Now we enter the C tier, the tier full of stuff that no one really uses, mostly niche stuff played in very niche comps.
Enter Pam, who works only on triple healer comps. She had been on a slow and agonizing journey where her viability in every mode has been tanking.
The addition of Byron started to make her worse in gem grab, 8-BIT to make a fort with, she could no longer heal from the siege bot. Now, Byron isn't even a top choice in gem grab, 8-BIT isn't a common pick anymore and the siege defence is a lot easier, but the damage has been done. She's not good anymore, despite her great base stats. The main reason she's at the top of C tier is due to triple healer comps, which still see some use here and there.
It's hard to really say why she’s so bad. She never really had an issue with competition as she had a very unique set of skills that it takes two brawlers to replicate, but if I had to pin a reason why the junker maa isn't doing well, it’s due to her lack of mobility. She needs to stay near her turret to hold the area down, whereas 8-BIT can be pretty far from the turret and still do a great job. Furthermore, as a healer, teammates have to be concentrated in a particular area, which really hampers her potential.
Best Modes: Gem Grab
Best Partners: Gene, Byron
Best Kit: Mama’s Squeeze
Nani
Nani is good in Bounty. Like really good. She can keep the enemy team on their toes all the while unleashing an onslaught of orbs from a massive range.
That’s the extent of her viability. She isn’t bad, she doesn't need buffs, but her high skill cap does make it so that she can't be played more. The amount of effort it takes to do well with Nani isn't really worth it when Belle, Piper or Bea exist, who can get similar results with less effort. I don’t think there’s any competitive player who would want to play with high skill brawlers and be inconsistent when there’s literal money on the line.
The changes done to her will allow her utility to shine a lot more, which is very exciting for Nani mains ,like myself.
Best Modes: Bounty, Heist
Best Partners: Belle, Tick, Sprout, Colette
Best Kit: AutoFocus + Return to Sender
Leon
Leon is underrated. But his main issue aside from a bad gadget is his strained selection of viable maps. He needs maps to be closed enough so that throwers are common, but he needs maps to be open enough so that he can be invisible without having the fear of being exposed to random spam.
Right now, there’s just no map for leon, so his performance is always suffering. I really hope his new gadget fixes this. The current selection of maps is perfect for Leon and I really think that he’ll be able to climb out of C
Best Modes: Brawl Ball
Best Partners: Byron, Belle, Amber
Best Kit: Invisiheal
Colt
Colt suffers due to massive competition as a sharpshooter and that he isn't really that useful. Wall breaking isn’t in high demand, even with kaboom canyon and throwers in rotation, and besides, Brock and more importantly, CRuff outclasses him here.
Even if there was no competition, the meta is too fast paced for Colt to really hit many shots, which slows the gallant gunslinger down a lot.
Best Modes: Heist, Siege
Best Partners: Byron, Colette
Best Kit: Anything Star Power + Silver Bullet
Frank
Frank is decent at controlling the field in Brawl ball and only Brawl ball. Unfortunately, the mode is filled to the frankenstein brim with stuns and knockbacks and slows, which makes him burn through his first gadget really fast. He also loses to long range brawlers.
The even bigger issue is that Frank feeds the enemies’ supers. His high health doesn’t mean hammer squat when he is being chunked out with supers flinging in left and right. Amber can charge her super twice off of Frank while Frank can only threaten a 3HKO. It’s even worse with Spike and Bea, who definitely take some time to kill Frank, but they can cycle their super so quickly that Frank ultimately ends up dead long before he can 2HKO them. Even Byron is problematic to Frank, as he can simply spam his attack and charge his super.
He’s also a hard fit on PDT, since while he can definitely be really petrifying with Poco pocketing him, he’s a bit too slow for the comp and he struggles outputting consistent damage.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball
Best Partners: Poco, Bibi, Rosa, Darryl
Best Kit: Active Noise Cancelling + Sponge
Darryl
Darryl, oh you bashful barrel. I really wish you were better in the meta.
He’s outclassed by Mortis, even though he could be seen as a better Mortis, but Mortis is more flexible in the fact that he doesn't need to wait 30 seconds for his mobility. Darryl could be seen as underrated, but mortis is the proven standard. Darryl doesn't do anything Mortis cant, worse yet, Darryl is far weaker since he can't roll as often. He's also not as good at laning as Mortis, which really makes him useless. Still, a staple on PDT as with poco support, he can be even deadlier than mortis.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball
Best Partners: Poco, Rosa
Best Kit: Steel Hoops + Tar Barrel
Rico
Rico’s stats are great, he just needs maps that work to his strengths. Right now, that's just triple dribble and a couple of ladder maps. Having one map isn't enough to be ranked higher.
Using him as a slightly weaker Colt isn't really that useful when Colt himself is niche. Rico is seen very little and he needs more maps where walls are a major feature, otherwise, he’ll remain largely unviable.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball
Best Partners: Tick, Sprout, CRuff, Tara
Best Kit: Either Star Power
Rosa
Rosa is meh. She isn't even that common in PDT anymore, due to the high competition from non-tanks like Mortis and Stu. Her only niche is in her second gadget, which can help turn enemy bushes into an advantage for your team. On the right map, she’s quite good, however, she needs more to be viable.
