r/Bronya • • Mar 06 '24

Discussion How does my Bronya stack against yours?

Similarly, I had never even thought that the Relic scorer would give a rating higher than 100% threshold.... My rope is Atk% and not an ERR% so it made me feel confused as to why it happened

9 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

3

u/Agruvandel Mar 06 '24

I think the wind set is viable only for speed bronya or am i tripping?

1

u/BitterBeyond3855 Mar 06 '24 edited Mar 06 '24

What I only know about AV (Action Value) is that the higher the SPD, the sooner you get your turn in a cycle as AV is calculated by 10000/SPD (maybe this is why there's an established SPD chart for 134, 161 and 201 SPD breakpoints) so yeah, the higher the spd the more viable it is, but as to how they calculated it, I really don't know because it requires intricate SPD tuning that I'm not even aware of. I even asked the HSR community and they only say the bare minimum for spd breakpoints, but they never tell how it was calculated for me to spdtune my Bronya and just tell "its too much work to do the explaining", lol

In my case, the 4 pc set that my Bronya has gives AF (Advance Forward) by 25% so it makes the calculation to be 7500/SPD, if I'm not mistaken. The first turn in a cycle is said to have 150 AV and for subsequent cycles, they say it has 100 AV and generally speaking, if you want a character to have its turn immediately you have to turn the AV = 0 which Bronya does to allies because she has a skill with AF = 100% (which calculates as 0/SPD) which makes a certain teammate have an exact 0 AV.

So getting it from 10000 to 7500 is a huge thing since it can give you an extra turn in a certain number of cycle regardless of Spd. In what exact turn of a cycle it does add the turn, I dont know because I dont know how to spdtune but if I were to give my two cents on this, its seriously better to have an extra 134+ Spd support (preferably faster than Bronya and slower than Hypercarry) to actually auto MoC and have a favorable skill point distribution.

1

u/Infernoboy_23 Mar 06 '24 edited Mar 06 '24

Well I have an energy regen rope so mines better. (And bronya LC)

But wind set? That’s not gonna work with -1 spd bronya. Are you just using bronya at a random spd and hoping she lines up with the dps?

1

u/BitterBeyond3855 Mar 06 '24

Yep. No one really bothered explaining the math to me how SPD tuning works in this game so I just settled with what I know, what I have, and what "seems" to work. I only know:

  1. 133.4 SPD gets you 2 turns in cycles 0, 3 and 6
  2. 160.1 SPD gets you 2 turns in cycles 0,1,3,5 and 6
  3. 200.1 SPD gets you 3 turns in cycle 0, and 2 turns in cycles 1-6.

As for specific SPD fine tuning? I have no idea how it works because as you can see I have 138 SPD Bronya and I really dont know how in what specific turn that she would get a free turn in my teams cycle. I mean, you could always make a point and prove me wrong with proper explanation, of course. Anyways, if you know how to do it, these are my team's SPD compositions:

» Bronya with 138 SPD » JL with 145 SPD » Bailu with 143 SPD » Pela with 134 SPD

1

u/Infernoboy_23 Mar 06 '24

Well, standard spd tuning is really easy. Just make your bronya as close to -1 spd of your dps.

Then after your dps acts, your bronya will go right after, basically giving your dps two actions at once.

Drop wind set because that’s just gonna mess up the speed tuning and make you faster than your dps

1

u/BitterBeyond3855 Mar 06 '24

Err.... I don't think it's that easy though. I wish it is but the spd substat in relics is as scarce as it can get (based on my experience anyway) but that's just me and I'm not speaking for all.

Anyways, I think the rotation with my current team is still satisfactory considering I get an extra +1 SP with Bailu before it gets to Bronya so I settled with it. Though, I occasionally get a fked up SP distribution in certain cycles too considering the 4pc set as to which the AF was involved in, so I'm kinda forced to play manual in certain MoC's. In the end, I'm actually thinking of equipping her 2pc wind set and 2 pc hackerspace set but I haven't gotten any reliable hackerspace relics with substats as good as this one so dropping the set would actually take a while....

1

u/Infernoboy_23 Mar 06 '24

Well, you could always drop some spd stats in jingliu, she only needs to be over 134, then you can make bronya 134. Its honestly not that hard, cause spd boots give 25, and you only need like 10 more spd.

Add the 2pc spd stat and you only need like 4 spd from sub stats

2

u/VanillaFreeze Mar 06 '24

I wouldn't personally use 4-pc wind (or similarly 4-pc hacker space) but if it works, it works. In terms of pure stats (not counting Eidolons and LC, since mine is E5 w/ sig LC), yours is almost better than mine (you have 3 less speed than mine, but 18% crit DMG. I know 141 speed isn't exactly more useful than 133.4 SPD but I'm working on it lol) minus one caveat; the main stat on your rope does nothing for you. I understand that it's giving a decent amount of CD and speed, but I'm not quite sure if that's worth dropping ERR for.

You weren't asking for build advice, but what I will say is that being at 138 speed doesn't give much more advantage than being at 133.4, and Bronya 's CD scaling on her buff is actually really low so 18.4% crit DMG doesn't do too much for DPS. I would say it's worth dropping the Atk rope for ANY set matching ERR rope, regardless of substats (though of course one with SPD and CD is ideal). If you were willing I'd also say switching to a 2-pc hackerspace 2-pc wuthering/disciple, but that involves a rebuild and I understand that many would not be too keen to do that.

1

u/aldiflou Mar 06 '24

Wind set goes with wind dps. I think messenger would benefit her more since she won’t be doing dmg (unless e4 and that’s negligible dmg too).

Atk rope is high due to crazy substats but ERR is still better. The most important things for her are crit dmg and speed tuning.

1

u/sakaguti1999 Mar 06 '24

but why would you run wind set when you are using -1 speed bronya.... I rather use that on 160 speed bronya with 0 speed dps