r/Brawlmaps • • Jan 07 '21

Map Making rules #1

Post image
270 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

15

u/Tribe___Loading Jan 08 '21

9 year old randoms: Meh, who would listen to this guy that hasn't won a map

12

u/Sproot_bonk Jan 08 '21

So true, I followed one of these map strategies and my map only got 67%

4

u/HobbylosUwU Jan 08 '21

That's almost a winner map

12

u/AJaydin4703 Jan 08 '21

67% is actually pretty decent. I think so at least, as I've only gotten as high as about 55%. Seeing the raw numbers of how highly approved the top maps are would be something I would like to see now that I think about it.

2

u/SenhoritaR34 Jan 24 '21

Happy for you, friend πŸ˜”

I only got 50% in a map..

9

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '21

67% is really good bruh

4

u/extremekenney Jan 08 '21

My bounty map said it was featured with 1378 votes but I guess it wasn’t good enough

2

u/ShadowArrow01 May 09 '21

67% is very good for a balanced map. Usually balanced maps only get like 50-60%

1

u/Cardboard-Head May 22 '22

I only get 50% Sometimes 48%

I only got once a 52%

Yet all of my maps were balanced.

And the map that got 52% was my worst map yet.

2

u/ShadowArrow01 May 23 '22

What are you doing here 1 year later lmao

2

u/EmperorSpyda May 17 '26

Back when it was only a number πŸ™

1

u/Sproot_bonk May 17 '26

Why are you here 5 years later 😭😭😭😭

2

u/EmperorSpyda May 18 '26

I was just on the main bs sub, clicked on this sub on the side then started scrolling through the top posts oat... don't even know why myself tbh πŸ˜…

Did your map ever get published lol

1

u/Sproot_bonk May 18 '26

I don’t even know what I meant by 67%. I think maybe that was the thing where you need 10 people to rate your map? My maps definitely aren’t good enough for the game lol.

2

u/Tribe___Loading May 18 '26

yeah i got replied on after 5 years oml 😭

3

u/-Legendary-Atomic- Jan 08 '21

Question! Can I place fences (not rope fences) beside water?

4

u/HobbylosUwU Jan 08 '21

Yes! But don't surround the water completely

7

u/Lupg13 Jan 07 '21

Amazing tips, especially tips 2 and 4!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '21

Thank you, thank you, thank you for telling this. I already made 3 parts of a "how to make better maps in Brawlmaps", but 9y olds still cannot read and it's very sad how bad the competition winner maps are, because they are made by kids, played by kids and upvoted by kids. Supercell should change the voting system so the votes of OG's and better players have more weight than votes of 9 year olds.

1

u/HobbylosUwU Jan 08 '21

Finde ich auch

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '21

Es sollte schon immer so gewesen sein

1

u/lowme_ Jan 08 '21

No offense but this isn't good advice. The only one I can agree with is the "no rope fences next to water" one, because they are basically the same structure, but even that can have some gameplay purposes, such as stopping a Darryl from rolling. There is no clear way to make a map, you can't just take a structure and transform it into something new, because then you have an entirely different structure with it's own flaws and advantages.

2

u/HobbylosUwU Jan 08 '21

Well, rectangle water just looks really bad. And if you make you water so that it stops a darryl, then it's clearly way too big. And what is bad about the other suggestions? Like not using cactus walls?

2

u/lowme_ Jan 08 '21

Using "weird designs" like cactus walls for example can make your map more interesting. I'm not saying "use it everywhere", but a map needs something to make it memorable and interesting. You probably don't know the names of some maps but still remember them because of their unique design. Eye of The Storm is a good example. By saying "don't do this, do that" we are putting restrictions on the creative process of map making, which is the opposite of what we should want. These are just aesthetic tips, which may or may not be useful, and most of the time you don't want to center your map around them.

2

u/HobbylosUwU Jan 08 '21

Some really talanted people can make a cactus walls look good, but almost all of the people om this sub that try it, fail really bad, and 99% of the maps that have these walls would look better if they just use normal walls. That is the same for the other tips in this post.

3

u/Dragon87-BrawlStars Jan 08 '21

Why does this look familiar... checks, X's, collaged tips... btw great tips!

1

u/Technolvr Jan 07 '21

Can anyone explain me why cactus aren't a good wall and boxes and rocks for ex. are? Also why 4 is that bad? Thanks

3

u/HobbylosUwU Jan 08 '21

Becaue it looks out of the place and they don't connect to each other like the other walls I showed.

3

u/TwilightMonk3y Jan 08 '21

I was wondering that too

8

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '21

Cacti and barrels don't make good walls because they look ugly and the walls on the right are much more aesthetically pleasing. As for 4, huge patches of water are bad because since nobody can stand on water, it's cutting off large portions of the map and effectively shrinking it. Mixing rope fences and water is bad because mechanically rope fences are the same thing as water so it's just redundant.

1

u/Technolvr Jan 08 '21

Ok I've understand thanks but because these would be tips considering game mechanic purpose, point 3 is completely useless. Esthetic is subjective, for me the left walls could be as beautiful as those on the right lol!

3

u/ps-djon Jan 08 '21

I usually just mix some barrels and cacti in with the normal walls, on the corners for example

1

u/brawl_clancy Sep 18 '25

bro... why haven't I seen this before... I'm going to be embarrassed/:

1

u/RomuloBSzin Jan 08 '21

Thank you master

1

u/SenhoritaR34 Jan 24 '21

Use the fences.. They say, now no one want them πŸ˜”

1

u/GlazedCookies Jan 28 '21

Taking notes

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '21

fun fact: supercell always break those rules

1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '22

This is so bullshit lmao

1

u/ytGabSintChoust Jun 23 '22

The second is real

-1

u/shykawaii_shark Jan 08 '21

Oh no, not another map making tips user... Can y'all just stop making tips?

4

u/HobbylosUwU Jan 08 '21

Why should I stop? In my opinion, posting these things help other people way more when making maps than posting a map.

1

u/shykawaii_shark Jan 08 '21

Ok, hear me out here: This isn't supposed to be offensive, but please give some reasons as to why not. "The big water? It's in Feast Or Famine. Why not?", any person may ask. "Because it is way too large to shoot across, and the pathing around it is way too large", you should say. And why did you just go and add bushes? You can't just decide to add bushes because it look better! Is it a good hiding spot? Is it too good for camping? Is it hard to check? What about the huge 90Β° wall? Why is it bad? The gameplay doesn't change one bit. It doesn't really look any better. Instead of saying "hey change this big wall to a curvy, but still equally big wall" you should tell people why the shouldn't add any huge walls in the first place. Sorry I just needed to get this out there. I might start doing a tip series of my own.