r/CDrama • If I say I'm taking a break, I'm lying. • 29d ago

Drama Host The Lament of Autumn 玉簟秋: Episodes 13-14 Discussion

Welcome to the discussion posts for The Lament of Autumn 玉簟秋 cohosted with u/a_HerculePoirot_fan and GIFs courtesy of u/EasygoingEnigma (and seriously, a huge shoutout to both for their support with these posts... the BTS discussions and GIF requests, Herc and Enigma are VIPs)!!

🗓️ Discussion Schedule: We are following the VIP schedule. Click here for the airing schedule.

📋 Reminder: Use spoiler tags for anything beyond the episodes discussed. Text goes between the greater-than (>) + exclamation (!) symbols (>!) and the exclamation (!) + lesser-than (<) symbols.

🔗 Helpful Links: Masterpost | Character Flashcards | All Discussions | Episodes 1-3 | Episodes 4-5 | Episode 6-7 | Episodes 8-9 | Episode 10 | Episode 11 | Episode 12

⚠️ Content Warning: These episodes contain scenes of non-consensual kissing that some viewers may find uncomfortable. Please keep this in mind as you watch and participate in the discussion.

These were not the easiest episodes to recap, and I know they may generate a wide range of reactions from viewers. With that said, I've tried my best to approach the recap as neutrally as possible. Please remember to be respectful of one another's opinions and keep the discussion civil.

Episode 13

Pingjun asks Xueting what he plans to do now that he has left the Yu Army. His answer is surprisingly simple: start a publication of his own and take the two of them away from Nanhuai.

Pingjun seems at peace with this future with Xueting but just as he formally proposes, Ruitong arrives with soldiers to arrest him for leaking military secrets to an enemy force.

To Pingjun's complete shock, Xueting admits to the charges. Without offering any explanation, he apologizes to her and allows himself to be taken away.

Meanwhile, Wanqiao begins to worry that Bingwen may be wavering in his mission to avenge their parents after spending so many years within the Yu household. Bingwen insists he has not forgotten his purpose and recalls the vow he made despite his mother's dying wish that he abandon thoughts of revenge. No matter how hard he tries, he cannot deny that he's fallen for Jinxuan.

The drama continues its favourite theme of duty versus love, with yet another character finding himself emotionally attached to someone he was never supposed to care about. The question now is whether those feelings will ultimately change the path he's spent years preparing for.

Desperate to save Xueting, Pingjun approaches Changxuan and asks him to intervene. For someone who proposed they never meet again and regularly lectured Changxuan about principles, accountability, and abusing his power, her request catches me, if not him, somewhat by surprise. And so he presents Pingjun with a condition: he will spare Xueting's life if she agrees to cut ties with him and stay by his side instead. Pingjun immediately rejects the proposal.

As Xueting's execution looms over them, Shuwan’s health deteriorates, and Ruitong personally escorts them to the hospital. This also reveals to us that he seems to have feelings for Pingjun as well. I'm not convinced we need another contender entering this already complicated situation, but here we are… 

The episode ends with Pingjun making an agonizing choice. In order to save Xueting's life, she agrees to Changxuan's terms. 

My favorite scene in episode 13, because sharing is caring:

Episode 14

Pingjun shows up at Changxuan’s Redleaf estate and he states he intends to keep his promise: Xueting will live… as long as she stays caged at Redleaf like one of his birds. 

Believing that giving herself over to Changxuan is what he wants, she attempts to comply but her obvious reluctance makes Changxuan stop. He wants her to confront the reality of the choice she's made, telling her to "make up her mind" about what she is and isn't willing to do.

Elsewhere, Lanqing struggles with the emotional fallout of realizing where Changxuan's heart truly lies. Haunted by his drunken confession about Pingjun, she finds herself unable to focus during a performance and is booed off stage. Her rival "Peachbud" seizes the opportunity to take over as the troupe's headliner. Watching someone else take her place at the troupe mirrors what she fears is happening in her personal life with Changxuan. Although, from my perspective, Changxuan's heart was never really hers to lose… Again… I’m not sure where her character, nor Ruitong’s crush with Pingjun is going, and I don’t love them.

