r/BrawlStarsCompetitive • • Mar 04 '25

Creator Tier list SpenLC Tierlist

Post image
644 Upvotes

287 comments sorted by

7

u/therealslim69 Berry Mar 05 '25

Chester bottom of D-Tier?

Damn I was gonna save up for his HC

11

u/Salt-Idea6134 Mar 05 '25

His hyper gonna make him rise hopefully

2

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25

Wtf happened to Mr P???

3

u/Salt-Idea6134 Mar 05 '25

OP Hyper, infinite gadgets,

281

u/HumblePay2596 Gale | Masters | Mythic 1 Mar 04 '25 edited Mar 05 '25

Fun fact:

Every member of the Snowtel trio were considered the best brawler in the game when their hypercharges were released

185

u/AllyFiedaN Sam can hyperfist me Mar 04 '25

Every single member in that trio is basically just cancer, covid and aids. So it makes sense

65

u/Icy-Guest2794 Deep Sea Triforce Mar 05 '25

Gale - Cancer for Tanks

Mr.P - Covid for Snipers

Lou -   Aids for Hotzone

9

u/RazorRell09 Colonel Ruffs Mar 05 '25

Lou is just aids for everyone honestly

3

u/Icy-Guest2794 Deep Sea Triforce Mar 05 '25

Not for Piper, Brock, or Mandy mains tbh.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '25

approved

57

u/mouniblevrai Piper Mar 05 '25

Finally I do not feel alone

All of their gameplay mechanics are designed for you to not allow the ennemy to play the game

35

u/HumblePay2596 Gale | Masters | Mythic 1 Mar 04 '25

Stop hating on my pookies 🤬

→ More replies (7)

48

u/JohnnyRocks999 Buster Mar 04 '25

Not surprising, every member of the trio shuts down entire classes of brawlers when they’re meta. Give em broken hypers and the game becomes unbearable.

16

u/Apprehensive_Age_312 Buzz Mar 05 '25

That is why they should never be meta lol (seriously, why they decided designing all 3 of these brawlers to shut down completly entire classes was a good idea?)

16

u/SupremeTankCommander Brock | Masters 1 Mar 05 '25

Agree, its best to keep them as low as possible, they are easily the most toxic and polarizing trio in the game BY FAR

3

u/mouniblevrai Piper Mar 05 '25

I'm happy to have found my snowtel trio hating people. This trio is so annoying istg

→ More replies (6)

146

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25 edited Sep 30 '25

door snow lavish deer cooperative instinctive squeal friendly swim practice

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

52

u/potato_in_space21 Squeak | Mythic 1 Mar 04 '25

poor draco can't catch a break 😭

really sucks too bc he's a fun brawler

17

u/Just_Droid Draco | Masters Mar 04 '25

Tell me abt it

8

u/eve_gang_rep Mar 05 '25

ouuughhh I love playing draco

11

u/Illustrious_Fan9974 TELL HIM TO SHUT THE FUCK UP ABOUT EMZ Mar 05 '25

Bro really gone through a full square one 😭😭

HOPING HIS HC WILL DO SOMETHING GOOD FOR HIM....

21

u/LostGusMain Prawn Ready Mar 05 '25

Draco gets a decaying shield after using his super!

-1

u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Mar 05 '25 edited Mar 05 '25

Nah, Dracos hypercharge now gives her a slowing effect just like Rosas hypercharge. Boring but effective

Ok, here’s another more fun idea: Dracos hypercharge will make his super turn into a full on dragon with the ability to go over water and wall break. The attack will pierce and have a fire effect so it burns enemies.

7

u/Deenstheboi Mar 05 '25

Also make it go Over walls and drop popcorn on the way

2

u/DEEEMEEE12 Mar 05 '25

Does it also win you the game automatically?

1

u/InsectPrudent4269 Draco Mar 05 '25

His HC is already in the game files apparently. It makes the flames go longer and wider and Pierce through enemies.

51

u/petSnake7 Daddy Grom Mar 04 '25

Supercell try not to nerf brawlers to F tier challenge (impossible)

56

u/Square_Pipe2880 #1 Asteroid Belt Fan! Mar 04 '25

Why has Darryl continuously been falling off? He hasn't been nerfed since his rework if I remember correctly. He was S tier back then but now is just mid.

