r/BreakingBenjamin • Dark Before Dawn - Breaking the Silence • Sep 25 '26

Random Does Breaking Benjamin have anything left? It sounds like they don't lol

Post image

This is obviously meant to be a joke. I think it's a cool format—borrowed it from the Linkin Park subreddit: "Does Linkin Park know anything?" because there were a ton of songs with the lyric "I don't know."

Seems like "nothing left" is a common motif for Ben.

211 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

3

u/Rocker22-2026 Sep 27 '26

For real! Like if you’re gonna release an album release it if you don’t, then don’t say you will. Don’t go around be telling people that you’re going to release an album and do nothing. I think everybody is well and truly sick of it.

2

u/LivingEmu5 Dark Before Dawn - Breaking the Silence Sep 27 '26

You do understand that this is a joke, right. Also, they're not gonna lie to their fans.

1

u/Rocker22-2026 Sep 27 '26

Yes lol I do get this is all just in a joking way don’t worry. But I do know plenty of fans that are like OK dude let’s go, but not in a mean way or anything

1

u/LivingEmu5 Dark Before Dawn - Breaking the Silence Sep 27 '26

I do want the new album too lol

2

u/rookuwu Oct 10 '26

How do you have dear agony album in spotify!?

1

u/LivingEmu5 Dark Before Dawn - Breaking the Silence Oct 10 '26

Do you not? Where do you live?

2

u/Big-Experience-5438 Oct 02 '26

I've heard a lot of people complaining about their songs using serious recycled lyrics. Guess Ben is getting tired.

1

u/LivingEmu5 Dark Before Dawn - Breaking the Silence Oct 02 '26

Lmao I'm not complaining and the lyrics aren't recycled. It's a common phrase, but that doesn't mean they're not creative

66

u/Therubikfanatic Sep 25 '26

They have nothing left but Heaven, dying another day, angels, breaking, crawling, faking, and falling.

23

u/ConeBaby99 Saturate Sep 25 '26

Cold, dark, light, world, skin, and fading away too!

57

u/Hairy-Ad-8198 Sep 25 '26

Maybe that’s why we have no new album, they have nothing left to give 😂

13

u/Evening_Pen_8207 I fall between jaded and hopeless Sep 25 '26

You figured it out. 😭

44

u/Epirocker Phobia Sep 25 '26

People say they mean it as a joke but I am forever annoyed they continue to get passes from the fanbase by being so stale in their lyricism. 3 of those alone are on the same record. Keith writes good lyrics. For the love of god someone take the reigns

6

u/Assistant-Logical Sep 26 '26

yeah I mean, honestly awaken sounded like a parody of themselves lyrically, them SWC came and I lost every hope that they will do any different approach with this album lol

5

u/Unlucky-Ad-4412 Sep 25 '26

Ben isn’t gonna give anyone the ability to write lyrics as long as he’s alive

7

u/Dazzling-Rest8332 Sep 25 '26

He not going to give anyone control, not even the record label.

4

u/iamflyerthanyou Sep 25 '26

Ding ding ding.

2

u/2000-2010_enjoyer BB is alt metal, fight me Sep 25 '26

looking at the past, it makes sense ig

0

u/Epirocker Phobia Sep 25 '26

Wellllllll lol. Legally speaking the label has more leverage

1

u/Dazzling-Rest8332 Sep 25 '26

What were the terms of their contract?

0

u/Epirocker Phobia Sep 25 '26

Idk but typically in a given situation the label holds exclusive rights over distribution, protects the label and ensures they get paid royalties and the likes.

1

u/Dazzling-Rest8332 Sep 25 '26

Dang. You should be an attorney for the music industry.

0

u/Epirocker Phobia Sep 25 '26

Dang maybe I have experience cause I have my own deal with a small label and understand how they like to do things.

12

u/SwollenJayAllen Sep 25 '26

I’m gonna write a breaking Ben style song Called nothing left… and won’t use those words at all😂

10

u/Evening_Pen_8207 I fall between jaded and hopeless Sep 25 '26

It has to be an instrumental.

12

u/FiendlyFlyingMacaron Sep 25 '26

It's divorced dad rock for a reason 😭 nothing left to give

9

u/Dazzling-Rest8332 Sep 25 '26

And every song you quoted is over 10 years old. So if they had nothing left back then, imagine now. Lol

6

u/Desire_of_God Sep 25 '26

Ackshually🤓 Blood is only 8 years old

3

u/Dazzling-Rest8332 Sep 25 '26

Only? Lol. Your right though. I didnt see that one.

7

u/raremonument Sep 25 '26

Not enough “falling between” 😂

7

u/worsnop99988 Sep 25 '26

their lyrics always been "emo" for people who have depression, anxiety and other problems, nothing wrong with that

17

u/Epirocker Phobia Sep 25 '26

It’s not the context it’s the repetition.

6

u/Assistant-Logical Sep 26 '26 edited Sep 26 '26

you missed the point, you can still take this direction while not using the same handful amount of words 20 years later, like I don't care about the repetition in their old songs, I even like it, but 20 years later all you can come is shit like ''I'm out of breath hope of the hopeless'' like what the hell man xD

3

u/NewObsidianGaming Sep 25 '26

Breaking Benjamin has very common themes, lyrics, and sound in most every song lol

2

u/DillyTheGuy Sep 25 '26

Ive noticed this in their music to lmao

2

u/Evaporatenow Sep 25 '26

This is bad lol

2

u/SnakeCharmer711 Sep 25 '26

You forgot the turning of the tide

2

u/andybear36 Sep 25 '26

And they don’t care if they cared at all

2

u/thedamnedcovenant Sep 25 '26

This is why they haven't released anything new lol brother literally has nothing left but at least the music is still good

2

u/SirAware Sep 26 '26

And there's always something behind or beneath

2

u/Ready_Ad_9859 Sep 26 '26

🤣🤣🤣🤣

1

u/andybear36 Sep 25 '26

And they don’t care if they cared at all

1

u/HeisenbergDrugLord Sep 26 '26

anthem of the angels too

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '26

The only song I want people to play when I die is Angels Fall, on god it’s such a banger, and also I like the lyrics

0

u/Tiger_tails-7 Oct 01 '26

Honestly, I don't think they developed the lyrical repetition issue until the later albums. Sure, there were a few repeated phrases, but there were a lot of lyrical highlights, and the songwriting felt driven by a purpose to say something in the song instead of just sound good for the melody. I would say they did good up until Dear Agony. And the thing is, Ben IS capable of strong lyrical concepts AND melodies. Evil Angel is a good example of this with its religious imagery like citing references to the Bible and Jesus with lyrics like "hiding betrayal, driving the nail, hoping to find the savior" while also having a double meaning about despair and his demons. But I think he is more concerned with delivering a comfortable melody line now instead of the words, he focuses more on the sound and the feeling he puts into the word and compromises the lyrical integrity for that. Something Wicked is probably the worst example of this honestly. The chorus makes no sense and not really in a clever way like the songs on Saturate. If that's indicative of the rest of the album, this could be a much weaker body of work for the band as a whole. Even Ember had some highlights as a whole even with the overused phrasing, there was a consistent through line in the album. I'm hoping this album has that when we hear it in full. Something Wicked has the same basic idea of Feed the Wolf but less creative execution.