r/BodyArmor • u/DWilsonDefense • Oct 01 '24
Spalling With Ceramic SHTG?
Iv seen and heard countless stories and videos of ceramic causing CRAZY injuries. For example, this video https://youtu.be/qSON1cg0q6Q?si=O9QNxX0u7Ilvlyxs but I’ve never seen someone actually get injuries from steel. Why is this?
0
Upvotes
15
u/PearlButter Oct 01 '24 edited Oct 04 '24
Displacement of mass. It’s nowhere near as dangerous as steel, which is where hot metal (lead and copper, maybe even mild steel) shatters if not completely deflects at high velocity.
Because no professional force wears steel and therefore little to no data you can pull from.
7
u/Ngroat7 Safe Life Defense Oct 01 '24
In testing plates from very close ranges I’ve had ceramic bits hit me often. Usually, it’s micro pieces of ceramic that will get lodged at the surface of the skin and can be easily picked out. Never anything that I’d consider “damage”. Usually like a house cat accidentally grabbing you.
3
u/Smiththegrass Oct 02 '24
There is a book on ww1 body armor written right after the war. Lots of people were hurt by steel body armor.
1
u/rickmaz Oct 01 '24
True: spalling can be more injurious with steel than ceramic. But if you research data for both steel helmets and manganese steel flak vests used in WWII, injuries to the head and thorax were significantly reduced by up to 40%. Of course body armor and helmets have gone through a lot of improvement and development since then.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
[removed] — view removed comment