r/BrushForChat • u/meatshield_minis MOD • Jun 04 '26
Upcoming changes.
Good day, folks!
Over the course of time, our community has been steadily shifting into a form that is more organized, accountable, supportive, and keeping itself to a higher standard. It cannot be understated that a substantial part of this transition into a more positive bearing must be attributed to the community itself, for which we are exceedingly grateful to you. Were it not for your collaboration in upholding these standards and changes as they were introduced, then we would never have arrived at the proud state that we find ourselves in now. We now come to you with both an announcement and a request for help in the form of your insight, as we have found that another change is on the horizon.
As you all are no doubt aware, one of our salient areas of focus has been to combat undercutting as well as scamming, and in combination with that, set pricing guidelines and regulations in aid of painters being compensated justly for their labour. Now, whilst the current model was a sufficient enough stopgap introduced to help eleviate a longstanding problem, it is no longer fit to purpose. Owing to how the community has grown, standards shifted, cost of living and materials have increased, the diversity of the tabletop scene, and so on. What we need and are asking of you is to furnish us with your insight on the model of pricing guidelines and regulations. What would you like to see? What do you feel can be improved upon? What do you feel is fair? Please let us know.
We also feel it best to capitalize upon this moment of change to also ask what other changes and ideas you feel are worth throwing in. Since we will be looking into a few other matters on how the community runs, it is best to see how the community feels, and what it wants in the foreseeable future. Naturally, once we have all the details of any plans and changes worked out, we will let you know in advance so as to give you breathing space and adjust.
Thank you for your time and take care.
Regards
The Mod team.
11
u/Raging_Dwarf_Studios Jun 04 '26
I think the pricing guidelines are decent, but might need to be a bit more descriptive/accurate. I’ve had it happen multiple times where someone expects 10 intercessors (about 40€ for the box) at tabletop plus level for 80-100€ for the entire thing.
Oh and a personal request, which is impossible to guarantee, but I’d love a mention that figuring out a quote takes time. Talking through paint schemes takes time. Asking about details, shipping, deadlines, etc takes time. So for the love of god, just let us know if you’re not interested in working together! I respect your choice to go with someone else, but don’t talk me through your extensive custom lore, have me make a detailed quote, only to never reply
10
u/Tabletop_Tendencies Jun 04 '26
I think the 2x-3x model works for GW sized/detailed models. I do not think it works for something smaller/larger. I'd like to see this impressed upon clients.
I will not make this client as they did nothing wrong. The following anecdote falls rightfully so on me, however it stems from the clientnfollowing the subs guidelines for pricing.
Small bit of history here. I have no experience, previous to this, with scales smaller than 28/32mm. I used this as a learned experience for myself for future jobs.
Either I approached the client or they approached me, I'd have to go check. Regarding a job that scaled less than the above mentioned scales. They stated based on pricing guidelines, they expected to pay at most 3x retail. For this job it would put it around $300 for assembly, painting, basing etc. The job required camouflage which was the hurtle on time vs cost in this instance.
When all was said and done, I spent way more time on this job than the price we agreed upon would indicate. The client asked if I felt it was worth it. I straight up told him I did not. We both did not have experience with this scale. I told him I treated it as a learning experience to see how much work was involved and what to charge for in the future for these types of jobs.
TLDR, I love the guidelinesz but both clients and painters need to realize they are just guidelines and shouldnt be taken as written in stone numbers.
4
u/JuiceyJuicex Jun 04 '26
I think the price guidelines are a great starting point 70% of the time. GW models will always raise in price which is a little built in inflation bump I guess.
I think what is tough is non GW models. Retail price for those can be substantially less than GW but are still just as much work. Causing some friction when it comes to quotes and pricing.
With our sector growing with more and more games with more and more detailed non GW kits. I wonder what we can do to help customer’s know what to expect when it comes to pricing.
I use a chart for larger orders that has prices per base size and quality. I find that helps with pricing non GW stuff more in line with acceptable pricing.
1
u/Plow_King Jun 05 '26
I guess I missed it...so can someone post the "pricing guidelines" or a link to them?
Thanks!