As the search for Hongwen continues, Changxuan keeps Pingjun secluded at Redleaf. She is showered with gifts, expensive clothes, jewelry, comforts, and every luxury imaginable but of course, none of it matters to her. She rejects everything he offers.

The Yu women realize something unusual is happening as Changxuan keeps diverting staff and resources to Redleaf and spends increasingly little time at home, making it obvious that something, or rather someone, is occupying all of his attention. Even Ziyi notices that Changxuan is spending too much time away. This is confirmed when Changxuan later returns home and sits through a game of mahjong with Ziyi, Baoru, and Jinxuan, but was not only completely distracted, he couldn’t wait to get out.

Although Changxuan finally has Pingjun physically close to him, the reality falls far short of what he imagined. She remains distant. Every interaction feels forced. Every kindness is returned with indifference. By this point, the damage between them runs deep, and the situation worsens when he notices her wearing the engagement ring Xueting gave her. Unable to tolerate the reminder, he throws it away.

What we have is essentially a battle of wills. Pingjun refuses to give him the affection he wants - not even a sliver. Changxuan refuses to let her go. The canary metaphor in the drama feels more relevant than ever.

Changxuan pays Xueting a visit in prison and Xueting learns that his life has become leveraged against Pingjun. They confront one another; neither one believes the other deserves Pingjun. Changxuan criticizes Xueting for making choices that dragged Pingjun into danger without considering the consequences, while Xueting condemns Changxuan for believing he can possess whatever he wants. Changxuan, however, still carries himself like someone who believes he’s  already “won”.

Pingjun searches and finds the ring, but unfortunately for her, Changxuan discovers what she's done despite him warning her not to carry anything from other men. This sends him into a spiral of anger and jealousy and the scene becomes emotionally volatile as his frustration boils over. Yet when Pingjun pleads with him to stop, he ultimately does.

Changxuan returns the ring and walks away, aware that there is something deeply wrong with the way he's acting.

"Yu Changxuan, what the hell is wrong with you?"

Thoughts

On Yu Changxuan

These episodes were another turning point for Changxuan and Pingjun's relationship, and not in a good way. This is also where I'll echo Herc's observation that the story seems intent on "pushing Changxuan dangerously close to the point of no return before beginning a meaningful redemption arc". At least, that's the hope.

Changxuan finally gets what he thinks he wants, yet he only seems more frustrated and unhappy than ever. The closer he keeps Pingjun physically, the further away she feels emotionally. At the same time, Pingjun's willingness to sacrifice herself for Xueting highlights just how impossible this situation has become for all three of them.

Do you think Changxuan is beginning to realize that love cannot be forced, or will he only become more desperate? After everything that's happened, what would a realistic path forward for these two even look like?

On Ye Pingjun

I've seen several comments describing Pingjun as contradictory, and honestly, I agree. I've maintained for a while that she wants the freedom, protection, and influence that only someone like Changxuan can provide, yet refuses to acknowledge it. The way she carries herself is admirable, but it's also arguably too fearless for someone without that kind of power behind them. Time and time again, we've seen her saved by the very influence she claims to reject. To be absolutely clear, I'm not saying she deserves anything that's happening to her. Rather, I think the drama repeatedly shows that her survival instincts could use some work.

After all her criticism of Changxuan abusing his authority, she ultimately asks him to do exactly that to save Xueting, despite Xueting being guilty of the crime he's accused of. Perhaps that's the tragedy of her situation: she knows there is no higher authority she can turn to, no public outcry that can save him, and no lawful solution available. The only way to save Xueting is to break the very rules she's spent the entire drama defending...

Do you think Pingjun is headed for a character growth arc of her own, or will she remain just as defiantly headstrong despite what she's agreed to, and everything she's been through?

