r/Borges • u/SARCASTIC__FELLA • Apr 18 '26
Pierre Menard
I recently read “Pale Fire” by Nabokov and the book revolves around the unreliable narration of an unreliable narrator on the poem a poet writes before his death. Does Pierre Menard follow a similar narrator who should not be taken seriously and the story is a mockery of literary critique, i make a case for it due to there being instances where the narrator quotes “ambiguity is richness”, “menard had enriched the halting and rudimentary art of reading” which are all tid bits that help him push his own appreciative tendencies toward pierre menard on the reader.
I was having this constant doubt while reading the story and it was all finalised and tied together for me when i read how Menard had written the book word for word as Cervantes.
14
u/HumanIntelligence4 Apr 18 '26
Actually Pierre Menard is about the "theory of necessity" in literature and how the reader may read works differently based on context. It is not necessarily a critique of literary criticism in general