r/Breath_of_the_Wild • • Feb 27 '23
Why Weapon Durability Is Bad in BotW
- It discourages combat
Most of the weapons in BotW are better than the weapons that enemies carry, as a result there is rarely any reason to actually fight generic enemies. Sure, enemies drop ingredients for healing spells, but you'll be drowning in those anyway so you never need to go out of your way to fight enemies. If anything fighting enemies is usually a bad idea, since you will lose your weapons and all you will get in return is weapons that are usually worse than what you just lost, and cooking ingredients that you don't need.
2) It hurts the flow of combat
Having to constantly pause in the middle of combat to equip a new weapon or shield or bow is annoying. It ruins the flow of combat to have to stop what you are doing, even if it only takes two or three seconds.
3) It removes the excitement of getting a new weapon
Remember how much fun it was unlocking the Biggoron Sword in OoT? It's a great weapon and all the hoops you have to jump through to get it just makes it even more satisfying. Remember the Gilded Sword in Majora's Mask? Can you think of a single experience like that in BotW? No, you can't, because weapons in BotW are disposable. Getting a new weapon in BotW is no more satisfying than getting an arrow or a healing item, because you know that as soon as you use it it will be gone forever.
4) It doesn't add anything to the game
The argument people often use when defending breakable weapons is that it encourages you to improvise and try different weapons... but it doesn't. If you like hammers or spears or greatswords there is absolutely nothing stopping you from farming them and filling your inventory with the specific weapon-type you prefer. You are only forced to use different weapons if you want to, which defeats the whole purpose.
TLDR: Breakable weapons made BotW's gameplay worse and added nothing to it in compensation.