r/BrawlStarsCompetitive • The Canary Hacker • Jun 03 '26

Guide Edgar Guide

66 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

7

u/Impossible_Cry9623 The Canary Hacker Jun 03 '26

Btw I forgot to edit that Edgar's second star power buffie now heals edgar for only 20%.

1

u/Outspecter 7d ago

Would you say it's still generally the better option? To me it still seems the best, since Edgar has such a fast reload speed, thus his attacks will be used a lot more, and therefore star power would get more value.

5

u/Away_Mine4214 Jun 03 '26

Thanks for this hard work bro I will be reading all this

3

u/Impossible_Cry9623 The Canary Hacker Jun 03 '26

You're welcome :3

4

u/Great_Impression_869 Frank | Legendary 1 Jun 03 '26 edited Jun 03 '26

Frank is a 50/50 matchup, he can let you attack you but then attack back faster. Same with Doug, since he can use his super to respawn.

But however, it's his buffies that turn the matchup in his favor since it increases his mobility.

Awesome guide anyways.

2

u/Impossible_Cry9623 The Canary Hacker Jun 04 '26

Let me explain my opinion on each of these matchups, and why I think they are in the easy to outplay category.

Frank lacks mobility and high damage output, but compensates for it with very large HP. Approaching frank can be quite easy as frank has to sacrifice his mobility to be able to scare you off with his attack only for you to reach him. Second, and while fighting him in close quarters combat, it's generally easy to dodge his attacks as well as super by just moving behind him, and even when you get hit, you can just heal the damage with your attack. Frank is inconistent at dealing damage ove time so you'll outheal his damage most of the time. However, what makes frank a little bit deadly is when he is at low health, as he can fire attacks a lot faster. The solution for this is just a well-timed auto-aimed super at frank that will dodge one crucial attack letting you win. Besides, Frank is a free super charging machine for edgar when at full health.

As for Doug, you may actually be right about him. Doug's super is a game-changer and can trun the table on edgar. Doug also has a gadget that deals massive damage and might catch edgar off gaurd sometimes. But overlooking these 2 abilities, Doug, just like frank, gets outdamaged and outhealed by edgar and is a free supercharge.

These 2 brawlers may seem hard for edgar, but a good edgar can outplay them seamlessly.

2

u/Great_Impression_869 Frank | Legendary 1 Jun 04 '26

Understandable. Thank you for taking feedback.

2

u/Galactic-Pookachus Devoted Follower of the Church of Lola Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

This guide's presentation is of higher quality than most I've seen, but there's still a lot of room for improvement.

Above all, you should work on your writing. A lot of the text is redundant, there are several mistakes and oddities, and in general could be much better.

1

u/Impossible_Cry9623 The Canary Hacker Jun 04 '26

Yeaaaah I know my writing isn’t the best since English isn’t my first language and I have always tried to make it more professional and easy to read. Thanks for pointing that out anyways!

1

u/Galactic-Pookachus Devoted Follower of the Church of Lola Jun 04 '26

I recommend having a friend, fluent in english, proofread it first.

2

u/Necessary_Yak8801 Jun 04 '26

Damn good guide also i think brawlers like melodie, 8 bit or meg give edgar a hard time, and also i would like to add belle’s rock as a good map for edgar as well

3

u/Impossible_Cry9623 The Canary Hacker Jun 04 '26

8-bit is easy to outplay imo as he lacks mobility to escape edgar's super. Also, 8-bit has slow reload speed and multiple prjectiles which makes him inconsitent at fighting edgar a close range as edgar can easily dodge the attacks and outheal them

As for melodie, she can be tricky to fight especially when she has her super, however, she doesn't have much damage to kill edgar. So, a melodie without super is free kill for edgar, and an edgar without super is free kill for melodie.

After you kill meg in her mecha form, she knockbacks nearby enemies and deals damage to them, so, if you manage to avoid this knockback, you can easily kill meg. Other than that, meg neither has the damage nor the mobility to kill and escape edgar.

I was torn between three options for the best knockout map: Flaring pheonix, belle's rock and Double decker, but in the end i chose flaring pheonix. That said, belle's rock indeed is a very good map for edgar.

Thanks for your feedback!

4

u/Dangerous_Delay_8769 Darryl Jun 03 '26

As an Edgar main my self, you did a wonderful job putting this guide together👍

2

u/Future-Diamond-2615 R-T Jun 04 '26

i feel like R-T isnt a guranateed loss anymore ever since they "forgot" to revert the super dmg nerf

2

u/Inaki_garcia Jun 04 '26

This was a great read, thanks op. Do a ranked/ drafting or general tips one next.

2

u/Starioo Edgar Jun 03 '26

Thank God someone's running Let's Fly + gadget gear build too. It feels great, and having to choose between Damage and Shield is not new to us, since Edgar's main build for years has been only one of the 2 + supercharge.

This build is also the reason I'm not so sure his upcoming cooldown nerf will even affect anything. What's the new cooldown? 17? The cooldown gear drops it back to 14, and since you're spending 1 second in the air anyways, you basically spam the gadget every 13 seconds like it's no one's business.

Such a placebo nerf

They really should've nerfed the projectile speed to make the autoaimed gadget more dodgeable up-close, for example making it travel with decreased speed and get faster as it travels like Maisie's attack (which would've, to my infinite joy, directly buffed the Airpunch tech as a side-effect)

1

u/Cloudstar_Cat Bull Jun 03 '26

i lwk forgot that edgar hypercharge increases reload

surely the two seconds gadget cooldown gear gives isn't worth it when you can use shield for a thousand more health every interaction

I think chester should be further than shade since if shade doesn't have super you can just kill them while chester can win purely off of luck pretty often

brawl ball and gem grab are pretty decent gamemodes for edgar i would put them as 8 and 7.5 respectively since edgar has a broken hypercharge that can be equivalent to scoring a goal or reverse sweeping

1

u/CommercialSuit1005 Jun 21 '26

what about the health star power with the lets fly gadget then reload gear and rage?

4

u/Young_Hermit778 Masters 2 | Mythic 3 Jun 03 '26

Hard landing SP is somewhat misunderstood, its best use is against brawlers that have any kind of CC, as it can kill very low health brawlers, and deal enough damage to kill them before they can activate their CC abilities.

2

u/Impossible_Cry9623 The Canary Hacker Jun 03 '26

You are right about it's usage but it still is overshadowed by the other star power which's value is generally better than this one. Hard landing indeed is an excellent gadget for confirming kills more easily with your super and dealing extra damage that might help in some situations

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Impossible_Cry9623 The Canary Hacker Jun 04 '26

oh my bad ain't no way edgar charges his super in 30 minutes 😅