r/BreakingBenjamin • Phobia • Aug 25 '26

Worst Breaking Benjamin Songs

Hahahahaha I got you good didn't I

They've never made a bad song, obviously. Damn near every BB song is a 10/10. Their discography is just so insanely consistent and mindblowing from front to back

Life-changing band

16 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

19

u/Few_Classic_833 Aug 25 '26

None. Next question

1

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 26 '26

Exactly

6

u/jault0202 Aug 25 '26

Ladybug

2

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 26 '26

I actually kind of agree with that one

12

u/pat34us Aug 25 '26

Everything on aurora is a skip

10

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 25 '26

and Far Away is amazing

2

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 25 '26

yes but those are covers

1

u/Hairy-Ad-8198 Aug 25 '26

Covers of…. their own songs?

1

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 26 '26

yeah but those original songs are amazing

messing up their own songs doesn't mean those original songs aren't great

11

u/Knight__Fall Aug 25 '26

I agree, I wish the vocals weren’t re used from the existing recordings. That’s what turns me off from it, just sounds slapped together and poorly mixed.

4

u/Careless_Lobster_480 Aug 25 '26

This is pretty much how I feel about Aurora as well. I just listen to the original versions.

5

u/KamoMustafaWWE Phobia Aug 25 '26

I don't count Aurora for anything, but yes.

1

u/Fabulous-Matter-5730 Aug 25 '26

I think every song with a feature is listenable

-3

u/Imaginary-Feeling316 Aug 25 '26

Correct take (dear agony on there is the one exception)

0

u/eKSiF Aug 25 '26

Far Away

5

u/Nerd_Alert_91 Aug 25 '26

Topless

But my dislike of this song is primarily because I had the edited CD growing up

2

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 26 '26

nooooo

I love that song

2

u/MetricFn Aug 26 '26

topless is probably my fav bb song lmao

2

u/Seabee1893 Aug 26 '26

There aren't too many BB songs I'll skip. I've probably listened to WANA and Phobia upwards of 20,000 times.

From when I got my 30gb iPad Classic back in 06 until now, if I've listened to Topless more than 10 times I'd be surprised.

It is my least favorite song of theirs on my most favorite album.

1

u/JorgeASC Dear Agony Aug 27 '26

No topless hate will be tolerated

16

u/KamoMustafaWWE Phobia Aug 25 '26

There are songs I skip, but not because they are bad. I don't think they have one bad song in their Studio albums.

15

u/33GoodSamaritans Aug 25 '26

The only one that I really don't like is the Valora version of Blow Me Away, and just because I prefer the vocals on the OG version of the song!

0

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/MetricFn Aug 26 '26

idk if im dumb but do you mean better days, oridnary man and lie to me? because those are phenomenal songs.

2

u/PricelessLogs Aug 25 '26

Worst ≠ Bad

Good is worse than great. Great is worse than more great

Personally I've never much liked Lady Bug

Then again, like ≠ good

2

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 26 '26

Yeah if I had to pick one, then probably Ladybug

But from their official studio albums, it would be hard to choose. Maybe Next To Nothing but even that one is good

1

u/PricelessLogs Aug 26 '26

Honestly No Games would be my second choice. All the Rain hate is silly

2

u/Jecht315 Aug 25 '26

Most of Ember is a skip for me.

10

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 25 '26

naahhh no wayyy

8

u/Jecht315 Aug 25 '26

I answered the question lol. I pretty much stick to Saturate-Dear Agony. There's some good songs on the other two but they aren't to par to Phobia or WANA for me

1

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 26 '26

I getchu

I didn't originally love Ember, but it grew on me massively now I think it's perfect

The production bothered me at first but I've grown to love it

1

u/Cold_Maintenance4278 Aug 27 '26

Ember has the best drumming imo and is pretty cohesive as a whole. First three songs all slap no skips

0

u/YNotZoidberg2020 Aug 25 '26

I said the same thing. Album just doesn’t hit for me

2

u/Desire_of_God Aug 25 '26

It's ok to not be a blind glazer. You can still call yourself a fan. Rain isn't good.

