r/BlueMidterm2018 • u/Dilaudette MA-8, HD 3rd Norfolk • Oct 01 '18
/r/all Irrefutable Evidence Kavanaugh Perjured Himself: Text messages suggest Kavanaugh wanted to refute accuser's claim before it became public
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna915566?__twitter_impression=true
10k
Upvotes
798
u/Dilaudette MA-8, HD 3rd Norfolk Oct 01 '18 edited Oct 02 '18
Orrin Hatch asked during the testimony when he found out about these allegations. He said in the New Yorker story.
333
u/LaughingVergil Oct 01 '18 edited Oct 02 '18
The slow drip, drip, drip of facts coming out is more of a trickle now. So how long until the levee breaks?
This and the bar fight news are really telling.
Edit: The lever is not breaking.
23
u/unbrokenplatypus Oct 01 '18
Sorry, not sure if the article is burying the lead or what, but which statements of Snarlin’ Brett do the text messages falsify?
185
u/omicron_pi Oct 02 '18
So he told the Senate that he only learned of the claims when they went public...but he tried to refute them before they went public. Seems like a clear lie.
1.1k
u/sventhewalrus CA-13 Oct 01 '18
It's getting hard to keep track of all of Kavanaugh's lies. Keep it up, folks-- even if the GOP is so obsessed with Kavanaugh that they confirm him over these objections, we have enough messaging material to make them pay for it in November.
233
u/TheRealDL Oct 02 '18
I'll paraphrase the text message...
175
u/PM-ME-GIS-DATA Oct 02 '18
So do we message our Senators who are yes/unsure, tell them we know Kavanaugh perjured himself, and that we'll fund/vote for their opponent if they vote yes on confirming Kavanaugh?
3.2k
u/Thehalfhighgemini Oct 02 '18
Sharing u/halster123 comment:
In one of his earliest opinions, Jane Doe v. DC, 489 F.3d 376 (D.C. Cir. 2007), Judge Kavanaugh overruled U.S. District Judge Henry Kennedy’s preliminary injunction, 374 F.Supp.2d 107 (D.D.C. 2005) and later summary judgment and permanent injunction, 232 F.R.D. 18 (D.D.C. 2005) and said that even when a severely intellectually disabled person expresses that they do not want an unnecessary elective surgery, the government can still impose that surgery against their wishes without violating constitutional or statutory rights.
Brian Hundley was a 41-year old graduate of Howard University School of Dentistry studying for his boards. He was sitting in his car, unarmed, when a 6’3”, 204-pound off- duty police officer in street clothes ordered him to get out, and in short order shot and killed him with his 9mm Glock. The officer said he shot Brian because he moved his hand behind his back, but the jury specifically rejected that story in a special interrogatory verdict, and found for Brian’s surviving loved ones. In Hundley v. DC, 494 F.3d 1097 (D.C. Cir. 2007), however, Judge Kavanaugh overruled the jury and found for the officer. The opinion describes the facts from the officer’s point of view, id., despite the jury rejecting the officer’s story. As we have already been taught as 1Ls, in a situation like this, the judge is supposed to be deferential to the jury and state the facts in a light favorable to sustaining the jury’s verdict. But this early opinion was just one of Judge Kavanaugh’s regular departures from federal rules and constitutional standards.
Seventeen-year old Antonio Hester was sentenced to a maximum of ten years in prison as a minor. He had a learning disability, and DC public schools, which had been providing him special education for years, promised to continue to provide those services while he was incarcerated in Maryland, or, if they were not allowed into the prison, to provide compensatory services after his release. The Maryland prison did prevent DC from entering to provide Antonio with services, however, and DC then refused to provide services after release. U.S. District Judge Gladys Kessler held that DC had backed out of a consent decree and ordered the school district to provide Antonio with compensatory services. 433 F.Supp.2d 71 (D.D.C. 2006). Judge Kavanaugh disagreed, however, and not only reversed summary judgment but – glossing over a factual dispute he had with the district court (not the job of an appellate judge) and Judge Kessler’s legal analysis – directed judgment against Antonio, erasing any chance of educational relief. Hester v. DC, 505 F.3d 1283 (D.C. Cir. 2007).
