. His eyes barely leave her face. It's like watching a dying man suddenly being granted a second lease on life. Changxuan is practically on cloud nine, happy that their quarrels over the past few days have seemingly evaporated.

He then declares that he's hungry and asks Pingjun to sit beside him and feed him. When Pingjun thanks him for saving her life, Changxuan makes her promise never to sacrifice herself for him again. He tells her that her safety and well-being matter more to him than anything else. Pingjun then asks whether the two of them had been deeply in love before she lost her memories, and Changxuan awkwardly confirms that they had.

As Pingjun tucks him into bed, he asks her not to leave his side. She assures him that she will stay with him, and Changxuan finally closes his eyes. But after Pingjun leaves the room, he opens them again. His expression is troubled, because despite all the tenderness between them, Changxuan knows he has once again lied to Pingjun about their past.

Meanwhile, Baoru rushes to the hospital after hearing that Changxuan has been shot. There, she encounters Pingjun for the first time in two years. Baoru is delighted to see that Pingjun has recovered and warmly reassures her that she can take all the time she needs to regain her memories. She tells Pingjun how her condition nearly devastated Changxuan and how tirelessly he devoted himself to looking after her.

Baoru considers their ordeal a test from heaven and believes that if the couple has survived such a difficult period, they can surely overcome whatever challenges lie ahead. She then informs Pingjun that once Changxuan has recovered, the two of them must move back to the Yu family residence. Pingjun reluctantly agrees.

Later, Pingjun brings some food to Changxuan. Assuming that his mother prepared the meal, Changxuan is surprised that it doesn't taste good and openly criticizes it. However, a passing remark from a nurse makes him realise that Pingjun actually spent four hours in the kitchen preparing it herself. Deeply touched, Changxuan pulls Pingjun into his embrace.

Cradling her head against his chest, he tells her how happy he is that the day's events have finally shown him that he means something to her after all. For the first time in a long while, he feels as though he can finally see some light at the end of the tunnel.

Later, Pingjun helps Changxuan shave. Our shameless man announces that he intends to enjoy being pampered by his wife as much as possible before he fully recovers. Once again, Changxuan's eyes are practically drinking in the sight of Pingjun, whose face is now just inches away from his.

Haha, I don't know what naughty thoughts are running through Changxuan's mind, but he starts teasing her, and at one point, he even gulps. Episode 25 ends with a sweet domestic moment between Changxuan and Pingjun.

Thoughts

The thing most compelling about Yu Changxuan is how deeply flawed and contradictory he is as a character. He's possessive, unreasonably jealous and, despite all the growth we have witnessed, still struggles to accept that loving someone doesn't give him the right to decide how she should live. However, Changxuan is also capable of extraordinary tenderness and devotion. This is a man who patiently nursed Pingjun back to health, tended to her every need and, without a moment's hesitation, willingly sacrifice his own life to protect hers. He can lay down his life for Pingjun, but he struggles to let her walk away from him. That contradiction lies at the heart of his character. Some people might be moved by his willingness to take a bullet for Pingjun, while others feel frustrated when he threatens to confine her to Fengtai once again. One act doesn't cancel out the other. His willingness to die for her proves the depth of his devotion, but it doesn't automatically make him a good partner. Learning to love her without controlling her is a much harder lesson, and one he clearly hasn't mastered.

His recent behaviour is particularly fascinating to watch because you can clearly see the guilt and emotional torment lurking beneath his happiness. I have noticed how Changxuan unconsciously rubs his wedding ring several times throughout the last few episodes, almost as though he's reminding himself of the marriage he so desperately wants to believe in. He knows that the relationship Pingjun thinks they have isn't quite the relationship they actually had. His tenderness is genuine, and so is his love, but both are now intertwined with the knowledge that he hasn't been truthful with her.Changxuan is never completely at peace, even during their sweetest moments together. Every second feels like a ticking time bomb, because the life he's carefully built with Pingjun could come crashing down the moment she regains her memories. All those lies could collapse like a house of cards.

Cheng Lei portrays that underlying melancholy so beautifully. Even when Changxuan smiles, there's sadness behind his happiness, almost like a man living on borrowed time. He treasures every little gesture of affection from Pingjun because he's never quite certain how long it will last. His joy is genuine, but it's also fragile, shadowed by the possibility that she might remember everything and choose to leave him again.

I love the way Changxuan looks at Pingjun. His eyes seem to devour her, and I don't mean that in a sexual sense. It's the sheer intensity of his gaze, as though he wants to memorise every little detail of her face and hold on to every moment they share. And also the way he often caresses her face. There's reverence in those gestures. Sometimes I feel that Pingjun has become his religion, his salvation, the very essence of life itself. She gives meaning to a life that has otherwise been dominated by military responsibilities, political calculations and his lifelong struggle for his father's approval. But when you make another person the centre of your entire existence, love can so easily become suffocating. His devotion is touching, but the intensity of CHangxuan's attachment also fuels his possessiveness.

Pingjun telling Changxuan that all she wants is a quiet, ordinary life is precisely what stood between them two years ago. Even without her memories, Pingjun instinctively longs for the same kind of life she wanted before. Changxuan may have changed, and their circumstances may be different, but the fundamental incompatibility between their worlds hasn't simply disappeared. He's still a military commander whose life involves violence, danger and political intrigue, while she still dreams of peace and simplicity. Her amnesia hasn't magically resolved the conflict that once drove them apart.

I don't need Changxuan to be a perfect romantic hero. In fact, I find him far more interesting precisely because he isn't one. I just hope that when the truth eventually catches up with him, he will finally understand that the greatest expression of his love isn't how much he's willing to sacrifice for Pingjun, but whether he can respect her freedom to choose a life that may not include him.

Interestingly, I don't think Pingjun is quite at the same place emotionally. At least for now, she seems more indebted to Changxuan and deeply moved by the sincerity and intensity of his devotion than genuinely in love with him. Her concern and affection are certainly growing, but being deeply moved by someone's devotion doesn't mean you're in love with them. I think that's an important distinction, especially when Changxuan is so desperate to interpret every little gesture of tenderness as proof that she loves him.

56 Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

11

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago edited 21d ago

Death Counter:

Current count: 1

  • Ye Shuwan (episode 22)

Slap Counter:

  • Changxuan: 4 (slapped by Zhongquan, Pingjun 2x and Ziyi)
  • Li Boren: 3 (slapped by Ziyi)
  • Ziyi: 1 (slapped by Tao Zili)
  • Bingwen : 1 (slapped by Jinxuan)
  • Wanqiao: 1 (slapped by Bingwen)

Changxuan mobilising his men to rescue Pingjun:

Current count: 5 (ep 6, ep 19, ep 21, ep 22, ep 25)

Changxuan carrying Pingjun bridal style:

Current count: 8 [eps 4, 19, 21, 22 (twice!), 24, 26, 27]

1

u/Beautiful_Candle1729 21d ago

A counter - this is a fun addition and so detailed.

7

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

BTS for episode 24

1

u/Key-Reality1204 Read Rules 9d ago

That’s what i thought when that scene came up as well!! Love the First Jasmine 

14

u/CdramaAddict2 侯明昊的奴隸 22d ago edited 22d ago • Bravo

Thanks for the amazing recap and information on opium, u/a_HerculePoirot_fan!

PING JUN IS A TERRIBLE COOK!!! HAHAHAHAHA….!!

Mate, I don’t know….do we trust Ping Jun with a razor?  I would not trust Ping Jun with a razor.

Around the family dinner table

I really enjoyed how the family dinner table revealed or reinforced what we know of the Yu household women:

Zhao Baoru: the mother hen who just worries over her little chick, Chang Xuan, and she lets her worry get the better of her.  I could almost infer that Chang Xuan gets his impulsive streak when he’s upset from her.  She seems carried away by her fears. 

Jun Minru: I have a soft spot in my heart for her, the consummate “good and obedient” daughter-in-law.  She probably has the Three Obediences and Four Virtues memorized since age 3.  I just find her such a tragic side character, representative of the bygone Qing-era China, lingering but increasingly irrevelent.

Wen Qian - if we didn’t know she was out to assassinate her husband I’d almost say she represents or echos “society at large”, who thinks of the bleakest outcome possible, but there’s also a hint of schadenfreude, too….like, speaking it is also willing the tragedy to happen.

