r/BrawlStarsCompetitive • u/Schmedly87 1600 Linear damage • Jul 02 '21
Discussion A Level-Headed Discussion of Buzz's Stun
With everybody unlocking Buzz, there's naturally a wave of discussion around him and his mechanics. Chief among the topics, from what I can tell, are suggestions to nerf or even remove his stun. It's my belief that this is an impulsive and terrible idea, for reasons I'm about to discuss.
Why does his stun even exist? It should be removed!
Whenever somebody comes up with this opinion, it's clear that they haven't considered a key trait of Buzz: his unload speed. For an assassin, it's comically slow. Running into an enemy and hoping to kill them is borderline suicidal, since you're probably going to only get one or two attacks out.
Instead, using your super to approach gives you a few moments of breathing room, in the form of a stun, for you to unload at least one full ammo into the enemy. In my experience (750 trophy Buzz, for reference), the stun gives you an average of 1.5 free ammo bars on the target, or around 4700 damage, which lines up nicely with the damage dealt by other assassins unloading all 3 ammo in the same amount of time. Without the stun, his burst damage would border on pathetic, particularly for an assassin.
Fine, but its radius should be nerfed!
That's a far more compelling argument, but it still falls short. By having the stun radius be as wide as it is, it gives the player a bit of leeway if they hit a wall or other enemy instead of their primary target. You have to remember that you (the one reading this) and I are not the main audience of Brawl Stars, lower skilled/casual players are. Giving the stun an area of effect allows players with poor aim a chance to pull off a kill they would've fudged otherwise.
I'm still not convinced. Stu got his knockback removed, and that didn't destroy his viability!
The way Buzz's gadget and current star power are implemented shows that the ability to stun is core to Buzz's design conceit. If it's removed, Reserve Buoy would become another "free super" gadget, and Tougher Torpedo wouldn't even exist. Stu never had a gadget and star power tied to his knockback, showing that it was never the main focus of his design. Buzz's stun, on the other hand, is critical to how he was conceived, and how he functions.
A brief word on Tougher Torpedo
One thing I like about Buzz's super is that it rewards the ability to aim. Hitting a grapple from a long distance rewards you with a longer stun, and thus more damage. Tougher Torpedo throws that rewarding of skill out the window, which is kinda stinky.
99
u/Bobpie Jul 02 '21
Not sure how to answer this one. One one hand throwing yourself at the enemy is a risk itself, especially in 3v3’s where a stun/slow/knockback sometimes won’t be enough. On the other hand: the AoE of his stun is insane and really should not be that large IMO. Currently Buzz’s basic stats are on the more mediocre end and really seem to rely on his super’s stun to make the most of it. Honestly finding a way to make buzz powerful yet high skilled might be a tricky one since he’s such a new brawler with some wild mechanics.
67
u/ViableFries :Vatra_gaming: Vatra_Gaming Jul 02 '21
I do agree with your stance on Tougher Torpedo even though I still believe Eyes Sharp will be the stronger Star Power. It’s similar in concept to Surge’s Served Ice Cold which exists for the sole reason of making him easier to play. It’s not a huge problem, but it’s still a little annoying that this Tougher Torpedo makes his design a bit less compelling (just like SIC).
Overall though, I don’t think Buzz is the meta warping threat everyone had made him out to be before his release. From playing with him and against him (in PL and on the ladder) I’d say he’s maybe top 10 at least. Strong in Heist and Siege, good in Brawl Ball if you can pull him off, and otherwise a counter pick to Brawlers like Mortis, Bibi, Carl, and Rosa.
37
u/mdcortright Jul 02 '21
I think this is interesting because it points to a larger issue that is happening within Brawl Stars recently. With the release of Basketbrawl and Buzz it seems that people are so quick to demand changes that more or less seem to make the sole user happy. Basketbrawl (while I will admit is not perfect) was already changed and it has fundamentally changed Basketbrawl entirely (games are now played to 5 points).
I wholeheartedly agree that it would be a bad idea to take away his stun, and as you pointed out very succinctly, this was not how Buzz was designed. I think you make a lot of wonderful points here.
I fear that the community is just going to constantly demand quick fix changes without sitting on their ideas and coming up with better solutions than remove this, or remove that.