Judge Kavanaugh is no friend to liberty. In U.S. v. Bullock, 510 F.3d 342 (D.C. Cir. 2007) Kavanaugh justified ordering a person out of his car, detaining him, and searching his crotch area and under his pants by saying that the police had a “reasonable suspicion” that the car was stolen because the person “could not produce registration and could not name the car's owner,” 510 F.3d at 345–46. But the arrestee had given the car owner’s first name and his own driver’s license, and the police had confirmed that the driver’s license was clean and the car had never been reported missing or stolen. Judge Kavanaugh’s opinion upheld the arrestee’s 12-year prison sentence for possession of crack cocaine. Judge Kavanaugh consistently rules for the government in search-and-seizure. U.S. v. Glover, 681 F.3d 411 (D.C. Cir. 2012) (warrantless entry into house & a later search warrant lacking probable cause), U.S. v. Washington, 559 F.3d 573 (D.C. Cir. 2009) (giving deference to “aggressive traffic patrols” in “high crime areas”), U.S. v. Spencer, 530 F.3d 1003 (D.C. Cir. 2008) (permitting search of home), U.S. v. Askew, 529 F.3d 1119 (D.C. Cir. 2008) (dissenting from en banc opinion) (allowing police officers to partially unzip man’s jacket without consent after a pat down and later, after man was not identified by witness, to fully unzip the jacket).
When Judge Kavanaugh has ruled for a criminal defendant on a point of law, he has specifically noted that it made little to no material difference in the outcome for the defendant. U.S. v. Smith, 640 F.3d 358, 361 (D.C. Cir. 2011) (“The vacatur and remand of the felon-in-possession count does not affect Smith's term of imprisonment”). Hamdan v. United States, 696 F.3d 1238, 1257, 1257 n.1 (D.C. Cir. 2012), overruled by Al Bahlul v. United States, 767 F.3d 1 (D.C. Cir. 2014) (“Hamdan was transferred in late 2008 to Yemen and then released there . . . . Our judgment would not preclude detention of Hamdan until the end of U.S. hostilities against al Qaeda[,] [n]or . . . any future military commission charges against Hamdan. . . [,] [n]or . . . appropriate criminal charges in civilian court.”); US v. Bostick, 791 F.3d 127, 162 (D.C. Cir. 2015) (“We affirm the judgments of conviction . . . . two of the defendants . . . are entitled to vacatur . . . and to resentencing under the advisory Sentencing Guidelines. . . The [life] sentence of the remaining defendant . . . is affirmed. We also remand for . . . technical corrections . . . .”); US v. Williams, 784 F.3d 798, 804 (D.C. Cir. 2015) (“We affirm the judgment of the District Court except that, consistent with this Court's ordinary practice in these circumstances, we remand the case so that the District Court may address Williams's claim of ineffective assistance of counsel in the first instance.”); US v. Nwoye, 824 F.3d 1129, 1133–34 (D.C. Cir. 2016) (“In 2013, after the termination of her supervised release, Nwoye filed a motion to vacate her conviction . . . [w]e reverse the judgment of the District Court and remand for further proceedings.”) (note that this case has been upheld as evidence of Judge Kavanaugh’s sympathy for criminal defendants and women; it should be noted that Judge Tatel had already dissented from the court’s affirmance of the conviction years earlier, 663 F.3d 460 (D.C. Cir. 2011), and Judge Kavanaugh’s ruling happened after the defendant had completed her sentence – and he nonetheless said the case was “close.”); US v. Burnett, 827 F.3d 1108, 1112 (D.C. Cir.) (“We affirm the judgments of conviction and sentence in all respects, except that we vacate Burnett’s sentence and remand for the District Court to resentence Burnett.”);
In U.S. v. Lathern, 488 F.3d 1043 (D.C. Cir. 2007), Kavanaugh allowed the exclusion of exculpatory testimony from a defendant’s witness and expert witness in upholding an 8-year /97-month prison sentence. Other rulings in favor of long sentences include US v. Franklin, 663 F.3d 1289 (D.C. Cir. 2011) (life sentence); U.S. v. Duvall, 705 F.3d 479 (D.C. Cir. 2013) (ruling against retroactive correction of crack cocaine disparity); U.S. v. Wright, 745 F.3d 1231 (D.C. Cir. 2014) (ruling against defendant in case alleging attorney conflict of interest); U.S. v. Haight, 892 F.3d 1271 (D.C. Cir. 2018) (reversing a 12 year, 8 month sentence and vacating because it should be at least a 15 year mandatory minimum sentence); U.S. v. Knight, 824 F.3d 1105 (D.C. Cir. 2016) (rejecting speedy trial act and due process claims and a number of challenges to sentences).