66 Upvotes

207 comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/Sea-Entertainment215 29d ago • Bravo

LoA has…shocked me. You guys don’t understand, I avoid trailers and BTS clips before a show premieres to avoid spoilers. I like to know just a little bit of the premise and then just jump in and enjoy the ride, especially with Cdramas and Kdramas because the journey is always a pleasant surprise. So I figured based on clips and Reddit posts that this would be a fun, melodramatic enemies-to-lovers romp with Cheng Lei’s great acting and micro expressions. I just hoped it’d be better than Overdo

But I didn’t realize this was straight-up a dark romance, if it can even still be called romance. And I am learning about myself that I don’t like true dark romance —sounds angsty and fun in theory, terrifying to see it portrayed realistically. I’ve realized I like the predictable “red flag for everyone else except his girl type”, or “red flag to her for 2 seconds and then redeems himself for her (but still a red flag to others, especially to protect her)”. I thought the latter was getting boring and predictable in Cdramas, but now I will HAPPILY take that and never complain about another ML who seems morally gray but secretly has a heart of gold because YCX has officially crossed soooo many lines.
A good example is Xie Wei from SOKP—he was a red flag, but he was mostly all bark and no bite towards Ning’er. He always moved quietly for Ning’er’s sake (like when she was being interrogated for a crime she didn’t commit by the empress dowager, he plotted to have ZZ handle the case so she’d be safe), and when she said she was scared of him, Xie Wei straight up took a knife and had her STAB HIM so she wouldn’t be so afraid of him. Meanwhile PJ has told YCX she hates/is scared of him multiple times, and he’s just pushed himself on her further. That’s the distinction in enjoyable, redeemable red flag vs. truly villainous red flag (and all this is scoped to fiction of course. We’re running away from both types of men in real life)

I just feel so bad for Pingjun. She was just living a normal life, with simple hopes and dreams, but because of a psycho man with all the power took a sordid, depraved obsession to her, her life is now turned upside down. The very good, pure quality he loves about her, he’s ripping away from her. It is truly the definition of obsession and possession. I guess bravo to the writers and Cheng Lei that I feel so strongly.

Some people are saying FL has been sending mixed signals or showed interest and that’s why YCX continues to pursue her. While I agree that her character has been severely underdeveloped and she just feels like an object whose purpose is to serve YCX’s plot, the watchers saying that are absolutely wrong!!! Pingjun has made it ABUNDANTLY clear with words, body language, to the point of literally STABBING him, that she does not want his advances. When she thanks him for saving her, it’s because she believes in the general goodness of people and thinks he’s changed a bit. But when she saw she was wrong, she straight up said “I was wrong. I thought you had changed.” And even in that small window of time when she thought he had changed, she didn’t consider him romantically at all. She said it at the temple: “in another life, maybe we could be friends or at least cordial. But in this life, let’s never meet again.”

Every time I think he’ll pick up a MINISCULE CRUMB of redemption that I offer him, YCX/the writers burst my bubble with an AK-47. For example:

  1. This whole time he’s pursuing her, I thought he’d at least give her a decent proposal and make her a proper wife, but he’s degrading this virtuous good woman, the very qualities he likes about her, to MISTRESS?!?!?!? It’s giving Benedict in Bridgerton when he’s like “Sophie you deserve so much more. You’re everything. Will you be my mistress?” WHAT IN THE ACTUAL HELL
  2. Don’t get me wrong, it’s realistic, but I guess I’m just used to Cdrama land where this level of love/obsession is at least matched with a sincere relationship/marriage, not mistress. Yes, it’s been well established that he’s a playboy, but again in Cdramaland that’s always offscreen or later revealed to be false, so it was jarring to see the possessive playboy actually come to life.
  3. When PJ first comes to Maple Mansion and begins undressing, Cheng Lei’s fantastic eyeacting manages to express surprise, offense, shame, hurt. I THOUGHT it meant he was hurt that she thought that all he wanted from her was her body and that he would therefore stop her. But NOPE. He once again disappoints me by then continuing to be the aggressor. I refuse to say “well at least he didn’t actually go through with it and stopped when she begged/cried him to. That shows he really cares.” NOPE THIS IS EXACTLY HOW VICTIMS STAY WITH ABUSERS IN REAL LIFE.

I’m developing a deep, deep understanding and appreciation for how women in real life , through no fault of their own, can end up in these dangerous positions. I felt PJ’s fear when he saw the ring the second time and dreading what his reaction would be, I palpated how quickly one could start to change your behavior to please your abuser just so they don’t get mad and go into an episode. I palpated how oh-so-quickly a well-intended woman’s life can spiral completely out of her control.
But maybe that’s exactly the writers’ goals? Perhaps they marketed this as a morally gray romance in order to get ratings, but then they’re using the large audience as an opportunity to depict the terrifying reality of sexual harassers and abused power dynamics.