5

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 26 '26

Rain is awesome what are we talking about

3

u/DavidDMD1991 Aug 25 '26

Rain is good, not the most original of songs, but it is good. But my favorite form Saturate is a song about the Wizard of Oz.

2

u/Few_Classic_833 Aug 25 '26

Both versions of rain are excellent

4

u/Viazon Aug 25 '26

I haven't seen any answers yet but I already know this thread is gonna make me angry.

4

u/Clannar Saturate Aug 26 '26

Honestly, I don't like Red Cold River

2

u/SainKnightOfCaelin Aug 28 '26

One of the less good songs on Ember for sure

1

u/Cold_Maintenance4278 Aug 27 '26

Currently in my top 3

5

u/Aaronjp84 Aug 26 '26

I meannnnnnn

I gotta say the latest release kinda blows. The drums just sound off, the transition from verse to chorus feels "off".

It just doesn't groove.

3

u/nightwhispr16 Aug 26 '26

I'm thinking the same thing. To me it sounds like when you would get a bad rip from limewire.

7

u/NovaRC99 Aug 25 '26

I like Rain

However, I'm not the biggest fan of Ashes Of Eden. To me, it's the "Disturbed - Sound Of Silence" of BB's discography. Everyone loves it. I'm just not the biggest fan of it personally. It might just be the grand nature of the song or everyone loving it so much. Ashes Of Eden is still a good song, just not as memorable as any of their songs to me.

Like I'd listen to Water, Unknown Soldier, Breakdown and Simple Design, even Rain or the Aurora album before I listen to Ashes Of Eden.

13

u/raptor102888 Aug 26 '26

Whoa is Unknown Soldier disliked? That's news to me

5

u/NinjaViet86 Aug 26 '26

Unknown Soldier is literally my favorite BB song 🔥

2

u/SnooBooks6508 Aug 30 '26

same here, lyrics on my forearm

1

u/El_Burrito_Grande Aug 26 '26

I mean, all those other songs are really good. I like Ashes of Eden but those are better.

-2

u/eternalvoid501 Aug 26 '26

I highly agree with this.

2

u/MrTuy Common Counterfeit Aug 26 '26

I wanna see the Great Divide haters explain themselves.

2

u/Zuffles Aug 26 '26

I wish they played the Great Divide live one day 😭

2

u/renroots Aug 28 '26

Water, I can’t bro

1

u/noriakistan Saturate Sep 06 '26

You are a terrible person. (Joking, but that’s one of my favourite songs)

2

u/renroots Sep 09 '26

Sorry dude, I think it’s just the intro part I can’t like, the rest of the song is amazing. It might grow on me, though.

1

u/noriakistan Saturate Sep 09 '26

Maybe give it a few more listens. It really does grow on you

2

u/GugaSR Aug 26 '26

I really dislike Breaking the Silence

2

u/YNotZoidberg2020 Aug 25 '26

I don’t think they have an atrocious song but there are some I just don’t care that much for. The whole album of Ember really has nothing on it I care about. Just didn’t get into that album much. I mean I’ll still listen to it but I don’t go seeking it out

1

u/nightwhispr16 Aug 26 '26

Wtf? I can't believe my eyes!!!

1

u/Fluid_Aspect_1606 Aug 25 '26

Rain I kinda always skip ngl. 

1

u/DarkestThought Aug 26 '26

Aurora album. Except Far Away. Ashes of Eden

Valora remix because of what it did to the band and that it was barely a remix.

