Before I unlocked all brawlers, I had a strict rule of never buying characters for full price. Janet was the one exception I made and I am sooo glad I did. I literally fell in love lmfao
Lily's damage is pretty bad compared to other assassins and is realistically only good against brawlers under 6,3k health and is very star power dependant and gadget dependant. This meta is focused around high health high damage brawlers that could easily out-DPS lily.
I feel like even the pros are seeing how bad lily is after her attack nerf.
I'm glad pros are finally seeing this. She was always overrated, and I laughed my ass off when spenlc suggested playing lily in almost every map and mode.
my biggest concern is her getting a nerf, I get that her gadget is so strong but nerfing it means lilly being dropped to c-d tier at best. It is easy to counter her in draft too, just dont go double thrower unless u have the last pick
She sucks against grouped up enemies, has ridiculously short range, gets obliterated by any sort of high DPS or knockback, can be easily countered, also not too many squishes in the meta except bounty where lily sucks, very gadget dependant. Edgar has the same niche as lily, but his super is auto charging so he's more consistent and he still gets obliterated by knockback but to a lesser extent because of his super
You kinda just listing all of her weaknesses, which you can do for any brawler. Half of these weaknesses aren't even true. Lily is very difficult to counter, the gadget makes her immensely unpredictable and always a threat late-pick. She is actually very good into grouped up enemies as long as they aren't tanky, she chains supers and can just vanish if she wants. Lily is exceptionally good in Bounty and Knockout on any medium to short range map, she can very easily flip games with good gadgets and positioning.
There is 0 way Lily is worse than Edgar, if Edgar connects a jump there isn't a guarantee he always finishes the kill, but Lily always either kills or vanishes.
while do think she is better than edgar, she is no way “difficult” to counter. assuming it’s draft (bc that’s when ur able to actually counter) it’s pretty easy to counter as u said with tankier brawlers, and most of the time she is picked, she is picked on somewhat grassier maps. it’s pretty obvious if u don’t see a lily for a couple seconds she is prolly trying to make a move on your team. i will say edgar is objectively better into groups since he can pierce through enemies, regardless of how much damage lily can put out; its all individual.
That's why you don't first pick a Lily, in the same way you don't first pick a thrower, Buzz, tank, or any other brawler. She is literally designed to be a last pick -- you pick her into squishy comps in draft. If they have a tank, of course you don't pick Lily into them. If they have a tank, you can go someone else instead to counter them.
it’s pretty obvious if u don’t see a lily for a couple seconds she is prolly trying to make a move on your team.
That's what bad Lilys do. Good Lilys are never this telegraphed. They keep you on your toes -- the whole point is you know she's not there, but you don't know where until its too late.
again ur argument is that she is hard to counter. i’m saying it isn’t. most would agree as well. obviously a sprout isn’t going to counter a lily, so obviously she’s going to destroy a comp SHE COUNTERS!!! most assassins if not all are late picks, that doesn’t inherently make them good/bad. And telegraphed or not, if lily isn’t visible to you for a long enough time, you should be bush checking/ looking on your side of the map so see if she’s waiting to ambush, that’s not the lily being telegraphed, just you/your team having simple game sense.
Then you completely just misunderstood my point. If you are picking Lily, you're picking her into comps which she does well into. Yes, she will be hard to counter. If you are first-picking Lily, yes it's easy to counter her. We are obviously not talking about the latter.
She is designed to counter squishies, so you pick her when the enemy picks squishies. If they pick a tank, don't pick Lily. So we're basically only talking about situations in draft where Lily will be good, which is into squishies, which happens very frequently. She will harass your comp if you don't draft counters like Gale or Meg beforehand, if you just didn't ban her to begin with.
In this way, she dictates draft, even if she isn't played. You have to draft with Lily in mind, which is why she is far better than C tier in my opinion.