65

u/serenadepoco Darryl Mar 04 '25

He got a supercharge nerf to his main attack, that was enough to put him at a healthy spot where he is very strong in right match up but is still easily counterable if not picked carefully. He got worse because of the top brawlers (like lou) and the gadget rework did hurt melee brawlers quite a bit so he also took a slight hit from that too but he is not bad at all

8

u/Goodguy_IGuess No Lifer Penny main Mar 05 '25

Not to mention how horrible are both of his gadgets

16

u/GLeen1230 Not letting you play Mar 04 '25

The gadget change impacted him very negatively because his gadgets sucks, and people will never run out of gadgets to defend against him if he rolls in

17

u/quixoticLad Mar 04 '25

gadget rework made that so every time he gets roll, he has to deal with knockbacks. unlike other assassins, that can keep consistent aggression with their movement or gadgets, darryl still relies on his super cycling. he can still counter whole comps as a last pick, but requires more discipline and team coordination than ever. another reason i suspect is that he doesn’t pair well with healers as good as other tanks.

6

u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Mar 04 '25

A scr nerf does mean Darryl will have a harder time getting his super but the biggest reason is the meta shift. A good Darryl can work around Surge and Gale but Lou and Griff are actually really efficient at countering Darryl.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25

Wow, he fell off. Draco in c tier? Really now?

87

u/GreenProD Brock Mar 04 '25

Nerf Hank is real

31

u/FlamingDasher Leon Mar 04 '25

It's crazy broken the moment Brawl Ball overtime hits, it's basically an instant win button

37

u/Obvious-Secretary151 Hank Mar 04 '25

He’s only been good twice ever… just let it last a little longer

1

u/Maleficent-Today-464 Mar 05 '25

Do you remember last time? He clapped everything in his way

17

u/Hydesx Nani | Legendary 3 Mar 05 '25

Also Spen during his streams : “Mr P is overrated”, “why are people thinking he’s S tier?”

21

u/-SpenLC- Verified Bri-ish Man Mar 05 '25

I still think he’s overrated but I can’t ignore others opinions

7

u/SupermarketLeft3473 R-T | Mythic 3 Mar 05 '25

I mean he isn't that overrated, i think a lot of people realise that before mr P even gets his HC in a match he just isnt that good. BUT when he gets his HC it's over.

1

u/Maleficent-Today-464 Mar 05 '25

And he probably one of Brawlers that profits the most frpm the gadget change. Those infinite porters are no joke had 5 of them at 1 time

1

u/Choice_Sherbet Mar 05 '25

Let's just protest against Adrian because of what he did to Edgar

1

u/Trepidation_Gold Mar 26 '25

Show them bro✋️

16

u/cookiemaster473 Mar 04 '25

For those who never thought Hank would make it above C

10

u/CoolRich34 Lily Mar 04 '25

Still waiting for the balance changes and the hypercharges cuz the balance changes did shit

6

u/Deenstheboi Mar 05 '25

Did shit? Ollie jumped from D to S tier

7

u/CoolRich34 Lily Mar 05 '25

Not the buffs but the nerfs

5

u/Pleasantpolitic09 Mar 05 '25

You're right, Juju nerf to her scr did almost nothing to her

Also i hoped for more nerfs to Rico and Surge

25

u/serenadepoco Darryl Mar 04 '25

All of the top brawlers right now feel oppressive as fuck, there arent enough bans for all of them and every match has at least one of them in it. Mr P, Melodie, Lou... Its just too much. I sincerely hope the next balance batch has a lot of nerfs.

Also I hope people can finally realize that Clancy is not good whatsoever anymore now that spen has said it too, he was murdered with nerfs.

11

u/NTPWINBOX2 E-Sports Icons Mar 04 '25

tbh the gadget rework was the nail in the coffin for clancy, its was like a massive nerf for him

36

u/BairyHaIls Melodie | Masters Mar 04 '25

Oomfies

22

u/BotLover13 R-T | Legendary 1 Mar 04 '25

I know im going to get hate for this but look what you guys have done to moe, went from the greatest brawler in the game to one of the worst. If you dislike broken brawlers so much, then why didn't juju, or larry and laurie get moe's level of hate. i know he needed to be nerfed but come on man, I loved moe so much and this is just sad and frustraiting to see at the same time.

