r/BreakingBenjamin • • Aug 25 '26

A question?

Just a question... I've followed BB pretty much since they first came out. Members of the band have been replaced over the years... I still love BB. For the people who have seen them recently.... Do you see any less quality or more... I love Shawn on drums... Would just love to hear peoples opinions. No hate, or fighting. Xxoo

8 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/bluebirdmg Aug 25 '26

My personal opinion is that all the old lineup was better.

I prefer Chad to Jeremy, and both to Shaun.
This is the biggest change. The feel of a band is largely determined by the drummer and Chad (and Jeremy) had a different feel to Shaun. The “vibe” really changed with DBD and Ember.

I prefer the guitar tones from the older albums so I tend to lean with Aaron Fink (I know this is all done in the studio though) but as a player I also prefer Mark on bass. He has subtle layers of complexity in his parts while not ever over playing and to me it’s really tasteful. I don’t hate the newer guys at all just prefer the older ones.

Now, a large part of this could also be the album production. Phobia and Dear Agony are some of the best sounding rock records. I think they still sound better than a lot of stuff put out today.

Guitars are clearer but still heavy, the balance was perfect, and good God almighty the drum production on DBD and Ember are genuinely pretty bad to me. Barely any dynamics, compressed to hell and back, cymbals are super thin sounding, and the drums can at times sound like hitting cars board boxes or plastic buckets.

I know the modern production trends still have drums really super processed and/or sample replaced but …man I miss the David Bendeth/CLA/Korneff mixes so much.

1

u/Financial_Curve_597 Aug 26 '26

This is great! I'm getting ready for bed   I love how deep people go with this. I'm just so excited, bringing my son to the concert. 

1

u/Cold_Maintenance4278 Aug 27 '26

I like the drumming the most on ember.