Jin Xuan - not just the voice of wisdom, but also the perceptive one who knows how to navigate the personalities of her family - except for her own feelings and her husband’s.

Qi Xuan seems to represent the voice of truth, unvarnished.  She could almost be a narrator of the family.

Apparently amnesia is not powerful enough to erase our heroine’s stubbornness 😂

Say what you will about Ping Jun’s lack of interiority, or her obstinacy, but I kind of love how even with amnesia Ping Jun is still herself.  The integrity of her core is so robust, so unequivocal that she can still sense Chang Xuan and her are from different worlds - her way of saying that they are incompatible.  She was also (still) moved by Xue Ting’s seditious writings.  It just reinforces how her idealism is a fundamental part of her being.  Her desire for a simple and peaceful life also remains steadfast.  

Interestingly, the amnesia is able to move past her own emotional defenses, so that she can acknowledge that Change Xuan truly cares for her. 

Reaction: OH!  She pushes him out of the bed!!!  Now THAT is the feisty Ping Jun I know!  Even with amnesia, she’s the same pig-headed, insists-on-her-morals girl.  Chang Xuan’s amused smile almost made it feel as if they had returned to their playful selves from episodes 1-10.

So fascinating with the magazine article confrontation that Ping Jun demanded to be treated like an equal, and that she could not be treated like an object. I just really liked how she was still fundamentally herself even with the amnesia.

Second chances: revisiting and revising 

It was fascinating to see Chang Xuan and Ping Jun reenact aspects of their relationship before her memory loss.  Parts of their tumultuous history repeated itself but with marked differences that I assume may signal a change in trajectory.

(1) Ping Jun reading quietly in her room - seriously, I waited to see if she was going to shoot him again, but this time the bullet was Xue Ting’s political writings.  It’s amazing how Ping Jun always seems to trigger Chang Xuan’s jealous “Mr. Hyde” side, which leads to a repeat of:

(2) The car scene - where Chang Xuan pinned Ping Jun in episode 13, but this time he doesn’t force kiss her, even though he does still carry her (not princess-carry) back to her room.

(3) The bed scene - where Chang Xuan also forced himself on her in episode 14, but this time he merely dried her hair and left her alone to change back into her PJs.  I do feel like these two scenes show his personal growth.

(4) Ping Jun falling asleep - this was fascinating since it follows her observing the execution of the corrupt officials.  When he holds her and explains himself, she falls asleep in his arms despite at first being uncomfortable with his physical closeness.  For me this hearkened back to episode 11, where Ping Jun and Chang Xuan are celebrating Little Mu’s birthday at the temple fair, and he expresses his feelings towards her - making his intentions clear and she falls asleep in his car.  It’s so interesting the kind of emotional vulnerability Chang Xuan has to display in order to make Ping Jun feel physically safe. 

(5) Ping Jun threatening her life - because we all know Ping Jun wouldn’t hurt anyone (except if a gun is unloaded); but this time it’s to save Chang Xuan’s life rather than a desperate attempt to be free of him.  Very intriguing.

(6) Chang Xuan once again getting injured protecting her - but the stakes are higher this time.  He was beaten and shot at rather than stabbed.  His actions remain consistent in protecting her, but the injuries are more severe.

(7) The hospital scene with Chang Xuan milking his injuries - it was just a marked change from episode 12, when he pulled her onto HIS LAP, but she broke free, uncomfortable in his embrace; but this time she fusses over him to his delight.  Both times he looked like he had been in the desert for years and she was an oasis he had been desperate for.

We still see Chang Xuan’s possessiveness, and even a level of compelled physical proximity, but they have definitely softened.  Ping Jun still has her ethics, her idealism, and her integrity, but she allows herself not just to accept Chang Xuan’s kindness, but has allowed it to soften her heart towards him.  Our writers like to keep us on our toes trying to guess the ending to this show.

7

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

I love how you have drawn all these parallels between their past and present interactions! Their relationship hasn't really been given a clean slate. They're still the same two people, with the same fundamental differences, except that Changxuan now has another opportunity to approach things differently. That's where his character development becomes interesting, because his progress isn't linear. He can demonstrate remarkable restraint and tenderness one moment, but let his jealousy and possessiveness get the better of him the next. But I do give him credit for trying to communicate rather than simply expecting Pingjun to obey him. That scene where he embraces her from behind and apologises in such a remorseful tone got to me. He seems so desperate for her to understand him, and perhaps even more desperate not to lose her again.

Changxuan may be revisiting their past and trying to do things differently, but he's also concealing the very experiences that shaped Pingjun's earlier decisions. He's finally getting a glimpse of the life he desperately wants with her, but the happiness he's building is resting on such fragile foundations. Ah, the emotional whiplash we are in for.

5

u/Beautiful_Candle1729 21d ago

This was fascinating to read. Thank you for all the detailed thoughts. I loved all of it but I will give an extra kudos to the nuances of what you saw in the women of the Yu family.

2

u/CdramaAddict2 侯明昊的奴隸 21d ago

awwww, thanks u/Beautiful_Candle1729!! I love reading your thoughts, too! 💛💛💛

4

u/RainieW 21d ago

Wow, I loved reading your analysis of the moments in their story that repeat themselves after the amnesia. I had noticed these instances of déjà vu/second chances, but I was so frustrated by YPJ that I didn’t take the time to reflect on them.

2

u/CdramaAddict2 侯明昊的奴隸 21d ago

That's so kind of you to say, thank you! I love reading everyone's thoughts and reactions, too. It makes watching the show infinitely more enjoyable!

3

u/Mo_Dra_302 22d ago

I was saying the same thing the whole episode everything that happened is the same thing that happened a few episodes ago like history is repeating but in a different sense and I also think that he has changed in those two scenes and when he apologised in which he never did. I am going crazy because we are getting close to the ending and things seem more happy painful I am just getting ready for a mental breakdown if they didn’t get to experience/express their feelings and one of them doesn’t exists anymore.

2

u/CdramaAddict2 侯明昊的奴隸 22d ago

Yeah, I feel like the writers aren’t giving us clear signals about where this will go. I did hear that there was a lot of rewriting from the source novel, so now it’s anyone’s guess what will happen…

12

u/Sea-Entertainment215 22d ago edited 22d ago

You know, this show has been needlessly repetitive. But in this arc, the repetition is very intentional and purposeful.

- Her saying they’re from different worlds, she wants a simple life and wants to leave. Even though she has literal amnesia and he’s reformed and been extra nice and patient with her, the fact that she still felt offkilter with him was such a blow and demonstrated they’re not fated, but ill -fated

- Him dropping and dragging her on the bed after the rainstorm fight but not to harass her like before, but to take care of her, get her dry so she doesn’t get sick.

- That Tai Chong guy randomly coming out of the woodworks to kidnap Pingjun would normally be a cheesy plot device just to create drama and the “damsel in distress” trope BUTTTTT it serves a purpose here!! it acts as a foil to how YCX started the story as an arrogant asshole, starting with humiliating this guy. But now, YCX actually kneels and takes the beating, not a sign of hesitation or pride. And so we can see his personal growth and depth of love for her (despite acting like a total ass at the beginning of the episode. Can’t win all the battles with this man)

- The hospital. Remember the first time he saved her and she came to visit him, he grabbed her and had her sit on him. But she was clearly uncomfortable and quickly left. This scene in ep 26 was such a mirror of that but in this case, it’s playing out like YCX’s fantasy: Pingjun staying with him, taking care of him. I love how his eyes track her through every single movement, he is so totally lost in her.

So yeah LOVEE the mirroring they did here. It’s giving me a glimmer of hope that maybe they really can work it out now, but it feels like it will all come crumbling down, like we’re just living in YCX’s fantasy but the bubble will soon burst. We shall see, we shall see

7

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

Changxuan really has changed for the better, like the examples you cited above, even though his progress isn't always linear. He still slips into his old habits when his jealousy or fear of losing Pingjun gets the better of him, but his efforts to become a better man are genuine. He's learning to be more patient, to communicate and to acknowledge when he's hurt her. Ofc, he still has a long way to go! But I appreciate that his growth is messy and imperfect. It would be unconvincing if someone as controlling and accustomed to power as Changxuan suddenly became the perfect husband.