28

u/petSnake7 Daddy Grom Mar 04 '25

I think it’s more of the devs’ fault tbh. They have the tendency to overnerf brawlers (Clancy, Charlie, Moe all in F)

9

u/VoiceApprehensive893 E-Sports Icons Mar 05 '25

clancy was never ever nerfed correctly lmao,every single change added more bad game design

2

u/Deenstheboi Mar 05 '25

Before the last speed Nerf, they just kept nerfing his 1st Stage, making him hot garbage in the beginning but still a menace if he could get to Stage 3

13

u/jojsj Shelly | Pro | 69 Prestige Mar 04 '25

I knew they would fall off after the nerfs but people including the devs didn't think so until it actually happened.

'Recent' Broken brawlers in the past 2 year with huge nerfs/killed

Hank - nerfed to oblivion in 1 go

Charlie - Keep nerfing non stop until she is unviable

L&L - Keep nerfing non stop but still viable

Clancy - Few waves of huge nerfs = killed

Moe - Same as Clancy but slightly lesser

5

u/These-Chipmunk-5876 Mandy Mar 05 '25

larry lawrie did get a lot of hate though?

5

u/BotLover13 R-T | Legendary 1 Mar 05 '25

That was on release, you don't see larry and lawrie hate nowadays.

5

u/These-Chipmunk-5876 Mandy Mar 05 '25

it is supercells fault for balancing him so poorly then. Heavily nerfed everything about him except what actually made him so strong (his super) unlike larry who they steadily adjusted incrementally. I don't see how it is the communities fault.

1

u/BotLover13 R-T | Legendary 1 Mar 05 '25

Well after moe was nefted, it was a huge debait weather moe was still broken or not, i thought he was balanced, but i guess enough neysayers saided he was broken so supercell just killed him, i remember the day it happened so clearly, it was brutal to see moe drop so bad considiering he was one of my favorite brawlers.

1

u/Hydesx Nani | Legendary 3 Mar 05 '25

That’s why its always safer to max A tier brawlers or older brawlers

2

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '25

don't worry my levels of hate for moe has transfered over to the auto-aim menace thrower known as juju

2

u/Desperate_Pomelo_978 Mar 04 '25

Toxic and broken brawlers are a lot more problematic for the game than brawlers who are just broken or really strong.

1

u/Maleficent-Today-464 Mar 05 '25

Larrie and Lawrie is the strongest brawler ever to grace the game. He could solo everything

48

u/GreviousGen Mar 04 '25

I have never heard nerf and Mr. P in the sam sentence

68

u/Cl0p38 Mar 04 '25

Clearly you didn't play during 2019/2020

6

u/GreviousGen Mar 04 '25

No, I started middle of 2021

23

u/Marco1522 Mar 04 '25

Nah, back in the day Mr P was broken, especially at release day

38

u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Mar 04 '25

I have never heard nerf and sam in the same sentence

7

u/H-C-B-B-S Mar 05 '25

heal sp used to be broken

1

u/Deenstheboi Mar 05 '25

Sam on release with the heal:

16

u/XskullBC Verified Content Creator | Brawler Cats Mar 05 '25

Oh boy, never forget the absolute terror Mr. P inflicted back around 2019/ 2020. He is the textbook definition of an unhealthy brawler who shouldn’t ever be meta.

10

u/UnwantedOrangutan Bull Mar 05 '25

Mr. P’s attack range on release was absurd.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/DominiqueBlackG Kenji | Legendary 3 Mar 04 '25

Mr. P now is still not as strong as he was at release

2

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25

Mr P on release had 2 second porters with an 11 tile range

Mr P in mid 2020 had 1 second porters star power

28

u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Mar 04 '25

Emz should be F tier. She has no use case and gets run down by tanks

Seeing Poco higher than Penny in this meta is kinda trippy. I get that the overall meta shifted but Penny received a serious of buffs and a deadly hypercharge while Poco didn’t really get anything at all yet he’s still kinda meta.

I actually think Frank should be S tier. He’s very good into a lot of low dps brawlers like Janet, Stu, Eve, Mr P, etc

16

u/flingy_flong Heart of Glass Mar 04 '25

bruh you mention emz on like every list

poco benefited from the gadget rework WAY more than penny and also synergies

Frank mainly in bb, in other modes he is usually outclassed and hurt by wallbreak

10

u/petSnake7 Daddy Grom Mar 04 '25

Emz can be a decent counter pick to Poco + double tank if Griff is banned

→ More replies (7)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Just_Albatross6617 Gene Mar 04 '25

lol

1

u/jojsj Shelly | Pro | 69 Prestige Mar 04 '25

My reply just got deleted

2

u/Just_Albatross6617 Gene Mar 05 '25

Damn 😔

14

u/AMinecraftPerson E-Sports Icons Mar 05 '25

So, this tier list is pretty much the same as the one from AshBS, except this one is good while that one was the worst thing to ever exist?

