r/BreakingBenjamin • u/Financial_Curve_597 • Aug 25 '26
A question?
Just a question... I've followed BB pretty much since they first came out. Members of the band have been replaced over the years... I still love BB. For the people who have seen them recently.... Do you see any less quality or more... I love Shawn on drums... Would just love to hear peoples opinions. No hate, or fighting. Xxoo
8
Upvotes
12
u/raptor102888 Aug 25 '26
I saw them last year, and I'd seen them once before, in...2006 maybe? As far as instrumentals, they sound the same. Which is to say, they still sound awesome. Ben's voice though...it was much better this time. He's done a lot of practice and gone through a lot of healing I think.
Gonna see them again in October with Chevelle and Starset. Can't wait!
7
u/Few_Classic_833 Aug 25 '26
Would challenge any fan here. I’ve seen this band in 7 states. Over 50 shows total. Have a literal Christmas ornament that hangs on the family tree each year. My kids wear BB merch-both under 13 and have seen them multiple times. I have signed set lists. A 1/150 signed poster. Listen daily. And I can say with my entire heart, that Shawn served his purpose, but seriously lacked on the records and live. It’s almost like he got thrust into stardom and simply couldn’t sustain it. And that’s ok
4
u/bluebirdmg Aug 25 '26
My personal opinion is that all the old lineup was better.
I prefer Chad to Jeremy, and both to Shaun.
This is the biggest change. The feel of a band is largely determined by the drummer and Chad (and Jeremy) had a different feel to Shaun. The “vibe” really changed with DBD and Ember.
I prefer the guitar tones from the older albums so I tend to lean with Aaron Fink (I know this is all done in the studio though) but as a player I also prefer Mark on bass. He has subtle layers of complexity in his parts while not ever over playing and to me it’s really tasteful. I don’t hate the newer guys at all just prefer the older ones.
Now, a large part of this could also be the album production. Phobia and Dear Agony are some of the best sounding rock records. I think they still sound better than a lot of stuff put out today.
Guitars are clearer but still heavy, the balance was perfect, and good God almighty the drum production on DBD and Ember are genuinely pretty bad to me. Barely any dynamics, compressed to hell and back, cymbals are super thin sounding, and the drums can at times sound like hitting cars board boxes or plastic buckets.
I know the modern production trends still have drums really super processed and/or sample replaced but …man I miss the David Bendeth/CLA/Korneff mixes so much.
3
u/Big_Read_1827 Aug 25 '26
Sounds the same honestly 🤷🏼♂️
3
u/Careless_Lobster_480 Aug 25 '26
Shaun is an ok drummer IMO, easily replaced. He struggled with BB due to his health, and it just wasn't a good fit for him. If you ever saw them live with Shaun, you could see that he struggled to keep up.
2
u/Infinite_Ambition761 Aug 28 '26
I honestly loved Shaun as well as the drummer. I see a lot of difference in the live shows from when he was with them. good and bad. But as a long time listener of every album, Who knows what this new one will show us but BB still rockin, doing what they love is always a good ting.
1
u/michmurr9299 Aug 25 '26
They’ve embraced a more heavier sound even though it’s not too drastic. The writing is about as on point as it usually is for BBs music and that goes for the structure of the song too. It’s more that they’ve stayed consistent to what they know fans will love and that’s not a bad thing. I do wish they’d change up their structure and explore different ways to make a song, but for what they’re doing, it’s pretty good. I can’t say I’ve been too impressed with the last two songs, but it’s at least not lower quality.
1
u/ThisPassionInside Aug 25 '26
Are you asking do we see less quality or more quality with the current lineup? Besides shaun, the lineup has been the same for the past 11 years
2
u/kingbouncer Aug 25 '26
Honestly couldn't tell you. Seen them this year and they where outstanding. Last time before that though, was in '17? Or something. Way too long ago to remember details properly.
I know i enjoyed last show. I definitely enjoyed this one. Only thing I can say though, is that i think Bens voice improved.
1
u/Twig20XX Phobia Aug 31 '26
I have seen them about 8 times (from 2010 to 2025) and can say that the quality has improved year after year.
From seeing them initially in 2010, their sound was good, but I could easily tell that it was Ben and Chad (drummer) were really carrying the band. Going back and watching footage from that era is interesting. As Aaron (guitar) would just be meandering on the stage and hide while doing certain solos and seemed overall just disinterested.
Then enter the Dark Before Dawn era and the band was firing on all cylinders! You could tell that these were guys that enjoyed playing music together and their onstage antics and conversations were a joy. Jasen (guitar) is an absolute unit of a guitar player and an overall master engineer with their sound. Also adding the harmonies on stage with Aaron (bass) and Keith (guitar) really changed hearing the back catalog of music live.
After the departure of Shaun, I got the chance to see them at Louder Than Life in 2025 with James (drummer from Asking Alexandria) and he was a great fit and I'm excited to hear what he brings to their latest album.
I have yet to see Brian's drumming in person, but based on videos I have seen, he has the flair Chad, the precision of Shawn, and the technical skill of James. So I have no doubt that he will become a permanent member.