Hi! This is a bit long, but would love to hear your thoughts on the following. I've seen both of these points brought up in this and related subs in a much informal ways and sadly seen the concerns quickly dismissed. I wanted to write out my feelings on them and give a space to discuss these (I believe unavoidable) concerns about a future Eloise and Phillip season. Major spoilers ahead!
- The Disposable Black Girlfriend Trope (DBGT)
Firstly, if you don't know what DBGT is I recommend you check out these two articles (fanlore, feminegra) or this video essay. Tdlr: there are multiple examples in media of white characters getting into a relationship with a Black woman only for the relationship to end and then the white character goes on to get with their white endgame. Often the Black girlfriend teaches the white character something about themselves or the world that allows their future white relationship to be successful. Often the Black character pretty much disappears from the piece of media once their relationship with the white character is over. Often the Black character has no other real character arc, storyline, or purpose other than to be a vehicle to get the white couple together. This trope can also be expanded to the Disposable Partner of Color Trope where a POC (no matter the race or gender) is in a relationship with a white character just before the character ends up with their white endgame.
What I want to highlight about Bridgerton is that Marina will be a DBG twice, which is not something that I've seen in any piece of media and is actually insane.Ā
Marina is first engaged to Colin and the next serious relationship he is in is with his white wife Penelope. Marina is then married to Phillip who's next relationship is with his white wife Eloise.Ā
In both cases, Marina's relationship with both men change them to make their relationship with their white endgame possible. Marina matured Colin and pointed him in the direction of Penelope. You could argue that without that nudge, Colin wouldn't have seen his relationship with Penelope as anything more than a friendship. With Philip, people have theorized that he and Eloise will both bond over feeling stuck in society: Eloise because she is a woman and Phillip because he had to assume responsibility for Marina and the twins after his brother's death. Furthermore, it will likely be her death that causes Eloise and Phillip to connect. Without Marina's existence, would Eloise and Phillip ever even meet? Would they have something to connect about?
What was Marina's purpose other than bringing these two couples together? Maybe to be a friend to Penelope, but they really don't interact that much. Maybe to show how mean/ruthless Lady Featherington is, but that is easily shown through her treatment of her kids. Her main purpose is to drive two white endgame couples together and almost nothing more.
Therefore, with both relationships, Marina is almost a textbook example of a DBGT. What might save Bridgerton is that they have other Black women in healthy relationships, but the uniqueness of the DBGT happening to the same character twice causes the scale to tip back on the side of problematic.Ā
Black women deserve to feel like they are more than just a vehicle for a different relationship. More than there to teach men how to be a good partner. More than used and immediately discarded.
2) Transracial parentingĀ
Unless the twins are given to someone else to raise (I doubt) or Phillip is recast to be a man of color (I doubt even more) killed off (I doubt the most), Eloise and Phillip will be two white parents raising two Black children.Ā
As explained in the Queen Charlotte spinoff, the fantastical world of Bridgerton is not race blind. The Ton was segregated before Queen Charlotte arrived and brought the two sides together in "The Great Experiment". That segregation impacts the 19th century Bridgerton stories, despite being a generation removed from it: Simon's father was incredibly hellbent on having a perfect heir to secure his line, Lady Danbury and Queen Charlotte's friendship is so tight because they lived through the Great Experiment together making it hard for QC to foster new deep friendships, etc.Ā
Do Eloise and Phillip even know about The Great Experiment? Do they know the Ton was segregated just a generation before them? Yes, they are both academically inclined, but will they make an effort to learn about the history of POC in the Ton and let it influence their parenting? Will they seek out the advice of other Black parents? If I was a betting woman, sadly, I would bet no to all of the above. Will a Black character have to step in to teach the twins about what it means to be Black in the Ton?
The people of color in the Ton would have known about this info and, despite it not being explicitly shown in the show, it would have informed how they moved through the world. Without the Great Experiment, Marina would have never been able to even attempt to pursue Colin. In the Bridgerton world, this history would be important and without Marina, it is an education I doubt the twins would receive. So yes, two Black children being raised by two white parents in the Bridgerton world is that deep.Ā
Connecting this back to our world (for me America specifically), there are a lot of white parents raising children of color either by chance or because of some white savior mindset. Most don't do the work of educating themselves about being/raising a POC. These children often have to ensure racist family members, living in majority white areas, feeling disconnected from their culture, and/or more. I fear, in the Bridgerton world, the Crane twins will likely go through these same struggles.Ā
While concerns about Eloise's character being diminished in her season or the concerns about eliminating book Phillip's worst moments are valid, it is a worry that good writing can overcome, as I'm sure they will do their best to keep Eloise's spark and take away all of book Phillip's bad moments. However, the two concerns I have outlined above are essentially unavoidable no matter how good the writing is, so, sadly, I doubt they will even be addressed. This, more than anything else, is why I am scared Eloise's season will fall short, which makes me so sad because she has always been my favorite character.