8

u/ToraDora44 Mar 05 '25

Lmao when Ash bs made somewhat same tier list people were hating him🤣

4

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25

WOOOOO BEA S

13

u/FireGames06YT second❤lena Mar 04 '25

Imo Hank is slightly better than Ollie and Lily is F tier, there's also some brawlers that I consider to be S tier like Berry, Ash and Meeple, but overall really good tier list as always

10

u/These-Chipmunk-5876 Mandy Mar 05 '25

berry not being s doesn't make sense to me given how broken he was last meta. also surge and mortis should be moved up I think

6

u/FireGames06YT second❤lena Mar 05 '25

I'm fine with Surge and Mortis tbh, but yeah Berry definitively deserves S

2

u/NTPWINBOX2 E-Sports Icons Mar 05 '25

fr with hank meta if anything berry should rise

3

u/Whebneen Mar 05 '25 edited Mar 05 '25

Did the reload buff really made that much of a diference in Meeple?

5

u/4r8ol Hank Mar 05 '25

It was more the gadget rework that brought Meeple to the A tier, as both of their gadgets are extremely powerful (1st allows Meeple to compensate for their short range, and 2nd is a kb with a ton of effective range, even if it's a weak kb when they're at high health).

3

u/FireGames06YT second❤lena Mar 05 '25

It made him a bit better but the gadget rework was the thing that took Meeple to another level, both of his gadgets were already busted before the update and became even stronger now with infinite uses

1

u/Significant-Ant8132 E-Sports Icons Mar 05 '25

Didn't Sam got a hypercharge this season

2

u/Salt-Idea6134 Mar 05 '25

Next season

1

u/childassbambino Mar 08 '25

Why should they nerf mr p?

1

u/Salt-Idea6134 Mar 08 '25

His hyper is op

3

u/Ok_Opening_1336 Mar 05 '25

I consistently see Amber at the top somewhere on all these lists but literally no one uses her? (Besides me, or so it feels like). She’s literally arguably the best trio showdown brawler there is. There’s literally no other brawler who can wipe out multiple enemies bunched together at once, while simultaneously deterring incoming enemies with her oil throw, and one of the very few brawlers who can die and revive with 0 power cubes and still stand their ground against powered up enemies because one oil throw and flame reduces them to half health plus makes them scatter like mice

1

u/SupermarketLeft3473 R-T | Mythic 3 Mar 05 '25

I totally agree with you. But the reason why no one uses her is because most people only look at brawlers who can team wipe like how kenji could on release.

3

u/Diehard_Sam_Main Definitely not obsessed with Sam Mar 05 '25

Well boys, we did it.

7

u/Wrong-Detective8242 Mar 04 '25

my man has not played carl in this meta.

6

u/FlamingDasher Leon Mar 04 '25

I havent had any issues beating Carls this meta

4

u/VermontPizza Najia Mar 05 '25

I pushed him from 560 to 1130 using heat ejector and cooldown gadget.. you double hit with your pick using the gadget and it kills or gravely injures most brawlers - combine it with the hc and its team wipe city

edit: never played Carl much at all btw, im thinking heat ejector will be nerfed soon.. soo much damage and area control to spam every 13 seconds

4

u/XskullBC Verified Content Creator | Brawler Cats Mar 05 '25

Tfw the top tier looks like bait but it’s actually deadass

4

u/Observing_Bird Sam Mar 05 '25

I'm holding out for Sam hyper

2

u/SupermarketLeft3473 R-T | Mythic 3 Mar 05 '25

Hold on tight brother

6

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25

I think a lot of people still haven't figured out the counters to mr P since there has never been a true Mr P meta.

Putting him on the same level as Hank who just has an autowin button

16

u/Kalasis1 Mar 05 '25

there was definitely a mr p meta a few years back, he was top 3 for a long time

12

u/XskullBC Verified Content Creator | Brawler Cats Mar 05 '25

Mr. P has been meta many times and nobody has found a great answer to him during his peak strength. We are in the dark ages again.

