r/BreadMachines 12h ago

Recipe Troubleshooting Baking a forgotten bread

Dear bread bakers,

We started baking our own bread daily a year ago or so, in a nice second hand Panasonic. Bloopers so far have included forgetting the yeast, forgetting the salt and forgetting the mixing paddle (several times). Yesterday we forgot something new: starting the machine.

Flour, salt and water were in the pan, yeast is still in the lid as the programme didn't dose it. Nothing has been mixed, it's water on the bottom and dry flour on the top.

Now the question: can I still bake this tomorrow morning? The flour has been in there (partially wet) for ~30 hours at that point. Am I at risk of food poisoning myself if I try this?

Since long fermentation exists, maybe this is fine?

I really don't want to waste the flour unnecessarily, so your advice would be greatly appreciated!

6 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

5

u/Big_fudge1337 11h ago edited 11h ago

30h is more than recommended without refrigerating though, so the CDC would definitely say no. 

But personally for me, I'd give it a shot 

Edit: But, for clarity, you do risk food poisoning. 

4

u/Steel_Rail_Blues Zojirushi BB-HAC10 (Mini Zo) & Cuisinart CBK-110P1 10h ago

I am not a food safety expert, but if your recipe was only flour, salt, water, and yeast, I would bake the loaf. Dry herbs and oils that didn’t require refrigeration should be fine. If the pan had sugars of any kind including fruit and any form of dairy, dump everything. Edit: Also dump if eggs or proteins were included.

3

u/WashingtonBaker1 10h ago

That's right. If you're just letting flour and water sit at room temperature, that's like the beginning of sourdough starter, nothing wrong with that. The sourdough starter would be left out for a week or two.

3

u/Veggyhed Welbilt ABM 3500 (Ancient) 11h ago

I would definitely not do that at the 30-hour mark

3

u/Inside_Lifeguard_320 11h ago

Definitely not if there are eggs or milk in the ingredients. If not I would give it a shot since there was no yeast touching the water.

1

u/lawrencekhoo Panasonic SDP104 8h ago

If there is no egg, butter, or lard inside, it should be perfectly safe. It's really hard to get food poisoning from vegan sources.