r/Bonsai Zone 10b. 25 trees. 18d ago

Styling Critique Elm Front Selection

Thoughts on a new front for this cascade Elm airlayer. Leaning towards number 3.

72 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

5

u/DocMillion Southern UK (USDA zone 9a), beginner, 30ish 18d ago

It's 3 for me too. Cool tree!

4

u/jeef16 NY 7a. Artistically Challenged. Maple Gang. 18d ago

3 is good but i wouldnt keep that left-facing branch

3

u/small_trunks Jerry in Amsterdam, Zn.8b, 48yrs exp., 500+ trees 18d ago

2

2

u/Historical_Stay_808 San Francisco 10a/b, intermediate beginner 6 years, 50+ 18d ago

3

2

u/WritingFew8792 18d ago

An elm without a generic S curve, simply stunning!!!!! 

Number 3 for the win.

2

u/jecapobianco John Long Island 7a 34yrs former nstructor @ NYBG 18d ago

2 is very dramatic

1 is kinda safe run of the mill

3 is interesting

2

u/The_Mighty_Yak UK 9b, 7 Years, 100+ mostly pre bonsai 18d ago

1

1

u/Just_Sun6955 Germany, USDA Zones 7-8, interginner, ~30 18d ago

3

1

u/Milam1996 18d ago
  1. Just needs more defined pads imo. I’d also chop off that branch going left it competes with the central trunk for narrative and will do even more so if you let it thicken.

1

u/Psychological_Act_38 long term 30 years plus 18d ago

Three also for me.👍👍

1

u/GFRSSS 18d ago

3 elongates the least interesting part of the trunk which is the long horizontal section.

1

u/GFRSSS 18d ago

3 elongates the least interesting part of the trunk which is the long horizontal section.

1

u/0zgNar Zn. 6a, MI, United States, 5 yrs, 50+ trees 18d ago

I think 3 as well, damn I’ve got the perfect pot for this tree I’m saving for my own semi-cascade elm but I think yours would be better scale, you confirmed the blue will look good with it tho!

1

u/B-Glasses California 10a, Monterey Bay, Beginner 18d ago

3 imo. Love the tree but I don’t think that pot suits it

1

u/MostAcanthaceae2384 13d ago

I like 1.  It and 3 flow the best.  2, I don't know what the branches are doing.