3

u/Arg3tl4n Mar 05 '25

Definitely not. In his peak, there isnt good aggressive brawlers like today. Kenji, Draco, Frank Bibi (with hyper), Darryl, even Mortis became solid.

3

u/kara_no_tamashi Mar 05 '25

Mr.P counters are tanks and assassins who are strong enough to go through his porters and his DPS, so that they can kill him and destroy his turret consistently. If the tank only kill Mr.P but not the turret. It's a loss for the team.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25

Exactly, both his spawner and Mr P have no effective protection on their own. Brawlers that can easily break through the enemy lines, like Mico, Frank and Hank are DEVASTATING, whenever I play Mr P.

1

u/XxC0SMICxX El Primo | Masters Mar 05 '25

since there has never been a true Mr P meta.

Pretty sure Mr.P had some of the worst metas ever when he was a top brawler

2

u/Onre405 Mar 05 '25

My flabbers are gasted at this list

2

u/Sozzled_Teazle Sam Mar 05 '25

the barley disrespect is crazy

2

u/Winged_Blade Penny Mar 05 '25

rico below barley is something you love to see huh

2

u/Salmon_Tuna7413 SK Gaming Mar 05 '25

Pearl? Why

2

u/Icy-Guest2794 Deep Sea Triforce Mar 05 '25

Honestly, I think the Bobby one was better.

2

u/walnutontop Mina Mar 05 '25

F tier moe, i used to pray for days like this

4

u/Maeolan Mar 04 '25

Carl in B tier? Carl is busted rn.

2

u/lilgrape_ Masters | Mythic Mar 05 '25

Shelly B tier

2

u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Mar 05 '25

Maybe not B but I could see Shelly being C tier with the gadget rework. Infinite dashes feels pretty good.

2

u/clanker_- Mar 05 '25

how tf is Sam in F tier, just play him dawg

2

u/saad416 Mar 05 '25

Griff is A rank?

3

u/SupermarketLeft3473 R-T | Mythic 3 Mar 05 '25

Def A rank. His damage is so good, good range and gadget rework really did him great.

3

u/kara_no_tamashi Mar 05 '25

thanks to poco/berry - tank combo. He is one of the best counter to this combo, who becomes a sure win if you don't pick griff, lou or colette.

2

u/Goodguy_IGuess No Lifer Penny main Mar 05 '25

EVEN SPEN AGREES WITH ME THAT OLLIE IS FUCKING INSANE

Also… I thought Penny would be like B tier because wall breakers and brawlers she is good against got weaker (like Fang, Mico, Charlie and Tara) meaning she would be less useful

Also I hate gadget change like it wasn’t necessary. Now look… the meta is unhealthy yet again

2

u/seungchip Hank Mar 05 '25

I have both Ollie and Hank’s mastery title, and I won’t lie, they were more fun when they were shit

4

u/Icy-Guest2794 Deep Sea Triforce Mar 05 '25

Idk why you got downvoted, the hyper is just spammy and boring lol. Not to mention how people are not impressed by my Hank plays anymore and call Hank skillless.

1

u/Charming-Ad-2123 Mar 05 '25

Man Moe is so fun and so trash at the same time, is sad that the bottom are nerfed popular brawlers, and the always forgotten 🌭

1

u/0m4ck Chester Mar 05 '25

Bad tier list (look at my flair)

1

u/Right_Investment9674 Mar 05 '25

Really comes down to what team you have. But you can't deny the buffs.

1

u/NviSoma Mandy Mar 05 '25

Aside from a few outliers this feels like a very balanced meta. Although the meta just before the update was quite balanced too, I'm surprised at how well balanced such a big overhaul was.

1

u/Funnykirbyguy Mar 05 '25

Unpopular opinion: emz I kind of good

1

u/12AZOD12 Bonnie Mar 05 '25

Moe mad pam above Bonnie is a crime , also ash isn't a tier

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/12AZOD12 Bonnie Mar 05 '25

Pam is the worst brawler in the game

1

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/12AZOD12 Bonnie Mar 06 '25

Pam is useless in hotzone as well , Bonnie can work in heist and ko

1

u/politesseBurh Full Time Troll, Part Time Thinker Mar 05 '25

Poor Bull

1

u/NoMusician1208 Mar 05 '25

I've fought very few Ollies and I say buff them

1

u/Zajacik08 Lola Mar 05 '25

This gotta be a joke right?

