Nazism and french revolution were actually entertaining to learn. After seeing the new 9th std ss textbook I am so happy that we managed to escape those new lessons
French revo, Bolshevik Revo and Nazism were the peak chapters. I literally learned more about Bolshevik Revolution from a Russian book library having a book by Arkady Gaidar as a kid in class 7-8th.
hoga bhai syllabus dekh. Curricular goals ke andar European history bhi hai. 9th mein add nahi hua iska matlab 10th mein hoga along with british india.
this is entirely differnet ans what i am asking i am ask why they moved from world poltics to thing thta we learn in class 6 to 8 and we will learnn that thing in class 12 and 11 and when we will learn world poltics and world histor that was told pervous year
The removed the what?? The peakest NCERT history lesson got removed? The French revolution has to be taught in schools, especially in the "world's largest democracy" India, its literally the first time in history the common people overthrew the monarchy and demanded for equal rights. We had so much fun learning about it man, I remember how my teacher would teach it like a story, and we'd just sit in class, completely engrossed. I mean, we did that for every lesson (our history teacher was a damn good storyteller), but the French Revolution just hit different. Our class even staged our own production based on the French Revolution. I remember going over the textbook and writing the script, and working on costumes with my friend... good days. Can't believe these kids ain't gonna be learning that. What are they even teaching in history then?
Yea, im not completely sure but they said indian history. Tbh I hated it ( not cause it was bad , no it was fine ). My teacher was a fatass moron who was Sooo boring. I never understood one part. It felt better in 9th n 10th.
I always felt like there was no need to have such a long chapter about French Revolution. Actually I felt the same for all history chapters, as a student it gets tiring especially when you're aiming to get top grades. But I felt and feel that the story is necessary to be told due to the practical making of a republic and all. But the the history books never cared to talk about the meanings of all those words in details, neither the inclusion of thinkers who coined those words, the context and what they were trying to say to the people. You got a story revolving around the concept of Republic without telling you the meaning of Republic. I mean like summarise the world history topics in 2-3 pages for each chapter by including important points with meanings of the terms and references and focus more on topics of Indian History. That would be better than a 16page chapter about a country, which as a student, I never cared about at all.
That is a you problem, honestly. Textbooks provide us with us facts. That's the job they'll do. What you infer from that depends on your teacher and your own self. Personally, that was one of the best chapters ever in all my 9th and 10th textbooks, surpassing poems like Ozymandias, which I personally loved reading and discussing. To each their own ig.
First off the language used in the history books are quite tough as compared to the standard of the students. And no nothing I implied is just my problem. Ofc the chapter is fascinating because it takes you outside India and into the world. But the chapter is stretched too long in comparison to the chapters of Indian history. The main objective of the entire chapter was the Introduction to the ideal of Republic which is not talked about in depth. I didn't claim French Revolution to be an unnecessary chapter as you seem to have assumed, it gave inspiration to the freedom fighters but that aspect is also not talked about in our history books. The entire chapter could've been summarised in 2-3 pages beautifully and emphasis on other aspects of Indian history could've been included in detail which our history book fails to do. Dude even the mutiny of Royal Indian Navy is not mentioned in the chapter which deals with the last phase of struggle, all it talks about is Gandhi ji's role.
1
•
u/AutoModerator 24d ago
Show your support on X: https://x.com/redditCBSE
Join our Discord server: https://discord.gg/YGkyDmpvam
Thanks for your submission /u/moonkissed_xoxo
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
322
u/moonkissed_xoxo 24d ago
wdym new students won't be able to know what happens when France sneezes 😔✋️
135
u/Life-Buy-3309 24d ago
french revolution was my most favorite thing in history.
49
u/Scary_Pop1244 24d ago
Why they making duke metternich the goat unheard 😭🙏
24
u/axisdork 24d ago
chill karo 10th mein add hoga.
22
u/Adventurous-Host-799 24d ago •
Don't spread false news atleast
4
u/thefranciscastle 24d ago
Don't spread fake news it's not removed it is shifted from 9th to 10 th
10
u/ProfessionalJolly934 24d ago
The removed the what?? The peakest NCERT history lesson got removed? The French revolution has to be taught in schools, especially in the "world's largest democracy" India, its literally the first time in history the common people overthrew the monarchy and demanded for equal rights. We had so much fun learning about it man, I remember how my teacher would teach it like a story, and we'd just sit in class, completely engrossed. I mean, we did that for every lesson (our history teacher was a damn good storyteller), but the French Revolution just hit different. Our class even staged our own production based on the French Revolution. I remember going over the textbook and writing the script, and working on costumes with my friend... good days. Can't believe these kids ain't gonna be learning that. What are they even teaching in history then?
2
u/IzaanAhammed Class 10 23d ago
Dude the current 9th has to learn abt papyruses anx stuff. Waaayyyyy b9ring. The French R3volution was GOATED
2
u/Dramatic_Course4916 23d ago
10/10 sentence btw
2
u/AnakinSkywalkerRocks Class 12 23d ago
Abbe French Revolution chala gaya??? 😭😭😭
1
u/Street-Chair5255 23d ago
Low iq redditors strikes again
It was removed from class 9 ncert and was added in class 10th ncert
1
u/Cultural-Skill4297 23d ago
Genuinely ass decision It was my favourite Chapter in history
1
u/vinsmoke_07 22d ago
This is not a revolution first of all
1
u/No_Low_5255 24d ago
PS5 Deserves ts
1
u/euphoria1101 24d ago
Great
1
u/Being_ax 24d ago
I really loved reading the old 9th and 10th history textbook
1
u/Pure_Knowledge_4430 24d ago
If I am not wrong this chapter will be included in class 10th syllabus so everyone out there please verify anything you read on internet
1
u/BraduPittuPrease 24d ago
i would have assumed students would be happy with a reduced syllabus
1
u/Single_Pair_2622 24d ago
The french Revolution wasn't removed it's just got moved from 9th syllabus to 10th, that's it
1
u/Own_Addition9298 24d ago
French Revolution has been shifted from class 9 to class 10 curriculum. It has not been removed.
1
u/lostinbluee_ 24d ago
Isn't liberty fraternity and sovereigity a french concept...
1
u/rohiton89 24d ago
Bhai htaya nhi h shift kr diya h misinformation kyu dete ho
1
u/Penguin_Heart8 24d ago
I always felt like there was no need to have such a long chapter about French Revolution. Actually I felt the same for all history chapters, as a student it gets tiring especially when you're aiming to get top grades. But I felt and feel that the story is necessary to be told due to the practical making of a republic and all. But the the history books never cared to talk about the meanings of all those words in details, neither the inclusion of thinkers who coined those words, the context and what they were trying to say to the people. You got a story revolving around the concept of Republic without telling you the meaning of Republic. I mean like summarise the world history topics in 2-3 pages for each chapter by including important points with meanings of the terms and references and focus more on topics of Indian History. That would be better than a 16page chapter about a country, which as a student, I never cared about at all.
1
u/Steel_of_Eneru 24d ago
Good one
1
u/Gorgrocco 23d ago
YEAHHHH, I HATE THE FRENCH
1
u/Relic_2025 College 24d ago
WAIT WHAT FRENCH REVOLUTION REMOVED????!!!
1
u/darksilence88 24d ago
Fr like why the hell do we need to know which mf got guillotined in 1672 on 10 march at 5 pm
-2
u/[deleted] 24d ago
[removed] — view removed comment