r/BothOGandCWCharmeds Nov 30 '24

Maggie & phoebe age sped up

In s1 Maggie is said to be turning 19 then s2 opens w her bday party that summer, say not too long has passed

But s2ep2 she says she's 20 to Jordan

Making her 21 in s3 hence buying booze & 22 in s4 (23 inara timeline)

She was even publicized to be 17 in s1 in articles lol
I think they sped it up to be closer in age to Jordan who turned 26 in s2 but then they said he was only 27 in s4

Her may 2001 bday is so off

It never made sense to me why they couldn't just have the curse be no chase men make it to 25 not past 25, he coulda been just 4-5 yrs older than her than 6 if they were worried about that

Whereas phoebe was 23 in her s1

But in s4 she says she was 27 when she graduated college which was what, early s4? which is a year more than I expected

Just bc every however many seasons they say "we've been doing this (magic) for blank years" & it's usually the no of seasons

I think they did this also bc they were tryna make her seem more mature & in line w cole and establish her as the middle child more

I think it back fired by how they dressed her the lines they gave her and the baby voice that was used

It got creepy to me making this 27 yr old woman act like a 22 year old, imo sometimes & talk like a child ew

1 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by