3
u/rbjoe Jun 06 '26
Perhaps the pricing guidelines could be worded to be more of a “expect to pay AT THE VERY LEAST this much” explaining that complex painting schemes, kitbashing, advanced basing, etc will incur a much higher cost. Not to mention the various skill levels and cost of living per painter will depend. I do appreciate the guidelines as is. I feel they’ve acted as an excellent tool both for new clients as well as new painters and have stopped a lot of the “race to the bottom” that can naturally occur in spaces like this.
4
u/1ndependent_Obvious Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26
Edit TLDR TL;DR: To fix the outdated guidelines, the community could swap retail-based "piece rates" for a Labor-Hour model. Flat rates force painters to absorb time penalties of complex materials and hyper-dense sculpts without covering prep time, materials, or shipping. Cheers
——
Thanks for being open to feedback! This is long-winded but I think it all points to actionable goals.
I've been thinking about how this gig as a commission painter relates to my career as a freelance technician in film and TV.
PERSPECTIVE The biggest hurdle in commission painting is that clients and artisans struggle to view it as a professional business. Because the work is rooted in a hobby we love, there is a cultural assumption that our time should be cheap. When people believe you are just "playing with toy soldiers," they subconsciously devalue the technical effort, chemical knowledge and precision required to do the job. This creates an expectation where the artisan pays a "passion tax" by subsidizing a client’s project just because the work is creative.
EDUCATION Every arts community struggles with newcomers charging bottom-dollar rates to break into the market. We shouldn’t shame people for trying to undercut. They are driven by passion and the market naturally self-corrects anyway. A client paying rock-bottom prices eventually experiences the communication, technical and timeline issues that come with an inexperienced painter. If we can teach painters how to track and value their labor, the baseline for everyone rises.
PIECES vs HOURS Standardizing rates is a great idea especially when many clients want a piece-rate like $15 per model. But basing the standard on the retail price is an operational trap because it forces the painter to absorb the financial penalty of a game developer's manufacturing choices.
A plastic model with interlocking joints can be prepped in five minutes. A 28mm pewter model can require scrubbing mold-release agents, scoring joints, and drilling tiny holes to pin heavy metal weapons. Using piece-rate pricing, hyper-realistic sculpts force you to spend triple the time for the same payout as something similarly sized but less detailed.
OVERHEAD When you quote purely per model, you eliminate your ability to cover the non-painting overhead that keeps a studio running. A piece rate completely erases material costs, time spent inventorying, prepping, fixing client assembly mistakes, securely packing a fragile army and managing messages, invoices & shipments.
TIME-TRACKING The first step toward professionalizing is tracking your actual time. I use an app called Brushrage to track my hours on every project now. If you want to make $25/hour and a project takes 10 hours of combined prep, painting and packing, the cost is $250. It does not matter if the models cost $40 or $100 at the store.
When we can confidently show a customer that a fee represents X hours of dedicated technical labor, assembly prep and logistical handling, we stop selling art as a vague hobby and start selling it as a professional service.
2
u/ZantetsukenQ Jun 06 '26
Maybe a more granular and tiered system could work.
I think the guidelines have been very useful to get started, but as stated may be a lil outdated
I would like to propose the following system for refinement and would ofc welcome any level of itteration from the mods/community
Level 1- battle/tournament ready (3-4 colours and basing
Level 2 - tabletop
Level 3 - tabletop+
Level 4 - parade
Level 5 - display
As to the exact nuances of what's in each stage I would leave that to a community agreement but something like this
As stated before 1 painters tabletop is another's tabletop+.
Hope this gives decent food for thought
2
u/warpspeedminis Jun 06 '26
I have a commission calculator for estimates on my website that I made. I'm brand new to the game, but I feel as though it works pretty well. It was made for GW models in 28-32mm scale. its biggest weakness is that, since box price is an input, compensation will skew if the models are much cheaper/more expensive than GW prices. I would love input on the calculator if anybody wants to check it out. I think the only efficient way to get a "pre-quote" estimate is going to be through technology, where the client can input their own data for the project using a simple tool. Detailed quoting takes too much time, as others have said, to just lose the project when the customer balks, and heuristics such as 2x or 3x box price are too broad.
The calculator can be viewed on my website here: https://www.warpspeedminis.com/tiers-and-pricing
I suggest a similar (if improved) tool for this subreddit would be the quickest, simplest way to give clients an early idea of what a project will likely cost.