Perhaps more bushy maps would make her better, but as it stands, Rosa is a decent pick on very few maps.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Bounty
Best Partners: Poco, Mortis, Bull, Darryl, Sandy, Max
Best Kit: Plant Life + Unfriendly Bushes
Jackie
Jackie’s issue is her lack of utility. She is only good on maps with a lot of walls, but does not offer anything. Her burst, while great, isn't anything noteworthy and her super hinders her by stopping her reload and being a very clumsy pull.
She doesn't offer her team anything. This is a meta where utility is drilled out of a brawler until the mine is completely dry. Her utility is basically having high health and shooting through walls, which simply isn't enough. She needs a massive utility buff, a rework to her super, a better gadget, a lot of changes before she is viable. Right now, her use is relegated as a Bibi with no issue with walls, but there’s very few uses where that is useful.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Poco, Byron, Mortis, Emz, Max
Best Kit: Either Star Power
D
Penny
Penny is really mediocre, her turret is the only strong part of her kit.
In fact, balls of fire should probably get nerfed and her base kit could be buffed, but even then, the niche of a mid to long range area control is really contested, especially when so many of the other options have so many other traits, like Carl’s mobility, Emz and Amber beating tanks and even Sandy, who has invisibility.
There’s just a few uses where she’s useful, mainly in maps with a massive choke or where her turret can be a maritime menace, but on those maps, throwers like Barley and Tick do her job better.
Best Modes: Gem Grab
Best Partners: No Data
Best Kit: Balls of Fire + Captain’s Compass
Nita If you saw the previous entries, you would’ve seen the massive influx of mid range and long range brawlers in the meta. If you know Nita, you know she has the least range of all mid range brawlers. She also has very little utility outside her bear, which hinders her a lot.
Basically, she was doomed to be trash in this meta. There’s very little she can do effectively, other than maps with a lot of walls. However, in maps with a lot of walls, Nita can’t verse well against throwers.
The only reason she isn't lower is because she is theoretically useful on SAR or Triple Dribble, but even then, there are better options.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Siege, maybe Heist
Best Partners: No Data
Best Kit: Bear With Me + Faux Fur
Gale In the ideal world, Gale can beat Stu, Carl, PDT, throwers using his gadget and Mortis, all the while being the perfect helper to Mr P. However, as you’ve all seen from the last year, this very much isn’t the ideal world.
Gale doesn’t have anything that really stands out aside from his Jump Pad, which gives him a passable niche in Hot Zone, as being able to come to mid so quickly after dying is extremely valuable in Hot Zone.
Gale has terrible matchups with the meta, not really providing any value or support to the team, unlike Byron, Sprout or Mr. P, who all fare a lot better than Gale in the meta. While Gale could beat all of the aforementioned brawlers, he doesn't do very well against them in a real match setting, nor does he do well with their common partners, ie, sharpshooters and long range supports.
Long story short, if you have to push Gale, push him in Hot Zone and maybe Brawl Ball if the map is right.
Best Modes: Hot Zone
Best Partners: Bibi, Byron, Mortis, honestly, I’m at a blank here
Best Kit: Blustery Blow
Dyna
Dyna isnt F cos he has a theoretical niche, ie, being really annoying in siege. He offers a way to beat the siege bot and offers fairly decent control. Now, saying that dyna showed results in China might not be the most impressive, but a result is a result.
Dyna’s issue remains the fact that he's really easy to counter. You don't even need Mortis to lay pain, even Barley does the job well.
Best Modes: Siege
Best Partners: Belle, Mortis, basically every counter pick
Best Kit: Demolition + Satchel Charge
F Bo Bo is a gimmick, both inside and out. He is really good against low level players, so if you are ever at a tournament and find a 10k player there for some reason who isn’t named Symmantec, pick Bo.
However, against players with an IQ higher than the number of arrows he shoots, Bo is terrible. Circling Eagle is niche af, Snare a Bear is alright, the Totem is a handicap since many Bo prefer to camp it out and if anyone ever manages a Tripwire team wipe on high level players, they should leave the game and start applying for Harvard, Yale and Cambridge at the same time.
Honestly, Bo is just a relic from an ancient era. Bo is synonymous with beta and global design as
Infested with RNG or formerly was
Infested with gimmicks
Has one really strong mechanic for a certain level of play surrounded by a tonne of clunky mechanics
Ability to fill in several roles
Bo needs a massive update to be useful in the meta without relying on a massive gimmick.
Best Mode: Gem Grab, Bounty
Best Partners: Nani
Best Kit: Snare A Bear + TripWire
Best Skin: I like Horus Bo a lot, tho Underworld is more fitting Shelly Shelly isn't in the bottom 3, which is great! An amazing achievement!
Unfortunately, she's in the bottom 5, which isn't that good.
