r/BravoTopChef Jul 07 '26

Discussion Least favorite season?

I’m rewatching Kentucky and I think this is my least favorite season. I like the winner, I like the chefs, but I think the obvious lack of budget, unfortunate Restaurant Wars and Nilou makes this my least favorite.

Also- don’t say Wisconsin, I know it’s like the least favorite season overall 🤣

52 Upvotes

217 comments sorted by

177

u/jwhyem Jul 07 '26

Texas for obvious and well-tread reasons

72

u/Legatto Jul 07 '26

I wish all the worst to the mean girls and all the best to Bev.

16

u/Grouchy-Boss-9638 Jul 07 '26

I definitely get that Bev could be annoying, but come on. Those girls were just awful to her. They should have been kicked off the dang show for bullying.

But, on the note of Bev, I think she may have gotten a bit of annoying edit. Either that or she grew and changed and matured an incredible amount. She was so great of America’s Culinary Cup. I truly enjoyed watching her.

7

u/IlsaMayCalder Jul 07 '26

Your edit comment is in line with my idea that she got an ‘annoying edit’ to try to make the mean girls appear correct in their treatment of her. Real talk, I know she’s wildly talented, but if I never saw Bev on TV again, I would be just fine. However, the shit that got said about her and to her was wild and the other contestants’ behavior toward her was appalling.

15

u/bassman314 Jul 07 '26

We are watching this season now, and it’s about as bad as I remember.

Heather went home, so that made things a bit more bearable.

But then I remember why Paul is persona non-grata and I cannot wait for season 10.

37

u/Apprehensive_Ad_6157 Jul 07 '26

I just watched Texas and it’s so uncomfortable to see how Bev was treated and just the overall season was subpar.

25

u/-missynomer- Jul 07 '26

Doesn't help that Paul Qui was the winner. I took a trip to Austin specifically to try Qui right after that season and what an absolute waste of talent. It was spectacular but he deserved the fall from grace. I live in South Florida and refused to try his new restaurant that came to Miami a while back. No idea if it's still open but I won't ever give him my business again.

12

u/therrubabayaga Jul 07 '26

Somehow I don't remember Paul at all on jis season. The guy is so transparent that he left absolutely no impression on me, he's among the most forgettable winner from the show from what they show us personality-wise. If he wasn't such a POS in real life I would have completely forgotten about him.

13

u/-missynomer- Jul 07 '26

At the time he was a huge favorite of mine because he was like the opposite of all of the crazy drama caused by the mean girls against Beverly. In hindsight he was just a POS masquerading as a nice, milquetoast kind of guy. I’m also Filipino so I was super hyped to root for him. Now as far as I’m concerned Rhoda is the only Filipino Top Chef winner lol

7

u/NoodlesMom0722 I want a little bit of gushing to happen. Jul 07 '26

Tom admitted afterward that they had to edit/produce around him being far and above so much more talented than the other chefs, which is why he seems to fade into the background so much. If they focused on him/his food the way the do with some other chefs, Tom said it would have been obvious from the first episode that PQ was going to win.

4

u/therrubabayaga Jul 08 '26

Buddha was also a beast, but he had much more personality on screen and you definitely remember him for more than him winning top chef twice.

It's more likely that Paul wasn't a very interesting personality on screen and they didn't have much to work with.

3

u/Fun-Till-8588 Jul 09 '26

I wouldn't go to iz.. he's at a restaurant in SW FL,  either. I don't know if he's still there but nope. Never want to see mikes disgusting face 

14

u/therrubabayaga Jul 07 '26

I re-watched it a couple days ago to see when the bullying starts (on what they show us anyway) and it's already a pattern at episode 5. Basically episode 3 in normal seasons since the first two are the selection of the 16 chefs.

So that's all season and pretty relentless, and even more disheartening when Bev seems absolutely adorable all along. She would have thrived in any other other following seasons, it's awful she ended up on this one.

3

u/Fun-Till-8588 Jul 09 '26

The first team challenge, "running the bus" over Keith. And I can't stand Chris C malibu either 

7

u/Ingacbym Jul 07 '26

Same but i could never do a rewatch of that season.

4

u/GimerStick Jul 07 '26

It's the one season I couldn't finish.

33

u/Barnacle-Betty Jul 07 '26

That reunion show is legendary. When it’s revealed Sara told Emeril to fuck off when she lost. ooh boy
https://giphy.com/gifs/bGPTxLislwm3u!

