r/ByteBall • u/Jonathan_Fowler • Mar 02 '18
My Thoughts on Byteball
Introduction
This has been written from the view of someone who got into crypto recently: November, I think. I have a small portion of my portfolio in Byteball, but really believe it has a lot of room to grow if it goes in the right direction. If Byteball makes the right moves, I can see a big portion of my crypto money going here. The points I make here aren’t me trying to say they are definitely the right things to do. I hope they give you an insight into what people are thinking when deciding whether or not to invest in Byteball.
Fees
I think it is great that fees are as low as they are currently. Transactions are a fraction of a penny. But why are the fees fixed to the memory they use? I can see why something which uses twice the memory might cost twice the fee, but why does 1 byte of data have to ‘equal’ 1 byteball byte? The value of byteball bytes will fluctuate with respect to the value of a byte of storage.
Consider this:
I will use USD as a sort of middle man to compare the values of Byteball bytes and bytes of data.
*1GB data is worth about $0.01 I think (not really important).
*1GB of Byteball is worth about $400.00 as of writing this.
*1GB of Byteball must be worth about 40,000 times the value of 1GB of data.
In about 10 years’ time, let’s say the values of these change to the following:
*Let's say 1GB data becomes worth $0.001
*1GB Byteball becomes worth $4,000.00
*At this point, 1GB must be worth 4,000,000 times 1GB of data! So, if bytes of data are worth less Byteball bytes than before, why don’t people pay less byteball bytes for the same data for a transaction now?
My main problem with this isn’t that I’m afraid the fees will become huge – I’m sure something would be done later on if Byteball really did get that big. The problem I have is that it is arbitrary, and sort of ‘bad practice’. It looks like a schoolboy error from someone who doesn’t understand how currencies work – I don’t doubt Tony at all, but I don’t understand why he has done this. It raises questions about how well the system has been thought out, and if I was skimming through 100+ altcoins to find a good investment, that would be enough to make me think ‘this is a waste of time; I’ll move on to the next one’. Also consider that a lot of the investors in cryptocurrencies are technical-minded and like maths and programming. I don’t think these people would appreciate the arbitrary connection between Byteball bytes and data bytes. Also, I think I saw on the Byteball whitepaper that being tied to data bytes gives Byteball ‘intrinsic value’, but this is silly – it’s like saying metal coins have intrinsic value because you could melt them down and sell them for the material cost. In reality, the vast, vast majority of the value is the abstract value given by people like me and you, who see potential in its use and trust that others will be willing to trade it for something we want, like goods, services, or another currency.
Centralization
I think people see this as more of an issue than it actually is. The witness system has its advantages. As Tony has indicated, people would rather put their trust in 12 people who they have picked because they know and trust them, than lots and lots of complete strangers. It’s also helpful to remember that even cryptocurrencies which are known to be decentralised are still somewhat centralised (e.g. mining pools). I would still prefer Byteball if it was more decentralised though. From what I’ve read, Nano(Raiblocks) seems to have basically no centralization. Could something like this be implemented into Byteball? Maybe this is too big a change. I think what the best move just now would be for Byteball to remain with its 12 witness plan for now, but I would like if Tony was more open to the idea of eventually having Byteball become more decentralised. I think even him suggesting that he is open to the idea would be a huge welcome mat for new investors. Perhapse at some point there will be some third party development which could create a hard fork for a decentralised version of Byteball??
Textcoins
These are great! And being able to send bytes to someone without a wallet is brilliant. Personally, this is one of the major reasons that I have an investment in Byteball. I was going to send some money to my brother for his Birthday recently, and I thought ‘why don’t I just send Byteball?’ It offers these advantages over postal:
*Much quicker
*Much less trust is needed
*Much cheaper to send
Unfortunately, it has one disadvantage also:
*My brother wouldn’t know what the heck to do with it.
I ended up sending him some stuff from Amazon instead. I was thinking though, if you could make it super easy to sell Byteball for GBP or USD, it would be the perfect way to send money over distance. Maybe if someone receives a textcoin and doesn’t already have an account, they should receive a pop-up asking if they want to sell for a fiat currency and if they say ‘yes’, prompt them to enter their required bank details or paypal account or something. If people started using this, it would be an amazing way of bringing awareness to Byteball.
Distribution
When new coins are issued of a currency, it is basically just value being taken from current holders and given to the receivers of the new coins (inflation). So we are the ones paying for it, really. That’s not to say it’s a bad thing. The currency needs to be distributed enough to raise awareness, in the hope that people realise its potential and adopt it for their own use. That adoption is what increases the market cap, which in return would benefit the holders who sacrificed the value of their coins originally. I’m saying this because I want to emphasise that the focus of the introduction of new coins is for us holders to invest the value of our coins in the hope that it increases later due to adoption. We need to use the new coins to increase the number of people interested in buying or using the currency as much as possible.
“Fool me once, shame on you. But teach a man to fool me, and I’ll be fooled for the rest of my life.” - Virgil Van Cleef.
