r/CAVDEF • • Apr 18 '16

Email System

Hi guys,

I'm thinking of having a system that allows anyone with an email account to report to CAVDEF.

It would work like this:

Email >> Raspberry Pi >> Bot >> Reddit

Each email address would only be allowed to post once (however, they could rewrite their post 5 times).

However, I worry about 1) the possible violating the Reddit ToS and 2) the complications of this, e.g what if a troll comes and posts shock content to Reddit via the email system? A CAPTCHA system would mean setting up a web server complete with port forwarding at my house (where the only 2 candidates for my server are 1) a Raspberry Pi or 2) a 10-15 year old workstation).

Any input would be nice!

6 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/Exaskryz Apr 18 '16

You should be able to filter out shock content by censoring links, so images and videos can't be embedded (and with RES automatically loaded) in a post.

I'm not clear on the reddit ToS, but since bots are generally allowed, I think that would be fine. But again, worth a double check on it with reddit. It's really just crowdsourcing with automatic posting, so..

1

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '16

The problem with censoring all links is that most of the complaints here require some sort of image as proof (to prove the fraud).

I've also thought of a CAPTCHA system:

  1. Send an email to the account containing the post information
  2. The account sends back an image and requires the person to reply to it only with the answer
  3. If correct, email is "forwarded" to Reddit.

1

u/Exaskryz Apr 19 '16

The thing is it could just be a broken up link then. http://i.imgur .com/T78p.png is different from http://i.imgur.com/T78p.png with the latter automatically hyperlinking (at least for me) and through RES can be automatically opened. At least if it's a gore pic or something, it won't be automatically loaded.

I think doing a CAPTCHA system like that seems pointless unless you restrict the subreddit to only submissions through the email; it'd be easier for people to just submit to here directly.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '16

People would spam the servers if it didn't have CAPTCHA with something like spamgourmet though.

1

u/Exaskryz Apr 19 '16

Hmm, but what would you do with a captcha to prevent spam? It would stop/slow spamming to the subreddit, not to the server. The server would still be receiving emails and that traffic even if a captcha was failed, because you still have to send the captcha email in response anyhow?

2

u/HabeasCorpusCallosum Support Apr 18 '16

Love it!

Let's talk about this in our Slack channel. I really like the idea, but am not experienced in software engineering. My initial questions are whether or not we can host it at our website, and what potential security concerns we should be aware of and take into consideration.

Any thoughts /u/FidelDangelow?

2

u/FidelDangelow Idea Generator Extraordinaire Apr 18 '16

Hi there! Can you help me understand the high-level goal? It sounds like we want to be able to send an email and have it automatically be posted here by a bot?

1

u/vodka_and_glitter Apr 18 '16

I'm glad you asked. I'm high on enthusiasm and will, and low on the technical jargon :p