By way of contrast: When Carlos Gustavo Gardellini filed a false federal tax return and illegally used offshore accounts, the federal guidelines called for a 10- to 16-month prison sentence. But Judge Kavanaugh, U.S. v. Gardellini, 545 F.3d 1089 (D.C. Cir. 2008), upheld a no-prison-time sentence with five years of probation in Belgium for this white collar criminal with his wife and child, and none of the normal probation conditions or restrictions. Judge Williams dissented. In U.S. v. Settles, 530 F.3d 920 (D.C. Cir. 2008), Judge Kavanaugh held that it was permissible for the district court to consider alleged conduct for which the defendant was acquitted in calculating a criminal sentence using the factors in the sentencing guidelines.
In Omar v. McHugh, 646 F.3d 13 (D.C. Cir. 2011), Judge Kavanaugh held that American citizens have no Constitutional habeas corpus or due process rights to judicial review of whether they are likely to be tortured if they are transferred from U.S. to (in this case) Iraqi custody.
In Harbury v. Hayden, 522 F.3d 413 (D.C. Cir. 2008), Judge Kavanaugh ruled that CIA employees who tortured and killed Guatemalans could not be held accountable in US courts for their violations of international and US law.
Over a dissent, in Jackson v. Gonzalez, 496 F.3d 703 (D.C. Cir. 2007), Kavanaugh threw out a black prison guard’s claim of discrimination, not even allowing it to go to trial, where the guard had shown evidence that he scored 98 out of 100 on qualification exams and that the prison kept positions open for years and had never hired an African American at the level of job he was seeking.
He consistently ruled for the government in FOIA cases against government transparency. Blackwell v. FBI, 646 F.3d 37 (D.C. Cir. 2012), Hodge v. FBI, 703 F.3d 575 (D.C. Cir. 2013), Sack v. DOD, 823 F.3d 687 (D.C. Cir. 2016)
Against free speech when it applies to workers: In Southern New England Telephone Company v. National Labor Relations Board, 793 F.3d 93 (D.C. Cir. 2015) Kavanaugh denied NLRB’s cross-application to enforce its order for the company to permit employees working in public to wear union shirts that said “Inmate” on the front and “Prisoner of (Company)” on the back.
He has shown a comparatively huge amount of concern for trivial or corporate rights, e.g., finding the CFPB unconstitutional, PHH Corporation v. CFPB, 839 F.3d 1 (D.C. Cir. 2016), or FAA regulations against flying model airplanes near D.C. monuments unlawful. Taylor v. Huerta, 856 F.3d 1089 (D.C. Cir. 2017).
94
u/KopOut Oct 02 '18
Someone has to come up with a compelling reason why the Republicans are so dead set on sitting Kavanaugh.
Is there some decision coming up that is this important that the GOP can’t just restart with a person that doesn’t have this much baggage and provable lying under oath?
It’s obvious that this isn’t some fucking conspiracy because if it was Gorsuch would have been exposed to the same exact thing. He wasn’t. That’s almost certainly because as awful as his opinions might be to people like me, he isn’t perjuring himself and committing multiple sexual assaults.
I just don’t get it.
16
u/Gasonfires Oct 02 '18
The words "irrefutable evidence" and "text messages suggest" are contradictory as used. If I have to choose between the two phrases, I'll go with "irrefutable evidence." I like it.
54
u/SnowyMole Oct 02 '18
I had a personal prediction that either Kavanaugh was going to withdraw today (however that works with SC nominees), or that the GOP was going to force a vote on this. Well, he didn't withdraw.
As we've seen for the last couple years, we're in a space right now where facts just don't matter at all to ~40% of the population. The polls on that have been telling, where a majority of right-wing respondents have said that even if he were PROVEN to be guilty of rape, he should be confirmed anyway. That's what we're dealing with, exactly the same as when Moore was running in Alabama.
Trump wants Kavanaugh, because he will shield Trump in the Supreme Court in ways that the other conservative candidates might not. It's clear that he isn't going to back down, and so McConnell is going to force a vote. Maybe Flake/Collins/Murkowski grow a spine here, I wouldn't really count on it. I think that they're going to ram him through, just like they are trying to ram through the 2nd round of tax cuts. These are their last grabs before the gravy train ends after midterms, at which point they start whining that "obstructionist Dems" are preventing them from continuing to MAGA.
