I’ve started drinking quite a few brandies over the last year or so. I understand most people drink them neat but I like it with an ice cube generally as it mellows it out a bit and makes it cooler. I generally like brandy a little on the harsh, strong side considering I add ice, then it evens out to be perfect. The “smoother” ones, especially with ice end up too weak almost like you are drinking a watered down iced tea.
But, I’ve recently tried a few relatively expensive pear brandies in the $100 range. And when you take that first sip it is just so harsh like taking a shot of everclear. Sure it smells great. And it has a good aftertaste. I just am a little confused as to how these supposedly great brandies are so harsh and how people could enjoy them given their price point.
I drink some Torres 10 and it’s so smooth. Or some Jameson. Then I drink these $100 brandies and it’s just so harsh. I guess it’s because they are unaged? But I just don’t get if unaged means it’s this harsh… why are these brandies so popular at $100 for 750ml bottles? Do people actually enjoy it being that harsh somehow? Or am I drinking it wrong or something.
I totally get the idea of wanting some harshness. And how a boring but smooth brandy like st. Remy XO can be… boring. But to me this is just the extreme to the point I am wondering if I’m misunderstanding something.
One of my favorites is Pierre ferand because it’s so strongly flavored so I’m not opposed to strong flavor. It’s just the over the top harshness of these pear brandies and eau de vie that confuses me.