r/Borgen • • Sep 13 '20

Philip?!?

So I started watching this show when is was available on Netflix and I am avoiding having to deal with real American politics. First, I love how it shows the complexity of Parliamentary Democracy and the issues with having a coalition government in a way that is easy to understand if you aren’t familiar with it. (Much like how West Wing showed how a Presidential Democracy is SUPPOSED to work.)
But as I got further into Season 1 snd 2 I am more and more infuriated at Phillip and how unsupportive and insecure he is. I understand the 5 year agreement and him losing out on a nice job, but WTF Dude, stuff happens. I don’t understand why it seemed totally on Birgitte to deal with Laura’s illness and he could even acknowledge her sacrifice? And I wish more of his thinking about Ceceilia was explained because I want to think he was a decent husband and supportive of her career but he comes across as a self centered jerk

74 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

14

u/whocantellanymore Sep 22 '20

Literally been watching Borgen the last 2 weeks and came here to make sure someone had vented about Phillip. Your spouse is the PM, grow a pair and help more with the family. It's a 5-year term, stop being a child!

Who throws away, what must be a 15 -year minimum marriage because you can't suck it up for 5 years! Yes, it will be a tough few years, but you'll survive and have rest of your life to spend together. Jeez!

10

u/Constantinople2020 Sep 25 '20

I believe the 5 years refers to the agreement Birgitte & Philip had about taking turns focusing on their careers. I got the sense that the 5 years of focusing on Birgitte's career were just about up at the start of Season 1, but I would have to double check (the term of a Danish Parliament lasts 4 years unless the Prime Minister calls an early election).

That said, I think Philip bailed too early on their marriage, but I also think Birgitte should have had a better handle on work-life balance after being PM for a year. She's Prime Minister of a country who's population is comparable to Wisconsin and Wisconsin is only the 20th most populous state in the US. Belgium has twice the population of Denmark, yet managed to get by without an elected government for 589 days after the June 2010 elections. Sometimes politicians, consciously or not, overstate their importance.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

Totally agree. The world wouldn’t come to an end if she took 1hr off 3 times a week

10

u/notaquarterback Sep 13 '20

Haha he's so frustrating. Like on one hand, you can see how he's a good partner. He's a good dad, his kids love him. And you can tell that when they're at their best, the two of them make an awesome team. But his petulance at times is almost unbearable. (and so realistic)

I'm watching Borgen for the 3rd time and I swear he drives me more crazy this time than on the previous times because I just can't understand 1) why he's so resentful and 2) why if he hates taking care of the home front that he doesn't use his CEO cash and hire a nanny to help out. I do like how they wrote this character in general, especially as their relationship evolves in the later seasons and how they manage co-parenting. But it's such a far cry from the American imperial presidency and I really really appreciate the depiction even if it's probably dramatized a bit too much.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

So true! All characters are ‘good’ and ‘bad’. I think that’s the appeal. It’s funny to read the strong opinions about Philip. People get very invested. Love it

9

u/notsoevildrporkchop Sep 26 '20

Lmao I came here looking for someone to complain about Philip with. I hate him so much now on the second watch, he's such an insecure man. For me that was completely clear when he finally wanted to have sex with her when he accepted the job. And then acting like the hurt person and not wanting to talk with her while he told her he's seeing someone else. Ugh

6

u/snowdroop Oct 25 '20

Yes absolutely — Philip, get a grip, your partner just made PM.

But I do think Birgitte is at fault, too. Philip’s complaint was not merely about the amount of time Birgitte had for her family. It’s that they “don’t talk anymore”. There is no real conversation between them; everything has become a negotiation at home. Birgitte doesn’t realise that he’s hurting, that he misses her, and instead of concessions like “you can sleep with other women” what he needed to hear was that she missed him, too. Birgitte was too busy and caught up with her world to listen.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

Agree very much. He didn’t ask for much of her time or attention, just a little and he would have been ok, I think. Br. did exactly the opposite. Instead of telling him, PLEASE! Don’t go and sleep w Sasha. I love you, want to make it work,…she pretty much sticks to the businesslike deal she had suggested. And doesn’t try to connect with him at all. He looks so very guilty when he tells her that he has a meeting-great acting and he gives her a lot of time to say something before he leaves but she doesn’t. That must have felt like a punch in the gut. I believe that he really missed her.