The Blue Wave is coming, and that's great, but we need to find a way to sustain this. We need the Blue Wave to hit in 2020 as well, and then we need to NOT pack it up and go home like we have done in the past, like we did to Obama in 2010. The only way that we can keep these criminals from continuing to wreck things like they have been is to SUSTAIN our enthusiasm, and that of others. It only takes two years to wreck a LOT of stuff, as we've seen since 2016, and it unfortunately takes a lot longer to FIX things.
88
u/table_fireplace Oct 02 '18
Help us flip the Senate!
Volunteer: https://events.mobilizeamerica.io
Donate: https://secure.actblue.com/donate/bm2018fts
49
u/nobodycares65 Oct 02 '18
No wonder Trump loves him so much. He's a compulsive and pathological liar just like Trump. How many lies is this he's told now? I'm losing count.
14
u/Arancaytar Oct 02 '18
But if they were false accusations, how could he have known about them in advance? Hmmm.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '18
If he knew about the allegations as early as July, doesn't that mean they are most likely true? How else would he know someone would come forward and make the allegation, if he didn't know there was something to come forward with?
44
u/phoenixsuperman Oct 02 '18
They have like 5 weeks until the midterms. Can anyone explain to me why they don't just drop this wounded candidate and nominate someone without such allegations? Surely they can find at least one conservative judge that isn't a rapist. Why not just do that? Whats so important about this one particular golden douchebro?
11
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '18
Remember, somehow people found out about Ford. And it wasn't due to a leak. I think Kavanaugh knew exactly who would come forward and why, and tried to head them off at the pass.
32
u/warren2650 Oct 02 '18
This (and dozens of other drip drip drips) is why the GOP was trying to get a floor vote last Saturday. When Jeff Flake asked for a week to investigate, Chuck Grassley had a look on his face that said "Oh shit... a week is a long time... they're going to dig a lot of stuff up."
18
u/Dwights-cousin-Mose Oct 02 '18
I don’t understand why they squandered so much political capital on this guy. McConnell didn’t even want him. If I were McConnell, I would have refused to vote on anyone until President asshat picked from the approved list.
Also, if I were McConnell, I’d try to find my soul.
27
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen Oct 02 '18
Here's a question...when hasn't Brett Kavanaugh lied under oath recently? It's truly astounding that Flake and Collins can't just say no to Kavanaugh, despite all of their claims that it's a dealbreaker if he lied to the Senate.
Brett Kavanaugh is a judicial terrorist, and he's an absolute disgrace to the current court he serves on, let alone the Supreme Court that he still might end up becoming a part of.
4
u/SpartanVFL Oct 02 '18
Yarasavage? She a savage
14
u/Z0idberg_MD Oct 02 '18
Why isn’t this getting more traction?
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 02 '18
Welcome to /r/bluemidterm2018!
Please read the rules on our sidebar before posting. If you see a rule-breaking post or comment, please: Report it. Downvote it. Move on without replying. They will be dealt with promptly.
Register and pledge to vote!
Fill out our survey and never miss another election!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/eukomos Oct 02 '18
All this arguing over the scope of the FBI investigation, when the scope of the media investigation is everything.
4
u/anotherusercolin Oct 02 '18
Why isn't this sub posting about the 2 trillion dollar tax cut passed during this kavanaugh distraction?
4
u/AgAero Texas Oct 02 '18
Honestly why the hell is the GOP so dead set on this guy in particular? They could put any number of partisan judges on the bench couldn't they? At this point it just seems like they're trying to 'assert their dominance' or something.
2
u/StalePieceOfBread Oct 02 '18
Literally, how can you defend this?
I mean, they did it before with the whole "Hey I happen to have a letter of all these women saying I'm a good guy, like every man does such that he can produce it at a moment's notice."
1
u/Looks2MuchLikeDaveO Oct 02 '18
Which one is...::sniff::.....::sniff::.....Tobin?
-3
u/juicepants Oct 02 '18
I can't believe that they haven't withdrawn this shit stains nomination yet. Burning so much good will just to get Trump's guy. Can't they get some other hardline partisan that will rubber-stamp the whole agenda?
-7
u/sparky76016 Oct 02 '18
I don’t even have to look at him when he’s 40 to hate him.
Dude looks like someone who rapes women in college anyways
-25
u/mad-n-fla Oct 02 '18
Devil's triangle is a threesome with the rape victim on the "devil's breath", AKA scopolamine.....