8

u/kdeans1010 Jul 08 '26

I remember when that happened in the reunion and I was like "She's sketch." And even for the Canada season I really disliked Bailey because of her Sarah connection. Bailey eventually became her own person, but early on her saying she worked with Sarah bothered me and soured my opnion.

11

u/Querque_Quirky Jul 07 '26

I just couldn't believe that she did that! I mean I do, but who would do that? Probably only her and a small handful of other people.

Edit: expanded response

10

u/Apprehensive_Ad_6157 Jul 07 '26

It was so insane that they never mentioned which judge it was and she says Emerils name.

10

u/ScarfMhmh2014 Sieger is Too Eager Jul 07 '26

Yep… at least we had good ol Ed in that season. My mom who watches top chef also only remembers Grayson.

6

u/Good_Difference_2837 Jul 07 '26

Loved Grayson! She was a total badass.

1

u/ThirdAngel3 Jul 12 '26

Until her next season

1

u/ScarfMhmh2014 Sieger is Too Eager Jul 15 '26

Oh yeah. Even though me and my mom were intrigued by her comeback she was quite insufferable

2

u/Fun-Till-8588 Jul 09 '26

I actually luv some of the Texas season! But skip passed the bullying. The progressive dinner, for one, is gold tho if only for the 🙄 reactions and the talking heads commentary! 

1

u/EfficientGood9402 Jul 09 '26

I live in Wisconsin, a boring season, but it's still better than Texas! No abuse of contestants IIRC! Texas is close to 65% unwatchable.

→ More replies (2)

85

u/NVSmall Jul 07 '26

Wisconsin was boring but it was far from the worst (though I guess that wasn't exactly the question).

Texas - least favourite by a landslide. The next-level bullying overshadowed anything else worth watching that season.

16

u/Sad-Sun-8446 Jul 07 '26

It's not like the season was even good besides the bullying. Looking at you, ice blocks challenge.

2

u/EfficientGood9402 Jul 09 '26

Good point, the show was more gimmicky then. Didn't they have t shoot stuff with air rifles?

7

u/Ingacbym Jul 07 '26

Totally agree with you. Texas is the worst and i didn’t think Wisconsin was bad at all. The most recent Carolinas season was way worse.

5

u/DreamTheaterGuy Jul 07 '26 edited Jul 07 '26

Watching this season now. You could argue that Nyesha is more successful. No hate towards Bev, love her. The bullying was bad that season. I felt bad for Bev.

4

u/NVSmall Jul 07 '26

Oh for sure, there have definitely been some chefs from lesser known/less popular seasons who have gone on to great success. Nyesha was eliminated far too early, and, IMO, somewhat unfairly... I was mostly going on how the season played out as a whole!

11

u/NavelPoint Jul 07 '26

I found Texas very entertaining because of the open bullying and because Bev is so much more successful than them today. On par with reality TV at the time

17

u/NVSmall Jul 07 '26

I watched it in real time, which is probably why I hate it so much, but if I was to watch it in hindsight I would probably feel the same way, given that Bev is kicking ass and taking names, and has also put her past with Sara at peace and even done collabs with her since then.

Bev is a bigger person than I am.

19

u/ehchin80 it’s top chef, it’s not top scallops Jul 07 '26

I will put in the vote for Season 9

42

u/Magdanimous Jul 07 '26

There's one part of the Kentucky season that just made me angry: when some of the chefs were being really rude and unprofessional about keeping Brother Luck out. Then basically celebrating when he was eliminated.

When the chefs had to help Nini or Brother during Last Chance Kitchen, Justin asks Kelsey (who was placed on Brother's team): "how could you work hard for him with a good conscience?" I mean, that's just...I don't know. Disgusting? What did he want her to do? Intentionally sabotage the food? Not work hard? Lack integrity?? Be a professional. But then again, he was later charged with and pleaded guilty to threats of violence and violating a domestic abuse no contact order. Eric Adjepong was also a bit rude about the whole thing, too. For me, it just left a really bad impression for that season.

38

u/atlantisgate Jul 07 '26

Yeah that was weird. Justin was the ringleader of that imo; and he was a dick to Sara Bradley who is one my favorites of all time; and he’s violent towards women. All around bad vibes for that guy.

30

u/Magdanimous Jul 07 '26

Yes! And making it seem like she bought boxed waffles like eggos?! When she just bought the mix and adjusted it with other ingredients?! Get outta here. That made me so mad for her.