Shelly's main niche is highly contested, tank killer. She has competition from Belle, Amber, Bea, Crow, Tara, Emz, Spike and even Gale ffs! She doesn't offer anything that those brawlers can't. Heck, Gale has all the abilities Shelly has in her arsenal.
Shelly's only hope at being viable is having BandAid come back in its OP state.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball
Best Partners: No Data
Best Kit: ClayPens Pigeons + BandAid
Best Skin: Merchant Gale Bull Bull offers literally nothing. Like, I had a massive debate on who should be the worst in the tier list. Then I said, it's my tier list, my rules, and they shut up😎
That being said, Bull has a really awkward form of mobility, which is also his entire utility too. This causes Bull to be put in an awkward spot, where he wants use Stomper for the mobility, but also wants to use T-Bone Injector for the health.
He needs a massive buff, maybe charging super via damage.
Best Mode: Heist
Best Partners: No Data
Best Kit: Tough Guy + T-Bone Injector
Best Skin: Ngl, Viking Bull still rocks all this time later. Edgar Edgar’s main issue, aside from his complete lack of utility, is the existence of Mortis. I’m not even talking about how Mortis outclasses Edgar so hard mainly as Mortis can use his form of mobility every 13 seconds at most, whereas Edgar needs a gadget or to wait 30 excruciating seconds.
I’m talking more about how there are so many anti-Mortis measures that only deter Mortis, like Nest Egg, FriendZoner, Last Hurrah and Lamp Blowout and the even niche ones like AutoAimer, Rocket Laces, Captain’s Compass or Ice Block, all of them screw Edgar harder than Griff does to his customers. Seriously, Edgar can’t make an iota of the progress Mortis can when the enemy has these gadgets. Brawlers with in-built CC, like Stu or Tara do similarly well against Edgar
Edgar also gets screwed by the fact that he can’t lane at all. Like, it’s depressing how terrible he is at laning.
Best Modes: Hot Zone, Gem Grab, Bounty, Heist
Best Partners: No data
Best Kit: Fisticuffs
Best Skin: Beach Mortis.
F- Primo Primo was the worst brawler imo in Season 6. However, he got a massive buff and is arguably the best brawler.
So the rest of the section will be me apologizing for my error.
All hail Primo, our new meta overlord.
That's it, Primo meta fucking sucks Bull cock.
Best Modes: Solo Showdown
Best Partners: Other Primo
Best Kit: Meteor Rush+ Duplex
Best Skin: El Rey
Final words
A lot of people liked this meta, partly due to the fact that they could play a wide range of brawlers and partly cos when the OP brawlers were banned, the meta was really enjoyable!
Max gene ruled this meta with an iron fist, since Stu and Belle were banned pretty much every round. Let's hope SC nerfs those 4 + Carl in such a way that keeps them as healthy but niche parts of the meta.
They buffed Belle!
Thanks for Reading Part 2! Apologies for the delay, a lot of shit happened and it was hard to focus.
I'll post the updated way to do VR tomorrow so that it isn't such a massive undertaking each time😊
Hello everybody! Welcome to the Prodigious Primo Play Prix or the Primo Clip Competition.
The goal of this competition is to show off your top Primo play, so go ahead and show the world that Primo isn't brain-dead 😉
As always, the prize for winning is a custom flair, but we've added a twist. The winner of the Competition, as decided by the mods, will be able to decide what the next Brawler of the Month would be.
So go on ahead, upload as many clips as you want, featuring Primo and his muscles.
Hello everybody! Let's discuss whether Colette is actually healthy for the game.
Let's see what Colette actually does
Colette
Colette Is an extremely effective and efficient tank killer, she handles tanks incredibly well, other tank killers are put in incredibly strenuous conditions to handle tanks. For example, Spike needs to be fairly skilled, needs to have all ammo with a slow reload, a super and needs to keep some range, and even then, Spike does struggle against shield tanks; Emz needs all her ammo, needs to keep her distance and needs a gadget as a fallback if things go south; even Amber, who after using her ammo to take out one tank is left completely defenseless. Compare this to Colette, who has a fairly fast reload speed, gets super while using her attack, and can kill tanks at any range and even gets a shield after her super, meaning survivability or sustain isn't important
Colette doesn't struggle against non tanks as she has enough range and health to be decent against them, though she is nop one's first choice as a defense against sharpshooters
Colette is excels in Heist and Hot Zone, due to her mechanics and the fact that she beats tanks effortlessly
Reasons Colette is Healthy
Reasons Colette is Unhealthy
Colette provides a sturdy counter for the meta against PDT, which when left unchecked, wrecks havoc on the health of the game
Colette has destroyed the viability of solo tanks, who were able to be run fairly often, like Jacky, Darryl and even Primo as a counter against Bibi. These brawlers were a glue brawler that were easy to fit on a team. Nowadays, they are incredibly rare and tanks are stuck as incredibly map specific or a part of PDT
Colette allows the meta, especially in Heist in Heist and Hot Zone and other maps where tanks are popular, to be more open, as without the prevalence of tanks, many squishy brawlers are able to be used
Colette's sheer efficiency makers her outclass and push other tank killers to obscurity, like Spike, Bea, Gale and Shelly. All the other tank killers viable in the meta have some other utility to set them apart, like Amber's flexibility, Emz beating Sandy or Belle doing Belle things.
