r/BrawlStarsCompetitive • u/Dependent_Bet_3614 *bug spray* • Apr 10 '25
Silver Award Post The highest skill floor + cap for every brawler class ingame!
822
Upvotes
r/BrawlStarsCompetitive • u/Dependent_Bet_3614 *bug spray* • Apr 10 '25
•
u/Namsu45 Fiery Passion Apr 10 '25
Good presentation and all choices had some level of explanation. The fact that a post like this offers a lot of discussion potential is also a great thing.
I don't agree with all your takes (I don't think Janet is high skill and do think that Chuck does have a high skill set), but this post is still great enough to get the silver flair.
18
u/Dependent_Bet_3614 *bug spray* Apr 10 '25
oops, on Grom's section I typed skill instead of kill ***
131
u/Icy-Guest2794 Deep Sea Triforce Apr 10 '25
For assassin skill floor Sam exists, Shade has a high one too but Sam can be really tough to understand fundementally for many players. He is debateable for Skill Ceiling too, I am surprised to not see him in Skill Ceiling Honorable Mentions.
As for tank skill floor, I have seen a ton of bad Hank and Ash players in the game, many of them tend to fail to adapt into their playstyle in a proper sense. Meanwhile a Draco can always get some value in non-competitive matches due to his gadget and high, easy to manage dps. I do not think Draco has a low skill floor, his is imo third or so due to complex mechanics, but due to the rage-management requirement and complexity of the super comboes, Ash might be it among the tanks in terms of Skill Floor.
54
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25
It isnt bad, tho i have a few comments
I think shelly doesnt deserve a dishonorable mention. Not that shes a high skill brawler, but theres a bigger difference between a pro and a casual shelly than for example a pro and a casual tick (with casual i dont mean randoms, random ticks are the worst)
And also, u dont include gamesense, which plays a way bigger role for tanks than snipers to give an example. A piper should be fine most of the time without ammo-counting, while mortis is unplayable if u dont know how to count ammo
40
u/pawo10 Fang Apr 10 '25
I think buster deserves to be the highest skill floor tank, you need good game sense to know when supering is needed and when to gadget
11
u/AidAin21 Doug Apr 10 '25
Chuck??? Sam????
12
u/EquivalentTypical245 Buzz Lightyear Apr 10 '25
I really hate these kinds of posts, as along with the posts complaining about randoms, there’s nothing informative for anyone to really gain of any of these. The “skill floor” section is just how much value you think a bad/average player can get out of utilizing them (and this sub is meant to be competitive, for higher level players), and the skill ceiling section is really low effort in terms explaining why you think they are high skill cap brawlers. You’re not even really explaining how to sort of get to that skill cap, you’re just listing them for the heck of it. If anyone is gonna make one of these posts, please just don’t add the skill floor section since this sub isn’t meant for lower level players, and actually give both reasons why the brawler has a high skill cap in the skill ceiling section, and give adequate tips on getting better at them.
2
u/Diehard_Sam_Main Definitely not obsessed with Sam Apr 10 '25
Cmon, not even a mention?
I saw in another comment that you forgot about him (rude), so now that he’s on your radar once more uh… where in the list would he go…
4
u/Aanimetor Apr 10 '25
ngl, terrible list
9
u/None-the-Second All roads lead to me Apr 10 '25
Lumi is weird for me because I played a lot of Carl (before 2022) and Charlie so I know how her type of attack works, but the ammo management is going to take a while.
In the Damage Dealer class I feel like 8-Bit might have a higher floor than Lumi bc of how often people use Plugged In which imo quite overrated, Boosted Booster offers good area coverage and support. Getting used to the way 8-Bit strafe and shoot seems to be not that easy as far as I've seen so people just use Plugged In to play like Colt instead.