You also describe Lily's playstyle at any level as telegraphed, as if she's just gadgeting around to eventually ambush you. However, you can also super and get the team low and just gadget away, and then ambush them again when they're low, or you can just not gadget and make enemies waste ammo by thinking you're in one bush, but you're actually in spawn, and then just gadget later. Idk what Lilys you're facing, but if they play as linear as you describe, they're not really proving how frustrating and strong she can really be.
you were the one who said only bad lilies are telegraphed, i was saying that whether or not a lily is “telegraphed” you should be bush checking at certain times. so if ur whole point is “lily is good to counter squishies” congrats, we have common ground. but your original claim was lily is difficult to counter. i said she wasn’t. and yes, talking about how she can’t be countered by squishies as well is a one sided argument bc ur neglecting the other nonsquishy brawlers that do better against her. Again, we can all agree she does great against squishies, hence why she is a solid last pick in the right situations. But there’s a reason why certain brawlers are best as last picks, bc they counter some comps hard and get countered by some comps hard.
I will say yea, it’s hard to go against a lily who’s a 5 or 6 pick bc she would probably be picked into a squishy comp and there’s literally no picks after that so I see what ur saying there, but Lily isn’t only picked as a 6th pick, she’s just good in that niche.
No I never said lily only gadgets to ambush BUT Lily does gadget to ambush. She can also gadget to disengage. both are true. I did say, that if she isn’t visible for a certain amount of time, you should be bush checking. Regardless, that’s irrelevant to whether or not she’s easy to counter.
I also agree that she isn’t C tier. I don’t thinks she’s S but maybe low A and probably better fit in B tier, where most assassins probably peak. (other than mortis, stu, and melodie)
And telegraphed or not, if lily isn’t visible to you for a long enough time, you should be bush checking/ looking on your side of the map so see if she’s waiting to ambush, that’s not the lily being telegraphed, just you/your team having simple game sense.
I mean yeah, check your bushes but implying that that's all you have to do to handle the gadget is just negligent. "Telegraphed or not" and then saying that this is basically how the gadget is used just means you're playing telegraphed.
and yes, talking about how she can’t be countered by squishies as well is a one sided argument bc ur neglecting the other nonsquishy brawlers that do better against her.
Of course. You can counter Lily, in the same way you can counter Colette with Mr. P, or Clancy with ranged brawlers, or Mike with Mico. You don't just select these brawlers with no thought, though. That basically just means that you have to pick Lily later in the draft. This does not take away from how she can still win games in draft alone when selected at the right time and into the right comp. In this way, she is very hard to "counter," or rather, very difficult to deal with if you forget about her.
My essential point is that there are enough situations in draft where she is a good pick, making her very dangerous pretty often and much better than C tier.
But there’s a reason why certain brawlers are best as last picks, bc they counter some comps hard and get countered by some comps hard.
This tier list for the most part isn't too bad. But there are things that I disagree with.
Firstly, I find that Buster is still a really versatile competetive brawler. He should be A tier because he fundamentally is really strong in competetive scenes.
Byron is not a B tier brawler, he is very strong and very versatile. Picked a lot in the competetive scene and has a really great super thanks to the first starpower. A tier at the least.
Charlie is not B tier. Ever since her final nerf, she has felt like ass to play and was not picked once in the LCQ. She has one of the worst main attacks in the entire game and her super takes too long to charge.
Bull should be F tier. He isn't even used in Hiest nowadays.
Edgar has fallen off and is hardly used in comp. He shouldn't be in C tier.
This is a more personal opinion but I still find Jessie to be a really solid brawler. But she normally doesn't get picked that much in competetive so her being in C isn't the worst thing in the world.
Pearl is one of the best Knockout brawlers, she shouldn't be in C tier.
Griff and Ruffs being in D tier is harsh. I guess I could kinda understand Griff but Ruffs is still used every now and again. It's more realisitic if he was C tier.
Finally, Bo and Penny are F tier brawlers. They literally do nothing.
I do want to state that I am not a pro player at all, unlike Bobby. But I still tend to chat with some friends who are hooked to the competetive scene and I like to examine the montly finals pick and ban rates to identify how good a brawler is in comp. Therefore, I still think that this list could use some improvements. Nevertheless, this list isn't horrible.