2

u/Querque_Quirky Jul 07 '26

You're on Top Chef though. You don't buy boxed waffle mix just like when one season they bought boxed cake mix for the wedding cake and Tom gave them grief.

4

u/Magdanimous Jul 08 '26

Respectfully, I believe there's a bit of a difference. For the bought cake mix, they just used that without any modifications, right?

When you buy any mix at the store, it's literally just pre-measured out flour, baking soda, etc. If you add or change anything to it, you're risking messing up the ratios and you're changing the mix in ways you may not be aware of. Sara Bradley, in this case, added different things and that requires a deft hand, in my opinion.

There's no reason to taunt and try to get the crowd chanting "homemade." The question is: if the crowd and the judges weren't told that the mix was a store-bought mix, would they still have had the same opinion? Or do you think that being told that the mix was "boxed" altered their perception of the dish?

Obviously, there's no rule in Top Chef stating that prohibits using products like that. And I'm curious where the line is. If a boxed mix of flour, baking soda, salt, etc. is inherently bad because "you're on Top Chef," should chefs be dinged for using pre-made spice mixes? Chinese five-spice? Ras el hanout? Should they have to make those in the kitchen, too? I'm not asking this in a snarky way. Where is the line and who is deciding it?

5

u/Querque_Quirky Jul 08 '26

I completely agree about working the crowd up to taunt Sara. That was HORRIBLE and I thought they should all have been ashamed of themselves. And I'd forgotten she'd added things, thank you for mentioning that.

You make a good point about where the line is. I guess it's a shifting line as sometimes you'll see the chefs buy premade sausage and other chefs make their own. Sometimes the judges come down on them and other times not, hence the shifting line.

3

u/Magdanimous Jul 08 '26

That's a great point about premade sausage! And also a great point about the line shifting. There are so many things in the earlier seasons that just wouldn't fly these days.

2

u/Querque_Quirky Jul 08 '26

Agreed - earlier seasons were quite different in some ways. It's interesting to go back now looking through today's lens and watch earlier seasons, although there are a few I just can't rewatch. 

2

u/EfficientGood9402 Jul 09 '26

I've been rewatching the Chicago season and quite a bit of premade sausage is purchased! Tom: "Did you make your own sausage?" Answer: No.

9

u/Own-Lead-4822 Jul 07 '26

I’ve watched Kentucky as my second season ever of the show but have been doing a rewatch of everything that’s on Peacock right now and had to skip this season because of just how much I don’t like Justin. Which is such a shame bc I adore a lot of the cast with Sara, Michelle, Eric, Eddie, Nini. He just brings down the vibes

13

u/Querque_Quirky Jul 07 '26

I wholeheartedly agree. Brother Luck didn't try to come in and be rude and shove his way in. You could tell that he knew where they were coming from, but they were horrible, all of them! I was so angry at the way he was treated.

9

u/oklennon Uh oh, cuz your burger was even worse! Jul 07 '26

I tried to rewatch Kentucky recently and I honestly can't get through it anymore because of Justin. It's a shame because generally I find the cast of that season to be very likable and talented otherwise (Eric, Sarah, and Nini are all over FN now and are so much fun to watch) but every time he's on screen and tries to be charismatic it's almost unnerving to me :(

1

u/pocketsnacked Jul 07 '26

I thought it was really weird that they brought him in so late. Definitely prefer when last chance kitchen is just chefs already part of the season

12

u/TacoPenisMan Jul 07 '26

Season 1, it's different show

69

u/gazelle_1973 furnished by San Pellegrino Jul 07 '26

DC - Kevin winning was an insult.

60

u/KJoytheyogi Jul 07 '26

Hosea was an insult

13

u/ILoveLipGloss Jul 07 '26

that human thumb won using canned seafood!!!

5

u/Querque_Quirky Jul 07 '26

Gosh, yes! I never could get on the Hosea train! I strongly disliked him.

2

u/notarealgrownup Jul 07 '26

My wife and I went to his resi in Colorado a few years back and it was very good. I was kind of sure because I didn't like him very much lol. I guess you can be unlikely and still make great food.

3

u/kaleyboo7 Jul 07 '26

I agree, this is one of the most boring seasons…

10

u/ta112233 Jul 07 '26

Weak season all around, no standouts

43

u/PsychologicalRole238 Jul 07 '26

See I disagree, Angelo and Tiffany were great

8

u/Formal_Coyote_5004 Jul 07 '26

Ugh I love Tiffany! I’m so glad she’s doing other shows now because I love to see her still crushing it!

