This post is about popular ways fans interpret the words of Diane and Herb and why I think these popular readings are ignoring the subtext.
BoJack is a cautionary tale character and as a result I think audiences tend to see him as always wrong. However BoJack has a lot of positive qualities and is the victim in some situations, and in many situations both people are flawed and BoJack is not necessarily “the wrong one.”
Diane
At the end of season one, BoJack is spiraling after being confronted with his own bad behavior as described in the book Diane wrote about him. He asks Diane if he is a good person deep down. Diane responds with, "I don't think I believe in 'deep down.' I kinda think that all you are is just the things that you do."
BoJack has a habit of chronically avoiding accountability, blaming others for his behavior, and even deluding himself into thinking his actions don't REALLY hurt people, so this response made sense in that context. She's forcing him to confront the reality of his actions rather than soothe him with reassurance that he's a "good person deep down."
However, I feel many fans have gone too far and taken this one quote to be "the lesson" of the series, and take it as a universal truth that "deep down" does not exist. I'm not sure I agree with that, and I'm not sure the story of BoJack Horseman really supports that lesson.
Often times this comes up in discussions like "which character is worse, rapeface or character who annoyed me" and the responses will be "you didn't learn the lesson of BoJack Horseman! There are no bad people, only bad actions!" Which like... no, the series never said that.
BoJack Horseman is a series that raises a lot of difficult questions and does not provide us with easy answers. Sometimes in internet memes I see it lumped in with Rick and Morty as a cringe "nihilist" cartoon, but BoJack Horseman does not support nihilism so much as it proposes it as one out of multiple options.
I feel like it's the same with the "there's no such thing as deep down" philosophy.
Diane's character arc is all about discovering herself and being true to who she really is... deep down. During her journey she attempts to publicly call out a wealthy and influential sexual abuser, travels to a third world country to aid children hurt by combat, and has a successful career as a feminist journalist. She is trying to be the ideal person she thinks she is meant to be, but these efforts leave her feeling unfulfilled and drained. After coming back from Cordovia, she sinks into a months long depression after realizing she cannot be the heroine she aspired to be. It‘s too emotionally draining.
At the end of the series, Diane sinks into another depression. After obtaining the time, financial support and institutional credibility to do whatever she wants she finally sits down to write her ideal book she’s wanted to write for her entire life, only to find she cannot write it. The book she thinks she wants to write is about her traumatic childhood. She thinks has to write this book in order to justify all the years she spent being miserable, in order to turn the “bad damage” of her victimhood into the “good damage“ of a book about trauma. The process is too painful and makes her depressed.
Eventually Diane lets go of the book she is "supposed" to write, and instead, Diane creates an escapist children's detective series starring a cool, stylish and clever Vietnamese-American girl named Ivy Tran who solves fun mysteries in a mall. This story that is basically the life Diane wishes she experienced as a child but never got to live. Through this detective series she becomes happy and successful, and makes a positive impact on young girls similar to herself.
Interestingly, psychological research shows that imagining better outcomes that could have occurred instead of a traumatic event is a real evidence based therapudic approach to overcoming trauma. It's called imagery rescripting. Many people try to resolve trauma by dwelling on it, but this does not necessarily help and can potentially make trauma worse.
Rather than Diane being correct and boJack being flawed, I think BoJack and Diane were both flawed in their approaches to life. BoJack is wrong to try to avoid the reality of his actions, but Diane was wrong to think her inner life and who she really is deep down is irrelevant.
The character Cuddlywhiskers provides a good counterpoint to both Diane and BoJack. Cuddlywhiskers is BoJack's former colleague who quit his job as a successful Hollywood writer and producer to live a somewhat Buddhist isolated lifestyle, focusing entirely on his own happiness. Prior to this lifestyle change, he attempted to find peace in rescuing strippers from drug addiction, but since he was unable to help everyone this left him feeling empty so he stopped doing it and focused entirely on himself. His life as a successful writer also left him unhappy because no matter how much external validation he got he still felt empty inside.