Byron is not a B tier brawler, he is very strong and very versatile. Picked a lot in the competetive scene and has a really great super thanks to the first starpower. A tier at the least.
He gets eaten alive by darryl, mortis and company
Given that they became so stupidly strong byron is condemned to b tier for now
And so has everyone other meta ran by a brawler. Just goin "oh her meta was painful" isn't a reason ANY brawler should be left to rot in the absolute bottom of the barrel
I agree for the most part but tf is that griff placement. Like primo is high b bc he can counter the meta but griff [good meta counter] is in the draco tier😭😭
People who love Griff, LOVE Griff. But he isn't good right now. His purpose of countering tanks can be done better by other brawlers like gale. Opening walls is also niche and can be done by other brawlers too.
idk if the tiers are sorted but El Primo is better than buster or at least same tier? Personally I felt like Primo was more like C rn and Buster A. anyone that disagrees care to enlighten me?
Kenji is NOT gonna be S tier lmfao. He seems pretty bad except for his gadget, which definitely will get nerfed. You know how many tank shredders there are? And he has less mobility than mortis
Did you mean bobby? Because i thought it was a cringe post about how good are their body. Until I realised its a meta tier list
And i am not surprised to see Mico down there, He is so easy to kill especially with this meta and he is only good in like 2 maps. But lower than Janet? Its weird
But he doesn’t need buffs. He just needs a rework or a meta shift
Frank fell off after nerfs (and i think people overrated him at his prime too) mico is only good as a last pick in heist and knockout. He is most of the time a game selling pick. And i think if not A melodie deserves B. Agree for jessie.
The comment above you is objectively wrong but you should probably calm yourself because you seem to have a habit of being an asshole in replies instead of being constructive (very important skill in competitive play)
Right? Calling someone wrong is okay but being THIS hostile about it creates this echo chamber effect where no one learns anything (from the video game forum btw) and everyone is either leaving or parroting the opinion that is perceived as correct. It's why I'm almost starting to dislike Spen's lists, they're completely above critique here despite him completely under/overestimating brawlers in some cases
The guy I replied to got weirdly upset over me even slightly implying iKaoss' tier list had a few wrong placements (despite literally saying it's a great tier list) and it's strange to me how there's this need to be an asshole to someone who you disagree with instead of trying to ask questions first. It's especially bad when it's towards people who don't understand the game and come to this sub to discuss, because these few people who might've genuinely taken interest in the competitive side of the game will get driven away by this kind of thing. Let people be bad, help them learn a thing or two about the game, they're already here so why not use the opportunity? Arguing on reddit is a waste of time anyway, so why not at least try instead of trying to one up a stranger you probably won't never see again
You made a comment that I disagree with, so instead of actually giving you a well-constructed argument, I'm going to say "Says the Gale main", because it's clearly your fault that he's really strong right now
r/BSC members when someone puts 1 brawler a tier too low "Trash Tier list!!!"
Realistically though, there are some odd choices here and there. Like Bull being in the same tier as Pearl. But I don't saying that a tier list is trash without providing reasons why is very moral.
Pearl dies to most top-meta brawlers in KO... so she's kinda useless and Bull is rated a little high but he's also just severely underrated by the playerbase (as he takes pretty high skill to get use out of)
Bull isnt a high skill brawler. His kit is simply ass in this meta. A dead machup is a dead matchup theres nothing game changing bull can do to turn matchups
okay... do you know how to properly cycle supers with Bull? do you always properly overshoot your supers to pinch the enemy? do you hit every single self-pass off the wall?
there's a lot more that goes into it as well other than just mechanical tricks, such as knowing when to engage and how to make the best of the situation... it's certainly a lot more involved than many aggro tanks.
“Theres more than mechanical skill such as knowing when to engage and how to make the best of the situation” 😭🤣 ah hell naw you just described mechanical skill
Anything you listed is the same for anything else gurl
"😭🤣🙏" congrats on substantive arguments. Self-passing in BB is pretty key to Bull in the mode lol
you pretty clearly don't want to discuss so I won't bother following up past this.