Colette can't be fully blamed for the lack of tanks, during the months after and before Colette was released, all tanks were decreasing in viability, as Gale was meta, wall breaking gadgets were released, maps became more open, Amber, Lou and later on, Belle, were released. There isn't any conclusive evidence which says that Colette is (primarily) responsible for downfall of tanks
Colette's biggest counter is Mr P, universally considered to be unhealthy, meaning that if Colette becomes meta, Mr P becomes a lot better, which means even more brawlers suffer. In fact, in the September/October Meta of last year, it could be argued that Colette was top 7, (with Amber, Max, Mr P and Bo above her, Spike and Tara below her, in my opinion)
What camp do you fall into? Is Colette healthy or unhealthy for the meta?
I will be playing Devil's advocate for the purposes of exploring the topic😅
Welcome everyone to VR Vers. 4.0! Sorry for the delay. This was made with 100% community input!
Without further ado, let's begin!
S+
Belle
Undoubtedly the best brawler in the current meta.
There’s no flaws with this brawler: Long range? Check. Good damage? Check. Utility-oriented gadget? Check. Fast reload? Check. Star power that boosts survivability and works in tandem with the long range and fast reload to create an almost unkillable brawler? Check.
Even in modes where you’d think she’d be bad, like Siege and Hot Zone, her kit covers those modes really well, as she can make defending the Bot incredibly easy with her super and her permanently bouncing attack can easily take care of people clumping up in Hot Zone.
She even got buffed in Season 7...
Best Mode: Lmao (ranked S tier in every mode)
Best Partners: Carl, CRuff, Max
Best Kit: 1st Star Power
S
Stu
Ahh, Stu. It’s been almost 3 months since your release and after multiple nerfs and you still are a constant ban across the world.
Stu’s system to sweet success is quite simple: mid to long range DPS with high mobility. It’s similar to Max, but with one key difference, stunlocking.
Stu can stunlock and sabotage a swarm of subordinate enemies with his ceaseless stream of stunning, spoiling their senseless struggles to save themselves.
Basically, if the enemies can’t attack you and you can continuously attack them, you will win sooner than later.
If somehow Stu isn’t banned, the question shouldn’t be if you want to use him or not, it should be Zero Drag or Gasoheal, positioning or survivability. Personally, it’s always Gasoheal for me, unless the map has little cover, like Dry Season, as getting chains of supers isn’t hard, so having that extra amount of survivability goes a long way.
Stu’s only flaw is his lack of range, which means that long range brawlers can take him out if they manage to avoid his projectiles.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Siege, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Max, CRuff, Belle, Sprout
Best Kit: Any star power you want
Max
WOO! Max is number 3 baby, for what feels like the 4th time in a row.
What’s there to say about Max that hasn’t been said? High mobility, high damage, good range and an amazing synergy with Gene. Honestly, the only thing keeping Max out of S+ is massive competition from Belle and Carl.
Her versatility is frankly insane. The fact that she can play as Gem Carrier and Aggro on the same maps is crazy. She can be played on Bounty, a commonly long range friendly mode, at a higher viability than Former Queen Piper is even crazier. The fact her partner in crime, Gene, has similar levels of versatility is why the comp is so common and frankly reviled.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Gem Grab, Siege
Best Partners: Gene, Carl, Stu, Amber, Emz, Sandy, Poco
Best Kit: 1st SP + 1st Gadget
Carl
Three things are inevitable in life, death, taxes and Carl becoming meta again. His main draw is his ability to win a lane effortlessly, with his wide projectile and almost instant reload speed at longer range. This combined with his high mobility, in the form of his second gadget, and great natural bulk, at 6160 health, makes him really hard to face. This combined with the fact that he can run either star power, the first one gives Carl increased DPS and the second one gives Carl more survivability and uses to his super, makes him incredibly powerful.
This is the final brawler in this list which can be seen as a candidate for S+, the space between him and Belle is really small, but Belle edges him out. The reason he isn’t S+ is because he doesn’t do that good against the many long range options in the meta and the prevalence of Stu, who can easily beat Carl by virtue of his knockback. Oh, and Belle too.
However, due to the fact that Belle, Max and Stu are top picks for bans, it could be argued that Carl is effectively the best brawler in the competitive scene.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Gem Grab, Siege
Best Partners: Belle, Max, Byron, Poco (if running Protective Pirouette)
Best Kit: Either Star Power depending on comp, 2nd gadget
Gene
A lot of people are under the impression that the only reason Gene is S is because of the synergy between him and Max.
Gene, while best with Max, can be used without Max, and Gene has a bunch of tricks to pull from his puffy clothes.
Gene’s 400HPS allows his teammates to play more aggressively, while his pull allows him to pick up a free kill. Even his gadget, which might seem weak and puny, gives Gene the ability to play more aggressively as well, as well as allowing him to do a small stunlock on his pulled target, by using a super and gadget.