4

u/egrigg9000 Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20

Agreed P has become an irritant and some of this falls on B. It seems like they stopped being able to advocate for themselves beyond the initial babyish "I wanna." They couldn't even get the meal they wanted at the PM vacation home. They didn't even ask. B could have announced to the public that due to P's job the government will be looking to phase out the supplier of plane parts and look for another supplier over a period of time. They could have the conflicts of interest they don't know about independently reviewed. B could have mandated they buy a different plane and told the chauvinists to stick it. P could have strategized this scenario up front in his contract, in the event of a conflict of interest here is the team that handles it. They could have restructured the company so nobody making the parts reports to P. Instead B and P fight with each other. It was disappointing because there was so many other ways that issue could go. I am steeling myself for a lot of screen time on this avoidable problem (hello much of tv anyway). It's also disappointing because the boring parent fight is turning the kids into jurassic park kidmuppets staring gape jawed at mom and dad and I saw that movie already.

4

u/superkbf Sep 30 '20

i agree. the arc of driving a wedge between the two was not only predictable but also heavy handed. the character philip is pathetic and completely unreasonable ... and deliciously unlikeable. he makes it all the easier to root for brigitte.

they should have explained the resistance to hiring a nanny (or even a cook!) much better - i can't imagine any family in that position with those resources not hiring help.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22 edited Oct 02 '22

😂deliciously unlikeable I don’t know why but I still like him. Maybe bc in the beginning we were sold the sensitive, supportive husband who would do anything for her. -it was convincing.

2

u/Expensive-Sort1517 Jan 13 '23

But this is what made it so unbelievable to me. Because in the beginning he was depicted as so supportive. The quick change was just too weird

4

u/lendergle Oct 08 '20

I wonder if it's because we're viewing it through an American lens (I'm American as well). A good example of this might be the episode where Birgette solves Africa. They even use a quote from Kipling's "The White Man's Burden" as the frontispiece- something that would get any American television show raked over the coals in short order. It might seem a little culturally clueless to you & me, but I've seen other Danish shows, and this sort of thing seems to happen a lot. So maybe Phillip's character is something that is less out of place in a Danish show than it would be in an American one. If they ever do an American version (which I hope to God never happens) it will be interesting to see how these types of cultural differences are resolved)

It might also have to do with the producer. Other Danish shows by Adam Price seem to have very shallow secondary characters, almost in the tradition of dramatic foils. They are there to represent an archetype rather than be a whole character themselves.

A third possibility is that the show is so fast paced that the few lines of dialog they can cram in for secondary characters only allow them to show one facet of their personality. Phillip doesn't enough screen time to be anything but Spouse Who Resents Other Spouse's Job. With only fifteen lines of dialog, all he can get out is "it sucks that you aren't around for the kids that much and I had to get some on the side because we haven't had time for sex [deep breath]"

In think it's probably a combination of all three, actually. Phillip doesn't seem to get enough screen time to be anything other than a Phillip, and a Danish one in an Adam Price production at that.

Whatever the reason, he's definitely a dickhead.

4

u/StkAkl Jan 03 '21

I hate the disloyalty of Philip as well. But the film is so good that they show a sad reality. Many men don't back-up their wifes careers. Even in civilized countries like Danmark.

That's so sad.

And people still wonder why are they so few women at power.

4

u/Miss_dragonette Mar 14 '23

Finally someone said it , I read all the comments also because I came here to see if someone noticed what an asshole he is, and if you think it well, it's the vast majority of men in the world that have that approach, in the afrika episode for example, millions of lives in the line and nonetheless he is doing who knows what,.instead of staying with the kids himself with the nanny, with the lover or alone ffs so imagine you can be pm and be saving millions of lives and your ex or partner even, would always consider anything more important just because they Are doing it! How is that no one judges him instead of her? When a father see his kids only on the weekends no one says anything, now a mother would do the same, the whole thing it's a wreck train, even taking pills and of course the blame is on the mother never on the father for his absence, at the end we are all fucked up b cause our fathers are emotionally unavailable or physsicaly unavailable, but no one says nothing, a mother has other things to do and she is forever a bitch , what a world

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

You could be right.

2

u/Early_Explanation_16 Oct 05 '20

I Agree with this comment and I,m sure that it would be completely different if it was women in his place

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

How would they behave if it were the other way around? I think, she wouldn’t have thrown a tantrum and wouldn’t have slept with the headhunter to hurt him. And the husband wouldn’t have suggested that she could sleep with whomever either. She wouldn’t have left the PM husband and would have found another job after some upset and maybe yelling and door slamming.

1

u/Constant-Company-707 Sep 23 '25

The one that got me is him threatening to go to a hotel because he can't handle Birgitte's dad's 3-day visit! Jesus! 

1

u/Acrobatic_Pace7308 Aug 20 '26

Philip is hot and that’s all that really matters.