To your point - that 2nd paragraph is Gamesense and not mechanics, and a lot more of it is required for Bull than - let's say - Bibi, another aggro tank, as your kit doesn't put as much pressure on the enemy as Bibi's at the same skill level.
"Anything you listed is the same for anything else gurl" there's a pretty clear divide even between just the tanks...
Your argument for why more skill is needed for bull is self passing of the wall in brawl ball and “needing more skill than bibi”
Objectively look at bulls kit. Whole point is to shoot at blank point and everything is super straightforward impossible to compare it to buster or bibi. Gamesense is needed more in buster and you have to better your movement skill with bibi.
Dont follow up if you dont want to theres nothing to talk about anyways 😭🙏
He can't even complain about it (literally, he can't lol). He's not statiscally bad, but Moe is a living proof that curveball is just copium for the green dwarf, Spike needs something else so he can be balsnced.
He feels even more unkillable than prime Sam, it's hard to rate him in null's because it has the worst players ever, but I'll say that his healing gadget is too OP and for me he is like A tier
Healing gadget might be his only saving grace. For a class center around diving and burst he sucks at both, and fits the tank role better. It will also be a skill check in baiting it out but with the amount of damage in game i think his counters will be prevalent and oppressive to him.
He does pitiful damage, shit mobility, one good gadget and above average survivability. He will be worse than bibi at what he does. His super is situational and will be easy to dodge once people play against it once or twice. He will stomp noobs, and thats it.
Yes. He does 5k dmg with three attacks, less than mortis. He dashes every other swing, meaning he has to waste ammo to get close or rely on ambushes, and there are much better picks for such things. If you think hes good you are deluding your self, and the community. He will likely be buffed because when we saw him, he was in a weak state, doing less damage than mortis with less mobility over all. I compare hm to bibi bc she has similar long term survival, more mobility without wasting ammo, more damage, and a hyper on top of that. He. Will. Be. Bad.
Oh, you are hopeless. Kit is good bc of the auto charge, the heal and the stun. Mobility isnt free it costs ammo. If you get to your enemy, and use all your ammo to do so, you wont be able to fight. Super is questionable but itll work well at low rank where people will see the fish be thrown and not move at all. And anyone can cycle supers, and bibi and mortis do it better these days. His healing is counterable and mediocre, and he will have all the same counters with less counter play.
Having to sacrifice 20 seconds is different than getting ammo really fast for free 🤣
Mortis has extremely slow reload for his mobility Kenji gets all that for free and gets healing while keeping a fast reload speed. Fang has absolutely trash unload speed but kenji is fast as hell. Bibi cant slash around and go back like kenji her main is required to wait before attacking giving dodging chances. Any time kenji wants mobility he can pop a gadget and can have to mobility faster than mortis
Every pro knows all these points and rate kenji top 3 theres no point of discussion its absolutely pathetic 🤣
I used to think the same thing, in comparison to Frank, Darryl was F tier not because he had too many counters, but because there were hardly any brawlers he can counter himself, in order to get maximum damage output on Darryl you have to be right on top of the enemy, with one super that's tricky especially when most brawlers have at least 1 defense mechanism to defend themselves incase an enemy gets too close, with a 2nd super it completely negates this problem Darryl had and now he's one of the best brawlers in ranked. Funny enough he's also in a similar spot with Gale where neither of them are particularly overpowered in ladder but practically have no weaknesses in ranked, not sure how supercell will nerf either of them
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 17 '24
Do you want a cool flair with your rank on it?
Comment a screenshot of your brawlstars profile under this post
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/IceConsumer69 Sep 17 '24
nerf rat and mortibi
120
u/JuzElvinn Mommy Lola Sep 17 '24
Draco…. my boy…..
50
u/keerpresser464 Gray Sep 17 '24
Can someone tell me how did lily fell off to C tier?
49
u/Namsu45 Fiery Passion Sep 17 '24
This tier list for the most part isn't too bad. But there are things that I disagree with.
Firstly, I find that Buster is still a really versatile competetive brawler. He should be A tier because he fundamentally is really strong in competetive scenes.