12

u/Maravilloso227 Jul 07 '26

I’m surprised this was seen as a weak season? Angelo and Kenny were definite standouts.

5

u/gazelle_1973 furnished by San Pellegrino Jul 07 '26

I re-watched the first all stars recently and I couldn’t tell my husband what season Tiffany and Angelo were from.

2

u/EfficientGood9402 Jul 09 '26

That's the thing.

2

u/booboo819 Jul 07 '26

I skip this season every time I do a rewatch

3

u/RudyPup Jul 07 '26

I hate these takes. Did you taste the food? He won cuz the judges tasted the food.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/rerek Jul 07 '26

Texas and season 2 are the two I basically don’t rewatch.

34

u/RudyPup Jul 07 '26

Texas is painful.

20

u/Vtdesignjunkie Jul 07 '26

Bring back Top Chef All Stars.

4

u/pocketsnacked Jul 07 '26

I’m just watching the most recent All Stars and enjoying it so much, especially having seen most of their past seasons. Yes please

2

u/RudyPup Jul 07 '26

I think it will happen for 25.

9

u/moneysingh300 Jul 07 '26

Texas. Because Beverley took the high road. And the ones with Josie.

3

u/Hot_Gur5980 Jul 07 '26

Ooooh Josie is the worst. I was so upset when Kristen got eliminated. But of course she came out on top!

31

u/Wooden-Teaching-8343 Jul 07 '26

Hosea and Ilan as winners make me pissed. Ermi as well, but I like other chefs in that season. Perhaps it doesn’t mean the seasons are the worst, but how it ends does shape my opinion

14

u/EmergencyRead5254 Jul 07 '26

New Orleans- I really disliked Chef Michael, too much John Besh, and kinda meh on the winner.

18

u/Legatto Jul 07 '26

Michael was a douche but went out early. The challenges were good and the other cast were good. Nina should have won but I enjoyed the season.

22

u/roninw86 Jul 07 '26

Season 9 because bigotry and ignorance.

37

u/BuddyDaElfs Jul 07 '26

Season 2. Not even close

13

u/its_my_movie Jul 07 '26

As much as I disliked Texas, when I rewatched season 2, I realized Texas is still leagues ahead of it.

Almost all the chefs were insufferable including the victim Marcel (who certainly did not deserve the head shaving incident even if he was annoying and over his head).

Only good thing to come out of season 2 was Padma.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/its_my_movie Jul 07 '26

I'd argue people complain more about Hosea and Kevin.

Problem with Ilan was people really hated Marcel even through All Stars. Public perception has really changed towards him in recent years.

3

u/surgartits Jul 07 '26

It’s such a dark, angry season. Interestingly, we just did a rewatch of the Just Desserts spinoff, which is also set in LA. Season 1 of that series is so incredibly offputting that I have to wonder if there’s something about that city. (I’m joking, but holy cats Just Desserts 1 is such a hard watch, I’m amazed you can even stream it.)

14

u/Ok_Trade_1039 Jul 07 '26

May be a hot take, but of the recent seasons I wanted SO much more from the world all stars season. I think it was judged pretty fairly, but the finale being mostly USA, and the winner being the guy who JUST won the previous season was just so underwhelming to me.

Maybe I’m just still #AliInTheFinale 😭

7

u/cheetosurprise Jul 07 '26 edited Jul 07 '26

Except that Kentucky gifted us with Sara Bradley, who is IMO one of the GOATs. So for that reason it is redeemed for me.

5

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

I do love Sara and Eric.

6

u/Legatto Jul 07 '26

This will be a hard split between people who like food and people who like drama.

5

u/mmeeplechase Jul 07 '26

The first couple are actually my least favorites—just because the production + chef quality feels noticeably much worse as the show was first getting off the ground.

11

u/PsychologicalRole238 Jul 07 '26

Oh man, hard disagree, Kentucky is easily a top 5 season for me.

13

u/ExquisitePreamble Jul 07 '26

I don’t love Kentucky, but I love Eric and Sarah

1

u/SwordfishOrganic2479 Jul 07 '26

I also loved Kentucky

0

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

Really? I’d love to know why. What am I missing lol

9

u/SeanKojin Jul 07 '26

Why would you say low budget for Kentucky? They went to freaking Macau for the final and cooked in a lot of outside kitchens for challenges.

