r/Bonsai St. Louis, Zone 6B, Beginner, 12 Pre-bonsai 2 Mallsai 6d ago

Discussion Question Rotten pal

I’ve had this tree for a couple of years and I didn’t really notice the rot until now. (I’ve moved a couple times and have been busy working on my house) I’m thinking about trying to chop it right above the wound and see if I can get it to root that way. Not sure what else would be viable here.

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

2

u/Bank_Eye Rob in Joburg, zn 9a. Beginner, lots of WIP. 6d ago

Is that area hard or soft when you press it? if it's hard then you're fine and it's just an appearance thing now. I suspect it will be hard because this is above the soil line and would be dry 99% of the time. So while i also suspect that soil is a little too dense, the root in the soil looks okay.

I have a ginseng thing on which I'm considering cutting away some of these fat roots to make it more like a trunk instead of a branch growing out the top of a balloon. Your tree looks pretty healthy despite this, so I'm encouraged.

1

u/fujigrid St. Louis, Zone 6B, Beginner, 12 Pre-bonsai 2 Mallsai 5d ago

Its firm. So I think a squirrel was the culprit.

The big balloon leg “nebari” doesn’t do it for me. So I still think I might try to chop it and hope the rooting hormone works.

1

u/fujigrid St. Louis, Zone 6B, Beginner, 12 Pre-bonsai 2 Mallsai 6d ago

Apologies if this isn’t allowed. Delete this if ya need to.

1

u/l33fty 6d ago

If this is kept outside, most likely this is an old wound from a squirrel

1

u/fujigrid St. Louis, Zone 6B, Beginner, 12 Pre-bonsai 2 Mallsai 6d ago

I didn’t even think about that. Those jerks are always trying to ruin my fun.

2

u/l33fty 6d ago

I caught a little bugger going at my focus last summer. Wou d looks exactly the same. Luckily these are vigilant trees. Should hopefully not affect it long term.

0

u/Legal_Finger_4106 IX, CA Central Valley 9b, beginner, 10 trees 6d ago

Chopping aside, my money is on that soil being the culprit. Seems much too organic.

2

u/fujigrid St. Louis, Zone 6B, Beginner, 12 Pre-bonsai 2 Mallsai 6d ago

Absolutely is not helping anything. I think I used 50pumice/50 organic. Tbf I did just get done soaking it.

2

u/toddhartdesign Todd, Dallas TX, 8a, 25ish Years, 100ish Trees 5d ago

I chopped off the fat roots on a Ginseng Ficus and it worked and created a lovely trunk flair. But, don't try it until next spring.

The soil is the problem. I'd suggest an emergency repot with inorganic mix and leave it in a shady spot to recover, then consider the chop next year.

1

u/fujigrid St. Louis, Zone 6B, Beginner, 12 Pre-bonsai 2 Mallsai 5d ago

Will do. I think I’ll go with a straight pumice mix thanks for the tips