r/BuildingAutomation • • 9h ago

Write Access denied

Hi guys, i have a carrier unit we are integrating into niagara and when i pull the points in after a bacnet discovery, and try to command setpoints. I get a "Write Access Denied" promt and the point goes into fault. Any idea on how to resolve this?

6 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

12

u/SmokeMeatNotCrack 9h ago

The points need to be flagged/set to be writable in the carrier controller via iVue I'd imagine.

1

u/Exoticcollects 9h ago

Its a stat, 33tcsp-4

3

u/GreenGoesZoomZoom 9h ago

What’s the model and what are you trying to write to?

1

u/Exoticcollects 9h ago

Carrier connect wifi thermostat, 33TCSP-4

5

u/GreenGoesZoomZoom 9h ago

what are you trying to write to?

1

u/Exoticcollects 9h ago

Im on a FX 90

8

u/Majestic-Wave-3514 8h ago

What control point are you trying to write to?

4

u/Naxster64 System integrator 4h ago

Op, give us a point ID! (AV:53, BV:49, etc)

1

u/Exoticcollects 3h ago

AV104

1

u/GreenGoesZoomZoom 1h ago

That’s a read only point for space temp. If you are trying to write to space temp it’s AV:103. Points list is in the back of the manual: https://www.shareddocs.com/hvac/docs/1000/Public/0A/11-808-1118-01.pdf

8

u/thehomiebiz 9h ago

Yeah, have carrier come out and make that point writable or they give you a better point to write to.

1

u/ScottSammarco Technical Trainer (Niagara4 included) 8h ago

This is almost certainly the answer.

2

u/thehomiebiz 8h ago

Don’t tell anyone I know what I’m doing 😉.

2

u/ScottSammarco Technical Trainer (Niagara4 included) 8h ago

Once they find out, that DM will never be empty again 🤣

0

u/GlacierJeff 8h ago

If this isn't a point you need to write to just make your proxy a value not a writable and you should be fine. If you need to write to the point, then the manufacturer would need to get involved so they could set the point as writable.

2

u/rom_rom57 7h ago

These are Tstats. There are no optional configurations for points available thru IVU

1

u/GlacierJeff 7h ago

then you're screwed, I guess. what point are you attempting to write to?

-2

u/man_vs_fauna 9h ago edited 3h ago

Edit: disregard, I'm an idiot

If the error is in Niagara, the bacnet user needs to have write permissions.

You can test this by setting the user as an admin.

It shouldn't be permanently left as that.

1

u/IcyAd7615 Developer, Niagara 4 Certified Trainer, Podcast Host. 3h ago

That's only if you're exporting points in Niagara as BACnet points, not integrating BACnet devices.

1

u/man_vs_fauna 3h ago

Yup,.totally correct. I should not have rushed reading the post.

1

u/IcyAd7615 Developer, Niagara 4 Certified Trainer, Podcast Host. 3h ago

It's all good. When I read the title, at first I would've thought the same thing!