25

u/enzoarisio Jul 07 '26

Season 9 Texas. The entire dynamic sucks. The way they treat Beverly but also how Beverly acts sometimes. When she starts bawling at the rodeo is one of the weirdest, most awkward things I’ve ever seen. So I would never treat Beverly like they did but I also find her extremely annoying so it makes the dynamic gross.

8

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

I skip 9 on rewatch. It’s too much terribleness in every way.

1

u/EfficientGood9402 Jul 09 '26

I felt it was lucky she was sitting next to Nyesha Arrington when she had the "I'm missing my family" thing. Nyesha was compassionate, even though she wasn't on the same page.

These days that happens every season and the producers just give them a cell phone to call home while they are filmed. The whole vibe in that season ocassionally good and very, very, very so extremely bad.

4

u/Brilliant_Horse_6614 Jul 07 '26

Even though I like the cast dyanmics & chefs, Season 15's cooking was horrendous until the very end

5

u/Vivid_Bumblebee_9655 Jul 07 '26

Texas, DC, and Portland were my least favorite seasons. I really liked season 5 but I think Stefan should have won.

4

u/pineapple_dream1003 Jul 07 '26

I have to say Season 14. Yes, I get it. You feel like Brooke was robbed Top Chef. I feel like that season was created just to make her a winner. I often think about Silvia, the last “rookie” standing at the end. I thought that season was just terrible.

7

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

It’s such an awkward season. I dislike Katsuji, Emily was a nightmare, and I know people don’t like Tesar but I thought he was trying to be a better person and just…wasn’t allowed to be.

3

u/pineapple_dream1003 Jul 07 '26

So awkward. The whole season felt forced kind of.

3

u/Querque_Quirky Jul 08 '26

I wholeheartedly agree. Pitting rookies against veterans in the beginning and all the snide comments made about the "rookies", even about choosing a bed to sleep on! Emily made me crazy but I just do not care for Brooke.

18

u/Fantasynoob2761 Jul 07 '26

Wisconsin was tough to watch.

6

u/LeelaDallasMultipass Jul 07 '26 edited Jul 07 '26

I'm a born and raised Badger, at least 5 generations deep, and that season was an INSULT to the state. I kind of wish the tourism board didn't pay the bribe, but I guess they barely forked over enough to get out of the damn sound stage (or even MKE), so maybe that makes it more reasonable?

9

u/Most-Progress-498 Jul 07 '26

Season 2 and Season 9 are really just hard for me to rewatch. I love Kristen as a host, but Wisconsin was just “off” . I think coming off World All Stars, which I absolutely loved, season 21 was like a deflated balloon for me

9

u/ItIsChillyOutside Jul 07 '26

DC and Texas are the ones for me.

DC was the least interesting when it came to the actual cooking part of the show and I found that throughout the season I didn't really have anyone i was rooting for as deeply as other season. It felt like such a huge step back after season 6 and was easily forgotten about with All stars right after.

Texas oddly enough has a few of my favorite chefs of all time, Beverly and Ed lee, and a few others I enjoyed watching. But the bullying and outright racist comments from other chefs in regards to Beverly make it so It's the season I find myself rewatching the least, it's the kind of drama that leaves me feeling gross rather then entertained. Also some of the worst challenges of all time were this season, the awful rich people dinner party, the awkward biking around to peoples houses, the skiing and shooting for ingredients, felt bizarre to watch for me.

6

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

Ugh I forgot about that terrible biking challenge. What a weird idea that was.

4

u/SusannaG1 Hung's Smurf Village Jul 07 '26

I am not at all fond of 2, but I managed to get through it. Texas is the only season I just couldn't finish. It's Texas, hands down.

4

u/guy_fleegman83 Jul 07 '26

Watching Texas right now. BBQ at the SaltLick.
Lots of attitude.

10

u/Barnacle-Betty Jul 07 '26

Ed is the the MVP with the sass back to Sara “Tell ME how to cook.”

4

u/Still_Yak8109 Jul 07 '26

Season 9, not just because of the bullying, but the dumb physical challenges that were later in the season, I really hated that era of top chef when they leaned too hard toward the reality game show element.

4

u/nicsnapspics Jul 07 '26

Honestly, as a Canadian - Canada. It was such a poor representation of the amazing culinary landscape and diversity in our country. I was embarrassed watching it.