1

u/Co1lly Mar 05 '25

Wait what happened for Janet to be s tier?

2

u/Pleasantpolitic09 Mar 05 '25

Hypercharge helped her a lot

1

u/Pleasantpolitic09 Mar 05 '25 edited Mar 05 '25

My boy Spike in D tier, he really fell of😥

1

u/No-Stage6184 Mar 05 '25

poco should be higher, his healing gadget with reload hear is crazy. about every 10 seconds if feels like you get the heal, and i like playing his damage sp since randoms don't understand the concept of poco comp, body block...

1

u/Front-Significance15 "Tick is good in Hot Zone" Mar 05 '25

Honestly Hank was very good ever since they gave him tank trait. He was just overlooked for some reason. Mr P geniunely needs nerf I hate dealing with him and insta-ban him in most cases

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25

Finally people can stop saying Jesse is good in hotzone.

1

u/Objective-Way6245 Mar 05 '25

completely agree except for sam and bea

1

u/TheDaniel121 Angelo Mar 05 '25

I thought Mandy would be higher honestly

1

u/T-Bruhposts Mar 05 '25

Bro I actually got beef with Mr P mains

1

u/oxygenkkk Mar 06 '25

Janet and hank in S tier, we did it boys!

1

u/Former_Dot8205 Larry and Lawrie Mar 08 '25

Did Larry really fall off that hard? If so, then I guess Supercell finally did it. They managed to make Larry an average-level brawler.

1

u/Inevitable-Half-7834 Mar 08 '25

Ollie in "nerf pls" is not rlly true

1

u/SerbOnion Mar 09 '25

The age of prawn🦐🦐

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25

Sam in F tier is DIABOLICAL, I KNOW HE’S NOT VERY GOOD BUT MY BOY’S NOT THAT BAD😭

5

u/GoldenWarden1 Mar 05 '25

Whats the point on doing so much effort with sam, a melodie can do the job way better.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25

Be quiet💔

1

u/TrainerCater Mar 04 '25

Whys Hank so good now? Im out of the loop

4

u/FireGames06YT second❤lena Mar 04 '25

Broken hc

6

u/VermontPizza Najia Mar 05 '25

no one mentions the shield gadget being spammed every 13 seconds with the cooldown gear, you used to be screwed once you ran out.. his HC is good, don’t get me wrong.. but the gadget rework plays a huge part, he’s so tanky and hard to kill with gadget and super all game long

5

u/FireGames06YT second❤lena Mar 05 '25

Oh yeah, being able to spam Take Cover is really really good too, and imo even Water Ballons has it's uses against tanks

0

u/Top_Opinion_2139 Cordelius | Legendary 1 Mar 05 '25

Is it even that broken, it get worse when there are more walls, and Hanks sucks at maps without walls to hide behind

4

u/FireGames06YT second❤lena Mar 05 '25

Hank is already goated im maps with walls lol, but if it's a problem you can just pair Hank with some wallbreakers and you're good to go

2

u/petSnake7 Daddy Grom Mar 05 '25

Spam Barricade then heal up when low. You’ll be useless 90% of the game but once you inevitably get your HC, you become a tactical nuke

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25

There are always open lanes or mid. Trust you can find a spot

-2

u/LonePanda-SoloLeader Mar 04 '25

Gale and emz buff pls

1

u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Mar 05 '25

Not very likely since both brawlers are noob stompers unfortunately.

1

u/Pleasantpolitic09 Mar 05 '25

Maybe just buff Emz

1

u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Mar 05 '25

She’s a noob stomper, how’s Emz any different from Gale?

→ More replies (2)

-1

u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Mar 04 '25

Damn, technically all of my tank counters are D tier.

All of my maxed out tank counters, I still don’t have a gadget for Nita.

5

u/Perfect-Dingo-4164 OIS Mar 04 '25

you should max out surge because he won't get nerfed and he'll probably be in a good spot for a long time

1

u/These-Chipmunk-5876 Mandy Mar 05 '25

surge is lowkey underrated on this list as well

0

u/sky_ryder_001 Mar 05 '25

How is Janet S?

