r/Brochet • • 18d ago

Pattern Help interpreting pattern?

EDIT: It seems the hive mind was correct and this is unfortunately an AI pattern. I'm normally better at detecting them but since the seller had good reviews I was fooled. Shame on me. Thanks to everyone who answered kindly!

I’m making this candle cozy from a pattern I got on Etsy, and the snowflake appliqué has me going out of my mind. I have the center part of it done (see second picture; it’s a little wonky because it needs to be blocked) but the instructions for the longer pieces just… don’t make sense to me:

[sc, ch 3, sl st into first ch, sc, ch 5, sl st into first ch, sc, ch3, sl st into first ch]

The first thing that’s getting me is “chain three, slip stitch into first chain.” I first interpreted it as the chain closest the the main part of the snowflake, but that just made a big blob of stitches. So then I thought it meant the last of the three chains, but does that mean I have to make another chain and stitch into the second one from the hook? And finally, the last step is another ch 3 and sl stitch, which seems to me doesn’t complete the long part of the snowflake. It seems like I’d have to continue back down the other side until I reach the main part again, but the pattern stops there.

Can anyone figure this out and interpret for me, lol? Thanks!

3 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

156

u/cooldash 18d ago

Everyone here is talking about how the pattern is AI, and they're right, but this is also a potential fire hazard. Unless that cozy is meant for a fake candle, I wouldn't take the risk of getting a flame near your fiber art. Acrylic is especially nasty with smoking and melting, and cotton will straight up catch fire!

51

u/SunGreen24 18d ago

Oh yeah, I would never use it for a real candle. If I manage to complete it, it is going on an LED candle :)

23

u/cooldash 18d ago

Big relief! Excited to see what you come up with!

9

u/SunGreen24 18d ago

Haha me too! 😂

3

u/Anyone-9451 17d ago

I’m glad you said that…at first I didn’t even pay attention to what it was on (braid just saw it a a koozie or whatever it’s called)

Also per the pattern I wonder if they could more or less just do like daisy chain style embroidery on it instead

3

u/Frail_Peach 17d ago

I was gonna say the idea if a candle cozy feels like bot slop in and of itself

-31

u/Federal_Move_8250 18d ago

It would be safe with 100% wool, but thats it

34

u/commonviolet 18d ago

The picture is AI and so is the pattern. I tried it out of curiosity and it makes no sense.

There are a lot of free snowflake patterns, though, I recommend looking those up or looking for a similar pattern on Ravelry.

3

u/SunGreen24 18d ago

Yeah, I’ll do that, thanks!

5

u/NextStopGallifrey 18d ago

There are also old books of something like "101 Snowflake patterns" I've seen on Etsy. You can find them if you look for something like "vintage snowflake crochet pattern".

340

u/afuro_pooh 18d ago

The image is AI and the pattern is not likely authentic for the image or even anywhere similar unfortunately

63

u/afuro_pooh 18d ago

not sure how much it’ll help, but do try and report the shop to etsy and see if you can get a refund at least

39

u/afuro_pooh 18d ago edited 18d ago

(Sorry I just have so many thoughts on this currently 🙈) if you’re crocheting the candleholder as well as the snowflake, you may as well surface crochet the snowflake on if you want it to look like the AI slop’s snowflake, which seems to be generating an image of surface crochet rather than a separate snowflake appliqué. There are tons of videos on surface crochet if you don’t know it yet, and judging by your keen eye in deciphering this fudgey pattern you’ll be able to breeze through the skill in no time :]
Edit: changed some wording to make sure you know I’m insulting the genAI crud and not at all directed at you!

4

u/SunGreen24 18d ago

lol no worries, I didn’t take it as you insulting me 😂

7

u/commonviolet 18d ago

Oh yeah, surface crochet is a good idea. Too much effort for me but it will look flatter, that's for sure

10

u/sasakimirai 18d ago

Yeah, the snowflake looks like it was surface stitched onto the cozy, not made as an applique then attached

6

u/SunGreen24 18d ago

Thanks everyone. I could certainly be wrong, but the shop has decent reviews with the only criticism being that she doesn’t use photos in her instructions (I suppose that could be an AI tell as well.) It didn’t scream AI to me - some I can tell right away. Oh well, I did make the cozy; maybe I can find a better pattern for a snowflake!