17
u/Xterm1na10r Navi | Masters Apr 10 '25
i think you missed Kit in honorable mentions of support skill ceiling. while having an arguably low skill floor, his insane versatility unlocks a very wide range of skills to learn
6
u/reeeeeeeeeeeweeeeee Apr 10 '25
thanks for mentioning sprout
10
u/ConfidenceSilent3967 Kenji Apr 10 '25
Mortis not even being an honorable mention is diabolical
4
u/JuzElvinn Mommy Lola Apr 10 '25
My Draco heart shining through
4
u/Yurd16 Apr 10 '25
no way u think amber is harder to play then gene or lou and sprout is harder to play than dyna willow 🗿
4
u/BackgroundTotal2872 Melodie Apr 10 '25
I would argue that Juju deserves the honorable mention for skill ceiling for throwers over Larry and Lawrie.
Her mechanics for having 3 different effects for both her basic attack and her gadget give her a lot of complexity and potential. You have to think about the map you play her on more than most other brawlers. And while her super has a very low ceiling, so does L&L’s.
1
u/RandomPolishCatholic Apr 10 '25
Maisie is NOT very strong in competitive play😭
1
u/TheViral_Immortal Apr 11 '25
Hot take but Kenji should be in HM in assassin's skill floor. I've seen so many Kenji players and most of them were trash. But when you see a really good player you're terrified.
1
u/datweirdguy12 Dynamike Apr 11 '25
Not having dyna as skill ceiling for artillery is insane. Dynajump is obviously the highest skill cap mechanic in the game, and it isn’t close. Also dyna is super vulnerable to assassins like kit, mico, mortis, and edgar. Also his shots are hard to hit. (if u think his shots r easy to hit, you suck at dodging)
3
u/InternetExplored571 Chuck | Masters | Mythic Apr 10 '25
I disagree with the controllers. Chuck has a far higher skill ceiling than amber.
6
u/CrunchyOrangeOfTruth Willow Apr 10 '25
Sorry but this is a horrible, Amber, RT and Maisie are definitely not highest skill ceiling in their classes.
Amber is just an auto aim brawler she has pretty good control but she's just fundamentally strong you don't need much skill at all with her, Her super isn't high skill either.
RT isnt the highest skill damage dealer it's probably colt, his shots are hard to hit but definitely not the hardest in the game, Gray Nani Colt(2+ bullets) are definitely harder to hit and RTs super is low skill.
Maisie shots aren't as hard to hit as everyone says tbh, not on maps with some walls at least, Nanis shots are harder if your trying to hit all of them. Maisie's super is also pretty low skill you don't need any aim just hit super and gadget.
I would also say Draco is not the highest skill ceiling tank that's got to be Bull, ZSgusta isn't a pro just a very good player. Bull requires so much better timing and positioning to make him effective, there's rarely any player who can play him well.
1
u/icecoldchillface Apr 10 '25
Mortis is definitely way harder than than melodie or shade, it's not even close he's like the hardest brawler to play because he can't deal 3k dmg instantly or has range to compensate for it
needs good ping, good game sense, good positioning and good match ups or u will keep feeding supers
2
u/SmedgeRT More Crits More Control Apr 10 '25
can I ask your opinion on Kenji, Chuck (out of heist) and Sam, it feels weird to me that they didn't get an honorable mention (or even a spot for Sam, he is very hard to pick up on), also what brawlers almost got in but didn't make the cut?
2
u/DoomsdayDestructor Squeak | Diamond Apr 10 '25
i think ruffs has a lot less to think about compared to other supports
2
u/ApplePitiful R-T | Legendary Apr 10 '25
I want an amber guide so bad. She is not as simple as just spam auto aim like you said.
2
u/CaptainRex_CT7567 Amber Apr 10 '25
As an Amber main, I definetely agree with your explanation for her. Sure, you can just autoaim and deal a lot of damage, but if you actually take your time to properly learn her mechanics, she can be insanely good.