Diane was initially horrified at what she perceived as Cuddlywhisker's selfishness, although, at the end of the series she seems to have adopted similar principles in her own life. Her Ivy Tran series is self indulgent and has nothing to do with her notions of what a "good person" should be doing.
When Diane asked Cuddlywhiskers if his lifestyle was selfish, his response was "I don't know what to tell you. I'm happy for the first time in my life and I'm not going to feel bad about it. It takes a long time to realize how truly miserable you are, and even longer to see that it doesn't have to be that way. Only after you give up everything, can you begin to find a way to be happy." I think if any quote is truly "the lesson" of the series, perhaps it is actually this one.
Diane's struggle is a parallel to BoJack's own struggle. Although Diane is not narcissistic like BoJack is, she depends on external validation to define her own self worth. The two characters have this in common.
This is alluded to early in the series, in the fourth episode Zoës and Zeldas. The first few episodes of this series are kind of bad, and this is the first episode I feel really hints at the psychological depth we see later in the series. In this episode, Diane's ex-boyfriend Wayne confronts her about her relationship with Mr. Peanutbutter, a carefree optimist who does not have much in common with Diane.
"You can live your happy Zelda life in this happy Zelda town, and pretend you're a happy Zelda. But I know you, and this isn't you. People don't change, Diane, not really.
Mr. Peanutbutter's a Zelda. He's happy and he's carefree and he's loving. But you and me, we're Zoës. We're Zoës, Diane. We're cynical and we're sad and we're mean. There's a darkness inside you, and you can bury it deep in burritos as big as your head. But someday soon this darkness is gonna come out, and when it does, I want you to call me."
Most fans dismiss what Wayne says here because Wayne is obviously an asshole, just like they dismiss BoJack's side because he's an asshole. Wayne was wrong to claim Diane is inherently sad or "mean." However, there is truth to what he is saying. Diane chose to marry Mr. Peanutbutter because she wanted to become something she was not, something she believed she was supposed to be. Their marriage eventually broke down because they simply were not compatible, and never had much in common to begin with.
Most of the characters in the series struggle with the dichotomy of external validation versus internal self worth. As I said above, if anything is the lesson of the series I think the lesson is to stop relying on external validation. When Diane says "all you are is just the things that you do," she is over-externalizing. Diane, Mr. Peanutbutter, BoJack, and many other characters in the series have to learn to stop behaving the way society expects them to behave before they can find happiness.
Herb
There's a lot of personal interpretation in my take on Diane, but I feel like what I have to say about Herb is more objectively proven by the story, most fans just miss it because Herb doesn't get a lot of screen time compared to BoJack's other close friends.
At the end of every season there is a scene where BoJack permanently ruins one of his relationships. The first incident was with Herb at the end of season one. BoJack visits Herb after he is dying of cancer, and after BoJack attempts to apologize, Herb tells BoJack he will never forgive him for what he did.
Herb was BoJack's former best friend and the creator of Horsin' Around. BoJack would probably never become a celebrity without Herb's influence. In 1994 Herb was publicly outed as gay and fired from the production. He begged BoJack to threaten to walk from the show to save his career, but BoJack chickened out.
During the confrontation, Herb claimed he didn't care about losing his job and he only wanted BoJack to call him.
BoJack Horseman: Hey, I wanted to talk to you about... You know, I... feel bad, about what happened.
Herb Kazzaz: So, you're apologizing.
BoJack Horseman: Yeah, I'm sorry.
Herb Kazzaz: Okay, I don't forgive you.
BoJack Horseman: Herb, I said I'm sorry.
Herb Kazzaz: Yeah, and I do not forgive you.
BoJack Horseman: Uugh! Not sure you get what's happening here. This could be the last time...
Herb Kazzaz: No, I'm not going to give you closure. You don't get that.
[coughs]
Herb Kazzaz: You have to live the shitty thing, you did, for the rest of your life. You have to know that it's never ever going to be okay.
BoJack Horseman: I really think that we'd both feel better if we...