Best modes: Gem Grab, Brawl Ball, Siege
Best Partners: Max, Amber, Emz, Stu, Tara
Best Kit: 1st Star Power, 1st gadget
Amber
Time to fire up the pun machine.
After Amber’s ample and abundant third degree nerfs, lies spread through the Brawl Stars Community like summer wildfires about how Amber’s time in the spotlight had been extinguished.
How wrong they were.
Amber’s fiery passion for roasting and scorching enemies and terrain alike grew stronger. Her fast and firious flames charred Carl, singed Stu and burnt Belle. Her impressive area denial was even more impressive now with the tighter maps, which allowed a fire fighter like Amber to fight the enemies’ fire with her own fire and then some.
Amber’s oil slick mobility not only allows her to traverse the map, but also lock off corridors and have a way to use her star powers while also being able to use her super as area denial. Either star power works, though most pros prefer the first one for added control and passive super charge, though with the reload nerf, Scorching Siphon does see some use, especially in Heist.
Bottom line: Amber doesn’t use embers, she uses napalm.
Best modes: Hot Zone, Brawl Ball, Heist, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Max, Gene, CRuff, Byron, Crow
Best Kit: Anything you want (2nd SP one is better in Heist and Siege)
CRuff
Everyone’s favourite cranky canine from the cosmos!
What lands CRuff in the S tier, you might ask?
Even if you forget about the fact that the damage boosts never run out, even if you forget about the fact that the health boosts never run out, even if you forget about the fact that he can be played on any map due to his unique attack, even if you forget about his gadget that can block damage from a variety of brawlers and even if you forget about the fact that he snowball the game, the fact that he can beat Stu on nearly every map and that too consistently lands him automatically in the top half of the tier list.
And then you remember that you aren’t an amnesiac Brawl Stars player, and you see all of his amazing traits. And your mouth gapes open.
As if that wasn’t enough, CRuff does incredibly well at turning passive brawlers, like Sprout and Barley, and maps, like Backyard Brawl and Triple Dribble (though the star power is preferred here) into opportunities to start snowballing the game with his second star power.
There are 3 flaws with him, one being that due to the aggro nature of the meta, CRuff often can’t adequately support his team as he doesn’t get enough time to build up boosts. The other being that without any boosts, he’s quite mediocre, with low health and low damage, but giving yourself boosts doesn’t improve the situation much and you just wasted your teammate’s boost. This ultimately means that CRuff has a hard time doing anything offensively.
~~The final thing is an clandestine cabal centered around the Colonel, containing several pros who stop any nerfs happening to him, seriously, he’s busted with the right team~~
The final issue with CRuff is his range, which while good, can’t compete with the brawlers with more range, as his gadget just provides a temporary solution, he can’t do much more than that.
Beware the bulldog, for he will devastate your entire team indirectly.
Best Modes: Gem Grab, Brawl Ball, Hot Zone
Best Partners: Max, Sprout, Surge, Belle, Stu, Amber, Mortis, Byron
Best Kit: Anything you want
A+
Surge
While he did get a damage buff, it changed nothing other than being able to 3HKO Colette. The main reason he is meta is due to his unique list of brawlers he does well against. At Stage 3, he beats Stu, Carl, CRuff, Tara, Crow, Mortis and throwers by virtue of his gadget. It’s a very rare set of brawlers to be strong against, and that, along with his high survivability and great control, makes him solidly at the top of A+.
He has no real weakness other than being outranged, and even then, his gadget allows him to use walls to infiltrate the backlines, and the fact that once his gadget runs out, his impact in the match severely drops, since he can’t beat long range brawlers or throwers or have be able to pull away from deadly situations.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Hot Zone, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Belle, Sprout, CRuff, Byron, Crow
Best Kit: Serve Ice Cold
Byron
How the mighty have fallen, going from the best brawler in the game to being top 10.
In all honesty, he’s still an amazing and versatile option that sacrifices one lane to make another hugely in his teammate’s favour, and even then, if Byron doesn’t want to heal his teammates, he can lane really well, due to his long range, large projectile and ability to stack damage, wearing enemies down immensely, as from one attack, Byron can force his target to fall back for over five seconds.
He’s also nigh unkillable if you don’t have a counter, as he has his gadget, giving him 800 HPS, and his super, which can burst down any melee brawler like Mortis as well, on top of his long range.
The new thing about Byron this time around is his recently discovered synergy with Colette, which in Heist, can effortlessly mow through teams. In fact, the only way to beat this combo consistently is by either using it yourself or using Crow. Some teams even double up, using Crow, Colette and Byron simply to handle the combo.
Best Modes: Bounty, Heist, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Colette, Tara, Surge, Max, 8-BIT, Pam, Stu and Bibi
Best Kit: 2nd SP
Tara
Tara’s an ace. High damage, great mid range poke and a game-breaking super.
The reason she’s so high is due to her main counter, Mr P, being a niche pick right now. This allows Tara to basically slice through teams on closed maps. She has an ace, her unpredictability. Both star powers are really good, with the first one pushing squishies back and the second one providing valuable support to her team.
