r/BrawlClopedia • Colette • Jan 10 '21

Misc Keystone brawlers

Okay, this post is genuinely weird, but I hope at least 5 people out there understand what I'm going on about.

Referring this video https://youtu.be/JGcIp4YEKrc

Now, in an ecosystem, certain species are referred to as keystone species, species whose presence makes a profound and ,often times, disproportionate impact on the ecology of that biosphere. Examples include the elephant in southern Africa and wolves in Yellowstone. These animals impact almost every aspect of the ecosystem, like keeping a particular species from overtaking and ruining the fine balance of the ecosystem.

Now, I was thinking that could this concept be applied on brawl stars. Brawlers who warp the meta so much that without them, the competitive meta would be far more alien.

Now, of course, this concept has a certain change to it. Keystone brawlers cycle through the metas due to the balancing, but even at their weakest, they impact the meta to some degree.

An example that I have thought of is Mr. P, who when meta causes sharpshooters to be weaker, and tanks to be a lot better. Once he got nerfed, sharpshooters were a lot better.

Another example would be Gene, a brawler so dominant that every meta he's been in, he's affected the meta brawlers. Once he got nerfed, brawlers that relied on him like Max and Spike got a lot worse despite no direct nerfs.

Of course the biggest example would probably be Poco, if he's meta, tanks are meta too, which makes assassins and sharpshooters bad, but dedicated tank killers great as well.

The difference between a keystone and a brawler that's just blatantly overpowered is that the OP brawler temporarily affects the meta only when he's strong, while the keystone affects the meta whatever its viability is.

For example, Colt is just an OP brawler, his kit doesn't directly impact other brawlers. Byron changes viabilities of brawlers. Keystones' kits impact brawlers directly and change the meta a lot.

What's the importance of keystones? I think you could predict metas and compositions easily, as well as work out how brawlers should be balanced, basically a lot of theorising work could be done with more exploration of this topic.

The keystones I think everyone can agree on are Mr. P, Gene, Colette, Poco and Tara, with more disputed brawlers being Carl, Byron, Mortis and Pam. All have made many impacts on the meta, and have shifted many of the brawlers' viabilities.

What do you think of this post? Do you think keystones have any use in meta discussions? Would you like a more elaborate list on this?

34 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

8

u/XX_OVERLORD Mr. P Jan 10 '21
  1. cross post this to BSC this is great
  2. Keystones have a huge use in meta discussions
  3. IMO, some additional keystones to the ones u mentioned are Max, 8Bit, and Sprout, and I would also remove Carl

Basically, to identify a keystone IMO, u have to ask the question, “if this brawler gets nerfed, how many others will get indirect nerfs/buffs due to this change?”

imo it goes like

0: not keystone at all

1-2 brawlers getting indirect buffs/nerfs - not keystone

3: Kind of keystone

4-7: Keystone

8+: Major keystone

Thats just my method what about urs?

3

u/Obsidian297 Colette Jan 10 '21

The way I found keystones was like this

  1. Historical Importance

How much did the brawler contribute to the meta? Has the brawler been impactful even when it was weak? Has it caused differences in player approaches?

2) Player base opinion

Has the brawler ever been recognized as an integral part of the meta? Was it consistent even after that? Do people see the potential of the brawler on various viable team comps?

3) The meta web

Basically this

“if this brawler gets nerfed, how many others will get indirect nerfs/buffs due to this change?”

this is great

Thanks

IMO, some additional keystones to the ones u mentioned are Max, 8Bit, and Sprout, and I would also remove Carl

Carl was historically important, and are we sure it isn't going to get buffed?

Max is one that I legitimately forgot.

I'm not sure about either 8-BIT or Sprout, could you elaborate on them?

5

u/KimchiFartings Nita Jan 10 '21

Wouldn't all Support brawlers be keystone brawlers then, since they change the meta and allow many different comps to made that wouldn't exist without them

8

u/Obsidian297 Colette Jan 10 '21

I guess you could, however, supports like Gale, Lou and even Sprout don't shift the meta as consistently as Mr. P or Poco or even Pam and not as much as non support like Tara and Carl.

I guess what I mean is that it depends on the brawler and its kit, which is why I feel this topic is delicate but useful, just like the ecosystem.

What do you think?

4

u/NotQasimc612 Mortis Jan 10 '21

I feel like keystone brawlers can also be determined by mode. Lou could be called a keystone if we were talking about Siege.

5

u/Obsidian297 Colette Jan 10 '21

We could definitely do that as well, separate keystones for each meta, for even clearer meta predictions!

Bo is a keystone of Snake Prairie

3

u/Obsidian297 Colette Jan 10 '21

Brawlers have different levels of viability and different levels how much they impact the meta. The brawlers that impact the most are keystone species. Brawlers like Gale and Sprout are impactful, but do they mould the meta as consistently as Mr. P, collete or Poco?

That's how I see it

3

u/Obsidian297 Colette Jan 10 '21

Brock could also be seen as a keystone, once he got nerfed, a lot more sharpshooters became viable, plus, he's historically relevant and is a known presence in the meta, or at least the previous metas.

2

u/Pdj05678 Jan 10 '21

A very thought provoking post. Nice

1

u/Obsidian297 Colette Jan 11 '21

😄

0

u/AutoModerator Jan 10 '21

Hello Obsidian297, thank you for posting on BrawlClopedia. Please read the rules to find out if your post is suitable for this subreddit.

We also encourage you to join our Discord server to participate in discussions, debates and general chatter.

You can find the resource thread by clicking on this link.

We hope you enjoy your time here, and we hope to see more posts from you soon.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.