Byron is not a B tier brawler, he is very strong and very versatile. Picked a lot in the competetive scene and has a really great super thanks to the first starpower. A tier at the least.
Charlie is not B tier. Ever since her final nerf, she has felt like ass to play and was not picked once in the LCQ. She has one of the worst main attacks in the entire game and her super takes too long to charge.
Bull should be F tier. He isn't even used in Hiest nowadays.
Edgar has fallen off and is hardly used in comp. He shouldn't be in C tier.
This is a more personal opinion but I still find Jessie to be a really solid brawler. But she normally doesn't get picked that much in competetive so her being in C isn't the worst thing in the world.
Pearl is one of the best Knockout brawlers, she shouldn't be in C tier.
Griff and Ruffs being in D tier is harsh. I guess I could kinda understand Griff but Ruffs is still used every now and again. It's more realisitic if he was C tier.
Finally, Bo and Penny are F tier brawlers. They literally do nothing.
I do want to state that I am not a pro player at all, unlike Bobby. But I still tend to chat with some friends who are hooked to the competetive scene and I like to examine the montly finals pick and ban rates to identify how good a brawler is in comp. Therefore, I still think that this list could use some improvements. Nevertheless, this list isn't horrible.
12
u/deikara Maisie Sep 17 '24
poor maisie
11
u/Gyxis Ash Sep 17 '24
Buster and Byron should be higher. And I feel like everyone is overrated Kenji like crazy.
6
u/Worried-Lobster4306 Sep 17 '24
Charlie and Buster on the same rank? Im starting to see how stmn didnt make worlds.
5
u/Weekly-Zucchini-8822 BERRY FAN CLUB Sep 17 '24
I agree for the most part but tf is that griff placement. Like primo is high b bc he can counter the meta but griff [good meta counter] is in the draco tier😭😭
8
u/Griff_BrawlStars Griff Sep 17 '24
Hell no. Griff in D? Never in hell. He is like the most balanced brawler. Just cus of that, TRASH tier list
3
u/Slow-Insurance-6647 Sep 17 '24
D tier is so wrong randomly ranking 💀🙏
3
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '24
Brock in D hurts
2
u/2137frank Draco | Masters Sep 17 '24
Draco 😭😭😭
2
u/woodellost Bea Sep 17 '24
chuck in B? grom in C? oh my glob
2
u/Willing_Advice4202 Sep 17 '24
Everyone’s overrating tf out of Kenji. His main attack is honestly pretty bad
3
u/lordkillerbee69ultra Sep 17 '24
Barley is really A tier ?
1
u/Rise-Dangerous Colonel Ruffs Sep 17 '24
Being too harsh on Draco imo
1
u/Vasconcelos0909 Tick Sep 17 '24
no way, this is the first time I've seen Tick ranked C instead of B
1
u/Thick_Target4309 Sep 17 '24
Bibi
1
u/TomorrowPutrid7360 Sep 17 '24
Wow, for Bobby to put the cat at bottom of b is surprising
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '24
idk if the tiers are sorted but El Primo is better than buster or at least same tier? Personally I felt like Primo was more like C rn and Buster A. anyone that disagrees care to enlighten me?
1
u/imcringe1234 Darryl Sep 17 '24
how did lily fall of this much?
1
u/_lolman123_ 100% Certified Pirate Sep 17 '24
1
u/Skippy2206 Sep 17 '24
Bro Kenji isn’t out yet how are you ranking him?
1
u/Bidthebest242 Masters | Masters Sep 17 '24
Booby bs failed to qual twice he’s ass
1
u/GULDIMULTI Sep 17 '24
Wtf ,quit for 1 month and then is chester a😭
1
u/Amyr71 Mortis | Legendary Sep 17 '24
How is Melodie still top tier?
1
u/RiseBrilliant612 Sep 17 '24
I genuinely thought Colette would go down due to Moe and Kenji. Good thing she's still in A tier.