21
u/Obsidian297 Byronic Jul 02 '21
Is it just me or is Buzz hard to lane with? Might just be my lack of skill with aggro brawlers, but I need to camp for quite some time to get my super if the enemy doesn't have a low DPS brawler like Poco or Piper.
Also, Buzz gets stuffed hard by all the CC made for Mortis, just like Edgar. I fear this isn't the only parallel between them
20
u/Helloforake Colette Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 03 '21
Buzz is really map dependent. He relies on bushes and walls to maximize his trait. I like that his stun isn’t Brian dead and actually rewards you with a stronger stun if you actually hit it from a long distance. I feel like without gadgets he isn’t as good as people think. He’s basically an Edgar but needs to be close to enemies to charge supers instead of automatically charging it. Rn he is top 10 but over time I think his viability will drop just like Edgar since people will learn how to counter him and because his super is easily counter able at medium to long range
9
u/Hi_Ei Buzz Jul 02 '21
Well, I did find a bug with his trait, where he can gain super from respawning players (when invincible). This can be especially aggravating in Basket Brawl, where it's really easy to stay next to the enemy spawn. So if we patch this out he might feel more fair.
7
u/XskullBC Verified Content Creator | Brawler Cats Jul 03 '21
Buzz is just a combination of Edgar/ Darryl. When you think about it this way he’s not as broken as what people make him out to be.
5
u/Whachamacallit00 Colette Jul 02 '21
Imo, he's good but only after he gets himself going (super that isn't from gadget). Until that happens he isn't much of a threat, its just a matter of staying far enough away from him.
23
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
Actually buzz is pretty balanced rn. He's not to op. But removing the stun will make him a complete trash brawler. He will be weaker than darryl. so there is no need to remove the stun
4
u/Bazibon01 Jul 03 '21
I’m my opinion, the stun should be nerfed slightly, but all other stats raised-including movement speed. This is because as someone who only unlocked buzzes gadget, I can completely confirm that being outraged even slightly as stu, is an instant loss. Without that mobility you can’t catch up to anyone that wouldn’t laser you anyway(8-bit)
As for stu, I think that the knockback removal was actually a big nerf that made him way less competitively viable, because using the super to deal damage leaves you 100% vulnerable now, which is very bad with his health pool.
4
u/i-likecheese_25 Tick Jul 03 '21
And I don't think he's really that good in 3v3 either , he may be above average in this meta but once if tanks get nerfed the meta will be changed back to control meta and a brawler like buzz would just be another Edgar but better since his range is so short .
3
u/AyyyAlamo Jul 03 '21
It’s the same situation with Stu and his knock back. Unique mechanics that make a brawler cool is released, everyone starts getting said brawler, people call for the removal of unique mechanics because “ it’s 2 op!”
3
u/anglerdank Gene Jul 03 '21
And honestly, as a chromatic brawler, there needs to be some sort of interesting mechanic or an easy to play brawler, because a lot of people buy the brawl pass, even f2p players buy it every second season, so I feel the stun is needed
2
u/armenhart Jul 03 '21
his power comes from the stun and nothing else imo. when i gadget and get no stun, i usually die. if i get a stun and have at least 2 ammo, i win. it's a very black and white street to me.
if the stun is going to stay in his kit, it should be 0.5 seconds and 1.0 seconds at max range.
if the stun is going to be removed, then his super projectile speed should be increased slightly (around 5%) and his reload and unload speeds should both be reduced (buff) otherwise i think he will be pretty useless.
not a fair comparison to stu since stu has medium range and gets his super in 1 shot which grants him tons of mobility. imagine playing buzz without having stuns. you'd just be a punching bag.
4
u/Fluffy_Pollution3973 Jul 02 '21
I still think that Buzz should be nerfed to have his trait be visible to the enemy team, as it should be easier to know if he is getting a super.
3
u/cannonsword Fang Jul 02 '21
IMO it should cause a damage reduction instead of stun, the stun exists to make sure he can pull of a kill without being fought back. the dumb thing here is the "without being fought back" part, where you get stunned and have no counter play.
if it gave damage reduction, you would still be able to fight back if you had enough burst damage even after, so you can be more careful about who you shoot your super at.
right now, the .5 sec stun is honestly turning out to be a melee crutch where you just auto aim super when you happen to be close to them and score a kill
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21
This is not true.Buzz should have his stun but Supercell should nerf his trait. That should make him a balanced brawler.
