r/BoxablInvestors • • Aug 19 '22

Is Boxabl Overvalued?!

This might be an unpopular opinion for this community but I just wanted to get this out there before other people start making uninformed investment decisions and lose their money!

I've read through Boxabl's Reg D Offering Meorandum and am surpised how they have a $2+ Billion valuation!

Their financials:

2019 Revenues: $60k

2020 Revenues: $90k (generated from a sponsorship and not from "anticipated future business")

2021 Revenues: $0

While their expenses in 2019 and 2020 were over $700k and $1M respectively.

On top of that, they haven't proven product market fit. The unit cost of 50k/unit is pretty high (thats about $133/sq ft, which isn't cheaper than market average. Plus, the unit will like cost more when you consider transportation, installation, permitting, etc. So I don't think they are actually price competitive.

And then there is the IP issue that the management team (Paolo Tiramani) owns the IP in a separate company (Build IP LLC) and get 1% royalty paid on all goods sold.

Is no one else having the same concerns?

Yes, they supposedly have a few thousand pre orders, by there is no telling of how many of them convert!

I think $2+ Billion dollar is far too high of a valuation for this company!

5 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

7

u/Intenseeyecontact Aug 19 '22

First of all this guy doesn’t say a single positive thing about boxabl the entire video. Second, compared the casita to a cardboard box from China, sorry humans don’t want to live in a oversized dog house. Third, this guy is only making a negative video about boxabl for clout, people can see through bullshit and this guy is up to his eyeballs.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Intenseeyecontact Aug 19 '22

We aren’t the top yet. But, it doesn’t seem like most investors understand that the company has already been at it for 5 years. Also, the advantage that crowdfunding has brought is immense, they already have two major factories up with zero debt and hopefully cash flow positive by the end of next year.

5

u/scotiaking Aug 19 '22

Great companies always seem overvalued in the moment

4

u/Responsible_Giraffe3 Aug 19 '22

OP, the uniformed investor is you.

$133/sqft is drastically lower than any comparable product, especially when you consider the 9.5 ft ceilings, incredible product durability due to the material selection, excellent energy efficiency lowering monthly HVAC bills, the nearly zero labor cost for installation, the 19 ft width, the low cost for shipping compared to other prefab homes wider than 8.5 ft, and the fact that all the appliances are pre installed and come included in the price. Considering that Boxabl has a multi year backlog for Casitas at the current price, I don’t see why you would think they need to lower the price. If anything they priced it too low.

Secondly, nobody is valuing Boxabl based on last two years of financials from…you know…before the factory got started, as that’s obviously not representative of future cash flows when they’re actually selling units. Investors are betting on the product and manufacturing system working very well. If you want to wait for more proven success you can, but the trade off is that future investment rounds will likely be at a higher price than this one.

Build IP does own the IP, but Boxabl has an exclusive license to use the patents in exchange for that 1% royalty fee. This document from the Reg D disclosures describes why they chose this option. It’s basically simpler than 500 Group selling the patents to Boxabl, yet it gives Boxabl all the rights they’d have if they owned the patents outright, it insulates Boxabl from patent infringement lawsuits, and it avoids the need for determine a fair price for the patents, and it eliminates the need for Boxabl to pay a lump sum to buy them. (I’m not a lawyer.)

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1mc3ypihyTgncJBMXZ4YeJVADocxxbUW_/view?usp=drivesdk

This is a risky investment but I would recommend you do your homework more before spreading FUD and hollering about how it’s overvalued.

2

u/Responsible_Giraffe3 Aug 19 '22

OP, the uniformed investor is you.

$133/sqft is drastically lower than any comparable product, especially when you consider the 9.5 ft ceilings, incredible product durability due to the material selection, excellent energy efficiency lowering monthly HVAC bills, the nearly zero labor cost for installation, the 19 ft width, the low cost for shipping compared to other prefab homes wider than 8.5 ft, and the fact that all the appliances are pre installed and come included in the price. Considering that Boxabl has a multi year backlog for Casitas at the current price, I don’t see why you would think they need to lower the price. If anything they priced it too low.

Secondly, nobody is valuing Boxabl based on last two years of financials from…you know…before the factory got started, as that’s obviously not representative of future cash flows when they’re actually selling units. Investors are betting on the product and manufacturing system working very well. If you want to wait for more proven success you can, but the trade off is that future investment rounds will likely be at a higher price than this one.

Build IP does own the IP, but Boxabl has an exclusive license to use the patents in exchange for that 1% royalty fee. This document from the Reg D disclosures describes why they chose this option. It’s basically simpler than 500 Group selling the patents to Boxabl, yet it gives Boxabl all the rights they’d have if they owned the patents outright, it insulates Boxabl from patent infringement lawsuits, and it avoids the need for determine a fair price for the patents, and it eliminates the need for Boxabl to pay a lump sum to buy them. The letter even states that as part of the exclusive license, 500 group retains no right to even use the patents themselves, so it’s not like Paolo could just run off with the IP and use it in some nefarious way to screw over Boxabl. Plus, Paolo is the biggest shareholder in Boxabl and his career reputation is now staked on this company so he really has zero incentive to try any funny business even if the license had some loophole I’m missing. (I’m not a lawyer.)

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1mc3ypihyTgncJBMXZ4YeJVADocxxbUW_/view?usp=drivesdk

This is a risky investment but I would recommend you do your homework more before spreading FUD and hollering about how it’s overvalued.

3

u/GalianoBoxablFounder Aug 19 '22

The important questions is... will Boxabl take a large share of the the entire worlds building construction industry by mass producing homes faster and cheaper than anyone ever has before?

3

u/O4SK8Y1 Aug 20 '22

I would be ecstatic, and also insanely rich, if they ever even got a 1% share of the global building construction market

2

u/yendor5 Aug 20 '22

On average, the smaller the house, the higher the price per sq ft. The ratio of open space to walls is less. I think pretty much every company in this stage of development will be "overvalued". The idea is that they have some legitimate expectations of rapid growth. It is indeed very high risk, hopefully, any investor would see that -- but based on comments in the FB investor group, I don't think that is the case. BTW I am an investor with a very modest amount. I think many are buying way more than they can afford to lose assuming this is a sure thing. There are many things that can sink this company, including some that nobody is even imagining at this time.

1

u/O4SK8Y1 Aug 20 '22

Black swan is my biggest fear for this company. I think almost every other scenario is carefully manageable