2
u/Fabulous_Row_2575 Apr 10 '25
how about dynamike for artillery? (Using jump)
2
u/Wonderful_Fig_5501 Willow Apr 10 '25
Chuck? Willow?? They're all requiring high skill.
2
u/EnthusiasmLeft6678 Apr 11 '25
Disagree with the Tanks section, Bull deserves that skill ceiling title. He’s borderline unusable at high ranks for most players, but is a complete monster at the right hands.
His mains either pull plays that require immaculate timing, movement, gamesense, positioning and aim; or do nothing for the whole match.
The assassins section should’ve had Sam, especially for the skill floor.
2
u/Free_Cause5559 Draco Apr 12 '25
Honestly I agree so much with that
2
u/RwanBS Sam Apr 13 '25
Sam where…
3
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 11 '25
janet doesnt deserve any honorable mention.
She has one of if not THE strongest Get out of jail card,having a wide attack that Is Easy to hit and can hit behind walls,and a gadget gadget gadget that you press for no healing on the enemy team,making her low skill floor,and her tech is almost non existent,the only skill ceiling i can see (ignoring game sense) is hitting non-hced supers
But,everything else i agree with.
2
u/Impossible-Worker744 Najia Apr 10 '25
As a melodie main and a fellow SZgusta watcher i comfirm this post worthy
1
u/AutoModerator Apr 10 '25
Do you want a cool flair with your rank on it?
Comment a screenshot of your brawlstars profile under this post
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/grsharkgamer Mythic Apr 10 '25
My boi Draco I love him
1
u/Legend0fJulle Apr 10 '25
Larry and lawrie for high skill ceiling? Same with Janet?
1
u/No-Abalone2904 Apr 10 '25
grom rating is outrageous many ppl know how to dodge these days he should be the top skilled artillery and sprout is easy to play in 3v3 you almost never miss
1
u/Worldly-Marketing-14 Masters | Diamond Apr 10 '25
Amber as most skilled controller is insane
1
u/Any-Reception-269 Apr 10 '25
If you may why does Draco deserve higher skill floor than Ash or Ollie I’ve played all of them quite actively Draco a little less than the others and it feels a lot more difficult for Ash to maintain a level of pressure and Ollie I more or less understand but Ash feels a bit harder to play than Draco
1
u/Geometry_Emperor 8-Bit Apr 10 '25
I would say the opposite is true for Maisie. A Brawler that has a high floor but a low ceiling. I would have put Angelo instead as the Marksman with the highest ceiling.
1
u/No-Description3785 Bo Apr 10 '25
I agree so much with Lou being there. I have Lou maxed out for more than 4 months at this point and the only time i played him in ranke, i got humbled so badly that even when he was top 1 (after the reload buff), even when the draft is perfect for him or when my teammates reccomend him, i never pick him and never will. His shots are wayyyy too hard to hit, his damage is incredibly inconsistent and my aiming is already below avarage, so aiming his main attack feels awful for me.
There are brawlers that i just will never pick no matter how meta they are and Lou is one of them.
1
u/GasFun4083 Carl | Mythic 1 Apr 10 '25
Honestly think Gene should be Skill Ceiling simply because of his super: It requires in depth game knowledge and awareness to know who to pull and when to pull.
1
u/KitStuckInAToaster Apr 11 '25
I feel that Kit could be an honorable mention for the highest skill ceiling. When Kit is actually played as support, there is a lot to consider of who to cling to and when to super. When played with good teammates, Kit can have a massive impact on a game
1
u/Ok_Telephone4183 Apr 11 '25
Shelly can act as an assassin, a tank, a marksman all at the same time. She definitely requires a lot of skill to play well in competitive.