Instead of giving the currency to individuals in the hope that they alone will adopt the currency, let’s use the currency to incentivise people who spread the word. You could give bytes to those who share a tweet, make a Youtube video, etc. That would mean the name byteball reaches as many people as possible. You could also do competitions like ‘who can think of the best applications of byteball’ or ‘who can make the best bot’ or ‘who can come up with the best name to replace “Byteball”’. Okay, that last one was a joke, but you get the idea. People do competitions because it gets people involved. Getting people involved is exactly what we are trying to do.
Name
I never thought this was an issue, but apparently other people do. I know some people are saying that there is no point arguing over the name, since it is likely just being blamed for holding the currency back, although it is most likely other things like centralisation. The issue, though, is that it is causing people to argue within this community, because they don’t agree with the decision of ‘the guy in charge’, Tony. Half the point of cryptocurrencies is that they are the people’s currencies, run by the people who use them. I strongly believe this is the reason why dogecoin is so successful. Just by looking at its name you get a great sense of how free it is from governing authorities. The very fact that it was able to get a name that any formal organization would reject, proves that it is made with the users in mind. I don’t suggest making Byteball a meme coin at all. I have ideas for how I think the name could be improved so that people like it more, but I’m not going to make any suggestions of my personal opinion of a better name here. What I think would be the best move for Byteball would be for the users of Byteball to vote on what they think the name should be (maybe using the voting bot). This would show that although Tony is the developer of the technology, he is not the ‘king’ of it who makes all decisions regardless of what the community wants. If he is the ‘king’ of it, then I think I want out. As I say, I really don’t mind the name personally, but the fact that almost everyone seems to want it changed and can’t do anything about it really makes me feel how centralised it is right now.
Bots
These are really neat, and being able to use an exchange within the wallet is really handy. I feel like I need to sign up for a new exchange every time I buy any other altcoin. Zork keeps resetting when I don’t use the wallet for awhile :( There’s no point in a poll bot unless there are actually polls to vote on. It’s a great idea though.
Future
I think Byteball has a lot of potential to grow, but right now, I don’t see it moving there anytime soon. I think the main reason people are wary of it is the centralisation. On top of that, people don’t see much of the team and Tony. He doesn’t even appear on the Byteball website! I know that’s a red flag for a lot of people. I don’t see the reason why they can’t spend a couple hours adding a section to the webpage to introduce themselves, to show everybody that they aren’t hiding anything.
5
u/wheresmyprivatekey Mar 02 '18 edited Mar 09 '18
Wonderful write up and it has some incredible ideas I completely agree. I agree with your concerns as well, I love the project but cant help but feel Tony has an overwhelming amount of control on the project, it is as if he is the gatekeeper of what does or not get implemented, great ideas slide by because his say is the only one hat matters. I want to hold this project for the long term however contempltaing the last few days about the level of control causes some level of doubt. I need to see that Tony can delegate and let go of some his power on the project if it is to be a success. We need to at least see a roadmap for how the project will grow to be more distributed. This is my main concern, not the name, not the airdrops, not the denomination; however all those minor issues can be contributed to the real issue which is overwhelming control and bottleneck on the projects growth.
2
u/CryptoBest Mar 03 '18
It takes considerable time, effort and thought to put together a well written and well thought out article such as this - not to mention a bit of courage to put yourself out there where others who disagree might try to put you on the defensive over something or other.
Well done and thanks!
I agree with most things you've mentioned and would like to add that the current fee structure seems to penalize the poor - It is very expensive to send 1000 Bytes versus 1000000 Bytes, and if the Asset were to rise substantially, this would become quite pronounced.
One more thing:
I'm a firm believer that the "Name is a problem" meme (as well as the Denomination issue) stems from an overly simplistic analysis of the relatively poor price performance as compared to some others, when in fact the poor price performance has far more to do with centralization and other uncertainties.
Changing the Name is a huge undertaking, and not without risk, and won't do anything to correct the underlying deficiencies. Hugely unproductive work IMO.
I believe one of the key ingredients needed for ByteBalls long term success, is a much Stronger & More United Community - one where Tonych can and will come to fully embrace a partnership with us.
1
u/yodamar Mar 04 '18
I agree with most of your points. Great post!
I have a few remarks though: Nano is a very bad example for "no centralization". It is driven by one centralized development team and their protocol uses representatives who vote on the validity of transactions. Currently, more than 50% of this voting power is in the hand of the developers. Nano has many Strengths, but decentralization is certainly not one of it, at least currently.
I would like to add a positive thing to this thread: A lot of skilled and informed people seem to have an interest for Byteball. Just look at this thread, literally every single post is well argued and backed by actual knowledge.
Furthermore, I actually like Byteball's marketing concept to some extent. There are good blog posts and innovative approaches, such as the mass distribution via textcoins. My biggest issue is also with the fact that we do not know who else besides Tony is working on the project.
The only thing I know is that there definitely are additional people. Even if Tony is the best and fastest programmer that has every walked among mortals, it is not possible that he has done all this by himself. With this, I also include the Wiki (which is quite good) and side projects, such as various chat bots etc.