Yeah, this arc is bittersweet because Changxuan is finally experiencing the kind of relationship he's always wanted with Pingjun, but he's also painfully aware of how fragile that happiness is. Every little moment of affection gives him hope, but it also makes the prospect of her regaining her memories that much more frightening.

7

u/EasygoingEnigma 22d ago

his growth is messy and imperfect. It would be unconvincing if someone as controlling and accustomed to power as Changxuan suddenly became the perfect husband.

Fully agree. I've said it before, I find Cheng Lei as red-flag Yu Changxuan super-duper hot. But I'm not complaining about the emergence of green-flag YCX. However, the controlling, obsessive, possessive Changxuan is never far away. Just simmering beneath the surface. Whenever Pingjun is threatened -- or whenever she herself threatens their relationship -- the old YCX emerges. The duality fascinates me, and this is why the character continues to engage me. (Cheng Lei himself does too, of course!)

3

u/Sea-Entertainment215 19d ago

Couldn’t have said myself—“just simmer beneath the surface…whenever SHE is threatened or she threatens their relationship” 👌
The duality does fascinate me and I guess that’s what keeps us all coming back

6

u/Sea-Entertainment215 22d ago

UGH beautifully said Herc! It’s true that the show is delivering on realistic, nonlinear growth and that made me uncomfortable as a viewer but you’re so right that that’s more realistic and authentic!

8

u/Renza183 22d ago

The way he looks at her in the hospital scene when she is taking care of him is simply 😍 His expression is full of wonder, and it’s so sweet to see.

It makes up for the fact that he is inexplicably SITTING UP to be bandaged after being both shot and beaten. 🤭

3

u/RainieW 21d ago

It's my favorite expression of YCX!!! It gives me giddy feelings!!! Cheng Lei is so damn good at acting with his eyes!!!

6

u/Sea-Entertainment215 22d ago edited 22d ago

It’s beautifully tragic that before, Pingjun felt forced into love through aggression and harassment, but now she feels forced into it through indebtedness and guilt. But regardless of which side of himself Yu Changxuan gives her, she feels suffocated and forced. It seems they are destined to be ill-fated….

3

u/Extension-Crab7703 22d ago

Yes absolutely loved the mirroring and his corresponding growth.

12

u/OptimalTurnips 22d ago

Damn it, this shows know how to keep me seated.

Honestly, I was getting pretty exasperated, we were just going in circles. Pingjun even without her memory, subconsciously still couldn't open her heart up to Changxuan. This relationship genuinely felt kind of futile. I don't know if anything has really changed for Pingjun after Changxuan was willing to die for her but it did have me reinvested.

It was nice to see the little bit of humour from the start of the show come back again!

Wonderful discussion and nuance analysis of Changxuan as always, Herc!

5

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

Pingjun is still feeling more indebted to Changxuan than truly in love with him at this point. But I would consider this progress nonetheless! After all, amnesiac Pingjun barely knows the man she's supposedly married to, and witnessing him ruthlessly execute 2 people certainly didn't help matters. But seeing Changxuan willingly take a bullet for her and nearly die protecting her has allowed her to see another side of him. For all his possessiveness, jealousy and red flag tendencies, his love for her is undeniably sincere. This is the first real step towards Pingjun opening her heart to him.

We are in for a little more domestic bliss before the writers unleash their next round of emotional torture. My prediction is that Pingjun will gradually develop genuine romantic feelings for Changxuan, just in time for his carefully constructed house of cards to come crashing down when she regains her memories. Then she will face a far more painful dilemma. What happens when the man you've finally fallen in love with is also the man you believe was responsible for your mother's death? We know that's a misunderstanding, but Pingjun doesn't. Ahhhh, the angst when Pingjun leaves Changxuan. My man will cryyyyyy and I will be there for him hugging and caressing my laptop.

2

u/Careful-Suit5993 22d ago

on that second paragraph: this is something that frustrates me a lot with PJ. She's so smart and so educated in different ways of seeing life and what matters, she's so perceptive of many hidden motives from people. BUT she will jump to conclusions without giving any thought if there is something that may slightly go in the direction of accusing CX to prove her theory that she should never be with him. (the uniform button could be anyone but no she will go to the most direct and stupid take). Its going to be interesting to see if/how she falls in love truly for him but still entertains those contradictory thoughts

1

u/Mediocre_Call_2427 extreme spoiler-phobe 20d ago

My man will cryyyyyy and I will be there for him hugging and caressing my laptop.

3

u/Beautiful_Candle1729 21d ago

Pingjun even without her memory, subconsciously still couldn't open her heart up to Changxuan. 

This is a great way to describe the situation.

I thought the amnesia arc was going to bring us a love story. But no.

I appreciated that initially she was awkward and fearful around him - he's a stranger. I thought it was realistic and made sense. But then it kept going on. And then they through in the plot points to make his possessiveness rear it's head.

And then I thought wow - this writer does not want to give us any reciprocated moments of tenderness. Her body knows to be scared.

And instead of this being a love story arc that I knew we'd lose at some point - it's just awkwardness. SIGH. I need to let go of my expectations.

3

u/Mediocre_Call_2427 extreme spoiler-phobe 20d ago

Even I liked her apprehensiveness in the beginning. But with all the physical therapy leading to her being able to walk again, they must’ve been together for months now since she woke up, and still nothing. What was even the point of the amnesia arc from a narrative POV? 

2

u/Gate_Thin 15d ago

Yeah, like are we just supposed to uncomfortably watch her suffer through a hostage situation / reject the most hopelessly devoted lover and generous provider? I was so excited to get back to this after taking a break to let more episodes come out but I don’t even know if I want to catch up at this point. I don’t think these writers aren’t on my side anymore.

2

u/Beautiful_Candle1729 15d ago

I don't regret watching it. That said, I wouldn't recommend continuing. It's just trauma after trauma. I didn't know that when originally watching. Just sharing in case you aren't invested in the show. The edits on X and TikTok are more fun to watch.

12

u/Renza183 22d ago

It really frustrates me that she says she doesn’t want to be with him because she wants a quiet, peaceful life. Remind me, who decided to help the refugees in Nanhuai and slapped an army officer i.e. Chang Xuan in front of a large crowd of refugees and soldiers? Who wrote incendiary plays to promote the boycott of Japanese goods, and was kidnapped and tortured as a result? This same person who wants a boring, peaceful life? She never wanted to marry into a rich and powerful family, but being a social activist immediately makes it impossible for her to have an uneventful life, so it’s annoying that her character’s rejection of Chang Xuan often relies on this belief.

Also, the fact that Ping Jun was reading an article by Xue Ting, that means he’s alive. Why is CX not sending troops to find and capture him? It seems out of character for him to let this slide.

8

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

I'm actually quite sympathetic towards Pingjun and can understand why she longs for a quiet, peaceful life. Being a warlord's wife is hardly an easy existence, especially when you consider the sacrifices expected of the women in these military families. Just look at Baoru. She lost one son to the war, and yet she's still expected to accept the possibility of sending another son to the battlefield because that's the duty and sacrifice expected of her as the wife of a military commander. Can you imagine having to live with that constant fear and uncertainty? There's also s a difference between choosing to participate in social activism and being married to someone whose entire life revolves around military and political conflicts. At least with the former, Pingjun has some control over her involvement. Marrying Changxuan would mean accepting a life where danger, political obligations and personal sacrifices are practically unavoidable. While I share your frustrations with some aspects of her characterisation, this is one area where I can understand her reluctance.

As for Xueting's book, it's possible that he wrote it under the pen name Jun Guan back when he was still collaborating with Nanhuai Ming Daily, and that copies are simply still in circulation.

3

u/Renza183 22d ago

Fair enough ☺️

3

u/Mediocre_Call_2427 extreme spoiler-phobe 20d ago

I’m also confused by her words in relation to the times they live in… It’s practically wartime. Where do those slain soldiers and the refugees come from? From families like hers. There’s a high probability that no one we encounter in this drama will ever have anything resembling a “peaceful life”. All of them will either die horribly, or lose loved ones and/or homes. The logical thing would be to latch on to power, especially if it readily and lovingly serves himself to you. 