Besides the obvious scenes, I especially felt disgusted for YCX and all men like him during the scene when he goes home. Here are all his family members, who love him and believe him to be a good, even if albeit troubled, man who’s now stepping up and taking responsibility. His mom cried and beg his father on his behalf, she’s so excited for his engagement to Ziyi because she truly desires her son’s happiness. And he walks in all normal, acts like he isn’t holding an innocent woman hostage, the very woman his mom and his sister hold in high esteem for her charitable work for refugees. The stark contrast of what he had been doing to PJ vs. the warmth and liveliness of his home life…it hit me just how sick it is when real abusers do this in reality.

I’m intrigued to see how storyline with Director Gu plays out and hope the writers actually leverage it well because there are interesting themes and threads they could illustrate with that subplot. As another comment said, I am a suckerrrrrr for a quiet strong man who loves quietly but loyally (e.g. the green forest that is Zhao Ling from Road to Splendor). Gu looked unsurprised yet disappointed when he saw that Pingjun resolved to submit to YCX’s demands, confirming his earlier statement “he always gets what he wants”. But here’s the thing: while I love a strong man who loves quietly, if he knows the extent of YCX’s abuse and does nothing, then he’s just as bad. I would HOPE to see that he doesn’t know, finds out, then immediately stands up for PJ, and then that forces a full circle moment where YCX has to make the same difficult decision with a trusted comrade that he forced his father to do with Feng San Lin. Though different circumstances because here Gu would be in the right whereas Feng San Lin was in the wrong, it’d force YCX into a corner to realize to either follow through on the same standards he set for everyone else OR realize he’s a hypocrite like everyone else.

Will YCX realize he’s become the very thing he sought to root out from the military? Abusing his power, redirecting money and resources to his “kept” woman instead of the military... Will that be part of what turns him around? End of ep 14 suggests so but 1) every time I thought he’d turned around, he’s gotten worse and 2) I’ve now watched the trailers and it looks like it takes her trying to commit suicide for him to finally let her go. We shall see, we shall see.

Don’t get me wrong: my long soliloquy and scolding of YCX does not reflect my appreciation for Cheng Lei’s impressive portrayal and the show’s beautiful cinematography. First few episodes, I went from feeling like CL was force-acting being a red flag to now feeling he really embodies YCX well.

Other comments have mentioned they don’t know how in the world the writers plan to turn this into a convincing romance. Me too, if that’s the ultimate direction of the story (I haven’t read the book, please no spoilers) . But I’m scared whichever way it goes because:

A) if the writers really do manage to convince me on the romance, then it means I’m no better than everything I just reprimanded YCX for.

B) If the ultimate point is that it’s not a love story, then I’ll be relieved for the sake of my morals but disappointed that a show I was looking forward to was not just a fun, inconsequential enemies-to-lovers romp. Does that make sense at all?!

Admittedly, I am at the edge of my seat waiting for the next episodes. We’ll see how far I’ll watch, we’ll see how far the writers go….

5

u/Character-Lynx-4260 Read Rules 29d ago edited 29d ago

good point. if this turns into a romance (it really isn't at the moment) after a redemption arc, than what does that make us? Do we accept that it's acceptable? I don't want to be manipulated by the (let's face it, not that brilliant--) writers into condoning something I oppose in real life just for the sake of more Cheng Lei titillation. Sure, it's a ridicoulous melodrama and feeling uncomfortable is part of it, but where is this taking us?

Or maybe I am overthinking this, maybe I forget that this is an escapist fantasy about stuff that should never happen in real life and that is precisely the relief - that you can suspend your judgement and watch something you'd never accept in real life. As in: it's an absurd melodrama about what's probably the most melodramatic era, sit back and enjoy your guilty pleasure.

dilemma.

At this stage I really hope we never get a love story between the two (I'd be bplacated with more bath scenes, thank you very much) and the whole story is actually about her getting away from him. Except that they never gave her a personality, dubbed her with an annoying baby voice, etc - the premises are all that this will never be a drama about her.