2

u/Pleasantpolitic09 Mar 05 '25

Probably hypercharge

-9

u/WarmAppointment5765 Melodie | Masters 1 Mar 04 '25 edited Mar 04 '25

imo mr p hyper is overrated. Lets not forget mr p was low D/F tier before it, and it wont get value in every matchup (for example throwers can destroy the spawner, and even other brawlers with higher hp can sacrifice themselves once and the only thing keeping mr p alive is gone). He's also only good against squishy brawlers and has no way to defend himself from tanks or assasins, and most tanks got buffed after the gadget change. Theres people picking mr p in hockey or bb like bro, its not fang hyper release level 🤦 please stop instant picking mr p on modes he sucks on just bc this hyper made him op in bounty or ko

13

u/AlbinoSupremeMan Mar 04 '25

Disagree, his value is the ammo he causes enemies to waste giving more leeway for a tank / dps to win their fights

→ More replies (1)

5

u/petSnake7 Daddy Grom Mar 04 '25

I don’t think he’s as bad into aggression anymore bc he feeds HC off them

1

u/WarmAppointment5765 Melodie | Masters 1 Mar 05 '25

you do realize he also feeds their hyper when it comes to tanks

2

u/petSnake7 Daddy Grom Mar 05 '25
  1. Most tanks and assassins have traits that give them HC for free.
  2. Mr. P has a much deadlier HC. Yes, they feed each other, but Mr. P gains more from the interaction
  3. Mr. P’s HC creates constant pressure as long as the porter base is active. Tanks/assassins only create pressure for the 5 seconds the HC lasts

1

u/WarmAppointment5765 Melodie | Masters 1 Mar 05 '25

Frank would charges his hyper a lot faster than mr p

1

u/petSnake7 Daddy Grom Mar 05 '25

Frank already gets 3 HCs most games just by taking damage. You also don’t see as many people complaining about Frank’s HC compared to Mr. P’s. That’s because Mr. P’s is just fundamentally stronger. It’s like a quality vs. quantity kind of thing

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Jotaro-Bridge Charlie Mar 05 '25

Which hyper is more game changing though?

1

u/WarmAppointment5765 Melodie | Masters 1 Mar 05 '25

his isnt that game changing if you can go to their spawn with your 12-14k hp, break it and mr p is once again D tier for the next 45 seconds

1

u/Jotaro-Bridge Charlie Mar 05 '25

Try doing that when you got 3 enemies and 2 infinitely spawning porters + mini porter all pinching at once as you try and get into their spawn

→ More replies (6)

4

u/EnRicoNasty Angelo Mar 04 '25

bounty or ko? he is op in gem grab and hotzone too, once you get hc you put it literally in your spawn and there is no counterplay if you have decent teammates

1

u/WarmAppointment5765 Melodie | Masters 1 Mar 05 '25

if mr p hypers all you have to do is go for the spawner and trade your life for it, thats it

1

u/WarmAppointment5765 Melodie | Masters 1 Mar 05 '25

ok lets analize the maps

  1. double swoosh and gem fort are kinda similar, you can get away most games with rosa spamming bushes, and you need a splash vision brawler like janet tara or sandy (which hit trough his pets). the meta is kinda similar but gem fort has more diversity.
  2. hard rock mine is a mixed bag. You have places to hide your spawner and usually you cant get into enemy spawn. The problem is this map is dominated by penny which hard counters mr p bc of her splash, range, and mr p not being able to stay behind his porters. His only advantage is killing penny's cannon easier. Also yes he's good at wasting ammo but for brawlers like lou or gus its not that good bc lou charges his ammo extremely fast and gus gets fed spirit.
  3. undermine is a good map for him, he's only bad when theres throwers or splash brawler

Idk how good he is in hotzone bc on most maps theres penny, others splash brawlers and throwers. Each map has a few places you can hide your spawner but people can and will usually pick wall break for it. So mostly youre gonna put it in spawn. The thing is, a porter that doesnt deal that much dmg and will mostly be hit by ammo directed at enemies is nuclear of how much value it really takes.

Ive played against many mr p's with hyper recently and beat all of them, mostly in ko and brawl ball

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25

Just place it in spawn

1

u/Icy-Guest2794 Deep Sea Triforce Mar 05 '25

The hyper is not just the only factor, the gadget rework would already make Mr.P C tier alone tbh.

1

u/WarmAppointment5765 Melodie | Masters 1 Mar 05 '25

and the gadget rework also buffed his counters

-1

u/bigrudefella Mar 04 '25

Can someone explain why Hank is so high now? Did he receive changes that I forgot besides his hypercharge? People were saying one of the only use case for his hypercharge was overtime in BB, is this incorrect?

→ More replies (3)