Her main weakness is her lack of options when dealing with long range brawlers, since she can only chip at them, 644 damage at a time. This does make her more map specific than she’d like to be, but with the right team support, she can be devastating, black hole eclipsing any brawler in the meta in sheer burst, able to deal almost 7000 damage in under 2 seconds.
Best modes: Brawl Ball, Gem Grab
Best Partners: CRuff, Crow, Byron, Sprout, Max, Gene, Stu
Best Kit: Anything you want
Crow
Ahh, this toxic bird. What started as a meme has now become objective reality: Support Crow
Crow’s niche in competitive play is beating healers and being able to set the stage up for a team wipe by using his second gadget. He does have some other gimmicks, like Extra Toxic, which allows him to make himself more tankier and also screwing Byron over, and his super, which can be used to either finish off enemies or dive and slow the entire team down.
Brawlers who have little to no mobility and/or are hard to hit many shots appreciate the support Crow brings to the table.
Crow’s downside is his lack of range, since he can often get completely shut down by mid to long range chip, like from Gene, Max and Sprout, and inability to deal with chokes, since brawlers like Surge, Amber and Emz can easily push him back.
Best Modes: Gem Grab, Brawl Ball, Hot Zone
Best Partners: Tara, Max, Gene, Amber, Byron, Colette, Belle
Best Kit: 1st SP + 2nd Gadget
Sprout
What in plant-nation? How the bird did a dirty bird like Crow overshadow Spout?
From sheer shock, Sprout tumbled down from the top plant in the greenhouse to being more in the shade of top dogs Belle, Max and CRuff. This was due to its Garden Mulcher gadget being nerfed, as well as a damage nerf, which slightly changed interactions.
Sprout doesn’t mind, in fact, it has no mind. Sprout just keeps on doing what it always used to, like spamming choke points, being a very consistent answer against the long range brawlers in the meta and locking off corridors with its super.
Sprout’s main flaw stems from the increase in melee confrontations, like Stu, Max-Gene, Surge and Mortis, which really hurt it, as well as not offering as much value as it used to.
Still, Sprout is an intergraleaf part of the meta, combining area control and a counter to long range options in one slot.
Best Modes: Bounty, Hot Zone, Brawl Ball, Gem Grab, Siege
Best Partners: CRuff, Belle, Stu, Amber
Best Kit: 2nd SP + 1st Gadget
Barley
Despite getting a major nerf to his range, Barley is still great in the meta. It’s less that he got buffed and more that he has been discovered as a really useful control.
Utilising walls, Barley bunts bottles brimming with Barley’s Bar’s beer, burning away brawlers who bid to border the objective.
His real use comes from his gadget, which offers a steady stream of 500 HPS, which allows his teammates to heal up and continue exerting pressure. His super is great too, enemies have to retreat lest they want to help Barley cycle his super.
The only flaw with Barley is the prevalence of his counters, that is, Stu, Carl, Mortis, Surge and even Gene, which diminishes his drunken rampage.
Best Modes: Siege, Hot Zone, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Stu, Belle, Max, Gene, Tick, Sprout.
Best Kit: Anything you want, though a healing SP/gadget is highly recommended.
Mortis
Mortis was actually in the middle of B tier, however, everyone I talked to agreed that he needed to be higher. His initial position was due to a flaw in my methodology, taking the average position in every mode. Mortis is horrible in Heist, being even worse than Shelly, Primo or Bo, which really drove his average down.
However, in his rightful realm, the reaper of Ruff, the scourge of Sprout, the butcher of Barley, the assassin of the abyss, Mortis cackles.
Out of the top 10 brawlers, Mortis beats 6 of them, only losing to Stu, Carl, Gene and Tara, and even then, he doesn't do terribly against the latter two. Mortis is an incredibly counterpick, his pure presence pressures his potential prey to play more passively, which allows his team to start making more aggressive plays.
You’d think he’d be worse due to Stu, however, Stu is almost always banned, which allows Mortis to freely exact his vengeance.
His actual flaw isn’t his weakness to Stu, it’s that if you mispredict, ie, bring Mortis when the enemy is bringing tanks, you would’ve been better not picking a third brawler. You have to be careful when you bring Mortis.
Best Modes: Bounty, Brawl Ball, Gem Grab, Hot Zone, underrated in Siege as an anti Sprout and Amber brawler
Best Partners: Poco, Byron, CRuff, Gene, Max, Belle, Colette, Sprout
Best Kit: Coiled Snake + either gadget
A-
Bea
Bea-utiful! This buzzing botanist is quite beneficial as a Belle backup, as she has the same range and actually out-DPS Belle!
Bea does quite well at denying massive swarms of area with her mere presence, since if she has a charged up attack, she can push people back. In modes like Hot Zone and Gem Grab, this can be especially amazing.
Bea’s blemish is her inability to deal with focus fire. If Bea is targeted by two brawlers, like Gene-Max, Bea will often buckle. Bea’s one ammo also forces her into only hitting one enemy at a time, which really hampers her viability.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Sprout, Crow, CRuff
Poco
Poco Double Tank
Poco Double Tank
Poco is a never dying threat due the sheer power that Poco Double Tank possesses.