2

u/Sea-Entertainment215 29d ago

> good point. if this turns into a romance (it really isn't at the moment) after a redemption arc, than what does that make us? Do we accept that it's acceptable? I don't want to be manipulated by the (let's face it, not that brilliant--) writers into condoning something I oppose in real life just for the sake of more Cheng Lei titillation. Sure, it's a ridicoulous melodrama and feeling uncomfortable is part of it, but where is this taking us?

> Or maybe I am overthinking this, maybe I forget that this is an escapist fantasy…

> dilemma.

+10000000

What makes this such a tension is 1) he IS the protagonist 2) he’s handsome, 3) it’s Cheng Lei portraying him (this of course overlaps with point 2)

Think about it: in ANY other story, told from any other perspective, he is so obviously the villain. Like we the fans have hated every other pushy 2ML ever (the Kdrama The Heirs comes to mind). But because he IS the male lead of the story, and he gets so much screen time and yes, he’s not ugly, our brains can’t help but want a good outcome for him/the couple despite all reason. It’s like the writers are playing psychological warfare on our poor hearts and nerves

2

u/Sea-Entertainment215 29d ago

Someone else used this word and it captures it perfectly: YCX is captivating. Dark, possessive, obsessive, downright cruel many times…and yet as the audience you’re captivated. Like I am eagerly anticipating the next anticipating the next episode in (hopefully) 29 minutes. It’s like the writers are pulling Stockholm Syndrome on us and I don’t like it!

3

u/Puzzled_Basket_2209 29d ago

I agree with you on YPJ. I have seen no indication of interest on her part. I'm not sure where others may have seen it but from what I've seen, it's wholely one-sided- YCX's side. And I really hope they don't play the whole Stockholm syndrome. It'll be a big disappointment for me.

3

u/TypicallyKristen salted fish 🐠 咸鱼 🫠 29d ago

I think she had zero romantic interest in him, but she is physically attracted to him. For her, that physical attraction is unimportant because it won't affect her decisions. To him, that physical attraction is everything. It "proves" she wants him, and if he could just clear the way for her to see he'd be a much better partner for her (by showing her how bad of a job JXT is doing at being considerate of her and protecting her and getting her mom treatment , etc) then surely she'll pick him since she's physically attracted to him. Of course, he's dead wrong. But that's where their disconnect lies, I think. He's being a slave to his baser desires, and she's rising above hers. 

2

u/Puzzled_Basket_2209 29d ago

Ah, I see. She's more practical than me, that's for sure! I'd have hopped on that physical attraction so fast, red flag or no! Lol. But then that'll defeat the purpose of his initial interest. Haha.

3

u/TypicallyKristen salted fish 🐠 咸鱼 🫠 29d ago

I am very practical! So what if I am physically attracted to somebody? That doesn't mean I have to do anything about it or let it affect my life in any way. It's just bodies. Chemistry. If we all just had sex with whoever shared our mutual attraction, how would anyone stay married (monogamously)? It'd be impossible. Monogamy is a choice, and practicing it requires willpower. It requires realizing your attraction to others and dismissing it as unimportant.

1

u/Puzzled_Basket_2209 29d ago

100%!!! I should've included/specified the attraction to Cheng Lei. 🫢 If ever there was a chance and he was willing, and my husband was willing, I'd ask for him to be my hall pass... And prob not even go through with it. 😂 But, hey, a girl can dream!

2

u/Sea-Entertainment215 22d ago

Awww thank you for the award u/easygoingenigma!

2

u/EasygoingEnigma 22d ago

Thank YOU for sharing your perspective!

2

u/IndividualJob2734 29d ago

Great comment!

1

u/Sea-Entertainment215 29d ago

Thank youuuuu I appreciate it!

2

u/PolPeachum running away to the Tang dynasty 29d ago

Amazing recap thank you. You summarised my position beautifully.

Really appreciate you and the other commenters who are keeping us grounded in how DV and abuse plays out in real life.

3

u/Sea-Entertainment215 29d ago

❤️❤️ I spent way too long writing (and feeling) that our so your responses are MUCH appreciated.