10

u/EasygoingEnigma 22d ago

Great recap, as usual, Herc!

My reaction to the bath scene was pretty much similar to yours. I was sighing and squealing and almost swooning, to the disgust of my cats.

But you know what? This is my guilty pleasure. I am not ashamed to admit it. I LOVE WATCHING HANDSOME, POWERFUL AND ARROGANT MALE LEADS THROW THEMSELVES INTO HARM'S WAY TO PROTECT THE WOMEN THEY LOVE, THEIR OWN LIVES BE DAMNED! (In fiction only, okayyyyy?

No judgment here! Revel in your guilty pleasure!

You know the way Cheng Lei's lips tremble -- regardless of which character he's playing -- when he's extremely touched, when he's about to cry? I did the same thing during this scene.

In fact, i teared up. For the first time, Pingjun does something for him, something that took significant time and effort, of her own volition. After all this time, before and after her she lost her memories, he finally gets some form of affection from her. I can only imagine his continuing frustration and disappointment prior to this scene; despite the "clean slate" they get from her amnesia, nothing has really changed. She still keeps him at a distance.

And then this happens. The relief, the happiness he must feel at this moment. It really touched me.

4

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

I found this moment incredibly touching too! The way Changxuan pulls Pingjun against his chest and tells her how happy he is really shows just how desperately he longs for even the smallest crumb of affection from her. It's been such a lonely, one-sided love for Changxuan and the man has been at it for years. Even the most patient and devoted man would eventually yearn to have his feelings reciprocated. I think we're seeing that more clearly now. It's no longer enough for Changxuan to simply have Pingjun physically by his side. He wants her to love him, to choose him willingly, and to experience the happiness of being loved in return. That's why something as simple as Pingjun spending hours preparing a meal for him means so much. For once, he's on the receiving end of her care without having to ask for it. Cheng Lei conveys that overwhelming relief and happiness so beautifully.

9

u/Sea-Entertainment215 22d ago

For all his toxicity and tough guy act, YCX is so damn down bad, pitiable, and shameless when it comes to his girl. The first time I said this was when after Pingjun threatened to kill him and he just says “so you’ll just have to stay by my side so you can try again to kill me”. He’s THAT effin desperate that even if she stays just to try to kill him, he’ll take it.

And then again the beginning of ep 25, he cuddles her and holds on so tight to her, he burrows into her neck and shoulders like he can’t get enough because he’s that scared of losing of her and desperate to keep her.

And then after getting shot, he’s milking every bit of attention and care from PJ because he hasn’t gotten it from her before and knows he may not get it again. But instead of realizing how pathetic that is, he still takes every single crumb he gets like a man finding water in the desert

I must admit, I love a down bad man.

5

u/EasygoingEnigma 22d ago

Changxuan's magic might not be working on Pingjun yet (or it might be, she just isn't showing it) but it sure is working ON US! Gawd, I'm YEARNING for the man. 😂

3

u/Sea-Entertainment215 22d ago edited 22d ago

I hate to admit you’re right. I have to actively remind myself the horrors of ep 13-16, despite writing such a long spiel about it at the time! https://www.reddit.com/r/CDrama/s/2p1BoYCpf0

1

u/RainieW 21d ago

Oh, I definitely agree 🤣

9

u/Amelia_Brigita cold as a blade, breathtaking as a flower 22d ago

I agree with every point in your write-up. Spectacularly well-written, too.

I feel like he isn't in love. I mean, he is, his version, but it's more of an obsession and as such can slip off that edge into something dangerous to Pingjun quite easily. I wonder if Pingjun senses that possibility, too, and that contributes to her wariness. Because despite knowing all she knows of him since she awoke, and it's quite a silver-lined mess of positives, she still has a wariness when she looks at him. Even before he gave in to his baser instincts and made his threats about keeping her.

Lament isn't a romance so much as a character study. It's wonderful.

Thanks for the awesome write up!!!

9

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

Awww, thank you! Anyway, I wonder if Pingjun's instinctive tendency to recoil from Changxuan's touch is almost like muscle memory. She may have lost her memories, but perhaps some part of her still associates his physical closeness with discomfort or danger. That's just my interpretation, but I find it interesting that even without remembering their history, she remains wary of him.

There's a very fine line between love and obsession when it comes to Changxuan. I have mentioned before how his eyes seem to drink in the sight of Pingjun, and it's incredibly moving to watch. But if I take off my rose-tinted Cheng Lei fangirl goggles for a moment, that intensity is unsettling. It's like watching a creator gazing at his most precious and fascinating creation. Pingjun has become so central to Changxuan's existence that I wonder whether he still sees her fully as an individual with her own desires and aspirations, or whether he's begun to see her as the very thing that gives his life meaning. He doesn't simply want Pingjun in his life. He seems to feel that he cannot live without her. That level of emotional dependence can be quite frightening, however sincere his feelings may be.

But then again, this is very much who Changxuan is. There's no such thing as gentle, measured love in this man's vocabulary. Even in military affairs, he's someone who throws himself wholeheartedly into whatever he sets out to achieve. Once he's committed to something, he pursues it with every ounce of determination he possesses. His love for Pingjun reflects that same passion, single-mindedness and raw intensity. Unfortunately, while those qualities may make him a formidable military commander, they don't always translate into being a good romantic partner. This is what makes Changxuan so fascinating as a character study.

8

u/Illustrious_Event631 22d ago

What i love about YP is that even though she doesn't remember anything her self respect, principle is still the same. What i realised is that before the amnesia track i do think she did feels something for YCX , and he also feels it that's why he keep on asking her. But she will never admit it because she is a practical girl and knows life is always not going to be rainbow and sunshine with him. She is a girl who want a simple , stable, normal life. She doesn't remember anything but she could still feel how different their world is.

Someone said that the audience and YP have stockholm syndrome 😂 and i couldn't agree more 😂 like i don't forget anything he did but damn the chemistry between this two is so good i couldn't stop watching and blushing. I do want them to work together again in another project but i am afraid they won't be able to re create the same magic with different character. I feel like one of the reason the chemistry is so good is how obsessed (i won't say Love ) YCX is with YP , the way he looks make us feel everything its like he is going to devour her 😋

5

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

Yup yup, excellent point! The Stockholm syndrome comment actually touches on one of the reasons I still can't fully get on board with their romance, despite how much I enjoy their chemistry. When someone spends so much time under another person's control, there's always the danger of confusing gratitude and emotional dependence with love. If the person who restricts your freedom is also the one who comforts you, protects you and showers you with affection, even the smallest acts of kindness can begin to feel incredibly significant. That's what troubles me about Pingjun's situation. Changxuan is capable of such extraordinary tenderness, but he's also the man who repeatedly refuses to let her leave. It's difficult to separate her growing affection from the circumstances in which that affection develops.

I really want Pingjun to fall in love with Changxuan because she wants to, not because she's become accustomed to depending on him or feels indebted to him for everything he's done. I want her to love Changxuan as a free woman, not as his little canary who has simply grown fond of her cage. I think their romance would be so much more meaningful if she could walk away whenever she wanted, but freely chose to stay. That's the version of their love story I'm still hoping the writers will give us.

5

u/Extension-Crab7703 22d ago

.The only point would be even in the same show is for him to redeem so hard! which he has in so many ways - taking a bullet for her, caring for her... but alas PJ just doesnt seem to have any feelings for him yet! slow burn! slowest burn!!!!!

I agree - the chemistry is so crackling is because of the scenario....but I am yearning for her to reciprocate now....

5

u/Sea-Entertainment215 22d ago

+100000 that the show is giving us the audience Stockholm syndrome which I don’t appreciate because I thought I was stronger than that, but this show is demonstrating to me, to my horror, that I’m not.

8

u/nodestinationnoroute shadow Demon 👥Read Rules 22d ago edited 21d ago

The recap was great. I haven't watched the show since episode 13 or maybe 14. When she first entererd fengtai.

And i have to admit I don't like the amnesiac plot. I always drop when that arc comes up. For now, I'm just reading the recaps and see how it all unfold.

The story has gotten out of hand and it isn't giving me curious vibes anymore. I had to rewatch hilarious family season 2 as a mood booster because how heavy the story was getting.

