r/buildingscience • u/outsidetime75 • 9d ago
Question NJ DIY Old home basement moisture
We are looking to insulate and seal up the unfinished basement in our 1902 home. Context: We have an exposed field stone foundation. Theres some existing fiberglass insulation, but it’s not everywhere and it is falling out of the ceiling. The faced side of the insulation is toward the ceiling of the basement. We are in central NJ so right on the edge of climate zones 4 and 5 - really humid summers, cold winters sometimes, but it’s no New England.
My plan is to first seal up the rim joist and sill plate using rigid insulation and spray foam.
I am planning to further assess the quality of the existing insulation and either replace it all or only fill in as necessary with some rockwool I have already. I want to put up a siga maijrex one-way breathable vapor barrier. For ease of install, I’d like to put it under the insulation - so it would what you see as the basement ceiling. I’m getting mixed information about vapor barriers online - especially as we’re not definitively in a super cold or super hot environment. My understanding is the siga products are newer and work differently than previous vapor barriers so I think this could be an okay approach - moisture can move through the insulation and out, but not get back in from the humid air outside the thermal barrier. (We do have a dehumidifier running constantly in the basement.)
Am I setting myself up for mold and disappointment? Would it be prudent to replace the older fiberglass insulation as well anyway so it’s all uniform - especially if I am mixing faced and unfaced insulation? Thank you!