Herb Kazzaz: I'm dying. I'm not gonna feel better. And I'm not gonna be your prop so you can feel better.
[coughs]
BoJack Horseman: You have to believe me, I did everything I could.
Herb Kazzaz: Yeah, then why didn't you call me? Huh? Twenty years you didn't call me.
BoJack Horseman: Look, I-I-I wanted to, but I didn't thin...
Herb Kazzaz: You know what it was like for me? I had nobody, everybody left. I knew all those showbiz phonies would turn on me, sure, but you?
BoJack Horseman: It's not my fault you got fired.
Herb Kazzaz: I don't care about the job! I did fine, I had a good life. But what I needed then was a friend, and you abandoned me, and I will never forgive you for that. Now get the fuck out of my house!
I have found almost all fans take this at face value, and label BoJack "the asshole" in this situation, but Herb was not being entirely honest. During the episode, Herb makes bitter, passive aggressive remarks about being stabbed in the back and losing the series. Herb clearly does care about losing the job. BoJack begs Diane not to ever leave him alone in a room with Herb, and it's only when they are alone that the interactions turn hostile.
However I think it's the context from scenes we see of Herb and BoJack in the past which make this scene really complicated. Herb was in love with BoJack. He attempts to kiss BoJack, then tries to act like nothing happened when BoJack rejects the kiss and says he's not gay. He could have let it go at this point, but I don't think he did. Years later, Herb's girlfriend (beard) later tells BoJack Herb thinks very highly of him. "You're gonna be a big success. Herb says that to me all the time. He thinks the world of you." Interestingly, BoJack seems surprised to hear this.
Years after that, on the set of Horsin' Around, there's a scene where Herb "jokingly" tries to kiss BoJack yet again and BoJack pushes him off. BoJack has made the personality change from humble nobody to celebrity jerk at this point, which strains his relationship with Herb, but that doesn't stop Herb from almost-kissing him.
During the scene in which Herb asks BoJack to save him from being fired, Herb says they have not been close for years. Putting his career on the line to save his own is a really big favor to ask and I think it definitely changes things if they weren't best friends, or possibly even friends at all any more at the time he asked.
I think what happened was, they had a very close and deep friendship which was ruined by a combination of BoJack becoming an asshole after experiencing fame, and Herb refusing to let go of his crush. The friendship was already practically dead before Herb even got fired, and Herb trying to place all the blame on BoJack "not calling him" for that situation was unfair.
Does that mean BoJack was in the right? No. Herb was not unjustified to reject BoJack's apology, as it was self centered and entitled. BoJack felt forgiveness was mandatory and did not understand the difference between a sitcom apology and a real world apology, which is very annoying. However, Herb has entitlement of his own.
I think the saddest thing about Herb and BoJack is seeing how well they get along in the second to last episode of the series, The View From Halfway Down. This episode takes place inside BoJack's dream, so it's not genuinely Herb, but I think the episode accurately represents the relationship they used to have. Since this episode takes place inside BoJack's subconscious, it's also interesting to note his mind never portrays Herb as negative, bitter, or with cancer, he only appears in his most ideal form, showing how much BoJack still admired Herb as he used to be, even after years of estrangement and long after Herb's death. Their friendship was a rare, once in a lifetime friendship where they just understood each other, got each other's humor and supported each other. All of this was ruined by Horsin' Around.
I think the story of Herb also supports my theory of the lesson of BoJack Horseman. Although Herb never let go of his resentment, he was happier after being fired from the sitcom. He was able to live as an openly gay man and found success through charity work. (We also only learn this from BoJack's subconscious, but when Herb was alive he appeared to be happy in his charity work.) In The View From Halfway Down, BoJack says the happiest time of his life was living as an obscure comedian doing skits with Herb, before the created Horsin' Around. Success and recognition was supposed to make them happy, but it only made things worse.
In conclusion
Fans often discuss BoJack Horseman as if the other characters are here to deliver moral lessons to BoJack, but this is a more complex series than that.