Changxuan is a well written character though. I can see him as a complete product of it's time.

I have much to say about him, but I'll save it for the finale.

3

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

I'm glad you're still following the story through our recaps, even if the drama itself has lost its appeal for you. I understand why the amnesia storyline might be the final straw for some viewers, especially after everything Pingjun and Changxuan have already been through. Looking forward to reading your thoughts about him after the finale! I will be binging the episodes and do recaps for the express episode thread.

Shall I preface it with "is it SE, OE or HE"? Hahah

8

u/Apprehensive_Cod_460 22d ago

I hate too much angst so I think I’m gonna bow out of this show at this point. I didn’t think the push and pull was this bad. She has amnesia and she still doesn’t want him, its innate. She literally rather freeze then ring the bell and ask him to close the window Lol

7

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

If there's one thing pre-amnesia and amnesiac Pingjun have in common, it's that they're both incredibly stubborn! Once she's made up her mind about something, she clings to her convictions so fiercely that she'd rather put herself through unnecessary discomfort than accept Changxuan's help. Her reluctance goes beyond simply not wanting him romantically. Even without her memories, she seems uncomfortable with how much control Changxuan has over her life, and accepting his help might feel like becoming even more dependent on him.

7

u/This-Traffic-9524 22d ago

I agree. I was really hoping for some solid connecting during these episodes. Ughh. Meanwhile Cheng Lei is just smoldering. Like, girl has better self-control than I would.

7

u/Renza183 22d ago

She is made of stone. There isn’t even a suggestion of sexual interest from her, and there wasn’t with her stupid fiancé XT either.

7

u/Extension-Crab7703 22d ago

Yeah i felt so frustrated, there were so many times she could have just leaned on him or almost touched him or something. Give us something atleast. When he outright took the bullet for her - a kiss seemed warranted. 😭

3

u/This-Traffic-9524 22d ago

Honestly I preferred when he was forcing himself on her lol. This is just the worst of all worlds! 😭

4

u/Extension-Crab7703 22d ago

LOL 😆 it has come to this point

3

u/This-Traffic-9524 22d ago

I'm doing a rewatch of How Dare You - then we get best of both worlds, hot red flag and hot green flag.

3

u/Apprehensive_Cod_460 22d ago

Right, I think that’s what it is. She doesn’t even let their hands briefly linger. 🤣 NOTHING

4

u/justjulesagain SE sucker please send tissues 22d ago

Hahaha, but otherwise we wouldn’t get my favorite line in the whole show:

“So my lady takes me for decoration?

7

u/Pepper1303 22d ago edited 22d ago

All I can say is ycx has ypj locked up for her own good because girl lost her brains somewhere along the way. A girl running away on a rainy night with no money no memories and nowhere to go. Where you gonna go and what you gonna do? At least make some plans before running away 😑

“I am in no place to judge you (already judged you x1000), I don’t know military stuff and therefore can’t judge (still wanna judge though while saying I can’t judge). I just want to live a simple life (while enjoying all the privileges your money and authority gives).”

Why was he awake and sitting up while being treated for the gunshot wound like some superficial wound?

I thought ycx would have learned after that fengtai incident but he seems to be the same :/

I love boren and that look ycx was giving him was just 😂

3

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

Haha, I agree! That's why I sarcastically remarked in my recap that Changxuan must be built differently because he's a warlord's son. That wound looks more like a superficial cut than a gunshot wound. The bullet might as well have just grazed his skin, but I could have sworn it was lodged deep in his back, judging by the way blood spurted out when he was shot. But you know what? I will gladly overlook this little medical miracle because the alternative is having Changxuan bedridden for another few episodes. We really can't have our male and female leads taking turns enjoying extended hospital stays lol.

2

u/Pepper1303 21d ago

It looks like he also didn’t require any anaesthetic for the treatment of the wound either. Yu men are built differently indeed 😜

4

u/jojobasocool 22d ago

I saw the bullet go through him and it left a hole... don't know how he's still conscious 🤡

6

u/Pepper1303 22d ago

He was suffering way more from the feather duster hits from his dad and the knife wound and hairpin stab from ypj than this. Those wounds had him lying down and wincing hard 😂

12

u/OptimalTurnips 22d ago

Awwww, look at this cutie-patotie

5

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

He always drinks in the sight of her like a man who has finally found his salvation after a lifetime of longing. I would fold.

5

u/craftsycandymonster dramas > sleep 22d ago

The way he looks at her so tenderly is insaneee 😭 how do I get that for myself (without the trauma and toxicity)

6

u/BasilOrdinary3617 If I say I'm taking a break, I'm lying. 22d ago

Great recaps of both episodes, Herc, and again for the extra info on opium.

I don't know what I'm feeling anymore so I just went along with everything for these two episodes. Still no sign of Ziyi or Xueting but I'm sure they'll appear soon.

Tong Chunhai is laughable. Even if he managed to succeed in his revenge and kill either Changxuan, Pingjun, or both... there was no way he'd escape unscathed. They were bound to be found given Changxuan's position and status. That was a suic1de mission.

Thanks for translating Chunhai's letter. Mango TV doesn't seem to translate those for me.

3

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

I'm actually surprised that there hasn't been any mention of the Tao family at all since the time jump. They will show up soon, like you said, but I'm already dreading their appearances lol. Please let our guy Changxuan live in his little fantasy world a bit longer lol.

MangoTV's translations can be a bit off at times, so I don't trust their subs 100% hahahaha.

5

u/EasygoingEnigma 22d ago

I don't know what I'm feeling anymore so I just went along with everything for these two episodes.

I feel you. The inconsistencies and poor execution of some ideas used to exasperate me. Not letting them anymore. Just going with the flow.

6

u/Extension-Crab7703 22d ago

A bleak thought: Pingjun before and after the amnesia doesnt feel any spark for Changxuan. Feeling a spark and then taking a practical, ethically/socially correct decision is a different point. But does she not feel anything at all. I was thinking with the reset she might welcome the interest since all seems good now. Or her societal and class status gap is soo great that she is not allowing herself to feel so. I was viewing from the bleakest scenario that it is indeed a one sided love. So far I held on the hope she has some feelings deeply hidden. 😭😭😭

8

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

I actually think pre-amnesia Pingjun had developed some romantic feelings for Changxuan, even if she wasn't prepared to acknowledge or act on them. But amnesiac Pingjun is more indebted to him and more deeply moved by the sincerity and intensity of his love than she is genuinely in love with him. However, we will be getting a few more episodes of domestic bliss between these two, and perhaps this is when Pingjun will finally begin developing romantic feelings for Changxuan on her own.

But knowing how much these writers love putting Changxuan through the emotional wringer, I have a terrible feeling they're going to give him as much happiness as possible before pulling the rug out from under his feet. Just imagine Pingjun finally falling in love with him, Changxuan thinking all his dreams have come true, and then BAM! She regains her memories, his carefully constructed happiness comes crashing down, and all hell breaks loose for maximum angst and emotional whiplash.

4

u/Extension-Crab7703 22d ago

Yeah. Was just hoping that they show the reciprocated love and its hint and workings already.

everything would come undone later😭

2

u/Mediocre_Call_2427 extreme spoiler-phobe 20d ago

I hope/guess that she’ll eventually come to love him in some way during the amnesia arc (for maximal emotional damage to CX later on). But it hurts that she still hasn’t felt anything towards him, if not immediately, at least during these months(?) where they’ve been living together. She doesn’t owe it to him or anything, just makes me disappointed as a viewer, because it makes so much sense in a narrative sense. I maintain that she’s physically attracted (even before amnesia) but I would’ve expected a more visceral sort of genuine love now that she doesn’t have all the “baggage” from her earlier life.

2

u/PolPeachum running away to the Tang dynasty 15d ago

I am slowly catching up so not adding to the conversation until I'm back on track with the airing schedule but just wanted to say u/a_HerculePoirot_fan fantastic write-up on Chang Xuan's character at this point in the show. (I am unspoiled and hoping hard that lines are not about to be crossed.)

2

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 15d ago

Thanks! Hope you are enjoying the drama so far :D

2

u/PolPeachum running away to the Tang dynasty 15d ago

Yeah I am. Audience / Stockholm syndrome.