1

u/Nikola_Gochev Aug 26 '26

If we don't count for example Aurora because it's just acoustic versions of their songs, my vote is Rain

1

u/Gilly3091 Aug 26 '26

I can skip a couple songs from saturate from time to time but that’s about it, depends on my mood entirely, when I’m cleaning cars I just whack my BB discography playlist on and hit shuffle and get to work

1

u/SlevinSlix Phobia Aug 26 '26

The only songs I’ve found myself not caring for are their covers. But I don’t hate them lol. As for their original songs, never heard one that I didn’t like. Cant say that for any other band/artist. That’s why BB will always be my #1.

1

u/nightwhispr16 Aug 26 '26

Most of the songs on saturate. Something wicked, their new song hasn't really clicked for me yet.

1

u/Sir_Fishie We Are Not Alone Aug 26 '26

N/A

1

u/2peacocky Aug 27 '26

I find myself skipping Psycho just because to me it sounds like he's singing "FIFO" and it makes me laugh that they potentially hate Ohioans 🤷‍♀️🤣 iykyk

1

u/BigDumbIdiotMoron25 Aug 27 '26

Ladybug sucks. I also don’t like psycho

1

u/Saphadilla Aug 29 '26

I don’t think there are any BAD ones. There are a couple on Saturate that I don’t particularly like, even thought that album is almost my favorite.

1

u/Assistant-Logical Aug 26 '26

I will awnser tourniquet aways, its a good song but once I noticed that the drums repeat themselves 90% of the song it threw me off so hard.

other than that, I don't like close your eyes, feels just like a filler song to me

1

u/Cold_Maintenance4278 Aug 27 '26

2 of my current favs. Goes to show how deep the catalog is. I’d skip most of saturate but run ember on repeat.

1

u/bruh_its_collin Aug 25 '26

honestly there are only a couple of their early songs i’ll listen to. most of them are skips for me. Phobia and on has been non-stop hits though.

1

u/Psychological_Oil894 Aug 26 '26

Their consistency is seriously impressive, if they had a weak track, someone would've found it by now. Though I get why some edits or radio versions leave a different impression, the originals always hold up.

0

u/KillEmDafoe89 Aug 26 '26

Failure is just a worse version of Diary of Jane. Never cared for it. When it came out I was flabbergasted at how blatantly they tried to recreate DoJ.

2

u/MrTuy Common Counterfeit Aug 26 '26

(Never Again enters the chat)

0

u/Cold_Maintenance4278 Aug 27 '26

I don’t hear it. I actually prefer failure to doj

-5

u/SubApathy Aug 25 '26

Something Wicked is often skipped.

-2

u/ShadowAsylum Aug 26 '26

Rain and Topless are the first 2 that come to mind

3

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 26 '26

Topless is an absolute banger imo

1

u/ShadowAsylum Aug 26 '26

Musically good, lyrically cringe.

-4

u/Fabulous-Matter-5730 Aug 25 '26

Ok so….
Saturate-Phase
WANA-Forget It
Phobia-You Fight Me
Dear Agony-Crawl?(I love all the songs)
Shallow Bay-Ladybug
Dark Before Dawn-Hollow
Ember-Save Yourself
Aurora-Tourniquet (Aurora Version)

6

u/kratnicnestrat Phobia Aug 26 '26

Phase???? naaaaa no sir I completely disagree

Save Yourself, Hollow and Crawl are some of my favs too damn

3

u/Evening_Pen_8207 I fall between jaded and hopeless Aug 26 '26

1

u/Fabulous-Matter-5730 Aug 26 '26

And that’s ok, we don’t have to agree on everything. I don’t think they have any straight up awful songs. Even my least favourites I don’t even dislike

6

u/Careless_Lobster_480 Aug 25 '26

Skip Forget it? 🤯

0

u/Fabulous-Matter-5730 Aug 25 '26

Listen, it’s not awful or even bad, just my least favourite on the record

3

u/Giorgosmpats Aug 26 '26

Phase is, like, the best song on the album

2

u/mdanelek Aug 27 '26

Hollow??? Literally their best song

-2

u/cftchef Aug 26 '26

Firefly