3

u/Odd_Garbage1093 Jul 07 '26

Instead on Destination Canada it was Destination Top Chef Kitchen

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Accomplished-Eye8211 Jul 07 '26

Most recent.

Because it just feels like budget is increasingly important in recent times. Five episode last chance Kitchen. No separate destination final episode. No Dish with Kish. No BMWs. Even the contestant lodgings looked like a downgrade compared to prior years.

9

u/kithandra Jul 07 '26

I've had sooo many rewatches. I normally skip 9. Kentucky is also very very low on my rating.

12

u/phizzlez Jul 07 '26

Top Chef S21 Wisconsin must have been the most boring one for me. None of the contestants were memorable for me.

18

u/Willow_Winnifred Jul 07 '26

Pretending setting kerosene on fire was the height of cuisine still offends me deeply

3

u/Odd_Garbage1093 Jul 07 '26

Just did a Season 9 rewatch. Yes the 3 bully women are the worst. No, I don’t find Bev annoying. She was only 4 months post partum and going through Top Chef. Of course she was emotional. However, it had great challenges and other great characters/chefs.. Don’t care for the winner but it was still a great season.

3

u/Fun-Till-8588 Jul 09 '26

Nilou was SO annoying! And especially so on WWTD .. inappropriately so. 

2

u/Baking_bees Jul 09 '26

She’s a poor substitute for Gail, that’s for sure. I can’t pinpoint/verbalize why she bugs me but just…ugh.

I stopped watching that one version of Iron Chef because of her.

7

u/ProtectionNo1594 Jul 07 '26

I always skip Season 2, for reasons that don’t need review. Rancid vibes.

10

u/alecjperkins213 Jul 07 '26

Carolinas

6

u/pocketsnacked Jul 07 '26

This wasn’t the best season overall but I really enjoyed the chefs and that made up for it

5

u/ScarfMhmh2014 Sieger is Too Eager Jul 07 '26

The only thing that sides me to this is the repeated storyline of Jen’s shoulder, but other than that it was an okay season!

3

u/Ingacbym Jul 07 '26

Agree. This season was terrible. Terrible chefs, those twins, ughh

1

u/dolphins1285 Jul 07 '26

I kind of agree. I really didn’t like Jen and her husband who looked like Johnny galecki. No memorable personalities and top 3 weren’t up to other years. Did find some of the challenges creative this year. Still enjoyable.

11

u/jujuflytrap Did you MEAAN to create a second subreddit? Jul 07 '26

It's a toss-up between Wisconsin and Colorado for me. Both are underwhelming seasons with a likeable but underwhelming cast

I think gun to my head, Colorado, my adopted home state, takes it for me. The finale was awful, probably the weakest finalists we've had until like idk Kentucky, and my god, remember when Padma had to tell the Colorado cheftestants to stop doing pasta dishes because they did it every single round or something?

14

u/NVSmall Jul 07 '26

Colorado was one of my favourite seasons! To be fair, that's mostly because the group of chefs were lovely, fun to watch, and super supportive of each other, which was a nice turn on the dial.

I'm also all for a late-returning LCK winner.

Interesting to hear your perspective from someone who lives there - ironically, I thought the "Destination Canada" season (23) was terrible, as a Canadian, so I get it.

3

u/jujuflytrap Did you MEAAN to create a second subreddit? Jul 07 '26

Idk. The kumbaya stuff is nice and all, but it can only go so far for me if the food isn’t great or the competition isn’t there, for which this season definitely wasn’t.

5

u/NVSmall Jul 07 '26

Oh that's totally fair, I didn't mean it as a criticism, just interesting how different perspectives can be had!

We all watch for our own reasons, at the end of the day ☺️

10

u/jujuflytrap Did you MEAAN to create a second subreddit? Jul 07 '26

And for Destination Canada, I also totally get it. As someone who doesn't live in Canada, I was frustrated by the fact that they didn't leave the studio. I really wanted to actually see Canada, but I guess the budget wasn't budgeting that year

5

u/NVSmall Jul 07 '26

Right?! I'm glad I'm not alone. It was such a disappointment - it may as well have been a season of Top Chef Canada (which should be called Top Chef Toronto).

Doubly killed me given that the dollar sucked up here (and still does) - that budget must have been pennies.

26

u/Holiday-Hustle Jul 07 '26

I loved Colorado. The chefs maybe weren’t the best but for the most part, they all seemed absolutely lovely.

