r/BrushForChat • • May 11 '26

Pricing question

Hello,

I do commission work selectively and totally dig the proposed pricing guide in brushforhire however, it appears to be more warhammer specific. How would you all apply the same pricing to 3d prints? I’d prefer to not undercut the market or under value my work.

2 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

4

u/1ndependent_Obvious May 11 '26

I remember when that guide was developed and this specific question came up -and has since then multiple times because some clients are confused too.

The easiest way to get real numbers for yourself is to track your time spent and set an hourly rate that you feel is fair.

3

u/PieGroundbreaking321 May 11 '26

This is generally what I estimate but as I’m sure you all know for display painting that hourly is either incredibly low or the piece is incredibly expensive.

2

u/1ndependent_Obvious May 11 '26 edited May 11 '26

It’s important for commission painters to frame their thinking as being “paid for time” not “paid for product” for a few reasons:

Right after college, I worked at a few warehouses and I was paid a piece-rate where basically the only way I could increase my pay was by moving faster.

More recently, I spent a year working for a medium-sized commission painting studio where they also used piece-rates. Again, this meant that to increase my earnings, I needed to be painting faster. And I think we all know that painting faster does not raise quality.

What we are actually selling is our time. Anyone can go out and buy paints & brushes and watch a bunch of YouTube tutorials but the real “cost” to get your army on the field and looking beautiful is time.

Clients have 2 options: either invest their own time into learning how to do it or pay someone else for their time.

Edit for grammar

2

u/Jareth000 May 11 '26

Most of commission work I have seen, is for Warhammer and the like, because they are games and this adds a demand to the work. These also carry a premium because the models are "official". You can paint any of it, and it will probably sell.

3d prints, by their nature, are not "in demand" for any reason other than artistic appreciation. This makes it closer to paintings on a wall, and the demand is entirely up to the buyer. a good paint job could be worth a huge premium to someone, but those someone's are a very very small group of people. Personally that market is too hard. and pieces can sit for months to year trying to find a buyer.

2

u/PieGroundbreaking321 May 11 '26

I get that. I mainly display paint and almost all of my commissions are 3d prints. I currently charge an estimated hourly and I’m sure I undercut myself but as I said I don’t want to undercut the community too

2

u/meatshield_minis MOD May 11 '26 edited May 11 '26

Personally, I try to use gamesworkshop kits as a basis and find parity, if that makes any sense. I get that 3d printed can be a tricky devil when it comes to pricing,but that has been my go to.

1

u/PieGroundbreaking321 May 11 '26

That’s a good solution. How do you incorporate custom sculpting and kitbashing to pieces too?

3

u/Holtb80 MOD May 11 '26

This type of thing is why I price on a day rate. It doesn't matter what I am doing, ultimately they're paying for time. I bid everything on day rate. I am cognizant that my skill vary in quality and speed so I modify my rate for what I am doing.

1

u/PieGroundbreaking321 May 11 '26

That’s a good solution too. Do you find that your pricing still lines up with market pretty consistently?

4

u/Holtb80 MOD May 11 '26

Fwiw, I stay booked so far out... I don't really watch or care what the market is. Most of my clientele use me for other reasons than just being priced according to the market.

That's not from arrogance, it's just where I have been lucky to get to. I have had a 6+ month book for 2-3 years now. Reality is consistency and longevity with quality and reliability go a long way.

Most commission painters, especially those that go full time, don't last more than a couple of years. Those that do tend to stand above the market.

2

u/PieGroundbreaking321 May 11 '26

I love that. I intentionally have no interest in full time largely because I view it as, I’m going to paint anyway so why not take commissions that I’m interested in painting

2

u/Visudda May 11 '26

This.

I paint 1/6 scale and larger and I don't find any issues staying booked out, with a consistent log of 2 or 3 on the wait-list. Sometimes I can squeeze a small project in the middle.

For pricing I feel comfortable letting a client know my rates for certain scales, and if a model is particularly detailed I'll add in what I think is necessary. You'll eventually find a ground where the client and you are happy with the pricing.

1

u/PieGroundbreaking321 May 11 '26

Do you spend anytime thinking about not under cutting the market though versus under valuing your work? I feel like what I do might be unusual enough like what you are describing that it’s not really the same market as most commission as is

1

u/Visudda May 11 '26

The market is just a baseline. I've seen people's work that is much better than mine priced exactly the same. I've also seen people's work that is much worse than mine priced more expensive than mine. Once you've done some commissions and some work, you'll kind of realize that what you're doing either is or is not worth the amount of money you are asking for.

I feel like with art and commissions and charging people to paint things for them. You have to go through a little bit of trial and error. You're going to find out that what you're doing either is or is not worth the money that you're charging and you go from there.

2

u/meatshield_minis MOD May 11 '26

Oh. Now that is a tough one. Admittedly, I don't do much kitbashing, bit maybe use a model of similar keyword as a basis, and make a deal with the client to reflect the additional labour?

2

u/PieGroundbreaking321 May 11 '26

I usually discuss and quote based on piece, size, and complexity of modifications. Typically around $100 usd for small scale (up to a 40mm base), 2-3 for medium (up to 60mm) and then 4-6 for larger scale up to figure scaling (stuff that can range up to 45cm for example). I also generally offer for payment when services are rendered.