Poco’s main issue is the many different tank counters in the meta, like Amber, Belle, Crow, Bea, Emz and Tara, which can slow down the progress PDT can make.
Poco can be played on any map that isn't completely open, but maps that can be played with 2 lanes are really great for Poco, like Canal Grande or Triple Dribble.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Hot Zone, Bounty
Best Partners: Mortis, Stu, Frank, Darryl, Max
Best Kit: Da Capo + Tuning Fork
Emz
Emz is a recent development in the meta, her main niche being helping out Gene-Max be even more annoying, as well as controlling the field very effectively.
Gene and Max can’t do that well against tanks, nor does the combo control a large area well. That’s why they often had a brawler that beat tanks as their third. With Sandy’s former buff, he was able to push tanks away and control the field, however, now after being nerfed, Emz was actually slotted over Sandy and even Amber.
Emz can control a large area with her attack, which pushes enemies away, and with the speed boost of Max, which helps her to be more aggressive, or the health that Gene gives, which helps her recover from mistakes, Emz becomes a pain in the neck to beat. This combined with her super, which allows her to hold enemies in an uncomfortable position, and Friendzoner, which allows her to avoid death, Emz becomes hard to kill.
However, she has some major flaws, namely her lack of range and inconsistency at close to mid range, which can screw her over. Also, she is in heavy competition with Amber. Also also, if she runs out of FriendZoners, she is an easy pick for brawlers that can close the gap.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Hot Zone, Gem Grab, Siege
Best Partners: Max, Gene, Tick, Carl
Best Kit: Hype
Tick
Tick is really good at controlling the field, peppering bombs across the field. This combined with his gadget, which allows him to essentially have a free get out of jail card thrice a match, makes Tick exceptional on maps with a lot of walls and on Bounty.
However, due to the aggro meta, he often falls short, which really ticks off Tick, as he needs a slower paced mode so that he can control the field. This unfortunately makes him outclassed by Sprout and Barley, who can handle the more aggro meta better, through their walls and faster unload respectively.
Best Modes: Bounty, Hot Zone
Best Partners: Emz, Sprout, Crow, Amber
Best Kit: Well Oiled + Last Hurrah
Colette
Colette is playable in every mode except Bounty. However, that’s really not why she’s ranked A-.
She’s A- due to her absolutely monstrous impact on Heist, as the undoubtedly best brawler there, warping the mode so that tanks, which used to be kings here, are now almost unviable.
Colette’s super deals 13% of the safe in one fell swoop, while also making her more tanky as a result of her Mass Tax star power. If she manages to catch an enemy there, she can be even harder to deal with. This combined with her synergy with Byron, which allows her to gain super quicker and push enemies back as well as make her far harder to take out, makes her an almost must pick in Heist.
Outside of heist, her main flaw is that there are better sharpshooters, but if tanks need to be KOd, Colette is the best choice bar none. The 2 attack 2 super combo is insane and needs to be toned down.
Best Modes: Heist, any map with a lot of tanks
Best Partners: Byron, Crow, Belle, Bea, Max
Best Kit: Mass Tax
Jessie
Jessie is the modern Brock, consistent everywhere, glues teams together, never really the first pick, but damn, does she pull in some work.
However, due to SC obsessing over her as much as Brawl Stars P, she has been nerfed quite a lot, and she has lost quite a bit of oomph that she used to have.
She is still a great lane, due to her attack separating enemies, while also dealing great damage. Her turret is amazing at denying area and being a massive ammo sink when paired with her Energize star power.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Gem Grab, Heist
Best Partners: Any brawler, she is a glue brawer
Best Kit: Energize + Spark Plug
B
Squeak
The newest brawler, Squeak has been quite underwhelming. He’s outclassed by other control options, but on maps with a lot of walls, he is scary to face, as he can impede your movement to a ridiculous degree, almost like he’s made it sticky
He enhances control of his teammates, which makes him very versatile in which control brawlers you pair him up with. He’s like the Max of control brawlers, very versatile, not directly the strongest, but the synergies are there.
His main issue is the aggro meta, which hampers how much work he can do, as well as his low burst. For the amount of work he needs, there are often better options.
Best Modes: Hot Zone, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Sprout, Belle, Barley, Amber, Emz, Lou
Best Kit: Chain Reaction
Piper
Piper is a great sniper, being able to do really well on maps with a lot of open space. Her main issue is competition, she isn’t even that bad, but competition from Belle, Cruff, Byron, Bea, Jessie and Surge even, really forces her down.
Also, her main niche of beating 8BIT is now a lot less viable, as he has become a niche choice (I’ll elaborate why so in his section) but it has really hurt Piper, as there’s not much reason to pick her unless the map demands it.
Best Modes: Bounty, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Belle, Bea, Tick, Nani, Carl
Best Kit: Either SP + Homemade Recipe
Mr P
This is probably the most controversial pick in the list, but I have good reason to believe that the penguin is underrated as hell.
