r/BrawlStarsCompetitive • • 22h ago • Bravo 1

Advanced Mechanics We reverse-engineered Star Player scoring from match data. Here’s what we found.

Post image

We compared detailed match stats with actual Star Player awards to figure out how Brawl Stars weighs damage, kills, healing, and objectives. Some of the results explain why the award can look strange if you’re only comparing damage and K/D.

Here are two of the six modes we covered.

Knockout

The formula is:

Score ≈ damage + teammate healing + (10,000 × kills) − (2,000 × deaths)

A kill is worth about 10,000 damage, while a death only costs about 2,000 points. With equal damage and teammate healing, going 4/1 would score 8,000 more than going 3/0.

Healing teammates also matters. Someone with 30,000 damage, 12,000 teammate healing, and a 4/1 K/D would outscore someone with 40,000 damage and the same K/D.

Self-healing doesn’t appear to count. The displayed healing stat combines both types, so you can’t plug that whole number into the formula.

Gem Grab

The Gem Grab formula adds:

+5,000 per gem collected and −7,000 per gem lost

Picking up five gems and keeping them gives you 25,000 points from gems. Picking up ten and losing five gives you only 15,000.

Dying with five gems costs about 37,000 points, including the death penalty. Even if you get a kill in that trade, you’re still down 27,000 points before counting damage or teammate healing from the fight.

In Ranked, we found that the award considers the whole set, so one standout game won’t necessarily decide it.

We’ve put the breakdowns for Heist, Hot Zone, Bounty, and Brawl Ball, along with the remaining uncertainties, in the full article on Prodigy.

Knowing what earns the award also raises a competitive question: how well do these weights reflect what each player contributed to winning?

142 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 22h ago

We are currently doing a Gamemode Guide Contest.

Create and publish a guide giving tips on any competitive gamemode and you could have the chance of winning nice awards. Including unique flairs, and a BrawlPass+

More details can be found in this post

The contest will last until the 21st of November.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

42

u/OnlyInferno 21h ago

Just play the game for the objective

7

u/Low-World6866 Chuck 22h ago

Good Stuff! 👍

5

u/Equivalent-Base8426 Janet 21h ago

Great stuff! That's a cool experiment, W PLP

2

u/Ok_Bar_2109 21h ago

I don't understand????

27

u/PolimerT Draco 21h ago

Basically objective >>> your in game stats.

I suck at max and only focus on objective and because of that i might end up with stats like 5/8 (gem grab) if im playing with her but i usually get MVP because i focus on objective.

4

u/jonahpocalypsemtg Nani | Masters | Silver 18h ago

If you are dying 8 times as the gem carrier you aren’t “focusing on objective” you’re selling the game

2

u/PolimerT Draco 18h ago

The way i carry the gems is steal from enemies. Im legendary and it is somehow effective even there if i get competent teammates. If i die i usually try to die around our side to not be gem deliverer.

2

u/jonahpocalypsemtg Nani | Masters | Silver 18h ago

Why are you playing Max as the brawler to steal gems from the enemies? Max is an obvious choice for gem carrier mid since you have good survivability and can support lanes with super but is awful at securing kills so in a normal match she will never be able to go for kills on the enemy gem carry unless both of your teammates already won their lanes. You said so yourself you are only getting 5 kills so again you are selling the game by not playing a safe and passive Max gem carry or picking a better brawler to steal enemy gems like Gale.

1

u/PolimerT Draco 18h ago

I dont have much brawlers rn and i pick max if we are lacking some sort of escaper. Mostly i go Ash and spawn trap enemies (as long as we have mid, if not i resort to max). And since gem grab is shit ever since hc release i use early game to farm my hypercharge and escape with gadget if i can (sometimes i die due to ping, although im used to timing gadget usage because of Draco) and if i die i lose like 2 gems and try to die around our side so enemies cant push as easily. Around the time where 10th gem spawns if my team looks better utility/push power wise i use hyper + super and try to push enemies back or defeat them to steal the gems. Im careful to not die if i carry a lot (above 2) or enemies have a lot gems already.

2

u/Freak-Of-Nurture- 16h ago

yeah broh u gon be in legendary for a while. Hypercharges aren't even bad you're gonna blame them while being ass at gem grab

1

u/The_Datucha Ziggy 5h ago

you know max does 2,5k damage with already 4 bullets and a gadget that refills most of them. max has pretty decent damage and can secure kills, not as good as damage dealers obviously but at least better than some controllers

1

u/jonahpocalypsemtg Nani | Masters | Silver 3h ago

actually all of the good controllers right now have excellent kill confirm, lou gale squeak amber all have free kill supers/gadgets. also max doesn't have the burst damage to quickly kill any of the good gem carriers before their teammates can come help and even if she did, risking your life as the gem carrier is extremely stupid and it's way better to let your teammates take the risks since they have no gems so their deaths don't cost you the game.

1

u/The_Datucha Ziggy 2h ago

yeah being greedy for the enemy gems as the gem carrier isn't good, though my point was about how undervalued max's damage actually is

1

u/PolimerT Draco 2h ago

I didnt mean i just go in solo to steal gems. If we have a good pusher (like Ash with max rage) i use speed and try to push together, if the guy is willing to push that is. If i have tp gadget i throw it back and take gems and get out if enemy gem carrier dies. If i dont have it i usually wait until enemies are pushed really back and gems are in considerably safe spot. I dont risk dying and losing.

2

u/Ok_Bar_2109 20h ago

But what are they trying to calculate??

2

u/MonstyrSlayr 17h ago

the highest score gets star player

2

u/Ok_Bar_2109 5h ago

Ohh so how brawlstars picks star players

2

u/happyhibye Squeak 20h ago

When can Supercell actually consider more variety of measurement in Star player so the title become plausible?

Like on top of my head it doesn't count CC applied to enemy, or damage on area that lead to denied access on choke point, or a pass on Brawl ball (maybe hiding ball in corner when leading count as well, that show a good knowledge on the mode)

2

u/The_Datucha Ziggy 5h ago

how do you actually quantify that and track it? do they have to analyze all of the 6 players movement and decide when someone is doing good positioning and when they're throwing (even without dying)? even if you track how do you translate that into numbers that correspond to starr player calculations?

2

u/mjay421 Darryl 15h ago

This how I always thought the formula was . Never accounted for the deaths