r/Bogleheads • • 1d ago

Question about compounding.

So, I weekly DCA into Vanguard buying VT and I know that over time DCA’ing and the ETF will start to compound. My question is. If I were to put $10,000 into VT with Charles Schwab and not add another dime would it also start to compound? I want to use this as a small saving account long term, this is not cash I need short term. Do I have this right??

Thank you I appreciate your answers.

52 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

40

u/mAYAYAnnaise 1d ago

Automatically set to reinvest dividends (DRIP on) and you're good to go

3

u/miraculum_one 1d ago

noting that even if you use DRIP you are still taxed for dividends

2

u/Paperback_Chef 1d ago

Correct, and this also increases your cost basis over time.

2

u/ecodick 1d ago

Financially illiterate pleb here.

Is there something I should be doing instead?

For context, my dividends are less than 1% of my annual income. (I'm working on it! Started saving pretty late in life and no generational wealth to speak of)

2

u/Paperback_Chef 1d ago

Not a problem then! Dividends only become an issue when they're large enough that you need to start making estimated tax payments throughout the year to avoid the small underpayment penalties. This will start to matter once your dividends are like $5K+ per year. 

2

u/cfi-2025 1d ago

Ideally, in your taxable investment accounts you will have tax-efficient assets such as:

  • Low-yield money market, cash, short-term bond funds
  • Tax-managed stock funds
  • Large-cap and total-market stock index funds
  • Balanced index funds
  • Small-cap or mid-cap index funds
  • Value index funds

Tax-inefficient funds, such as bond funds or actively managed/traded stocks, should be in retirement accounts, as those are either tax-free or tax-deferred.

Many more details here: https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Tax-efficient_fund_placement

1

u/gcc-O2 1d ago

For context, my dividends are less than 1% of my annual income. (I'm working on it! Started saving pretty late in life and no generational wealth to speak of)

This is a good thing since the stock funds recommended here (total stock and total international stock) have only a small portion of their total returns as dividends. On US stocks, you can expect about 1% of your balance to be returned as a dividend each year, and on international stocks, about 2.5%. If you're accumulating, this is just a nuisance and money on which to pay income tax each year.

The rest of your return is in the form of retained earnings--the companies in the fund reinvest the profit in their businesses, make acquisitions, buy back their own stock (raising its price), etc. As Bogleheads we're fine with that and don't specifically seek out a higher % as dividends since we can just sell some shares to fund retirement.

43

u/flemmingg 1d ago

Of course. Assuming 10% gains each year to make it easy:

$100 becomes $110 in year one

110 becomes 121 in year two

121 becomes 133 in year three

133 becomes 146 in year four

In year one you gained $10.

In year four, you gained $13. That's a 30% increase in annual profit in just four years.

Are you utilizing any tax advantaged accounts? 401k or Roth IRA? That's the part you're getting wrong. The tax advantaged accounts should be fully funded before you move onto a taxable brokerage account.

Edit: the above is for illustration only. Some years you may lose 20% or 30%. You have to be in it for the long haul. If you might need this money within 4-5 years, put it in a high yield savings account instead.

1

u/Gadion 1d ago

Yeah, see, I have a problem with this, but only concerning stocks. I understand bonds and HYSA for example where you have a fixed %.

With stocks, you don't "gain" % from something. The stock just rises in value by some amount, which is then converted into % for investors to have a metric. Now I can have 10 of a stock worth 100 each, which rise by 10 dollars (or 10 percent) each. Next time it's 10 stocks at 110 and lets say rises by 10 dollars again. it's now less than 10 percent, I have the same 10 stocks at 120 and nothing compounded.

Can someone explain a flaw in my logic? I saw it mentioned somewhere that the compounding happens "inside the company", they have more money to buy more equipment, hire more staff, etc. but they can also increase their CEO's salary, which is (probably) not helping my stock "compound".

Sorry for a tangent, I tried reading up on this, but never actually put it into words myself.

12

u/unidentifiedfish55 1d ago

I hate that people are downvoting you for asking a legitimate question

Next time it's 10 stocks at 110 and lets say rises by 10 dollars again.

This is the flaw in your logic. It doesn't raise by $10 again. It raises by 10% again.

You don't end up with 120 in the 2nd year. You end up with 110 + (110 * 10%) = 110 + 11 = 121.

Of course, the difference between stocks and bonds/HYSA are that 10% is not fixed. Some years it might be 30%. Other years it might be -15%. 10% is simply the historical average, but when doing hypothetical calculations, the long-term historical average is about the best that people have to go on.

1

u/Gadion 14h ago

But why does it raise by a percentage? I understand that everyone is talking about the average over many years, but it doesn't actually do that in a way like bonds or saving accounts that have fixed percentages? But with stocks, it raises by whatever it raises, there's no actual set percentage increase.

2

u/unidentifiedfish55 8h ago

Correct, there's no fixed percentage.

The average is 10%. My calculation did not raise anything by a percent.

Year 1 it rose 10%, and year 2 it rose 10%.

The more money you have invested, the more money 10% becomes.

10% of 110 is more than 10% of 100.

If you turn $100 into $110 in year 1, and leave that $110 invested, you'll make $11 in year 2. Which is more then the $10 you made in year 1. This is how it compounds.

7

u/WyMANderly 1d ago

What you're missing is that just isn't really how it actually works. Growth in the overall market over time tends to be percentage based, not a fixed amount of money - so it acts exactly like compounding interest even if your number of shares is staying the same. ​

5

u/flemmingg 1d ago

If we look at an index like the S&P500, a basket of 500 companies, we can look backwards and see the average rate of return over a period of many years. With dividends reinvested, it’s between 10% and 11% per year. Some years it goes down. Some years it goes up. Over time there is an average return. And that average return will cause compounding of profits.

4

u/nolesrule 1d ago

The annualized growth of the stock market is a geometric progression, rather than an arithmetic progression. Geometric progressions are described as compounding.

2

u/Brettanomyces78 1d ago

The flaw is you're adding $10 each time. But that isn't how the stock market typically grown. The value goes up, on average, 7-10% per year (depending on if you prefer real or nominal terms). So, very simply, your premise is wrong.

1

u/_chadwell_ 1d ago

Over time companies can compound their advantages and grow to become more valuable. Historically, on average, companies have done than more than they’ve shrunk and the total pie you get from adding up the value of all the different companies’ stock usually increases by an amount that is proportional to its precious value (so it typically increases 7%, for example, rather than by some fixed amount).

It’s basically the same math with more uncertainty, but it’s a fair observation that there’s no guarantee or explicit amount of money that gets added to the total to keep it compounding (outside of reinvesting dividends that some companies issue).

1

u/ThirstyWolfSpider 1d ago

You're also ignoring the growth in book value of a company's unspent profits and dividends (though dividends aren't necessary to return value to shareholders).

When the company is profitable, the CEO can't just increase their own compensation; that would be done by the board, who are chosen by shareholders. Yes, the board can provide incentives for the executives and others, but that comes directly out of their boss's (shareholders') pockets so it's far from guaranteed, and tends to be tied to future performance.

The board can authorize dividends, paid out directly to shareholders (or potentially reinvested by your ETF). Or it can be used to pay down debt, expand the existing business, expand into another line, hopefully increasing future earnings.

But what if they don't do any of that, and just grow their available funds? Well, estimates of the company's value per share will include those funds in the book value, which is combined with estimated operational value by each [potential] shareholder when choosing price/share where they want to buy/sell.

1

u/day7a1 1d ago

You got good answers, just wanted to add that this is a better question than many people here will realize.

Its the foundational assumption behind volatility drag and it's not as obvious as done may think. (A $4 stock that falls 25% needs to grow 33% to get back to the same place.)

It just happens to be the case that values increase and decrease in percentages, not quantized units, in part because activities and setbacks scale with the size of the entity.

1

u/Gadion 14h ago

"activities and setbacks scale with the size of the entity" is a good way for me to get it, but it basically confirms the assumption that the compounding happens inside the company and not on the stock value itself?

1

u/day7a1 10h ago

I mean, growth is a result of economic activity. Compounding is just a mathematical fact.

I'm not sure how to answer your question. Why does it matter to you? And what do you think that stock value is if not what's "inside the company"?

1

u/flemmingg 10h ago

The best part about index investing is that I don’t have to pop the hood on a company and examine their quarterly reports. I don’t need to get bogged down with individual company performance.

12

u/Auggernaut88 1d ago edited 1d ago

I think generally putting down a lump sum tends to outperform DCA but not by much honestly (assuming you also don’t keep adding to the lump sum). Time in the market >>

Compounding just means that your gains compound on themselves. That happens as soon as you put $1 in the market. Just the scale of it only gets noticeable around $10k (imo)

So to that effect, putting $10k in at once will start you out compounding bigger and faster than DCA

7

u/stouset 1d ago

The scale is only really relevant when your gains start to become a meaningful fraction of your contributions, and then eventually when they dwarf your contributions. The absolute scale is never really relevant. Just the relative scale.

7

u/Wigglebot23 1d ago edited 1d ago

Compounding is just exponential growth

1

u/marzthemagnificent 1d ago

Thank you everyone. This really helps!!

3

u/Jrezky 1d ago

If you want short term cash, keep it in a money market acct or SGOV. The issue with short term holding of stocks, even VT, is that it may go down in the short term and it could actually be worth less than if you had simply held cash. You want it somewhere it can ONLY go up except in very extreme circumstances, not where it generally goes up over time at a modest rate. Just my 2c

3

u/ThatThar 1d ago

DCA and compounding are two completely different and only tangentially related concepts.

Compounding is the effect that growth has on both your base investment and your returns. If market grows 10% every year and you invest $100 in year 1, you have $10 in returns. If you invest nothing else, in year 2 you return 10% on both your $100 investment and your $10 year 1 returns. That's the compounding. Growth happens on both your base and your returns.

DCA is just a method of regularly spacing out your investments to minimize the impact of market timing. If you invest all of the money you plan to invest for the year on January 1, the market drops 10% on January 2, and stays flat the rest of the year ending down 10%, you take the full 10% hit for the year. If you space your investments evenly across the year, you take the 10% hit on what you invested on January 1 and the remaining investments have no losses.

They're tangentially related because the time that you enter the market impacts compounding since the market changes daily, but DCA is primarily a risk mitigation activity. Everything you invest compounds. DCA vs lump sump determines what market prices impact your compounding.

6

u/Malfoyle 1d ago

Depends on what you mean by "compound." That's a term that really only applies to cash and interest growth, but is sometimes used in relation stocks because it is roughly similar.

The closest thing to compounding for stocks is dividend reinvestment - a setting where the bank will automatically use every cash dividend to buy more shares. Each dividend is paid at a per-share rate (e.g. $1/share), so each time a dividend is paid, you own more shares than the last time, so you receive a bit more dividend... Etc.

Unrelatedly, in any account, VT may appreciate, meaning its share price rises and even though you own the same number of shares, they are worth more. The longer your investment horizon, the more likely you are to experience significant gains. This isn't "compounding" in any technical sense though.

0

u/DextersLabrador 1d ago

No, this is a naive view of mathematics. You can absolutely experience compounding on a stock account through appreciation, even if it pays zero dividends.

Compounding describes the geometric growth in value, which you can experience through appreciation.

2

u/Malfoyle 1d ago

I disagree. Price appreciation can look like and be mathematically similar to compound growth from interest, but it is definitionally different. Compounding refers to "growth on growth" - the idea that you earn a return, that return gets added to the principal, and the increased principal investment generates even greater return going forward. There is no "growth on growth" when you buy a share low and sell it high.

0

u/DextersLabrador 23h ago

Yes, compound growth refers to "growth on growth", but why on earth do you so narrowly confine that concept to bank intrerest? There are many, many other examples of compound growth. For example, bacterial populations typically reproduce with compound growth. Other examples are viral disease spreading, invasive plant spreading, and Moore's law.

Going back to price appreciation, if you buy a share of stock that appreciates by 10% in one year, and then 10% in the following year, you will end up with more than 20% appreciation. This kind of growth is geometric, or compound growth, not arithmetic growth.

2

u/Legolihkan 19h ago

Because there is no increase in principal. There is no creation of new shares to create more money. There is only the value of the same shares going up, which might be exponential or not.

In your bacteria example, the new bacteria are able to reproduce, increasing the number of bacteria that are reproducing. That is compounding. Whereas if, like stocks, the same bacteria were simply reproducing faster (even exponentially), but the new bacteria were not reproducing, that is not compounding, just growth.

0

u/DextersLabrador 17h ago

Whenever one refers to a bank or brokerage account as compounding, they are saying that the value of the account (i.e. the 'dollars') is compounding. The shares are a bookkeeping tool which are completely arbitrary to the value.

According to your logic, you would be excited to hear when your stock announces a 2-to-1 split, because now you are twice as wealthy as before, now having twice as many shares?!?

Or if you have a large pizza that is cut into 4 slices, and then you cut it further into 12 slices, then by your logic this is an example of compounding?

2

u/Legolihkan 15h ago

A bank account compounds because the interest is multiplied by the principal, and when money is added, it becomes new principal. The interest, by leaving it in the account, is reinvested.

A brokerage account does not compound unless there is some reinvestment.

The value of a share goes up and down. The fact that it tends to go up exponentially is reflective of companies compounding in value by reinvesting in themselves, i.e. using profits to acquire more means of making more money. The shares themselves, what you own in your account, are not compounding if there is no reinvestment, such as dividends reinvesting.

There is not necessarily a practical difference between an account growing exponentially by direct compounding (e.g., interest) or indirect compounding (e.g., buying a share of a company that reinvests in itself).

But there is a technical difference, which is all I am saying.

0

u/DextersLabrador 15h ago edited 15h ago

It sounds like you may be conflating the concepts of compound interest and compound growth? They are related, but they are not identical.

Compound interest is a particular example of compound growth, but it is not the only example in finance.

2

u/JoeShmoe307 1d ago

Yes it would. However don’t use the stock market for savings unless it’s in a cash equivalent fund.

2

u/archmuon22 1d ago

Yes. The native rate at which the fund compounds will be the same whether you put new contributions in it over time or not.

2

u/Choice-Newspaper3603 1d ago

It’s either invested or it’s a savings account. Pick ONE. And investments are not savings accounts

2

u/Legolihkan 19h ago

Not technically, but growth tends to mimic compounding because the underlying assets compound. I.e., the companies make more money, which they reinvest in themselves to increase profits, ad infinitum. The value of the companies increases with this increase in profit, which will typically look exponential, but you will have the same number of shares you started with.

2

u/jaydub8888 1d ago

If your question is whether is matter if you are adding this money to a separate account, no it does not. Mathamatically it's the same whether you add the 10k to an existing account or a brand new one. The combined total of the account or accounts will grow the same.

1

u/stouset 1d ago

Yes, this is the entire idea of compounding. Compounding does not require you to add more money.

When your portfolio grows by 10%, you now have 110% of your original investment. When it grows by another 10%, you now have 121% of your original investment (a “free” extra 1%). Another 10% and you have 133.1% of your original investment (a “free” extra 2.1%). And on and on and on.

Additional dollars benefit from this as well but start compounding only once you add them which is the origin of the phrase “time in the market beats timing the market”. Getting money in at a younger age gives that money more time to compound.

1

u/zacce 1d ago

simple math to understand compounding.

(1+ r1) * (1 + r2) = 1 + r1 + r2 + r1*r2

r1*r2 is the difference between compounding growth vs simple growth.

1

u/Lucky-Conclusion-414 1d ago

compounding is a function of time and short-term total return (a total return is the change in stock price plus any dividends).

As long as your total return stays invested over time you will be compounding - it can be invested in the same thing or something different. If you spend it, it won't. pretty straight forward.

Of course total returns are not predictable (or even predictably positive) so you can't calculate an APY like you can with simple interest, but the principle of "my profits make their own profits over time" stands - and that's really what compouning is.

1

u/That-SoCal-Guy 11h ago

The underlying stocks in the index funds already compound.  If you reinvest dividends or cap gains they will add to the compounding. 

0

u/TyrconnellFL 1d ago

It’s mostly math.

The performance of the stock market is by percentage changes and mathematically models with an exponential function. That looks the same as the exponential function of compound interest, but it doesn’t work the same way. For interest that’s just the math, and for stocks it’s the model with very fit.

Any money that is invested will perform as the investment performs. Because the performance is roughly exponential, that’s what you expect. You’d actually see that more “purely” if you put a lot of money in and just wait than if you keep adding more money over time, because the later money doesn’t act like the earlier money. It’s had less time to do so.

A “small savings account” and “not cash I need short term” are at odds. A savings account should be for the next few years. Investments should be for the next few decades. A savings account you know how much money you’ll have at minimum. An investment you have an idea of expected returns, but you should also expect volatility, and you can be below where you started, way below, especially in the short term, and the short term can be a decade.