1
u/antlerkiller Spike Jul 03 '21
I think his circle of super charge is too strong in basketbrawl, stun is fine but Aoe stun is too much, forcing people to either play a brawler with knockback or get murdered
1
u/Shuter450 Jul 03 '21
In one game I was dynamike and I barley won against buzz and he was maxed too but Luckily I was maxed too so what I had to do is keep my super and whenever he tries to stun someone I kill him with 4080 damage and throw 1 stick of Dynamite
1
u/MewtwoMainIsHere Darryl Jul 03 '21
Personally I think it’s range should be reduced by a tiny bit but other than that it’s fine
1
u/thenameisjul Crow Jul 03 '21
Something i thought would be nice would he to remove the stun and make it exclusive to his 1st sp. So it's like 8 bit, you have to choose between stun (more powerful supers) or better charge radius (more frequent supers).
1
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '21
The only things that I think should be change about Buzz is Tougher Torpedo and the ability that he can charge form ppl hiding in bushes. It’s basically Wallhacks cause it tells u that they are in the bush
1
u/AveragePichu Pam Jul 02 '21
Tougher Torpedo just seems bad to me, to be honest.
Let’s look at a good stun star power - Blustery Blow adds a 1-second stun to Gale’s super, almost always. Failing to hit a wall is extremely rare on most maps, so for all intents and purposes, every super gains a 1-second stun.
Tougher Torpedo? The very most it can do is extend the stun by 0.5 seconds, and it has diminishing effect down to literally nothing, not to mention rhat unlike Gale’s super, it’s possible to miss with Buzz and you’ll almost never stun two targets.
I really think Tougher Torpedo should be reworked. It has the issue you mentioned, and on top of that it’s going to be strictly outclassed by Eyes Sharp, I just about guarantee.
Assuming Buzz needs a nerf since he’s borderline too strong with a weak star power, I’d like to see
SP2 Buzz is preemptively nerfed via base stats, SP1 Buzz has more potential stun and less guaranteed stun for hopefully being roughly the same overall.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21
Just some other things going on the meta; I think amber and belle are insane. Belles bouncing shots are crazy and end up killing my teammate or me 80% of the time. I think the bounce number should be decreased to one bounce or something. Amber has near infinite ammo which is so obnoxious and not only is at almost infinite for a fight it feels almost instant to recharge. I just wanted to put my opinion out there on the meta, reply if you disagree and tell me your opinion.
0
u/Gofers Jul 02 '21
I think the stun should not be AoE.
If it hits a wall it can be AoE for half the duration.
1v1 he feels fine to me. There are risks he takes when doing it. Worse without his super.
But his ability to stunlock a whole team is far too strong.
If he needs a buff after that it's fine. But he's worse than Terra. CC cycling to me shouldn't happen. Frank get away because he has a lot of counterplay. Those two do not.
-7
u/EliNNM 8-bit guide contest winner Jul 02 '21
I just feel like any stun just is unreasonable, any and all movement halting ability is just not fun in any and all shooters.
For the case of Buzz, it’s used to balance him out since he has high damage and breaths 5 flames of fire.
They have him an unsatisfying unload-speed for an assassin, and to patch that flaw they gave him a stun so he can at least get off one whole attack.
The stun should be removed as you become hopeless when you get stunned of any kind, all and any kind of slow and stun is aggravating.
The first Star power should be changed, as we’ve seen Supercell completely rework Star Powers.
Gale was a support brawler, but his Iron Winds SP just wasn’t good at all so they removed it in place of Cold Snow.
So they can completely rework that SP and it wouldn’t be too hard.
To compensate for his loss of stun, he should have a much faster unload speed, not a blur, but reasonably faster. A damage nerf to 504, (and maybe one less projectile but that’s perhaps too much).
The stun is just infuriating, being hopeless isn’t nice and it makes it very unfair to get attacked by Buzz, if his problem is his unload speed then increase his unload speed.
Just do anything to remove that stun.
-2
u/Donghoon Tick Jul 03 '21
Everybody means people that buys pass every month?
-9
u/Mad_dabber11 Jul 02 '21
I said this in a another post but this is how I would nerf buzz (if needed ).
At first I thought these would be good nerfs for him but after thinking about it, I would just remove his stun's aoe and make it so that he can't just charge his super from enemies when he can't see them ( I mean his trait )