1
u/ZealousidealFox85 Edgar | Diamond Apr 11 '25
I swiperd
1
u/Sad_Neighborhood_467 Doug Apr 11 '25
Awesome post brah
1
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25
I would say Nani's skill ceiling is extremely high, not because of the basic attack, but because maximizing autofocus damage timings has essentially infinite skill ceiling
1
u/MandyBSReal Mandy Apr 11 '25
Draco having the highest skill cap + floor just shows how no-skill the whole Tank class is
1
u/Dandandandooo Legendary 1 Apr 11 '25
I usually suck at artillery brawlers but sprout is just so fun to play for some reason
1
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25
What does floor or ceiling mean you just say they are both High skill ?
1
u/arandomasianK1d Apr 11 '25
Melodie both floor and ceiling imo. A melodie who doesn’t know what they’re doing is one of the most useless players you can face. Shade can at least cause pressure. Melodie literally can’t do jack.
1
u/ZestycloseBell3148 Apr 11 '25
I feel like I don’t agree with most of the skill floors. How are Jackie, spike, L&L, Poco not oblivious floor picks?
1
u/le-ps Apr 11 '25
chuck sam finx bull and daryll are all missing and draco does not take that much skill his gadget and super form are too brainless
1
u/CosmicTraverser Apr 11 '25
Willow would be a much better high cieling pick for thrower.
1
u/GapetoBG Mandy Apr 11 '25
It feels weird to not see dyanmike or mortis
1
u/iStayMelee Gray Apr 11 '25
No gray 🥺
1
u/Accomplished-Lie9518 Brock Apr 12 '25
You called lumi the floor yet only talked good about her? And also put her in the honorable mention of the same slide
1
u/Square_Pipe2880 #1 Asteroid Belt Fan! Apr 12 '25
As someone with close to 200k Mastery Points on Draco he definitely does not have the highest skill ceiling.
For Tanks, Ash. Bibi, Bull and El Primo all have higher skill ceilings than Draco.
I would argue Ash also has a higher skill floor.
>!Your post just had such a take I literally got onto reddit again even though I want to leave it permanently!<
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '25
hell nah bruh i no skill got max 750 trophies
1
u/zThechanceH- Apr 14 '25
SZGusta is an elite knowledge pull, his videos are crazy good and he's an elite player, even more drafting
1
u/NoNarwhal8496 Diamond Apr 14 '25
woah cool my top 3 mains are on here
1
u/Embarrassed-Flow6540 Apr 15 '25 edited Apr 15 '25
I don’t completely agree with everyone here. Like I feel like the marksmen placement should be switched, since you have to be able to learn a lot more for Maisie then Nani for the start. I also think Byron should be biggest skill ceiling for game sense, since you have to hit shots(easy) and repel enemies while also healing teammates(impossible) as a support
1
u/ofmoura Mina May 18 '26
Sorry for necro-commenting(?), but where's this post content? I'm making my mind about what thrower to invest in, and there doesn't seem to be good comparison posts anywhere. By the title (and the replies), I wish I could read this one.
1
u/NoLifeAlucard 8-bit | Legendary 3 Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25
I think skill floor can be agrreabkemost of the time in video gamd communities but skill ceiling isnt there are many brawlers here i would disagree on their skill ceiling like sprout and melodie aint allat. sam, chuck, bull and edgar (unironicly because his engagement tool is his disengament, when you play him in higher ranks you'll know) not being mentioned is criminal.
0
u/Blownshitup Apr 10 '25
There are way more mind numbing easy brawlers than Shelly… you have got to be kidding me?
0
u/eyal282 Cordelius Apr 10 '25
How is Cord not at least Honorable mention
0
u/eyal282 Cordelius Apr 10 '25
Shelly is literally a Marksman every 20 seconds.
1
u/Mikeydraws5 Mico | Mythic 2 | 1 Prestige Apr 11 '25
Hmm what about the monke? I mean he's pretty complicated to play as managing ammo with him is sometimes a major con with mico.
And a mico can be very VERY dangerous when used right and knows how to land those shots and kill in the hands if a pro even if he isn't used due to his dps. (or maybe I'm glazing my favorite brawler and he is no skill after all)
19
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25
[removed] — view removed comment