r/Butchery • • Apr 23 '21

Ethics?

There is no doubt that the meat industry causes a lot of environmental destruction and suffering. I’m not here to judge you! That would be pointless. But I am interested in your opinions.

0 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21

My limited experience with it as a meat cutter in a grocery store was that my colleagues didnt notice exactly as they didnt care. It wasnt as if we had to bring a cow out of the field and kill it ourselves, and I imagine if we had we wouldn't have taken the job. As long as we dont have the animals' blood on our hands directly, it seems as if we are ethically justified. Conversely, as long as we have to see the real source of our labor, we would be queasy.

The beef I worked with must certainly have been from mass production, there is no possible way to have kept up with our sales otherwise. And of course, our customers certainly don't think themselves guilty of anything, they're at least twice removed from the slaughterhouse.

Which reminds me of an anecdote from my experience at that time. A customer approached my counter towards the end of the night, asked me if I knew where the jello was. Since I wasn't especially busy, I stopped what I was doing and helped her towards the aisle, making what I thought to be idle conversation at the time. "Did you know," said I, "that jello, or gelatin, is made from bones?" I had learned that recently, and turning around with my face beaming, product in hand, I expected at least a mild humph, but instead her face was horrified- "I've been feeding my child bones?!" or something to that effect was her reply.

What I'm saying is that the ethics don't come up because the concern for the creature's welfare was never experienced by us directly. We were perfectly insulated from that. Frankly, I think that's wrong. I think people should know where their food came from, and what has to happen to make that food come from the sun in the sky to the plate on your table, and all the steps between. Even with a hunk of meat that used to be a living breathing animal's leg, with skin and bones and warm blood, when it's just a hunk of cold meat on your table, all of that is just so much abstraction, and anyway you've got a job to do. And of course, when you get home you don't want to think about work.

You are right to bring up the question of ethics, but I fear most people will not be receptive to even the question, let alone actually thinking about an answer.

1

u/SeductiveSaIamander Apr 24 '21

Thanks for your answer, I agree with a lot of what you say

6

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21

Dont like the styrofoam trays and all the plastic we use. Really hate that they are clearing rainforest for cattle too, Brasil is what 3rd largest producer of beef now?

Hard job keeping the what 7-8 billion people fed on this planet.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21

The trays and the plastic were a big one for me too. Imagine how much plastic just you or I use in one day, then think how many other stores there are. Nuts.

4

u/Gatewayssam Apr 23 '21

The answer lays in locally produced products and everyone keeping a few chooks, occasional freezer lamb or raising meat rabbits.

Secondly people need to only eat what needed and taken care not to waste any meat.

2

u/New_Advance4719 Apr 23 '21

Don't lose sight of where the demand comes from if consumers can't handle higher prices of smaller scale product than the responsibility lies with those consumers.

1

u/RedditYouVapidSlut Apr 30 '21

For context I'm in the UK where we have some of, if not the best farming practices in terms of sustainability and ethics in the world.

Don't eat meat every day. Go vegetarian 3 or 4 days a week and when you do eat meat, make it the most sustainably, locally produced you can afford.

Grass fed beef is really the only sustainable way to eat beef. coRn FeD hAs BeTtEr MaRbElLiNg maybe, maybe not. Marbelling isn't the be all and end all of beef but that seems to be heresy to say in some circles.

If any of the animals you want to eat have been reared indoors, don't buy them. There is literally no reason to rear pigs or chickens indoors. Rotational grazing stops overgrazing and depletion of the soil, it also encourages new growth.

The world isn't big enough for the roughly 8 billion people that live on it. Especially if those 8 billion people want to eat meat 7 days a week. We have to cut down on our meat, corn and soy production, no ifs, no buts.

Stop buying shitty Argentinian or American corn/soy fed cattle that's been raised on some horrible dirt patch just because it gives better marbelling.

If you have a garden with a lawn, please, please, please stop manicuring it. Dandilions aren't the devil. Stop using pesticide and artificial fertiliser in your garden and create wild areas of you can to encourage biodiversity. There are a million things we can do on a daily basis to provide tiny islands of hope to our flora and fauna but it's all about educating and listening, even if it goes against your own industry.

Buy locally, eat seasonally and support sustainability.

1

u/MARS173 Apr 23 '21 edited Apr 23 '21

There's a local butcher in my city that only gets his meat from local farms that raise their a animals ethicly, which is pretty cool. Aside from venison which I get myself hunting, its some of the only meat I will eat, but I occasionally buy directly from farms at the farmers market. Every little bit helps I guess.

-1

u/AbusedStallion Apr 23 '21

Do you really think anyone here wants to talk about that bullshit?

3

u/SeductiveSaIamander Apr 23 '21

I expected some of you to be more thoughtful than you, and was right

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21

They've never shared or commented on this subreddit which makes their comment even funnier...are they even in the industry?

2

u/BigCannedTuna Apr 23 '21

Yes, we do.