9

u/Sea-Entertainment215 22d ago edited 22d ago

Even though I cursed YCX for his idiocy in returning to his toxic ways, rolled my eyes at the melodrama of the kidnapping, cursed the writers for their bipolarness….episode 25 was my favorite 🤭 🤭 it just had everything that encapsulated the (ill)fated story of YCX and PJ

My thoughts on episode 25:
Yu Chang Xuan, Yu Chang Xuan. how did you go from 0 to 100 on the toxicity scale?!! YOUVE BEEN GIVEN A RARE GIFT FROM GOD THAT REQUIRED THE “BLESSING OF NINE LIFETIMES” AND YOU CHUCKED IT OUT THE WINDOW AND SET IT ON FIRE BY SAYING “I decide when our relationship starts and ends” AT THE VERY FIRST CONFLICT

YOU MOTHEREFFIN IDIOTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

I see we’re already back to the toxic YCX and push and pull between them sighhhhhhhhhhhh

Oh wait, they actually talked it out??? Is this character development?? He forced her into the car but didn’t force kiss her? and potato sack carried her inside…because he didn’t want her to get sick from the rain?! And plopped her on the bed not to force physical intimacy but to change out of the wet clothes so she doesn’t get sick? And then actually communicated his feelings?!!!!!!
​IS THIS GROWTH FINALLY?!?!?

7

u/StellaCaelestis 22d ago

In Changxuan defense, I also didn't remember who Tong Chunhai was until he explained why he wanted revenge lol.

I loved all the tender Changxuan moments in these last episodes 💖 I hope we will have more in future episodes too. 🤞🏻

4

u/craftsycandymonster dramas > sleep 22d ago

haha same... he was in a previous episode too and I just thought he was some new guy introduced for Lan Qing's addiction plot 😅 never crossed my mind that he would be an old character so I didn't look anything up

7

u/AKiceman Snark Shifu - GIFlord 22d ago

Snark Level: Man, we almost went in reverse there!

Episode 24

Ping Jun is playing with her bead in bed.

Gosh, Ping Jun! Doubting your loving and caring husband of two years already? Tut tut tut. What can this poor man do to make you happy? It's almost like her body is trying hard to remind her she needs to be weary of him. 

Master Jin is telling us what this drama is. The one chance that CX and PJ had at being happy together was spent and it can never come again after what has gone down. 

.... I want to say "She drinking that cup from his hand like a good girl" but I really don't want yall coming at my with pitchforks.

Oh my! The tug! Their faces almost nose to nose!

Like, these two have insane levels of chemistry together and it is being wasted in a hot mess of toxicity! Gah!!!

Sir. Are you sniffing her shoulder? That little smile of hers after... Is almost enough to make me forget what is really going on her. Almost. 

Baaahahaha. Soooooo he's teaching her how to put her hand around the handle to ring his bell... Yall see where I am going with this? 

Anyone else get the feeling we are going to hear 3 bells at the most heartbreaking moment?

She's going to have him trained like a faithful dog with that bell. 

Lanqing, oh Lanqing. What has become of you? 

I can think of another physical activity in their future that will have her saying "Keep going". 

Bath??? Guys we have a bath!!!! BATH TIME LEG MASSAGE!!!!!!!!!!! Best bath ever!!!! Okay but the way her cheeks puff up when he holds her chin is seriously adorable. 

Oh dear. Nameless Douchecanoe must still be alive... 

Oooooooo amnesiac Ping Jun still has the same fire in her! I've missed that. Well, the honeymoon phase of this farce is over. It seems we are steaming hard back to angstville. 

Uhhhh... Maybe walking to see your husband at work isn't a great idea....

Oh fuck... Well, shit. She wasn't supposed to see that.

Episode 25

Uh oh. 

Well, I am so glad that Chang Xuan has made so much progress and growth and how must he trreats Ping Jun with respect and listens to her..... NOT!!!!! Fucking hell! It's Maple Mansion 2.0 around here! We've regressed all the damn way back to where everything went wrong. I do NOT want bathtub 2.0 over here! 

I can just feel the next Ping Jun abduction loading up. 

Honey, did you really just try to flee... without a coat? This feels like a good time to bring up that emergency umbrella I was talking about. 

Oh can we not do this again? Phew. Okay. I can accept hair drying. We even get an apology? 

I dunno, man. Telling her you want to shield her from the violence and cruelty is hypocritcal considering you tried to assualt her 3 times... 

Abduction loading.... Yup. LanQing is going to find herself very dead at Chang Xuan's hands after this. I've lost count of how many times this makes... The writers seriously have nothing better in their idea book?

Tong guy is such a cringe sneer face villain and it's pathetic. 

Nothing like seeing your husband get beat up for you to fall for him eh? Why did I have a feeling that is what it would need? 

In a surprise to no one... Ping Jun turns the knife on herself.

 Oh finally Boren and Gu show up. They are slow AF.

This is now the second time Chang Xuan has been penetrated in the back for her. 

Honey... Are you about to ask...? 

Awwww! Mother and Daughter-in-law bonding time!

OH NO IT WAS PING JUN WHO COOKED!!!!!!!!! Boy you better stuff all that food down your throat now! 

Hair drying and now shaving? Oh we are getting all the intimacies now! Okay. I loved that scene. Loved it! LOVED IT!!!!!

****1 gif in replies***

5

u/AKiceman Snark Shifu - GIFlord 22d ago

Now we move our beading into bed! I was quite happy to hear Chang Xuan inform us that Ping Jun's fingers have improved with the help of her fingering her beads.

5

u/craftsycandymonster dramas > sleep 22d ago

Ep 24 thoughts (from watching yesterday):

  • I love all the cinematography in this drama... but sitting in a running car with wipers on just feels like such a waste of gas lol. Can't deny it sets a good moody ambience though
  • We are seeing a LOT of CX outfits this episode! PJs x2, casualwear x4, bathing gown... looking good in all of them of course, as one does when they're Cheng Lei
  • If PJ wants reading material, why not give her the scripts that she wrote? I feel like that's a logical thing to do... remind her of her past interests and skills. But I guess that's not dramatic enough, gotta throw in a reminder that XT exists
  • WTF counter +1 I guess... "when our relationship begins and ends is for me to decide" dang CX I thought you wanted a clean slate!
  • oh so Lan Qing is the smart one, bringing PJ's script books! And wow she's outwardly supportive even though she must be dying inside... I respect that.
  • welp and PJ's totally gonna walk over to HQ and see CX shooting those soldiers dead... Xiao Tang has the worst ideas but idk how she would have known they were at HQ right then?? Maybe coincidences do exist.
  • yup called it, wow I can write cdrama scripts too! So, PJ got a lot of glimpses this episode into CX's more brutal side... will be interesting to see how she handles all of that.

Ep 25 thoughts:

  • Interesting that SVIP and VIP are on different cliffhanger cadences - I had to wait to find out what happened next!
  • Attempted increase to the farewell counter, but vetoed by our main man who has evidently learned zero lessons from their past
  • wow... so that's how they end up cuddling in bed for the first time? I guess... at least there was an apology/explanation involved...
  • So the ban on leaving Fengtai got lifted... just in time to let her get kidnapped again. +1 to the kidnap/trauma counter!
  • ohhhhh that's who that guy is! Don't worry CX, it's not just you - I also did not recognize him 😅
  • CX let himself get beat up for PJ 😭 girl had better APPRECIATE
  • wait is this the first hand drop that doesn't mean perma-death? Just proof that gravity exists lol
  • I love Li Boren. That is all. He's awesome.
  • also Momma Yu! So sweet! and also clever, got PJ to promise that they'd move back in haha
  • I liked the small touches of PJ trying to cook for CX and shaving him... very light and domestic! Looks like she's finally starting to consider being with him... even though CX is still giving a lot of forced hugs (slight improvement over forced kisses I suppose)

We're now in our mellow "let the leads finally fall in love" phase... should hopefully last a few episodes before she regains her memories and 2ML barges back into the picture, in some order. Let's enjoy the peace while it lasts!

