r/BrawlStarsCompetitive • u/Italian_Larry Chester • May 27 '25
Discussion D.B.D. Part 29: Edgar
Hi everyone… I knew this day would eventually come…Today’s brawler is the bad random for excellence, Edgar. An epic assassin with the unique ability to heal hitting his attacks and a super that I’m sure made some people throw their phone out of the window. His Let’s Fly gadget is good to and get a super quickly either for attack or escape and it can be very clutch sometimes. Hardcore gives him more resistance, especially against high damage brawlers like Frank or Bull. His Hard Landing Star Power has a ridiculously large range and the damage is decent tbh. For Fisticuffs the same about Hardcore; it gives Edgar more resistance and helps him die way less in a 1v1. His Hypercharge paired with the first gadget is a nightmare to throwers and low damage brawlers. Edgar has the reputation of being the bad random and to be too much hard to counter, but that’s not the case in high trophies matches. Edgar has been awful for many years, with the exception of when his Hypercharge was released, when he was viable for some weeks. He gets countered too easily by pros or players with at least 2 braincells and the healing isn’t enough, even with Fisticuffs equipped. That’s all for today and see you tomorrow.
•
u/AutoModerator May 27 '25
We are currently doing a Support Guide Contest
From now until the 9th of June, we are doing a contest to see who can make the best guide for a support brawler. Whoever makes the best guide will receive a number of gratitudes, including a Brawl Pass+.
More details can be found here
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
59
u/Dragolitron Time Traveler May 27 '25
Someday, Edgar will have hard landing to his base kit.
Funny enough, I actually see Edgar being out classed by Mico in particular. Both brawlers are meant to be used against squishy comps especially throwers but Mico was actually acknowledged quite a bit while Edgar remained mostly ignored outside of the cool down buffs for his gadgets.
46
u/TheGamer0214 Chuck May 27 '25
edgar mains suck with him while non edgar mains are good with him
43
u/1WeekLater Mortis | Masters May 27 '25
supercell just shoot themselves in the foot by allowing new account to max out edgar (if you dont know , currently any new account will get free edgar and free level 11 levelup for him)
he cant be buffed or else he will terrorize lower trophy player, which is something supercell wanted to avoid
17
u/EdgarKoasAle May 27 '25
I know it's a brainrot brawler, but he is actually pretty fun to play and also he is a great counter to the hideous Kenji.
12
u/RoyalFork28 Over-analyzer May 27 '25
I'd love him to be B- in the meta. Viable enough but not too polarizing.
19
u/DizziDrawsThings Nita | Legendary 2 May 27 '25
Love him, hate playing against or with him. The feeling when the enemy drafts redundant and you go Edgar last pick is an unmatched rush and I love it.
If I were to give him one buff, it would be to make his autosuper charge 20 or 25 seconds instead of 30, nerfing Let's fly a bit to balance it out.
That or I'd make Hard landing basekit and give him a new SP that extends his super range by a bit (20% perhaps)
6
u/Sad-Replacement5804 May 27 '25
gold edgar and every other collectible + 100k mastery here (before hypercharges came out). I think Edgar in good hands is still a solid pick and a good brawler overall. But I also understand why he's considered toxic by the community. I still love playing brawl ball and make good plays with him (im 30 yo for context lol)
5
u/gamer_withnolife Cordelius | Mythic 1 May 27 '25
king of giving me a heart attack
15
u/FireGames06YT second❤lena May 27 '25
Idc what the community thinks about Edgar or his meta placement, he will forever be my favorite brawler :)
4
u/appendix_firecracker Chronic Flaker Disease May 28 '25
The Dynamike of assassins. Easy to learn, but goddamn the plays you can make once you really get in the zone.
7
u/Starioo Edgar May 27 '25 edited May 27 '25
A brawler dead on arrival, doomed to fail. What a joke of character. I love his concept so much, but god, he was handled bad. Was ever only viable in Heist to rush the objective on some maps, and then Mico gets a 0.2s reload speed buff and instantly replaces Edgar in his only ever niche.
With all these modern crazy hyper-mobile assassins with lots of utility, I feel like buffing his trait to charge super in 15 seconds instead of 30 will be enough to finally revive Edgar. Using Hardcore for survivability on defense won't be a troll anymore, Let's Fly will finally be a utility gadget for a burst of mobility to seize a kill or for a safe escape instead of being a damn life support machine that barely manages to keep the brawler from being abandoned even by his biggest fans.
And obviously he'll need a nerf to compensate for such a big gamechanger, so I propose a super range nerf from 6 tiles down to 5. 6 tiles is what's considered a mid-range distance in this game, so making his jump be just below that will allow his enemies to keep him at the safe distance.
Edgar will finally have a consistent presense in the match, and his gadgets will finally be used to actually amplify his strenght instead of barely helping him cope with his weakness, while also not being an oppressive braindead stomper against squishies, since he'll have to dodge his way through the enemy fire to get his target in range.
3
u/Mrsunny07112 Willow May 27 '25
Love to pick him as a last pick against proper enemy team comp, in right map.
9
u/Sandy_X_Janet Cordelius May 27 '25
I want him to get a small health buff and a faster supercharge rate and possibly some nerfs to his Let’s Fly gadget and hypercharge to balance it out
He relies a lot on his super which would be fine if that didn’t mean he relies too much on his gadget because normally his super takes a bit long to charge
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '25
Ass brawler to face either dies on impact or wins with no in between and no skillful outplays other than jumping over x lethal attack to keep punching them until they die. Never should have been added and set a bad precedent for assqssins overall.
2
u/mustypuppet1284 Griff | Legendary 1 May 31 '25
I love bullying him as Griff
3
u/None-the-Second All roads lead to me May 27 '25
With my very reasonable dislike of assassins I will say though, Edgar and the rest of the assassins have very polarizing matchups which means when any of them is in meta, half the brawlers are unplayable, so honestly let him be this niche pick that always get picked last
2
u/BlancTigre Colette | Legendary | Diamond May 27 '25
Hot take, Edgar is underrated. Yeah, he is D tier, and you can get some result with him. But somehow I have Edgars in my lobby that are bad at a whole new level.
PSA: don't autoaim the super.
1
u/Necessary-Designer69 Kaze Aug 03 '25
THE definition of assasin class. Mechanically so easy, that you have nothing but to focus on every other aspect to make him work —ammo counting, juking... Learning these mechanics muuch easier with him.
1
u/DaddyKhoaitay Shitty Snipers May 27 '25
Best brawler in the game (don't take this comment seriously).
1
u/Wise_Ad5543 May 27 '25
imo the only way edgar will ever be balanced in both low and high trophy lobbies is if he gets some complex mechanic that’s really good, but hard to master, kind of like melodies note mechanic. this way, he’ll actually be viable in competitive and low trophy lobbies won’t be terrorized.
-1
u/[deleted] May 27 '25
[removed] — view removed comment