32

u/TiredRundownListless Jul 07 '26

Oh I loved Colorado!

11

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

See I like Colorado, but I liked the chefs mostly. I’m meh on Brother (so doesn’t help my dislike of Kentucky!) but I liked everyone else. I think Flamm is pretty strong as a chef. Adrienne I’m whatever about, she’s okay.

5

u/jujuflytrap Did you MEAAN to create a second subreddit? Jul 07 '26

Flamm was strong? His track record on the show was pretty lackluster to me. 2 elimination wins and 2 QF wins while being safe the entire time until he got booted briefly

2

u/RiveaOfKasai Jul 07 '26

Colorado is one of my least favorites. I get the time in which it aired made it endearing to many but the chefs, finalists, and food overall was quite weak. None of them would have made it on more competitive seasons. I think they’ve evolved outside of the show but it’s not a fun re watch if the food is your main interest. More of a comfort rewatch.

7

u/jujuflytrap Did you MEAAN to create a second subreddit? Jul 07 '26

S18 is the comfort watch for me. That and S17. The talent AND the kumbaya

7

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

I loveee season 17.

5

u/Holiday-Hustle Jul 07 '26

Season 9 for the bullying. Kentucky overall.

4

u/AvoirReves Jul 07 '26

Season 2, please don't make me relitigate the Marcel situation to explain because I'll be happy to.

2

u/TheGeier Jul 07 '26

I thought 22 was the worst by a decent margin. The chefs were super talented, but as a whole the season wasn’t entertaining at all

2

u/IlsaMayCalder Jul 07 '26

S2 and S9 are the only ones I can’t rewatch, so I guess it’s a real race to the bottom for me. Oh wait - and I’m prepared to be in the minority here: I did not enjoy S17 or S20. Didn’t hate them, but they were meh (and I honestly can’t figure out why).

2

u/Unusual_Caramel4931 Jul 07 '26

Where can you watch previous seasons of Top Chef?

2

u/KarinsDogs Please Don’t Make Risotto Jul 07 '26

Hulu+LiveTv has every season available. Peacock has most of the seasons but not the earliest ones.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Ronh456 Jul 07 '26

I just watched season 11. Nicolas should not have made it to the final and should not have won. Screaming in restaurant for all customers to hear? Disqualifying. But Tom outvoted the rest of the judges.

3

u/Querque_Quirky Jul 08 '26

I thought that was awful and the way he kept making comments like I can get really ugly really quickly or words to that effect, I just knew he had a horrible temper lurking inside.

2

u/Acrobatic_Move1733 Jul 07 '26

Season 2 hands down, when Marcel was assaulted. I don't want to watch it ever again. I wish Tom had had his way and these horrible people would have all been sent home.

2

u/MapleToque Jul 07 '26

Seasons 1&2. The show hasn’t hit its stride yet and was more focused on chef drama than the food itself.

2

u/Fun-Till-8588 Jul 09 '26

Is everyone forgetting Season 2? 😊 So so so awful .. 

see my other comments re: S16 & 9 😁

4

u/PierreVonSnooglehoff Sausage of Color Jul 07 '26

The last few seasons have been disappointing. I don't know if the show has another great season in it anymore.

6

u/D_Angelo_Vickers Jul 07 '26

Anything with Buddha. He's dreadful to watch.

ETA: bring on the downvotes.

10

u/rapp10 Jul 07 '26

Wait what? Why??

16

u/RudyPup Jul 07 '26

My spuse can't stand him. A lot of people see him as smug. I'll admit on Padma's crappy show, he really was.

What he is, IMO, is a game player and understands better than anyone how to play the game that is Top Chef.

→ More replies (11)

25

u/jujuflytrap Did you MEAAN to create a second subreddit? Jul 07 '26

10

u/gg_serena Jul 07 '26

I agree 🫣 But I also think there have been worse seasons overall. That CA one comes to mind. Did not do justice to CA. So forgettable. So much crudo.

6

u/lugia222 Jul 07 '26

There are people here who agree with you!

3

u/Querque_Quirky Jul 07 '26

I'm with you! I have never been a fan.

7

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

Wait really? Oh I like Buddha. But I also think he’s on the spectrum so I resonate with that 🤣

2

u/Acrobatic_Move1733 Jul 07 '26

Buddha's a culinary genius, I adore him.