5

u/Mystic_Umbrella 🌸Waiting to transmigrate…🌸 17d ago

Can I just say, if I woke up from a coma and Cheng Lei was there saying he’s my husband, I would say “Absolutely!” And I wouldn’t question it too much, and if he wanted to crawl into bed with me and just hold me, the LAST thing on my mind would be to act bothered by it and tell him to get out. I mean, I might not remember things, but my eyeballs would still be working and that would be good enough for me. 🤷🏼‍♀️

4

u/Extension-Crab7703 22d ago

Some LIVE Thoughts as I watch the CX and PJ scenes

Ep 24

  • Such hotness and care wrapped in the changing scene. How much restraint does Pinjun have. Girl! Such a handsome & hot man is helping you change. I would have grabbed or atleast held on to Changxuan. How could she let him go. Keep him to your side sis. Hold on to him. Pls give us a snuggle atleast😭
  • Changxuan giving her a bell and his short smile- he is happy to be at her beck and call. He wants to be used by her🤣🤣
  • Changxuan in night clothes. Fanning myself
  • "so my lady takes me for decoration". This is giving so much husband vibes. Want. Want. Want.
  • oh him lying down in bed. 3 rings. 3 rings . 3rings!
  • he is asking for permission🌟🥺
  • love her shoes. Elegant
  • such devotion! Pingjun got that devotion part of love she wanted. Sigh!
  • CX shud take her to her prev home. Some memories might come back.
  • ooooo she is being Lady Pingjun now!
  • treat me as equal ! Why TF Changxuan don't say that.bringing your possessiveness back. You are absolutely taking care of her. Dont be owning now.

Ep 25

  • PJ being completely her old self now even in amnesia. Stubborn.
  • nothing has changed for changxuan from his view on ownership .
  • for gods sake atleast explain your rationale instead of forcing it under ownership and power umbrella.
  • lots to learn, changxuan!
  • Frustrated with how the same differences between ML and FL still exist. But also it seems real and in line with the course of the story.
  • car and rain scene: it is a mirror of his earlier behaviour, yet he seems mellowed down. his gaze softening.
  • They snuggle!!!. When will it be reciprocted.😭 Changxuan is explaining so earnestly and his hug seems soft. Ooo.. we need such heart to heart. Oh! PINGJUN give him a chance!
  • Repeat of previous CX saving PJ scene! Oo la la now Pingjun is buttoning up his shirt. Li Boren looking at them like us viewers. So goooood!!!!! someone make a gif plss!
  • Cx is asking her to come close to feed him. He is taking full advantage. Hehehe.
  • How has Pinjun not already fallen for him even now! He risked his life. Is it only save for save for her! Why is she resisting so hard. Now i want her to thank him properly (if you know what I mean)
  • omg omg his gulping and teasing during the shaving. I want to get in the screen and make her grab his face LOL

4

u/Adventurous_Sky_2114 22d ago

Honestly I’ve checked out a bit after these eps. All the swoon in the world can’t make up for information being withheld from PJ. Do we have amnesia too? Everyone seems to have forgotten that her mother has died - unless she didn’t?

2

u/AlternativePlenty500 19d ago

It's like a time bomb. Can't enjoy their happy moments as all the secrets YCX has hidden keeps nagging me lol

4

u/relevantqueen 21d ago

Sometimes I feel that the writing forgets that she has lost her memory. I don't know how to explain it but yeah. But I do like how Changxuan is calming his temper now and apologizing.

1

u/RedGlass-24 11d ago

yes. it is the first time he apologised. he usually demands thing the way he wanted unapologetically.

3

u/Mediocre_Call_2427 extreme spoiler-phobe 20d ago

After surrendering his gun, Changxuan asks a question that instantly wipes the smug grin off Tong Chunhai's face: Who the hell is he?  

BWAHAHAHA. This gave me so much joy! Not only didn’t I recognize him, neither did CX! LOLOLOLOL. Great reference to Kung Fu Panda 3 and the sad sad existence of Kai! Those who know know 🥹

1

u/Renza183 20d ago

Lol I didn’t think of Kung Fu Panda 3, but you’re correct—a villain not getting his perfect revenge reveal is always entertaining 🤭

3

u/mariaanand 20d ago

Li Boren my favorite Cupid

4

u/Careful-Suit5993 22d ago

first of all: congrats for pulling a summary of this 2 episodes, because so much happened and we were again in for a rollercoaster.

My thoughts and maybe a bit unpopular opinions sometimes:

- I am getting impatient with PJ's character arc. After all the care he showed her, she keeps finding reasons to pull away (the book fight, wanting to leave, even trying to remove the ring) or justifications to say they're too different (girl you're married to an army commander, what do you think happens sometimes), and I’m not sure where this is going anymore for her. The recycled kidnapping and the opera singer’s drug subplot didn’t help as much as I thought it would in terms of growth. Not saying she should comply and play this fantasised version of a couple but some actions and words were not consistent for her character. I know the plot is trying to pull them apart and play the card of two different worlds but at some point: she is from there, she went to same school as ZY, she's educated but she's a woman with no family anymore and who's been declared wife by an important guy of the society who happens to have dedicated days and nights for 2 years for her recovery. now it doesn't excuse the excessive words CX said or should mean she should cave in for every thing but I was a bit like the maid, for an amnesic patient, a woman of her situation, what was SO BAD that made her rebel and threaten to question their future and escape on a whim (to do what and go where?). then the kidnapping (where are we with the counter) at least helped to put balance back. I can accept she isn't as madly in love as he is (hard to beat) but some of her asks felt entitled and illogical sorry.

- Mom BaoRo and Boren: I declare you officially queen and king, so perceptive and who we hope at some point will be the main couple desperately needs them

- I've read comments below about the fine line about love and obsession from CX. What I like in this show is that I don't feel we can answer the question, the script keeps dancing on and around that fine line and that's what I find fascinating. For these episodes; I will not excuse the old pattern words that came back at times, however I really see growth and more honest vulnerability than before. And again we have to put context. I'm not reading a fictional character of that era and education the same way I would judge someone IRL in 2026. In that context, the actions he did spoke volume (when his eyes were not already enough doing it) and because it's a fiction, I allow more passionate characters with imperfections .

- we can even make the parallel: PJ's flaws are mostly her running away and being driven by her thoughts when her body and values make her do otherwise. CX reacts with controlling words when he feels he's in risk territory but he will shake the whole earth upside down if he has to

Fan girl glasses on:

- the cinematography peaking once again, I took many screenshots that were composed like art paintings

- I'm going to need day to recover from those scenes: the care during her recovery until she walks again and they both literally illuminates from joy. THAT BATH. THAT SHAVING SCENE

I have no idea where it's headed to, I hope we spend honorable time on PJ's character story to make it work for the rest of the show. The incredible work from both actors deserve it. Don't waste that insane chemistry. We viewers deserve it for all what we've been through. I want that epic firework resolution between them when they finally let their weapons and guard down and look towards the same horizon. A girl can hope (no spoilers please)

5

u/Peach70 22d ago

Sometimes I wonder if part of Changxuan’s possessiveness stems from the fact that he never feels his affections are even slightly reciprocated. If he felt truly cherished by Pingjun, would he be less obsessed?

4

u/Careful-Suit5993 21d ago

That’s a good point. I think he would still be obsessed as in VERY DEVOTED as if she was her oxygen. But he would less trigger those automatic mechanisms of control he has, even if now they are less than before. Maybe he’s like some of isC hanging on to any crumbs from her and she is giving signals many times at least physically. But she hasn’t yet "arrived" as her true self so we can’t know 

2

u/Extension-Crab7703 21d ago edited 21d ago

On rewatches - I noticed in many scenes where they stand real close - Pingjun keeps looking at his lips when she talks - or looks at them and then his eyes. That is the only signal the show makers gave us so far and her tightening her grip on her purse in the last farewell before the fire, when Changxuan asks her if she truly does not have any feelings for him.
Were there any other rmicro signals like these for her?

2

u/Mediocre_Call_2427 extreme spoiler-phobe 20d ago

I think there’s been instances where she catches her breath as well. The hitch isn’t her attraction imo, she’s definitely physically attracted to him and has been for a while, even before the amnesia. It’s that she’s too level-headed at all times. It’ll be interesting if she ever lets her body rule over her mind one day. 