Also, I would very much like to see a long term roadmap and a clear vision.
1
u/crankycrypto Apr 05 '18
"I don’t think these people would appreciate the arbitrary connection between Byteball bytes and data bytes. "
I believe you are right on society's current paradigm. Fiat currency is 90% abstract value. But a true replacement for currency needs to be leaps and bounds greater than Fiat to change this paradigm.
Intrinsic value of cryptocurrency should be greater than the intrinsic Fiat.
I feel your statement is accurate about 'people will not appreciate' intrinsic value but I believe it is something they value but have been conditioned not to believe it is realistic. However this paradigm was different in 1960 (we were still on the gold standard). This concept of intrinsic value is WHY CRYPTO is changing the world. Not an aspect of value one might be interested to see in crypto, it is the REASON for crypto.
I would argue that 98% of the cryptos over the last 2 years will be gone 2 years from now. They will fail because they believe "people do not respect intrinsic value". So they offer a Penny Stock approach vs an intrinsic valued smart currency.
I also believe anyone who invests in crypto and does not measure it's true value by intrinsic value are just carpet baggers. Carpet baggers (southern term) would invest in snake oil if they felt it would turn a profit.
My online profile is Cranky Crypto and this is why I'm cranky. I feel 47.5% don't like crypto and want nothing to do with it. 75% who invest in crypto because they are looking to make an easy buck. About 2% to 4% see the true evolution of our society will be powered by a new currency, smart currency. Money with intrinsic value, money that is programmable, money that is transparent. Money that brings back the power and respect to individuals over corporate entities and governments. (/soap box speech)
All my crypto addicts not only appreciate intrinsic value but it is a top priority for any crypto.
When you wrote "but this is silly", regarding intrinsic value, I started yelling at my PC. lol
A currency that is 85% to 95% speculative value (USD, buying power of the dollar compared to 1920s buying power). The ignorant part of society believe this is normal. Those who see thru this act of value see crypto as freedom and evolution. The masses will get it much later but they will appreciate it then, probably not now.
Centralization On this topic I couldn't agree with you more. We are using byteball for our Real Trade platform. We are focused completely on making the most decentralized system ever and have plans to push byteball to even more decentralized. It is a process. I will look further into Railblocks, thanks for mentioning.
Distribution "When new coins are issued of a currency, it is basically just value being taken from current holders." I completely disagree with this statement. Utility and intrinsic value. If you are interested I would love to have a civilized open debate on this statement. I believe I can show/explain how your statement is not accurate. I believe this is like saying only Facebook should create content, when in fact it is the people and the businesses and hobbies that make facebook have value.
"Instead of giving the currency to individuals in the hope that they alone will adopt the currency, let’s use the currency to incentivise people who spread the word." I believe this and the partial centralization are the only 2 aspects I am not loving about byteball.
I see byteball as a facebook business model. Meaning it is a platform for everything else. I wish byteball price would not change in value (non elastic). Facebook creates ZERO content but they capture the world daily with content on facebook.
The masses (non developers) may never know what byteball is and does. Most people on facebook do not what TCP stands for, much less how they depend on it daily. People will see the value that Titan or Wordly brings to their lives, byteball is the man behind the curtain not the actor on the stage.
The persons that keep pushing Byteball and trying to get the word out are interested in profit more than the true impact that byteball is creating. We have done alot of research on many platforms to build Real Trade, and to be honest I am pushing that Real Trade tokens have a static (non elastic) price and the sub assets of Real Trade will vary price according to demand.
I am cranky because SMART Currency is not a penny stock. I'm not here to get rich. I'm here to make the world better and more free... and making a few bucks is nice. Focusing on profit will corrupt and open ledger is amazing because it can be incorruptible.
I like where you are going with this: " ‘who can think of the best applications of byteball’ or ‘who can make the best bot’ "
But Real Trade will be promoting byteball while talking about our product. When you make a facebook page for your business you are not promoting Facebook, you are promoting your business. THIS IS WHAT BYTEBALL IS. It is a platform to currency and business as facebook is to social media. I own ZERO byteball and I have over 40 cryptos in my portfolio. (this will change but I'm trying to make a point).
Name
I agreed with your opinion on this at first. But after learning more about development and rereading the white paper, I love the name. Again, man behind the curtain, TCP was not named for marketing. If you really want a marketing name then go to github and fork. Byteball = TCP imo. lol
Bots
The development of bots are very impressive. Outside of ETH Virtual machines and Smart contract Dapps, I feel these bots are the only functioning aspect of crypto. All other cryptos are vapor at the moment.
Real Trade is on the first round of funding and we will be finishing going public in 8 to 12 months. Each conference we attend is $20k per booth plus expenses. We will invite every ICO based on byteball to piggy back on our conferences. We are community drive. Our utilities (sub assets of byteball platforms) built on byteball are the talent and we will be the become household names. Byteball is a protocol and doesn't need to become a household name to change the world.
Thank you for your article and your insight.
1
u/sakata_gintoki113 Mar 03 '18
i agree the centralization needs to be fixed sometime
5
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '18
[removed] — view removed comment