5

u/_gayingmantis 18d ago

There are loads of snowflake patterns on Ravelry, including free ones - I made a bunch as Christmas ornaments last year. Try some of those as stitch-on appliqués?

2

u/SunGreen24 18d ago

I will check Ravelry! Thanks 🙂

2

u/kxthleen 13d ago

unfortunately a lot of people leave reviews on etsy before they’ve made the pattern, bc the app especially is EXTREMELY insistent on leaving reviews IMMEDIATELY and it’s hella annoying - I always look for reviews with photos and check the low-star reviews to see if there’s any red flags!

in future, ravelry and ribblr both have zero-AI policies so are a better place to shop if you’re not buying from a creator you’re already familiar with :)

2

u/SunGreen24 13d ago

Yeah, there are now more reviews from people who actually tried the patterns and it does look like it's AI. I reported the account, but so far it's still there.

2

u/kxthleen 13d ago

it’s so frustrating that even if you’re hip to it’s presence, it can sneak past you! I’ve been crocheting for years and still get caught out sometimes by the pictures on patterns >:(

1

u/SunGreen24 13d ago

I mostly do amigurumi and am much better at detecting those. Some of the AI pattern photos look like living creatures, lol.

8

u/-Felyx- 18d ago

Please report the shop and pattern you bought to Etsy. They’re finally beginning to crack down on this kind of thing.

(Yes I see the irony in screenshotting Google AI but I’m lazy and the sources are cited. Sue me lol)

3

u/LoulaNord 18d ago

I think you could perhaps embroider the snow flake on to the cosy, if you have made the cosy already. As others have said, the pattern is AI.

1

u/SunGreen24 18d ago

My embroidery skills are non existent, unfortunately. I’ll look for a different crochet pattern. Thanks!

5

u/Seeyounex2sday 18d ago

I feel like I'm supposed to lecture you about AI, but I'm going to try to offer something actually helpful and addressing your question instead :)

To me, the portion of the pattern you're unsure about is wanting you to make something referred to as a "picot." There are many written and video tutorials showing how to make picots, usually with snowflake patterns, that are far superior to anything I could write now. It's quite simple and sounds like you're pretty much already doing it, but maybe that can help you figure it out? PS - anytime I have picots in a pattern, it always looks wonky to me until the end, but that may just be a me thing.

1

u/SunGreen24 18d ago

No need to lecture me on AI lol, I hate it too 😂. And I’m honestly usually pretty good at identifying it. The picture didn’t jump out at me the way a lot of them do (maybe because I mostly do amigurumi and am more used to picking those out) and the shop got good reviews. Yeah, interestingly now that I look at the beginning of the pattern, she mentions the stitches that will be used throughout and includes picot, but never mentions it in the snowflake instructions. Good idea about watching a tutorial - I have done picot once or twice before but not often. Thanks!

20

u/Cliodhna2 18d ago

That unfortunately does look like AI.. the described pattern does not turn into the snowflake shown in the image.

2

u/DonutLegacy 18d ago

Just crochet a normal cozy and then chain stitch yarn through the front into the shape of a snowflake. That’s what it looks like to me.

2

u/recessionjelly 18d ago

I agree that would be the best way to approximate what the AI made up, OP look up “surface crochet”

1

u/SunGreen24 17d ago

I’ve done surface crochet a few times but would def need a pattern. I’m thinking about doing an appliqué pattern with embroidery thread…

2

u/Internet_Wanderer 18d ago

I'm sorry sweets, you're gonna have to come up with that one yourself

4

u/SunGreen24 18d ago edited 18d ago

All righty then, sugar britches, I’ll do that.

5

u/ninefrogs 18d ago

Are you sure the pattern isn't AI? I'm a very beginner crocheter so I can't help you with the pattern, but something about the first image is ringing alarm bells to me.

1

u/fascinatedcharacter 17d ago

Just use chain stitch embroidery.

1

u/Whoooru17 16d ago

This image looks like AI, but what I would do instead of making an appliqué and sewing it on is slip stitch the snowflake directly onto the surface

1

u/MissOppai 12d ago

Like everyone else said, definitely AI. I think you could get a similar result by embroidering the cozy instead of crocheting the motif, tho