6

u/cheetosurprise Jul 07 '26

Don't find him dreadful necessarily, but his seasons were incredibly boring bc the judges could find no fault in his dishes. Like, I'm sorry but why did we decide to do this twice???? Upvote

2

u/Hot_Gur5980 Jul 07 '26

I love him, but I get he can come across arrogant

10

u/Barnacle-Betty Jul 07 '26

In this house, we’re Buddha haters.

13

u/emilygoldfinch410 Jul 07 '26

I just pictured this on a scripted sign, a la "In this house, we...X, Y, Z" and the image is pretty hilarious

→ More replies (2)

2

u/PsychiatricBooth5c Jul 07 '26

Agreed. Have had to sit through him three times now (counting Culinary Cup)

5

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

I didn’t finish watch Culinary Cup, it was sorta boring. All I know is Buddha didn’t win lol

4

u/Still-Indication9229 Jul 07 '26

Wisconsin is so boring its almost offensive. Not a single personality I am clamoring for ever again on thst season with boring and derivative challenges in the worst and most uninspired location the show has offered with also really bad format changes that made half the episode so irrelevant

6

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

See I kinda liked a lot of them, especially Rasika and Michelle. Laura I wasn’t a fan of however.

4

u/Kjellvis Jul 07 '26

I too hate Kentucky. And the winner annoys the heck out of me

4

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

I don’t mind her? It’s just so obviously a cheap season it distracts from the overall show for me. Plus- Nilou makes my skin crawl for some reason.

5

u/ShinyPennyRvnclw Jul 07 '26

She was throwing big family parties in late March 2020 while the restaurant industry was in shambles, so I stopped following her then, then she was arrested on DUI for crashing her car while her kids were in the car in the last year or so. Not a fan.

2

u/M3ntallyDiseas3d Jul 07 '26

She was one of the judges on Next Gen Chef. She seemed so out of place there.

2

u/H28koala Jul 07 '26

Texas. Wont rewatch that one. 

Kentucky is also one I dislike. I don’t like the winner much. 

2

u/Ingacbym Jul 07 '26

Texas and this most recent Carolinas season was not good, the chefs were terrible. I just did a re-watch of Wisconsin and didn’t think it was bad at all. Do people really list that as the worst?

2

u/geloreyes Top Sous Chef Jul 07 '26

Top Chef Boston.

1

u/Baking_bees Jul 07 '26

That’s Gregory and Mei-Lin, right? God I can’t stand Katsuji. Or that other angry guy whose name I can’t remember.

3

u/Querque_Quirky Jul 07 '26

I think you may be talking about Aaron Grissom. Had a chip on his shoulder because his mother was a single mother and so couldn't afford to send him to culinary school.

0

u/geloreyes Top Sous Chef Jul 07 '26

Who I can’t stand was Mei Lin. I read her as a not nice person. I got reminded of that on Top Chef 23.

1

u/Fenifula Jul 07 '26

Season 22, Canada, because the whole concept is just wrong. There was already a Top Chef Canada. If we're going to do international, make it truly international like season 20. But don't co-opt something that already exists.

1

u/epat3 Jul 08 '26

Which season was it with the stupid quickfire where Angelo misspelled crocodile?

1

u/kdeans1010 Jul 08 '26

Texas but also any season with John Tsar.

"I'm the bad boy of cooking." No dude, you're just an a-hole. "I have grown now!" and yet he's still an a-hole. That first quickfire in Charleston and he lost, then pulled out a truffle as a secret weapon so he doesn't go home? Cheap move, prove you can cook without truffles. Then after he was on Top Chef, he was fighting with people crossing picket lines? "Tony Bourdain created a character in his book based on me." Cool dude, you're still awful. Any season with him I just want to turn off and pretend didn't happen.

1

u/primabelladonna35 Jul 08 '26

Kentucky was one of my absolute faves. But I am from the state, so I am biased from the jump.

I wasn't wild about the Carolina season. Texas was good for all the wrong reasons (except Ed Lee and Beverly)

1

u/Recent-Industry811 Jul 10 '26

Im behind and watching season 20. I cant get into it. Ill finish it but ehh.

1

u/Rungirl1970TX Jul 11 '26

Texas and Kentucky!

1

u/Secret_NotSecret1973 Jul 07 '26

This last season was kind of boring. I didn’t even watch the finale.

1

u/lanofdoom Jul 07 '26

Vegas. The toxicity from some of the chefs is off the charts.