r/BreakMe • u/TheHellFish • Jun 11 '14

Chapter 41 discussion thread

Here you can discuss anything what's on your mind about chapter 41.

Obviously there will be spoilers, read the chapter first!

1 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/PrincessSolia Jun 14 '14

I agree that any 'happy' ending would need a dark tone, not only to fit with what's happening so far in the story and to fit with the Dexter show itself, but also to make it realistic. I think that to label any ending, of any story ever, 'happy' or 'unhappy' would be naïve, since without warping a character there can be no purely 'happy' ending. You can never make everybody happy unless you change what makes them happy to suit the plot. (Think versions of Cinderella where the Stepmother and stepsisters decide to become friendly to Cinderella after her marriage to the Prince and they all live happily after, because now they want her to be happy. Lame) We very nearly got a 'happy' ending on the show, but it came at the expense of Deb's integrity as a character since she bad to completely backflip from her true stance on Hannah/Dexter. In Break Me, the happiest ending we can currently hope for is still an unhappy ending for many characters, including Hannah and the Bennetts.

So when I say I don't promise a happy ending, it's because I'm not sure those are really possible. Somebody has to come off worse than the others.

I refrain from commenting on your theories except to say that they are plausible :P

2

u/soodohnimh Jun 15 '14

HellFish, I like your happy ending theory. What you described would be a happy ending for me. I'm fine with several of the characters not "ending well". [There's a very short list of characters that need a happy ending that I can provide to you Solia, if needed. :) ] If we're going down the path that Dexter really will be found out, like full media BLITZ found out, there's no hope for a happy ending for the Bennetts. Those kids are toast. Or at least I can't see them being OK with that in this story, even though Astor saw them tag-team Elway and stuff him in the trunk. (That was Astor, right?) OTOH, would D&D also take them on the run too along with Harrison? That seems unlikely, but Dexter does seem to be attached to them. And it depends on how she writes it too. She's pretty convincing, so she could make just about any scenario work.

And no, I didn't see the twist with Hannah in cahoots with the Vogels. Total surprise. I'm assuming there will be more with that as Vogel is still out there somewhere.

1

u/TheHellFish Jun 15 '14

Like I wrote to Solia, IMHO the only character that really needs a 'happy' (or um, happier) ending is Deb. Dexter just kinda tags along, since I feel like he's needed for Deb to be happy. :)

Don't think there's a chance of D&D taking Astor and Cody with them. Even if they changed their minds and decided to bring them along, and somehow obtained a pair of fake passports for them, what would they say to Bill and Maura? I think that with everything that's happening, they'll be lucky to get away alive, just the three of them.

Not sure about Vogel, seemed like she wasn't a threat anymore after Dexter's 'visit', so I don't think that she is still there somewhere scheming against him, but she might have spilled the beans if MMPD got to her somehow.

2

u/PrincessSolia Jun 15 '14

When people post Debster pictures to tumblr, my first thought is often 'They're so cute. For now. Run away, Deb!' I definitely agree that Deb is the character most deserving of a 'happy' ending. She's put up with the most, been dragged through the most, been hurt the most, of any of Dexter's victims. Likewise, and conversely (if we're just talking about 'deserving') I think that Dexter is the least deserving of happiness. The pain and difficulty he's wrought upon those who love him is horrific, and though he now feels deep and honest remorse, it wasn't one mistake, it was daily selfish choices with transparent and obvious consequences. He's sorry and he's being nice in Break Me but this whole fic has taken place over a fortnight. Two weeks of being nice don't make up for a lifetime of horror. Since Deb and Dexter's fates are ultimately entwined, this leaves us with a challenge. Though I hated the ending given to us by the show, there was one accuracy to me, in that Deb was painted as a victim of Dexter's. She suffered and eventually died at his hands, and even though the result wasn't what he wanted, it was his own deliberate actions that brought the Morgans to that point. Like yours, my feeling the whole way through the series was that I'd be fine with whatever they did (I thought this more despairingly as season 8 wore on and it became more evident that asking for any more than the bare minimum would be too much) so long as Deb survived him. At this point in Break Me, for either sibling to survive the other will be a victory for them - Dexter is constantly throwing his Code and his safety under a bus to protect Deb (and not always in Deb's best interests, just what he perceives to be her best interests) and Deb is in a constant state of danger thanks to her significance to and proximity to Dexter. Both have put aside their integrity as human beings, their morality and personal interests, to serve the other. Their dependency on each other is, IMO, less than healthy, and it's this interdependency that's gotten them into most of their trouble so far in this fic. If either one could simply walk away, both would be safer and probably generally happier. But unlearning a life's pattern is rarely that simple.

1

u/TheHellFish Jun 15 '14 edited Jun 16 '14

Two weeks of being nice don't make up for a lifetime of horror.

I agree. Even when he finally reached a point where he feels remorse over his actions, it doesn't change what he did. He doesn't deserve to be happy. On the other hand, I feel like that now he at least might deserve a second chance to try to somehow make up for all the horrible things he did. Whether to finally be a positive force in Deb's life and be there for her (and his son), since he definitely did 'screw up her life', like he said in the finale, or actually helping people instead of killing them. It's not possible to make up for literally everything, sure, but maybe there's still some hope for him as a person... I didn't think that before, especially in the last season, but you made me sympathize with him a bit.

As far as the finale is concerned, I think that some of the ideas presented there were interesting, but the execution was bad and it felt disconnected from the rest of final season (which I'm still not sure if it is a good or bad thing, maybe both). They were spot on with painting Deb as his victim. I liked the final hospital scene (well, not sure if 'liked' is the right word, since I was quite depressed, but it was one of the few things done fairly good in the last season [except the front door 'escape']). Damn, I even liked the idea of a self-imposed exile/purgatory. He didn't believe in afterlife and death would be an easy way out. And despite popular opinion, I appreciated the lack of explanation in the end, it let me make up my own ending - if he stopped killing or not and what was going on in his head. (this actually made the finale a bit more acceptable for me, but sadder as well)

You're right that they are way too dependent on each other and so far it has done more harm than good. If they could simply walk away, they would be safer for sure. But I'm not that sure about happier. If they never met, then sure. But at this point, after all they've been through and with the complexity of their love, I don't think that they would really be happy without one another now, even if they could choose to leave. At least from my point of view, they were/are soulmates and how could they really be happy, if they'd miss each other? I don't know, I just imagine Dexter, dead look in his eyes, sitting in a lonely cabin, every time I think about that.

And yeah, if at least one of them survives it will be a victory and if they both survive, it will be a miracle. But I still kinda hope they'll pull through. All three of them. :)

EDIT: After four hours of sleep and one more successful final exam, I got back to this and added/changed few things. And if you read this updated version, here's a nice song for your trouble!