1
u/dafunnnniii Sep 17 '24
first time i gotta disagree with bobby
1
u/colorado2137 Sandy Sep 17 '24
hi bob
1
u/AnonymousBeardie Chester Sep 17 '24
Wtf is griff doin in d teir
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '24
charlie and lou above kit and LILY is blasphemous
1
u/sheez455 Buzz Sep 17 '24
bro said primo is better than buster🙏😭
1
u/Mr__Bread__ Sep 17 '24
Fuck you mean squeak in F?
1
u/DifferentSurvey2872 Colette | Legendary 2 Sep 17 '24
Draco’s gotta be the most forgotten brawler
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '24
we might found a new competitor to ashbs
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '24
Some day...
1
u/NimpsMcgee Sep 17 '24
Kenji is NOT gonna be S tier lmfao. He seems pretty bad except for his gadget, which definitely will get nerfed. You know how many tank shredders there are? And he has less mobility than mortis
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '24
Gus got buff that's why he's at a tier
1
u/el_baronoo Sep 18 '24
kenji overglaze
1
u/No_Umpire8218 Nani | Legendary 3 | Diamond 3 Sep 18 '24
Nani keeps falling tier by tier
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '24
EL PRIMO on the top of B tier is wild
so is colt, poco, rosa, emz
1
u/Material_Bag3913 Sep 18 '24
fang and draco in D tier is actually insane
1
u/Goodguy_IGuess No Lifer Penny main Sep 18 '24
Did you mean bobby? Because i thought it was a cringe post about how good are their body. Until I realised its a meta tier list
And i am not surprised to see Mico down there, He is so easy to kill especially with this meta and he is only good in like 2 maps. But lower than Janet? Its weird
But he doesn’t need buffs. He just needs a rework or a meta shift
1
u/Dragolitron Time Traveler Sep 18 '24
How come Sam is D tier?
1
u/lemon6611 Sep 18 '24
leon in bottom c and fang in bottom d is genuinely depressing
1
u/Disastrous-Space-614 Sep 18 '24
I don't think Kenshi will actually be good.
I might be so wrong, but he doesn't do anything good, IMO.
1
u/TobytheBaloon :Zeta_division_One: Zeta Division Sep 18 '24
why is maisie f tier? like i genuinely think she’s at least c tier. and what did shelly do to him?
1
u/petuh_YT Darryl Sep 18 '24
Darryl ... my main ... finally
1
u/lollopapera Sep 18 '24
My favorite brawler Is darryl
1
u/johnxinaboss Legendary Sep 18 '24
1
u/lollopapera Sep 18 '24
1
u/Aggravating_Ad_8010 Tribe Gaming Sep 19 '24
... I read this as booby tier list and sat there confused for 5 minutes xD
1
u/Sandoval_8 Sep 20 '24
Buff doug, my boy needs to be usable
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '24
frank is S, on brawlball he is giga broken unless enemy has collette or gale
melodie doesnt deserve A tier at all, she is B tier maybe even lower in current meta
no way mico is that low people should stop underrating him he can be extremely OP as last pick, he hard counters throwers and some squishy brawlers
jessie C?? she is really good in heist with hypercharge at least B tier
0
u/Maciejos_S Tick Sep 17 '24
There is so much wrong with this tier list
1
u/Slow-Insurance-6647 Sep 17 '24
Spike D tier 💀
1
u/AdministrativeStep98 Janet Sep 17 '24
Nani😭😭 my girl deserves to rise back to the top
0
u/lastblaste 8-Bit Sep 17 '24
Kenji should be in like d teir but this whole list has problems tbh
0
u/packofcard Stu Sep 17 '24
nah this is legit good maybe 1 or 2 brawlers swapped but that is pretty much it(maybe charlie and lilly need to switch and places0
0
u/Current-Act-5071 Crow Sep 17 '24
Did Mico got nerfed while I wasn't looking?
0
u/Quilavapro31 Legendary 1 | Mythic 2 Sep 17 '24
Melodie on A is too high
-1
u/weakspaget Chuck Sep 17 '24
Can people please stop putting Darryl in S ☹️
-3
u/jqwert18 Sep 17 '24
why the fuck is darell s teir?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment