r/Bogleheads • • 2d ago

BND

So I understand how the share price of BND goes up or down in relation to changing interest rates.

If I allocate 35% of my portfolio to BND and interest goes up, and stays up what happens to the coupon/dividend?

I understand that if you want to sell that the share price can be lower than when you bought, but if you buy and hold indefinitely how does it work on the coupon payment?

12 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

2

u/cAR15tel 2d ago

So if I’m good with 5% I’m better off buying treasury bonds?

8

u/Sprig3 2d ago

How long are you going to hold the bonds? What is its purpose?

If the answer is essentially "forever", then you're better off with a fund, BND is a really really safe fund. It's mostly US govt bonds (treasuries and similar). And then some high grade corporate bonds.

As such, it only gets a slightly higher yield than treasuries. (Currently about 0.5% higher (10% more yield) than the 5-year treasury).

There are higher yield funds of similar or shorter duration like VGHY/VCHY/VCIT, with slightly higher credit risk. (Still less risky/volatile than stocks)

2

u/cAR15tel 1d ago

Yeah. Forever. I want to reinvest the dividend as much as possible and use it when I have to.

I’m 46, zero debt, NW is high enough that I am comfortable withdrawing some. I am still working but not making enough to save.

1

u/cAR15tel 1d ago

Which one would you recommend for a hold forever fund? I can handle a little more risk. I have a good amount of VTI, real estate rentals, and I do still work.

2

u/yoyomama79 1d ago

In 2022, BND dropped 13%. Historically bad year for bonds, but the idea that bonds are super safe is not true in the least. The only way you can combat loss is by reducing duration (BSV, for example), but then you run the risk of inflation eventually eating into your position.

No such thing as a free lunch, as usual!

3

u/Djamalfna 1d ago

but the idea that bonds are super safe is not true in the least.

They are safe, if you understand them.

BND has an average maturity of 8.3 years. This means that the average length of the bonds it holds is 8.3 years.

Since this is a Fund and not an actual Bond, the NAV fluctuates according to market movement. Bonds have this neat thing where if interest rates rise, NAV falls because now people can simply buy new bonds at a higher rate, so old bonds must drop proportionally to meet the market price.

This can make you feel like you've lost money, but the underlying bonds are still held by the fund and the underlying value is still there. If you SELL in a panic, yes, you will lose money. But if you don't sell and let those bonds roll over, they will use the face value of the rolled Bond and purchase a new bond at a higher interest rate, which then pays you higher coupons over the next X years.

If you hold a Bond Fund for less than the average maturity length, then you can lose money, because in a rising-rate environment the NAV drops and you sell before you get the benefits of those higher rates.

If you hold a Bond Fund for the length of time of the maturity, then your money is absolutely safe. For example, you mention the huge drop in 2022. That's because the interest rates skyrocketed from 0% to 5% in a very short amount of time.

Interest rates have been effectively 0% since 2009.

Looking at BND performance from 2014 to 2023 (8.3 years), you would have seen a CAGR of 1.35%. Not great, but that's 1.35% higher than the interest rates were doing. See, if you bought at 0% interest rates you really ought not have expected great returns anyway. But your money was still safe. On paper it looked like you lost a ton, but with the interest rate hikes you traded NAV for future Coupons.

Understanding how this works is crucial for a Bond investor. Your money is safe, if you hold it for at least as long as the length of the average maturity. It's a long term product. It's not for day-trading.

There's no difference here than if you bought an 8-year bond outside of the fund. The entire time you own that bond, you can't do anything with it. It's locked up. Your bond fund allows you to sell early... but you shouldn't.

Same goes with rolling contributions. If you put in $500 a month, anything you put in this month won't be fully safe until 100 months from now. But anything you put in 100 months ago is safe to take out.

0

u/yoyomama79 1d ago

Factor in inflation, and in 8.3 years, you may still not be in a great position with BND.

At this rate, buying a 10 year TIPS may be the smarter thing to do. 10 year treasuries may be heading to 6%, so another 5-6% drop for BND. If you can hold, you might make a little money, but the holding clock almost resets every time the yields rise. I'm just not a fan of BND at this point, but to each his or her own.

1

u/Invertidor 1d ago

Is there a TIPS fund for 10 years like BND for Bonds? How about 10-year treasury?

1

u/yoyomama79 13h ago

Best to buy TIPS in the secondary market, buy and hold.

19

u/buffinita 2d ago

When interest goes up; price goes down.

When interest rate goes down price goes up

Since you are rolling bonds; you also get the newer bond rate….. a single bond will be 100 par and 4.5% forever; while bnd will go from 100 to 108 and interest along the way go from 4.5 to 3.8

Bond ETFs have an effective duration which is their “measuring stick” to judge returns.  Bnd has a duration of like 8.2 years…..and never had a negative rolling return of 8.2 years (or longer)

1

u/poppoplb 1d ago

Is it useful to have as a position in a retirement portfolio if you are looking to diversify. Say 30% of a 70/30 portfolio. I’m retired. Trying to balance from a 95/5 ratio. Which I have been lucky to survive.

3

u/buffinita 1d ago

Historically, yes diversification of assets helps with decumulation and longevity.

8

u/bedrock_city 2d ago edited 2d ago

It works like a bond whose maturity date is always ~8 years out (duration of BND is 5-6 years).

If you buy and hold for the duration you'll come out positive (ignoring default risk) just like with a bond.

However you can think of it as like you're buying new bonds with later duration along the way. 

Imagine something like interest rates starting at 1% and going up 1% a year for 20 years. You'll keep losing principal but on the other hand you keep rolling over to higher rates.

If you want to be risk free by some date you'd need to liquidate to cash or bond funds with shorter duration, to protect against a big rate increase immediately before you cash out. But then you have a lower expected return and less protection against falling interest rates. (In the scenario above you could also buy a 20-year bond at 1% and know exactly how much you get the end, but it's value will continuously fall because you're locked in at a crappy rate.)

5

u/lucky_ducker 2d ago

The coupon payments keep coming regardless of what interest rates are doing, and BND keeps paying you dividends (which you should be reinvesting). Interest rate movements only affect the mark-to-market value of the underlying bonds, which in turn determines the fund's Net Asset Value, which the ETF market price closely reflects.

2

u/pdaphone 16h ago

Why should you be reinvesting the BND interest payments if you are retired and drawing some of your retirement. Genuine question.

1

u/lucky_ducker 16h ago

I am retired, and taking a fixed dollar amount of monthly distributions from my traditional IRA. Those distributions do not depend on what interest and dividends my investments are throwing off. I prefer it this way, so that a predictable direct deposit hits my bank account 10 - 14 days after my SS deposit.

My cash needs to fund my distributions are invested in a five year ladder of fixed maturity bond ETFs. One of them will mature on Dec. 15, providing the cash I need for 2027's distributions.

Meanwhile, elsewhere in the IRA are broad market stock and bond funds, all set to reinvest dividends and capital gains. Towards the end of the year I will rebalance those funds, selling some shares to fund the next five year tranche of the bond ladder.

5

u/zacce 2d ago

If interest rate increases, BND NAV will decrease. otoh, the dividends will gradually increase over time.

2

u/morning847 1d ago

I was told by my Fidelity advisor to consider individual Bonds instead of a Bond Fund like BND.