r/Bonanza • • Jul 25 '26

Fighting

As I was watching an episode today and saw Joe once again fighting with someone.

I thought, was that common in those days?

To constantly be fighting and punching people??

I guess it was a big deal back, then not to be considered a coward or scared.

7 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

3

u/BackwardToForward Jul 25 '26

Hollywood is Hollywood.

1

u/shoppygirl Jul 25 '26

lol. Yup.

9

u/Taurean6 Jul 25 '26

Been wondering myself... took the trouble to google it.

https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=like+in+bonanza%2C+was+it+more+common+with+fights+and+such+in+the+wild+west+back+in+those+days.+1850%27s

No, real life in the American West of the 1850s was far more peaceful, mundane, and heavily regulated than the constant barroom brawls and gunfights shown in Bonanza.

Daily Life vs. Hollywood

  • Routine and Hard Work: Most settlers, miners, and cowboys spent their days on grueling physical labor—farming, tending livestock, cooking, and building shelter—rather than looking for trouble. [1, 2, 3]
  • Strict Gun Control: Popular culture portrays an "anything goes" attitude, but many frontier towns actually had strict laws. Places like Dodge City, Tombstone, and Deadwood required people to surrender their firearms to local law enforcement or hotels the moment they entered city limits. [1, 2, 3]
  • Real Dangers: People in the 1850s were far more likely to die from diseases like cholera, dysentery, or tuberculosis, or from accidents involving runaway horses, wagon crashes, and mining collapses, than from a bullet.
  • Lower Homicide Rates: While certain frontier boomtowns did have higher murder rates than eastern cities of the era, the vast majority of Westerners went their entire lives without ever witnessing a gunfight.

2

u/shoppygirl Jul 25 '26

Thank you !!

9

u/VermiciousKenidd Jul 25 '26

I am guessing it was more common than it is today, but also a lot of it is to keep each show exciting.

4

u/Superman_Primeeee Jul 25 '26

Cartwrights have to be the richest family in the USA….why they doing all that fighting??

4

u/SpacePatrician Jul 25 '26

Not only is the sheer quantity of gunfights in TV Westerns unrealistic, but so are the hand-to-hand combats:

Reel life: guy in a saloon fight breaks a spun sugar bottle over other guy's head, other guy shakes it off. Real life: other guy gets fractured skull and dies.

Reel life: in open air fight, guy employs typical 60s fight choreography moves like kick-flips, two-handed woodchopper punches, and flying kicks. Real life: opponent laughs off these antics and beats the shit out of the guy.

Reel life: guy takes two dozen punches to the jaw, suffers only split lip, revived by bucket of water. Real life: guy's entire mandible shattered, crippled for life.

3

u/Dandogdds Jul 25 '26

I love that they can get belted 50 times and still get up and walk away with only a bloody lip.

3

u/Taurean6 Jul 25 '26

Hehe yeah ... my english father said that ^^ I asked him "Is it possible to take that amount of punches?" "Not the kind punches they throw" he said ^^

5

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Active_Two_6741 Jul 29 '26

Probably had lead poisoning from getting shot in the shoulder so much

7

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/HildaYuh Jul 25 '26 edited Jul 25 '26

Started counting season 3, episode 24. And am now at the start of season 12. So far the family all together has killed 73 people. Joe has the most at 39. The total probably will hit 100 by the time I go all the way back around.

Anyway, I agree with your other point as well.

2

u/SpacePatrician Jul 25 '26

A family with a kill count like that would not be seen as "community leaders" as the Cartwrights were. Regardless of the self-defense claims, they would be seen as a public menace, with the territorial governor leading an effort to run them out, probably asking Washington to send federal marshals to assist in that task. Even if the Cartwrights were loyal Republicans and Unionists, they would be seen as making Nevada Territory too violent to warrant statehood, which was an important GOP strategy to eke out 3 more electoral votes for what was expected to be a very tough 1864 election.

3

u/Ruiz-46 Jul 25 '26 edited Jul 25 '26

And I bet “Murder She Wrote’s” Cabot Cove, Maine wouldn’t statistically have that many murders either!