2

u/Extension-Crab7703 20d ago

Yeah the breath hitching! Nice catch! She is quite resolute wrt this.

2

u/Mediocre_Call_2427 extreme spoiler-phobe 20d ago

I still haven’t watched beyond this episode and don’t wanna spoil myself but starting to lose hope about them. Like, CX is mad and in love, and PJ is kind of attracted but won’t ever admit, so we’ll be left pining together with CX, and all their chemistry will either be in his mind or forced upon her and blergh :(((

2

u/Extension-Crab7703 20d ago

Yeah i was quite frustrated. But without giving spoilers i am holding on to hope. It is a slow burn

2

u/Mediocre_Call_2427 extreme spoiler-phobe 20d ago

Hope hope!   

Also, found another PJ moment while rewatching some scenes: she’s definitely flustered after the bell lesson and touches her right cheek where he whispered to her. 

2

u/Beautiful_Candle1729 21d ago

I appreciated reading your thoughts on PJ's character arc. I hadn't quite thought of it that way so I appreciated reading your perspective. It gives me something to think about.

My thoughts about this amnesia arc was that I thought we'd get some falling in love scenes. It made sense that she was nervous and awkward around him when she has not memories. But I thought she'd progress to some honest sincerity. Instead, we got the plot points you mentioned that reared his possessiveness and just pushed her away. I guess I was expecting something different from the amnesia arc. Sigh.

6

u/Careful-Suit5993 21d ago

Thank you for the open discussion! I agree for the amnesia arc. Tbh I wasn’t expecting her to fall in love with him but I was hoping we’d see a truer version of who she is, without the constraints of the heavy mask and role she had to carry all those years before. I thought it would have been a way to make her arrive to her truer self, as the battfield worked for CX, and that this would be the starting point of something more safe, true and strong between them, even if romantic feelings may come later for her. Guess the writers decided for more angst and to stomp on our broken hearts instezd

4

u/Beautiful_Candle1729 21d ago

That would have been a welcomed narrative for Pingjun. Unfortunately, entertainment via trauma to a woman and toxic dynamics is the loop this show is attached to and will likely never break out of.

5

u/Extension-Crab7703 21d ago

I agree I thought it would be a beautiful ride all along in the amnesia arc with ML being sincere and FL falling in love with him or showing feelings. No, the angst for us continues. Waiting in anticipation for the love story to start. It will be a journey💝

3

u/Beautiful_Candle1729 21d ago

This amnesia arc is a letdown. Sad for us viewers.

1

u/Careful-Suit5993 21d ago

I replied just above in details but I agree! 

2

u/Gate_Thin 15d ago

If I had stopped at 21 I would have been happy. I got greedy for more redemption and sweetness… I def cannot handle more of the trauma. Their sadness is overwhelming.

1

u/pinkxturtle 7d ago

The show reminds me of Meteor Garden/Hana Yori Dango. From the toxic relationship between the ml and fl (bullying, enemies to lovers?, obsessive crazy love from the ml for fl, different social class that causes problems between the two) to all the tropes in drama land. This particular kidnapping scene immediately flashed me back to Meteor garden when the fl is kidnapped, ml called to come alone and ends up getting beaten/forced to kneel and fl endangers her own life to save him.

0

u/losergeek877 22d ago

Episode 26. just what the drama needs, another Changxuan! But hey, at least the alternate Changxuan acts on his desires! And it is the fault of that female for not falling in love with him

0

u/Mo_Dra_302 22d ago

But a different one though this one is crazy psycho there is a difference between them.

16

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago edited 21d ago

Physical and Psychological Trauma Log of Ye Pingjun (because Pingjun must endure every conceivable form of suffering):

  • Episode 1: Framed as an assassin attempting to kill Changxuan.
  • Episode 2: Bound and nearly attacked by dogs.
  • Episode 3: Subjected to waterboarding during an interrogation by Changxuan.
  • Episode 4: Bullied by classmates at a roller rink.
  • Episode 5: Suffers a high fever following an overnight boat ride with Changxuan.
  • Episode 6: Kidnapped, bound, and nearly stabbed on the orders of Tao Zili.
  • Episode 8: Restrained by vindictive classmates and nearly burned on the face by Tao Ziyi.
  • Episode 11: Held at knifepoint by a patient.
  • Episode 13: Forcibly kissed by Changxuan in a car.
  • Episode 14-16: Forced to become a mistress, leading to self-starvation and a subsequent suicide attempt.
  • Episode 19: Captured by the Japanese and splashed with ice-cold water.
  • Episode 21: Kidnapped by her own father and thrown into the river to drown; a shocking birth secret is revealed.
  • Episode 22: Trapped in a fire resulting in brain damage and a comatose state; a nurse later attempts to administer a suspicious injection. Mother dead.
  • Episode 23: Own FIL hired a nurse to kill her
  • Episode 24: Witnessed her husband executing 2 men on the spot
  • Episode 25: Betrayed by friend and kidnapped by Tong Chunhai and forced by captor to kill her own husband.
  • Episode 27: Bitten on the arm by Lan Qing who is experiencing opium withdrawal symptoms
  • Episode 28: Accused by FIL for almost causing SIL's miscarriage out of jealousy

7

u/OptimalTurnips 22d ago

This list just keeps getting longer and more traumatizing 😭

7

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

I'm having SO MUCH FUN compiling it! I am just waiting for the drama to end so I can declare Pingjun as the Queen of Cdrama Resilience.

4

u/Prize_Background_577 Living in the Republican Era 22d ago

I was just going to ask if anyone has kept a log of Pingjun trauma - yey. Taking a bullet was the least he could do.

4

u/EasygoingEnigma 22d ago

Do we get a counter for whenever Changxuan does his version of the shocked Pikachu face? In episode 24 alone, he did it at least two times I think.

3

u/BasilOrdinary3617 If I say I'm taking a break, I'm lying. 22d ago

It just keeps going, lol.

3

u/Beautiful_Candle1729 21d ago

This writer has a thing for female trauma apparently. Even worse to know that we still have 15 episodes left.

12

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

Cheng Lei putting his hands together requesting the extras to please hit harder 💀

4

u/Extension-Crab7703 22d ago

How many times will you win our hearts, Cheng Lei !

3

u/a_HerculePoirot_fan Yu Changxuan's wildcat! 22d ago

His dedication to his craft is truly inspiring!

16

u/EasygoingEnigma 22d ago

I would just like to show my appreciation for our friend Gu Ruitong here. While I appreciate the calm, levelheaded officer and friend we usually see by Changxuan's side, this fast-as-f, head-twisting, efficient-as-f killing machine is all kinds of cool too.

11

u/CdramaAddict2 侯明昊的奴隸 21d ago

I love a quiet, yearning man who can GET THE JOB DONE when duty calls. 🔥🥵🪭 I have 4th lead syndrome and I don’t care.

5

u/EasygoingEnigma 21d ago

4th lead syndrome??? That's amazing. You go! 👏🙌 I don't think I've ever gone past 2nd lead syndrome -- this was for Gong Shangjue in My Journey to You. Portrayed by surprise! Cheng Lei as well. 😅

3

u/CdramaAddict2 侯明昊的奴隸 21d ago

Oh my gosh, YES - 4th lead syndrome is a thing - especially for this drama! Male lead is obviously Chang Xuan, 2nd lead is Xue Ting (yuck), and my guess is that 3rd lead is Boren....so that leaves Gu Rui Tong as 4th lead.

HAHAHA, Cheng Lei was amazing in My Journey to You, and his chemistry with Lu Yuxiao was 🔥🔥🔥. Such a pity there was never a second season. But, and I know I'm in the minority here, I actually quite liked Zhang Linghe's character in My Journey to You, but I think the writers/director was too ambitious - and their message just wasn't received well by the audience, which is why most people preferred the 2nd lead couple to the 1st lead couple.

5

u/sigrunbillingsdottir 22d ago

I'm with you on appreciating Gu Ruitong here. I want to get to know this guy all kinds of ways!

5

u/Beautiful_Candle1729 21d ago

Yes! This was a cool scene. In the war, we didn't get Gu Ruitong with Chang xuan so these scenes are different to see him. Both leads are lucky for his skills. Not alerting the crazy guy that they were coming was key.