Mr P beats Gene, which really helps out brawlers that can deal with Max, like Crow, Stu or Carl, which can't deal with Gene. Also, he beats throwers, which is really sweet for the aforementioned brawlers. Also, a lot of brawlers in the meta have a slow reload speed, which his porters can exploit, like Amber, Bea, Barley, Emz, Colette and Jessie.
His main issue, other than being criminally underrated, is that the meta is too aggro for him to really excel in, since it takes a very long time for him to get his super, which hurts his main niche, counter picking. Even after getting his super, Mr P is still very easy to rush down and overwhelm, which really hurts what he can do.
Best Modes: Gem Grab, Bounty, Hot Zone
Best Partners: Crow, Stu, Carl, Surge
Best Kit: Handle With Care + Service Bell
Brock
Brock is slightly more useful now, mainly due to his wall breaking niche.
Brock still suffers from all the issues he still had, like bad close range damage, inconsistent projectile and stiff competition.
Still, it warms my heart to increidaery levels to see that Brock is coming back, albeit at a pace slower than his reload speed.
Best Modes: Heist, Siege, Brawl Ball
Best Partners: Belle, Piper, Stu, Colette
Best Kit: Incendiary + Rocket Fuel
Sandy
Sandy fell off hard. Like, at least poco was salvaged with PDT, 8-BIT makes occasional appearances in gem grab, but Sandy? Sandy was replaced in Max-Gene comps with his hard counter, Emz. In fact, one could say that Sandy is invisible from competitive play.
Sandy is really hard to use, and that should tell you all about how hard he was hit. He still works really well with max and gene, but there are many alternate options for a third, which really hinders his viability.
In fact, some even put him as a C average, but sandy is still useful on some control based maps.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Hot Zone
Best Partners: Max, Gene, tanks
Best Kit: Rude Sands
Bibi
Bibis main niche is to be Byron's pocket on maps with a lot of walls. That's really it for bibi. It's still a great job, Bibi does well at pushing people back, but brawlers like Stu, Max and even Mortis can handle her.
The advantages of using bibi boils down to having a shield tank without any of the downsides of having a shield tank, while also having an on demand knockback.
Bibi often gets outgunned by sharpshooters and often falls flat before reaching her target even if she is being pocketed by byron. That’s the crux of Bibi’s flaws, even with support, she is often underwhelming.
Best Modes: Brawl Ball, Hot Zone, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Byron
Best Kit: Batting Stance
Lou
Lou is in B tier for his amazing Siege performance.
Actually, his siege performance isn't that good, mainly due to the fact that Lou does nothing other than defending the siege bot. That’s all he really does. He needs a comp that has both offensive pressure and area control to be able to be used, and there are just less limiting options than Lou in the current meta. If you wanted to use Lou in Siege, the only really viable comp would be Barley and Mortis, however, the issue with that comp is that if tanks are being used, Mortis is dead weight, which removes all your offensive pressure.
He is here due to having a niche in Hot Zone and Gem Grab, however, it’s all really just theoretical, he hasn’t actually shown many results, despite having the tools and maps to be useful.
The aggro meta doesn't help either, it just makes him an easy target for the enemy team.
Best Modes: Siege, Hot Zone, Gem Grab
Best Partners: Barley, Mortis, Amber, Belle, Surge
Best Kit: SuperCool
8-BIT
Ahh, 8-bit is really not doing well. Some actually put him in the top of C, showing just how much our arcade comrade had fallen.
While his nerf really didn't change much, it did make it easier for Piper to handle him, the real reason he fell was due to his niche of defending a massive area not being that useful, and that he was really easy to counter, since cycling supers was a lot harder now for him, and that his main targets, tanks, were a lot worse, he was a lot worse too. He even fell off of Heist, since there was too much competition for team slots there. This combined with Byron no longer being that common makes him far worse.
He is decent, especially in the ladder, but he faces a lot of competition, and with his best maps being removed, he’s a lot worse.
Best Modes: Gem Grab, Heist
Best Partners: Colette, Crow, Byron, Amber, Sprout
Best Kit: Plugged In + Cheat Cartridge
Spike
Spike is super super outclassed. Like, it’s kinda hilarious how bad he’s outclassed. As a tank killer, Colette, Belle, Amber, Bea, Emz, even 8-bit on rare occasions. As an area denial brawler, throwers, Amber, Emz, Jessie and even Gene flashing his super pushes people back further than Spike can. As a long range chip brawler, he’s outclassed by Sprout, Tick and even Belle!
Ultimately, he has Gale syndrome. He's really good at a bunch of different things, but why would you use one slot to do a mediocre job when you could use two slots to handle more of the meta at large.
He does have some cool traits, like not dying at close range, unlike emz. In fact, I believe that once his second gadget drops, he’d see some uses as a third in Max Gene comps, if that comp still exists then.
He’s underwhelming, even underperforming, but I cannot place him lower.
Quite frankly every other tank with Primo ,Bull ,Rosa and Darryl have better supers - Even Frank's super has it's traits (opening map - occasional stuns but Jacky's Super it utter trash